Emergency department human rights inquiry under way

Emergency department sign Human Rights Commissioner Les Allamby will chair the inquiry.

Related Stories

The Human Rights Commission inquiry into emergency health care in Northern Ireland has held its first day of hearings.

The health minister and the chief medical officer gave evidence.

The inquiry is investigating whether patients who encountered problems in their emergency department had their human rights violated.

It is the first time such an inquiry has been held in Northern Ireland.

In her first public appearance, the newly appointed chief executive of the Health and Social Care Board, Valerie Watts, was also due to take questions.

These more formal appearances from health officials will be mixed with real life experiences from members of the public.

Staff, including nurse managers, will paint a picture of life on the wards.

One patient who gave evidence told the BBC that her account would "be frank and honest".

Deirdre Dougal said she was moved from ward to ward when she was a patient at the Royal Victoria Hospital

"I will tell it how it was and how it left me. The standard of care was appalling," she said.

"The pressure on staff was enormous - I felt I was going to die."

Deirdre Dougal gave evidence on Thursday afternoon.

She said she had decided to give a submission to the commission after having "quite a poor experience" at the Royal Victoria Hospital's A&E department in Belfast in January.

'Complex conditions'

"I was moved from ward to ward," she said.

"Nobody seemed to know who was my consultant, who was in charge of me and that is because I have very complex medical conditions that all inter-link with each other, but at this stage you could expect that the NHS would be able to deal with that."

Mrs Dougal said she hoped that by telling her story, others would come forward.

"This is the first time in my life that I have ever spoken out about anything," she said.

"I want to encourage every single person out there to come to this inquiry when it goes around the country and tell because until patients who have actually received this sort of treatment or whose relatives have received this type of treatment, nothing is going to change."

Les Allamby Chief commissioner Les Allamby said the inquiry would, assess if the system was working

Unlike other inquiries, this will be held in the less formal setting of the Youth Action building at Belfast's College Square North.

While it is an informal setting, according to the inquiry's staff, the less adversarial backdrop does not mean it will not be tough in seeking the truth.

Its overall aim is to examine how the system of emergency health care in Northern Ireland respects, protects and fulfils human rights, focusing particularly on the right to health.

According to the chief commissioner, Les Allamby, it will assess if the system is working.

"Some of the people who have contacted us had a very good experience and recognise that staff are very dedicated and work very hard," he said.

"Others have had a very poor experience, therefore we want to reflect properly good practice and also where things have gone wrong."

Prior to public meetings getting under way, the team has been making "visits of observation" to at least one emergency department in every health trust.

It also examined practices at minor injury units in Downpatrick and Bangor.

"We witnessed the patient journey from when they went through the front door to the reception area, triage until they were seen by medical staff," Mr Allamby said.


Describing the visits as invaluable he acknowledged seeing the good and the bad, including staff running out of blankets, to patients being seen in extremely cramped conditions.

"This is not an ambush, but we do expect to ask questions about how the budget is being managed," he said.

Public hearings will continue across Northern Ireland until the end of October.

Among those asking questions will be a former UN Special Rapporteur on the Right to Health, Prof Paul Hunt.

More on This Story

Related Stories

More Northern Ireland stories


BBC News NI Live

    09:57: Changeable weather: Angie Phillips BBC News NI Weather Presenter

    Temperatures and weather will see-saw over the weekend. It'll be wet and windy again Monday then drier and brighter on Tuesday.

    Friday weather
    09:42: Civil servants register interest in redundancy scheme John Campbell BBC News NI Economics & Business Editor
    civil service redundancy
    09:31: Derry "mad as hell": Derry Journal

    Veteran rights campaigner Eamonn McCann says Londonderry remains "mad as hell" over the decision 50 years ago not to create a major university presence in the city, the Derry Journal reports.

    09:19: Sprucefield collision moved: BBC NI Travel

    Collision on the M1 at Sprucefield has been moved to hard shoulder, therefore traffic heading towards Belfast should ease soon on M1 and A1.

    09:02: Man arrested after M1 crash

    A 29 year old man has been arrested after a collision on the M1 at Sprucefield this morning which is still causing long tailbacks.

    traffic tailback

    It follows the theft of a car at Banbridge at 7.40am. The man was arrested on suspicion of burglary and dangerous driving.

    08:58: Extra smoke breaks? Good Morning Ulster

    Should smokers get special rights and extra breaks at work? That's the question posed by Good Morning Ulster reporter Rick Faragher in this morning's programme.


    Charities have appealed for employers to help staff who smoke to quit.

    08:44: Man 'trapped in machinery':

    Harbour police confirm that the man who was seriously injured yesterday at Hayes Fuels in Belfast, was trapped in machinery.

    Man trapped
    08:34: Tyrone unchanged: BBC Sport NI

    Tyrone boss Mickey Harte has named an unchanged side for Saturday's Division One match away to Dublin.

    Mattie Donnelly

    Harte has picked a half-forward line made up entirely of recognised defenders for the trip to Croke Park, including Mattie Donnelly.

    08:21: Waterside repair underway Northern Ireland Water

    A number of homes are off supply at Tirbracken Road in Londonderry due to a burst main. A repair is underway and it's hoped to have supply restored soon.

    08:12: M1 crash causing tailbacks

    The situation at the M1 collision at Sprucefield.


    Traffic appears to be passing in the outside lane looking at the Traffic Watch NI cameras.

    08:02: M1 blocked at Sprucefield BBC NI Travel

    Collision on M1 at Sprucefield. Two lanes blocked heading towards Belfast

    07:49: Carrick train cancelled: Translink
    07:41: No Evans response to spitting charge: BBC Sport NI

    Northern Ireland's Jonny Evans has yet to respond to an FA charge but has denied deliberately spitting at Papiss Cisse.

    Jonny Evans

    Cisse has accepted a similar charges and released a statement apologising for his actions.

    07:29: Weekend weather: Angie Phillips BBC News NI Weather Presenter

    I have your latest online video forecast for today & the weekend

    07:15: Shot men stable:

    Two men in their 30s are in a stable condition after being shot in the legs in Poleglass, on the outskirts of west Belfast.


    It happened in the Glenkeen area at about 20:45 GMT on Thursday.

    07:02: Hurt man 'critical':

    The Belfast Health Trust says that the man hurt in a workplace incident at Hayes Fuels in Belfast is still in a critical condition.

    Hayes Fuels

    The man suffered serious injuries at the premises in Belfast Harbour.

    07:00: Good morning Ciaran McCauley BBC News NI

    Hope it's a good Friday for you all - we'll be bringing you all the news, sport, weather and travel up until 19:00.



  • Replica of a cargo boxSpecial delivery

    The man who posted himself to the other side of the world

  • Cartoon of women chatting on the metroChat wagon

    The interesting things you hear in a women-only carriage

  • Target practice for Lithuanian troopsBaltic shiver

    Europe editor Katya Adler on the alarm at Russian muscle-flexing

  • Ruben ReuterRuben returns Watch

    Child TV star with Down's syndrome on life away from home

Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.