Best laid plans


So the marathon Stormont planning debate is over. But will the bill become law?

Predictably, the DUP and Sinn Fein voted through the inclusion of two far-reaching amendments, only published last week.

One enabled the first and deputy first ministers to create special economic zones in which planning may be unconditional. Another potentially restricted the right of objectors to go to courts to challenge planning decisions.

However, the Environment Minister Alex Attwood says that, if the SDLP remain in government in the autumn, he has the "nuclear option" of choosing not to move the bill at its next stage. So it might never reach the statute book.

The DUP and Sinn Fein argue that the new powers could prove important for creating much-needed jobs.

On Twitter, Sinn Fein's Barry McElduff has described Alex Attwood's threat as putting the selfish needs of the SDLP before the needs of the economy.

By contrast, campaigners like Friends of the Earth regard the latest measures as "Thatcherite", tilting the balance of the planning process too much in favour of economic concerns at the expense of protecting the environment.

During the Stormont debate, the TUV and the newly formed, NI21, echoed Alex Attwood's opposition to the new clauses, describing them as a "power grab" by the first and deputy first ministers at the expense of the environment department.


But Jim Allister and Basil McCrea went further than Mr Attwood, questioning why the SDLP remained in the Executive when their minister was being humiliated by the bigger parties.

It's interesting that Alex Attwood, talking to Stephen Nolan, put in his caveat about whether the SDLP will still be in government come the autumn.

However the speculation, recently reported by my colleague Martina Purdy, that Alasdair McDonnell may replace Mr Attwood with the West Tyrone MLA Joe Byrne appears to point towards a leader thinking more about rotating his ministers than quitting the administration.

Alex Attwood isn't the only minister who may soon be rotated. It's expected that the Strangford MLA Simon Hamilton (who acted as a front man for the DUP during the planning debate) will take over from Sammy Wilson as Finance Minister next month once the assembly goes into recess. Edwin Poots, by contrast, expects to remain in place at the Department of Health.

Something else to watch out for over the summer break might be any further word from the First and Deputy First Ministers on streamlining the number of Stormont departments.

In mid-May Martin McGuinness told me on Inside Politics that he wanted to move "as quickly as possible" towards cutting the number of MLAs and the number of Stormont departments.

Any re-jig (for example creating a new combined Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Development) would have an inevitable impact on planning.

That said, 18-months have passed since the First and Deputy First Ministers said the last rites over the Employment and Learning Department, yet Stephen Farry has still to give up his ministerial Skoda.

So don't hold your breath waiting for a more radical restructuring of the Stormont architecture.

Mark Devenport Article written by Mark Devenport Mark Devenport Political editor, Northern Ireland

Future Northern Ireland Assembly changes outlined by governments

Stormont would put arrangements in place for an opposition as early as March 2015, according to the government paper circulated to the parties at Stormont House last week.

Read full article


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 3.

    I am calling for the resignation of the SELB board. They do not represent the public and are not a democratically elected body. This Quango needs to be shut down now! There was a ground swell of support for the Dickson Plan to continue but this has been swept aside to placate the ministers wishes to do away with all selective establishments. Just as the rest of the world are turning back to them.

  • rate this

    Comment number 2.

    Best stitch up I've seen perpetrated in a long while. I think wee Alex's arrogance - always what "I've achieved", never a nod to his department that does the work; will always count against him. He's not what you would call "well liked" even though he did take the odd difficult decision, eg, causeway golf development.

    Some humble pie maybe ?

  • rate this

    Comment number 1.

    Absolutely right for TUV and NI21 to describe moving planning for special zones to OFMDFM as planning grab. Add in the denial of third party appeal and it becomes closer to a dictatorship. Pure hypocrisy of Barry McElduff to say "putting the selfish needs of the SDLP before the needs of the economy" while Sinn Fein are so blatantly putting their selfish needs before democracy and communities.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.