Change of tack over NI welfare reform

Mike Penning is having talks with Nelson McCausland Mike Penning is having talks with Nelson McCausland

Mike Penning's pugnacious performance on BBC Radio Ulster's Nolan show marks a change of tack by the London Department for Work and Pensions over the vexed question of welfare reform.

Previously, the London minister Lord Freud has held behind-the-scenes discussions with Stormont's Social Development Minister Nelson McCausland about what kind of flexibility Northern Ireland can be given to persuade reluctant MLAs to back the changes.

However, my invitations to the minister to explain what is going on have been spurned.

Perhaps because Mike Penning has just completed a spell at the Northern Ireland Office, he is happy to take a different route.

He launched an outright attack on Stormont MLAs, particularly Sinn Féin, for allegedly "burying their heads in the sand" over the financial implications of going it alone on welfare.

He is warning that multi-million pound fines will kick in from the turn of the year if the bill authorising welfare reform is not passed.

The executive has already negotiated some important concessions, ensuring welfare payments will not be monthly, as originally suggested.

The Stormont Executive has already negotiated some important concessions The Stormont Executive has already negotiated some important concessions

Other concessions enable money to be paid to a primary carer rather than automatically to the head of a household, and payments to be made directly to landlords.

On Wednesday, the former DUP Minister, Sammy Wilson, also claimed a solution has been negotiated to the problem of the spare room subsidy known to its critics as the bedroom tax.

Mr Wilson says executive ministers have agreed to spend £17m to ensure no existing claimants lose out as a result of the spare room charge.

If the deal is as definite as the DUP claim, this should get around the objections of Deputy First Minister Martin McGuinness, who told the last Sinn Féin Ard Fheis he would use a petition of concern to block any imposition of a bedroom tax.

However, the DUP is still frustrated that Sinn Féin has not agreed to repeated attempts by Nelson McCausland to push the Welfare Reform Bill forward.

It is within that context that Mike Penning has decided to shake a big financial stick at the executive.

Sinn Féin, for its part, says it is defending its constituents against what it views as a cuts agenda, and points to the delays and problems with the welfare reform pilot programmes in Great Britain as evidence that playing a waiting game might not be such a bad tactic.

Last time the Welfare Reform Bill came to the floor of the Northern Ireland Assembly, in October last year, the debate lasted until midnight.

The bill progressed with support from the DUP, Ulster Unionists and Alliance, but Sinn Féin joined the SDLP and the Green Party in the "no" lobby.

Since then, the Ulster Unionists appear to have become more sceptical about the welfare changes, so when the measure comes to the assembly again Sinn Féin may not have the option of voting no in the knowledge that this will not kill the bill.

Apart from weighing up whether any more concessions can be extracted, Sinn Féin will also have to consider the possible financial consequences if welfare parity is broken.

There is also the wider context of Sinn Féin's fractious relationship with the DUP and their opposition to austerity measures on either side of the border.

Whatever decision Sinn Féin makes, Stormont is likely to be burning the midnight oil once again, if and when, the Welfare Reform Bill returns for its consideration stage.

Mark Devenport Article written by Mark Devenport Mark Devenport Political editor, Northern Ireland

DUP debate: From Twitter reshuffle to power-play?

DUP members take to Twitter to pledge their support for party leader Peter Robinson.

Read full article


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 5.

    sekmet2 - what you pay in, you get back.

    What happens if you don't and have never paid anything in?

  • rate this

    Comment number 4.

    sergioGiorgio - I have worked for 30 years and pay substantial NIC. Should I be unfortunate enough to lose my job and have to claim Social Security Benefits ( NOT Welfare!) I would be receiving a handback - not a handout. You really need to stop reading the Daily Mail

  • rate this

    Comment number 3.

    Jim - for "welfare" read "handouts".

    People have to stop viewing this charity as their right and start working for a living instead of sponging of the state, read "taxpayers".

  • rate this

    Comment number 2.

    The Tory welfare reforms drafted for London are proving disastrous all over Britain. Universal Credit is in shambles, PIP looks likely to have more appeals than the notorious Work Capability Assessment. The least said about the malevolent bedroom tax, the better. And then we have tax credits being cut for young mothers. For once I can very much agree with our MLA's and their reluctance to do this.

  • rate this

    Comment number 1.

    SF and the DUP better get their proverbials in gear otherwise they risk upsetting their block vote of scroungers and job dodgers.

    Another 2 fingers up to the tax paying, silent majority of NI.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.