PSNI flags move 'most significant in years' says QUB flags expert

Dr Dominic Bryan from Queen's University, Belfast, carried out a major study examining the flying of flags in Northern Ireland Dr Dominic Bryan from Queen's University, Belfast, carried out a major study examining the flying of flags in Northern Ireland

Related Stories

A police decision to clamp down on flags in a mixed area of Belfast is the "most significant" flag policy move in years, an academic expert has said.

On Thursday, the BBC revealed police are to treat the erection of loyalist flags in the Ballynafeigh area of the Ormeau Road as a breach of the peace.

It followed a meeting between the police and Sinn Féin's Alex Maskey.

The flag expert, Dr Dominic Bryan, said although the move was a "significant shift" it would be hard to enforce.

Start Quote

Years gone by, certainly people using [Irish]tricolours have been prosecuted in the past, but the idea, the possibility that the use of a union flag in various public spaces will be treated as a breach of the peace, is a significant shift”

End Quote Dr Dominic Bryan Queen's University, Belfast

The police met Mr Maskey after Sinn Féin MLA complained that PSNI officers in his constituency had "brought themselves into disrepute" by watching flags being put up in the Ballynafeigh area.

In a statement to BBC Northern Ireland's politics programme The View, a police spokesperson said tensions were "particularly heightened" by the number of flags being erected in the area.

"As a result, police have directed that any future erection of flags on this part of the Ormeau Road will be treated as a breach of the peace," they added.

The Democratic Unionist Party (DUP) said the move was a mistake and would be "impossible" to police. The Progressive Unionist Party (PUP) has also opposed the move and has asked to meet police to clarify the issue.

However, the Social Democratic and Labour Party (SDLP) has said flags should not be used to "cause aggravation" and called for the new policy to be extended across Northern Ireland.

'Public spaces'

Dr Bryan, from Queen's University, Belfast, has conducted a major four-year academic project examining "the popular flying of flags in Northern Ireland" and has advised the Office of the First Minister and Deputy First Minister on the issue.

He told BBC's Good Morning Ulster programme that it would be "very difficult" for the PSNI to enforce the new south Belfast policy in a "widespread way".

"These things have to go to court and I'd say there would be a question mark as to what the case would look like going to court. However, it does show how things have moved on.

"Years gone by, certainly people using [Irish] tricolours have been prosecuted in the past, but the idea, the possibility that the use of a union flag in various public spaces will be treated as a breach of the peace, is a significant shift," Dr Bryan added.

The four-year QUB flag study was commissioned by the Office of the First Minister and Deputy First Minister, in part to evaluate the government's 2005 flag policy, the Joint Protocol in Relation to Flags Flown in Public Areas.

The academic said: "I would suspect this is the most significant move probably since the protocol was first written in 2005."

"To be honest with you, there has been a bit of a stasis over that period of time around enforcement".

Flags erected in the Ballynafeigh area of south Belfast Ballynafeigh used to be a unionist stronghold in south Belfast but the latest census data has shown that 57% of the people who live there now are Catholics, while 27% are Protestant

He added: "In principle, this has always been possible, but to actually say that this would be a breach of the peace is a significant move."

'No change in policy'

A PSNI spokesman said their policy for dealing with flags had not changed.

He said: "The experience within policing shows that the approach most likely to provide for public safety and prevention of disorder is based on the principles of engagement between local communities, working with agencies including local police, and resulting in local decision-making.

"The removal of flags is not the responsibility of the PSNI and police can only act to remove flags where there are substantial risks to public safety.

He added: "This is entirely in line with existing PSNI policy and practice and does not represent any change in that policy.

"We accept that this can lead to the perception of differing approaches in different areas, but this is the essence of local community resolutions in the absence of a wider consensus."

The DUP MP for East Londonderry, Gregory Campbell, said Irish tricolour flags have been erected in other mixed areas across Northern Ireland and claimed the latest move seemed to be "solely focused on getting the union flag down".

Mr Campbell said tricolours were flying in mixed areas of his own constituency, including the Heights, Coleraine and the Glens estate in Limavady. He added he believed tricolours were erected near the former Erne Hospital in Enniskillen.

He said police were going to face problems in many other areas and described it as an "unworkable solution".

"They are going to be inundated now with people saying 'right, here is a mixed area with flags flying here, we want the same policy implemented here'. Those areas will number dozens of places," Mr Campbell said.

PUP leader Billy Hutchinson said: "The message to the police is you need to police this society fairly. I want to know that you're not having a two-tier system - one for loyalists and one for republicans."

Sinn Féin's Alex Maskey said officers who watched flags being put up "brought themselves into disrepute."

But Mr Maskey said the erection of flags in his constituency was "bad for the local economy and very bad for local community relations".

SDLP leader Dr Alasdair McDonnell said: "People should not be allowed to cause aggravation, to cause disturbance and to use the flag, whether the British national flag or otherwise, as a tribal element and an element of provocation."

Ballynafeigh used to be a unionist stronghold in south Belfast but the latest census data has shown that 57% of the people who live there now are Catholics, while 27% are Protestant.

In the same census, 36% of the population in Ballynafeigh described themselves as Irish, 32% said they were British, and 29% described themselves as Northern Irish.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

More Northern Ireland stories


BBC News NI Live

    09:43: Safer inside

    Jimmy Carmen tweets to report strong winds, snow, thunder and lightning in Carrickmore, County Tyrone. He says he's too scared to go outside to take a picture!

    09:35: Road closed: PSNI

    PSNI Castlereagh tweets that the Ballygowan Road in Castlereagh is closed in both directions near the junction with Gransha Road following an accident. Drivers should expect delays.

