Green Deal complaints lead to Tivium refunds

Adam Harvey Adam Harvey handed over £199 upfront but has not received a new boiler and must rely on his old one

People who said they were let down by a firm offering services under a government energy saving scheme are to get refunds after a BBC investigation.

Gateshead-based Tivium Limited charges up to £299 to assess homes for improvements including new boilers as part of the government's Green Deal.

But after the BBC highlighted delays, three customers have won refunds.

Tivium has blamed the Green Deal scheme for delays and has agreed to refund fees for three customers.

Under the scheme, households can use loans to spend on energy-saving improvements, such as insulation and new boilers, with no upfront cost.

The customers whose cases were highlighted by the BBC waited up to 10 months and either did not receive assessment reports or failed to have new equipment installed.

Adam Harvey, from Cramlington, Northumberland, received a cold call from Tivium in July 2013 and handed over £199 for his report, which he eventually received. But he has so far been unable to get Tivium to fit a new boiler.

'Teething problems'

Dave Alexander, from Sacriston, County Durham, who paid £299 to Tivium in August of last year, added: "The guy's very words to me were 'Look, we need this £299 to go ahead, but don't worry about it, you can't lose it because at the end of the day if you decide that you're not happy with it you'll get your money returned.'"

He has yet to receive an assessment report.

John Clement from Barnard Castle, County Durham, also paid £299 last August and has so far not received a Green Deal report or new boiler.

After being contacted by the BBC, Tivium offered to refund all of three customers and in the cases of Mr Alexander and Mr Clement, offered a £50 gift voucher.

Boiler Less than 1% of Tivium's 6,000 Green Deal assessments have resulted in equipment being installed

The firm claims it has a complaint rate of less than 1.5% and blamed "teething problems" with the Green Deal for the delays.

But the company has admitted that of 6,000 Green Deal assessments it has carried out, less than 1% have resulted in equipment being installed.

A spokesman added that it hoped the situation would improve rapidly in the coming months.

The firm is being investigated by STROMA, the organisation that accredits Green Deal installers.

STROMA said it was investigating Tivium Green Deal Installers Ltd and its marketing company Tivium Ltd for potential breaches of the Green Deal code of practice.

Tivium said discussions with STROMA were ongoing and that it was confident they would result in STROMA's "full satisfaction".

The government acknowledges there have been problems with the Green Deal with a low initial take-up, but said more than £16m had been handed out since it was re-launched last month.

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Tyne & Wear


Newcastle upon Tyne

9 °C 8 °C

BBC Local Live

    14:44: Wareham hopes to continue Matt Newsum BBC Sport

    Newcastle United women's goalkeeper Laura Wareham hopes to continue playing despite suffering a suspected broken neck for a second time.

    Wareham, 21, suffered the injury midway through the first half of Sunday's 3-2 defeat by Bradford and continued on before she was eventually withdrawn. Having broken her neck in 2011, she had an X-ray that showed a break, although a CT scan came back clear.

    Laura Wareham

    "I can't wait to be back, it doesn't scare me," she said, "I just cannot wait to get my boots on and gloves on and get back training with the girls."

    14:34: Give us your feedback

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? It's written by reporters across the North East and brings you the latest news, sport, travel and weather all in one place. We'd like your feedback about this service.

    14:27: Keeping tabs on Dolan Hartlepool Mail
    14:10: No loans for Boro

    Middlesbrough FC tweets: Aitor Karanka has confirmed to the media that he doesn't expect any loan incomings before today's 5pm deadline.

    13:58: News on the hour

    The top local headlines at 14:00 include:

    13:43: Hughes' death 'so tragic' Martin Emmerson BBC Newcastle

    Australia Test batsman Phillip Hughes has died aged 25, two days after being struck by a ball during a domestic match in Sydney.

    George Alberts Vice President North East Durham Cricket League has said: "What a sad day hearing about the tragic death of Australian cricketer Phil Hughes.

    "We all thought helmets would stop anything like this happening but the one in a million chance has led to his death at the age of 25. So so tragic."

