Police Ombudsman's office at odds with Criminal Justice Inspectorate

Police Ombudsman Al Hutchinson Police Ombudsman Al Hutchinson has pledged to leave his role next June

Related Stories

The BBC understands the Police Ombudsman's office has withdrawn part of a statement it gave following a BBC Spotlight documentary.

It said the Criminal Justice Inspectorate (CJI) acknowledged its review on Troubles-related investigations, when implemented, would provide a robust model for dealing with the past.

The BBC understands the CJI maintains it made no such acknowledgement.

It has been retracted by the ombudsman.

The Spotlight documentary looked at the circumstances leading up to the decision by Sam Pollock, the former chief executive of the Police Ombudsman, to step down.

It also uncovered evidence of failings in several historical investigations led by the ombudsman, Al Hutchinson.

On Wednesday, the ombudsman's office released a statement in response.

It said that following a recent report by the Criminal Justice Inspectorate it had reviewed its processes regarding Troubles-related investigations.

It then went on to say that the inspectorate had acknowledged that its new approach, when fully implemented, would provide a robust model for dealing with the past.


However when contacted by the BBC, the CJI got in touch with the ombudsman office.

Following contact between the two bodies, the ombudsman's office then agreed to retract that element of the statement.

The BBC understands that the CJI made it clear that it had never given such an acknowledgement.

On Wednesday, Deputy First Minister John O'Dowd called Mr Hutchinson to resign immediately.

He was echoing a call made by the former chief executive of the ombudsman's office, Sam Pollock, in the BBC Spotlight documentary on Tuesday.

Spotlight found evidence of failings in Police Ombudsman investigations into complaints about three murders

  • John Larmour - The RUC constable was shot dead in south Belfast in 1988.The Police Ombudsman's office upheld a complaint in 2008 by his son, Gavin, that the police did not carry out a proper investigation. Al Hutchinson's report also said that not all information available to the police was given to the detectives trying to find the killer but it failed to tell him that the information was withheld to protect an informer.
  • Eugene Dalton - One of three people who was killed by an IRA bomb in the Creggan area of Londonderry in 1988. The Dalton family have said they have no confidence in the ombudsman investigation. A draft report into the bombing said there was evidence that the police knew about the bomb in advance but failed to warn the public. That report was later changed to say police did not know about the bomb.
  • Denis Donaldson - The self-confessed republican informer was shot dead at a remote cottage in Donegal in April 2006. The ombudsman declared the case closed in 2010 with a finding of 'no misconduct' by the police. Spotlight established that investigators were not aware of a potentially vital piece of information that may shed light on what happened in Donegal, a journal he was writing about his life. Investigators also failed to interview a special branch handler Mr Donaldson's family believe may have information about what happened.

The programme revealed details of tensions within the office which led to Mr Pollock's resignation.

Mr O'Dowd revealed he had discussions about Mr Hutchinson's future with First Minister Peter Robinson on Wednesday.

Mr Hutchinson has already said that he will leave his role next June.

The Office of the First and Deputy First Minister has the power to dismiss him, but Mr O'Dowd said Mr Hutchinson should pre-empt such a move by going at once.

"Al Hutchinson no longer has any positive role to play in reshaping policing in this society," he said.

"Every day he remains in office he is damaging the credibility of a very important part to the new beginning to policing in this society."

Mr O'Dowd said he would be having further discussions with Mr Robinson on Thursday.

Mr Hutchinson's predecessor as Police Ombudsman, Baroness Nuala O'Loan was also critical of the performance of the office but did not go as far as calling for his resignation.


"I think that is a matter for Mr Hutchison and the Office of the First and Deputy First Minister," she said.

"What I am really, really concerned about is how do you get the office back running as an efficient, independent, civilian, oversight body for policing in Northern Ireland?

"I think the question is how do we solve the problem quickly, what would enable the office to get up and running again and I think the ombudsman will be thinking about those things very seriously tonight."

Mr Pollock resigned in April because he had lost confidence in the direction and independence of the office.

He held his post for over 10 years.

In a letter explaining his decision to quit his £90,000 a year job, Mr Pollock claimed that there had been political interference in the work of the office, and a lowering of operational independence between it and the PSNI.

On Wednesday, a spokesman for the ombudsman's office said: "Following the broadcast of last night's television programme, a number of families who had made complaints to us about cases involving deaths during the Troubles left letters into our offices this morning.

"Their concerns largely go to the issue of confidence in our ability to investigate matters from the past.

"We are working to revise our procedures in this area."

In September, a report by the CJI said the office's operational independence had been lowered, and that Mr Hutchinson had lost the trust of senior colleagues.

It was the third highly critical report to be published into the work of the organisation.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites


BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.