Fresh consultation on care homes closure plans

Fionnuala McAndrew, Director of Social Care and Children, said they will work with all individuals concerned

Related Stories

A fresh consultation will take place on the proposed closure of NHS residential care homes in Northern Ireland.

The Health and Social Care Board acknowledged there were failings in how the issue was handled, but said future changes would be approached sensitively.

Care homes in the northern, southern and western trust areas were earmarked for closure in April.

In May, the health minister ordered trusts to suspend consultation plans.

The move followed a public outcry, with families and residents angry about how the matter was being handled.

Speaking on Wednesday, Mr Poots said it would be a time for people to come first, not buildings.

"I welcome the fact that that is how things are going to be done in the future," he said.

"It doesn't mean that residential care homes won't close in some locations across Northern Ireland.

"What it does mean is that each person will be treated as an individual, that their views will be listened to, they'll be respected and that will be core to this, that this will be about the individual not about the facility."

The health union, Unison, said while residential homes failed to accept any long-term residents, within five years there would not be enough people to justify keeping them open.

In October, the health board is to consult about what criteria should be used to assess a home's future.

Relatives speak out

Letty Doherty, 99, lives in Thackeray Place, in Limavady, one of the care homes in the Western Trust proposed for closure.

Her daughter Josie McCann said: "The residents and their relatives have been issued with letters this morning explaining this (consultation) and I think it has only succeeded in traumatising them more.

"They're all unsettled again after they had been settled a bit after the last episode. This has really upset them again, I think it's a bad approach.

"It's fairly obvious that the end product of this is all care homes are going to close.

"I don't think they intend to have any statutory in this area and all over Northern Ireland. I think it's privatisation by the back door.

Frances Anderson, the daughter of 85-year-old Irene Dinsmore, who also lives in the home in Limavady said: "I honestly thought that after the u-turn the last time that Mr Poots would leave these people alone and not evict them from where they're happy.

"But in my heart I knew this would come sooner or later because they're trying to save a little bit of money.

"Usually eviction's a punishment for not paying rent, but they haven't done anything wrong, they don't deserve to be evicted."

The director of Social Care and Children, Fionnuala McAndrew, said the process would be more transparent.

"Nobody would be saying that older people will be forced to leave their home," she said.

"Our experience is that when you work with families, you show people alternatives.

"We take our time to ensure that people are satisfied and ready for the change, that that can be done successfully."

Any major changes, including proposed closures, will require a second consultation.

While this time the board's response is more measured, the BBC understands its intention remains the same - to eventually close most of Northern Ireland's care homes.

That means more homes are likely to close in the next three to five years than remain open.

In May, the commissioner for older people criticised the lack of consultation with residents in NHS residential care homes facing closure.

Letty Doherty Letty Doherty, 99, is a resident of one of the homes proposed for closure

Claire Keatinge described the anguish expressed in the media and to her office by elderly residents and their families as "very serious".

"The Health and Social Care Board, I understand they did give a commitment that nobody will be forced to leave a statutory residential care home," she said.

"They need to stand over that and they need to show people what the alternatives are if a home is closing, they need to show that the alternative is better.

"The people in care homes need to be absolutely sure that they understand what their choices are and if their choice is to remain in the care home, they need to be able to express that clearly."

More on This Story

Related Stories

More Northern Ireland stories



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.