    09:31: Phantom purchase

    The Belfast Telegraph reports that the Ulster Aviation Society has bought a Phantom jet to put on display.

    09:23: Rail announcement in 'weeks' BBC Radio Foyle

    A member of Stormont's Regional Development Committee says he expects an announcement within weeks on an upgrade for the Londonderry-to-Coleraine railway line.

    Derry-Belfast rail line

    Speaking to BBC Radio Foyle, SDLP MLA John Dallat said the north west would have a "new service by 2016". Translink officials are in Derry to answer questions about the line upgrade.

    09:13: Go slow in snow PSNI

    As snow and ice head our way today, the PSNI has issued some advice for motorists driving in wintery conditions:

    • Slow down and leave plenty of room to stop. You should allow at least three times more space than usual between you and the car in front of you

    • Drive slowly on snow in the highest gear possible

    • Brake gently to avoid skidding. If your wheels start to lock, ease off the brakes.

    09:03: Ferry sailings cancelled

    All sailings between Rathlin and Ballycastle have been cancelled today due to the weather conditions.

    09:02: O'Connor 'not joining SF' Belfast Telegraph

    Sinead O'Connor has decided not to join Sinn Féin following a meeting with party officials, the Belfast Telegraph reports.

    Sinead O'Connor
    08:54: Snow pattern Cecilia Daly BBC News NI Weather Presenter

    As with rain showers the frequency and intensity of snow showers will vary from place to place and some places may see very little!

    08:49: Union reps on Donaldson review

    Patricia McKeown from Unison and Kevin McAdam from Unite joined Noel and Karen in the Good Morning Ulster studio to talk about the Donaldson review into our healthcare system.

    Good Morning Ulster

    It emerges that health unions didn't get the chance to share views about change with Sir Liam Donaldson.

    08:47: Thick snow in Dromara

    A Good Morning Ulster listener has texted the programme to say that there's a lot of snow in Dromara, and it's falling thick and fast.

    08:41: All white, Lexi?

    Lexi the golden labrador is waiting patiently for a fresh fall of snow in Portadown.

    Picture of dog in snow

    His owner Lucy McMullan took this picture with her brother Jack.

    08:33: Legal aid cuts warning: Good Morning Ulster

    Justice Minister David Ford will deliver cost-cutting proposals today.

    Justice Minister David Ford

    Solicitor Tony Caher tells Good Morning Ulster that a legal aid cut "will reduce access to justice".

    08:25: Mystery trophy

    BBC News NI newsreader Ann-Marie Foster has tweeted this picture of a sports trophy making a quick stopover in the newsroom before heading up the road to Moyola Park. Anybody know what it is?

    Moyola Park trophy
    08:20: Eastwood on driving licences

    SDLP MLA Colum Eastwood has been in our Foyle studio speaking about driving licences after a DUP motion to reverse the decision not to include the union flag on those in Northern Ireland failed.

    Colum Eastwood
    08:13: Snow in Cushendall

    Ballymena newsagent Eugene Diamond tweets: "Some customers coming in from Cushendall reporting snow on Parkmore. And it's drifting..."

    08:08: Early warning

    AMD tweets: Looks like it's started!

    Snowy road

    This early morning picture was taken in Knockahollet near Cloughmills. What's it like where you are?

    08:01: Stop smoking, start shopping Good Morning Ulster

    Northern Ireland could feature in trials in which pregnant smokers are offered vouchers to quit.

    Pregnant smokers

    Researchers in an initial trial in Glasgow found women who received vouchers worth a total of £400 were more likely to stop smoking. More coming up on Good Morning Ulster.

    07:55: Snow falling Cecilia Daly BBC News NI Weather Presenter

    Snow being reported in the Antrim Glens. Temperatures now falling away on high ground.

    Snow Wednesday Jan 28
    07:51: Linfield held to draw BBC Sport NI

    Linfield's title hopes suffered a blow last night when they were held to a 1-1 draw by strugglers Ballinamallard Town - new signings Grant McCann and Glenn Belezika made their debuts for Linfield.

    Grant McCann

    Elsewhere Coleraine and Glenavon also finished 1-1 while Dungannon Swifts beat Institute 2-1.

    07:42: Train talks on track BBC Radio Foyle

    Transport officials are due to meet in Londonderry this morning to discuss the Derry train line upgrade. Discussion coming up on Radio Foyle after 8.00.

    07:31: Lifeboats answer over 500 calls

    RNLI lifeboats and lifeguards answered 565 calls for help in Northern Ireland in 2014, the charity's annual statistics show.

    RNLI inshore lifeboat

    Lifeboats launched 261 times to a variety of callouts.

    07:22: Snow warning Cecilia Daly BBC News NI Weather Presenter

    Snow warning comes into force at 08:00 - some disruption is possible later.

    07:14: Winter in Fermanagh:

    Snow on the hills and sun on the water.

    Lough Macnean near Belcoo,

    This stunning picture of Lough Macnean near Belcoo, County Fermanagh, was sent to us by Sam Anderson.

    07:09: Child crime records review plan

    People with a childhood criminal record could be allowed to ask for a review under plans revealed by the justice minister.

    A group has campaigned for people convicted of minor offences as children to be allowed to apply to have their criminal records wiped.

    07:02: 12 new jobs Clodagh Rice BBC News NI

    Smith's Engineering in Ballymena is investing almost £900k expanding its premises and creating 12 new jobs.

    The company has seen significant sales growth, doubling turnover in the last three years.

    07:00: Good morning Ciaran McCauley BBC News NI

    Welcome back to BBC News NI Live for Wednesday, 28 January - we'll have all the news, sport, travel and weather right up until 19:00.



Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.