    13:25: Lunchtime TV Nisha Joshi BBC Look North

    Some of our region's best talent was honoured at the North East Sport Awards last night at the Billingham Forum. Look North's Jeff Brown and BBC Tees' Ali Brownlee were the hosts.

    Women collecting award

    There were prizes for some of the most recognisable faces from our region's sporting world - but those at grassroots level were rewarded too. I'll have a round up of who won what on BBC Look North at 13:30 on BBC One.

    13:11: Tax levy 'slap in the face'

    The north east's largest business organisation is warning devolution of tax powers to Scotland could harm the local economy.

    Newcastle International Airport

    The North East Chamber of Commerce claims granting our neighbours over the border the ability to set Air Passenger Duty - a tax levied on flights from the UK - would be a "slap in the face for north east business".

    Mark Stephenson, policy and research manager, said: "The government must set out, at the earliest opportunity, how English airports such as those close to the border will be protected should these measures be introduced."

    12:58: News on the hour

    The top local headlines at 13:00 include:

    • BBC Newcastle: A coroner in County Durham has broken down in tears while summing up the inquest into the death of a soldier killed in Afghanistan
    • BBC Tees: Middlesbrough and Thornaby are to get direct rail services to London, as part of a new franchise deal for the East Coast mainline
    12:44: ECB postpones announcement Martin Emmerson BBC Newcastle

    Understandably, following the death of Australian cricketer Phil Hughes, the ECB has taken the decision today to postpone the publication of the 2015 fixtures.

    Phil Hughes

    I understand next year's county cricket fixtures, including those for Durham, will now be published tomorrow instead at 10:30.

    Hughes died aged 25, two days after being struck on the neck by a ball during a domestic match in Sydney.

    12:26: MP's East Coast fears

    Darlington's Labour MP Jenny Chapman tweets: Deep concern in Darlo at possible loss of services on East Coast Line. Faster trains to N'cstle at our expense unacceptable.

    12:11: Keeper 'breaks neck' The Chronicle Newspaper
    11:58: News on the hour

    The top local headlines at 12:00 include:

    • BBC Newcastle: Members of the North East Sunday League have given their support to the man removed as vice president of Northumberland Football Association in a sexism row
    • BBC Tees: The new East Coast rail operators say they hope to be running direct services from Middlesbrough to London by 2020
    11:41: Stagecoach shares Joe Miller BBC News

    Shares in Stagecoach are up more than 8% following the announcement that it won the East Coast rail franchise. Meanwhile, rivals FirstGroup are down 5.6%.

    Inter City Railways, as the consortium is being dubbed, is not an even partnership between Stagecoach and Virgin. The former holds 90% of the capital.

    11:21: Fuel spill

    Drivers are being warned of disruption on the A695 at Blaydon between the Stargate Roundabout and B6315 junction.

    A fuel spillage has caused hazardous conditions, BBC Travel reports.

    11:09: Almost 900 die from liver disease The Chronicle Newspaper
    10:57: News on the hour

    The top local headlines at 11:00 include:

    10:49: Two hurt in crash

    Two people were taken to the minor injuries unit of the Queen Elizabeth Hospital in Gateshead following this morning's crash involving a bus and a car on the A184.

    A North East Ambulance Service spokesman said they were both reporting back pains.

    10:36: Couple die hours apart Hartlepool Mail
    10:27: Go North East disruption

    Go North East tweets: Due to an incident on the Felling Bypass near Whitemare Pool Roundabout, diversions are in place on a few services.

    #57 diverted from Wardley Slip Road onto Sunderland Rd, will turn at Wardley Terminus and will pick up from the first stop on Sunderland Rd.

    Southbound #X9 & #X10 - diverted onto Wardley Bridge along Lingey Lane & Follingsby Park, then normal route from Whitemare Pool Roundabout.

    10:17: Latest on A184 crash

    Police and ambulances are at the scene of a crash on the A184 because of an accident involving bus and a car. Northumbria Police has confirmed it received a call at about 09:10 but have no information yet on casualties.

    A194 bus and car crash

    There remains very slow traffic and one is lane closed on the A184 Newcastle Road eastbound in Washington between the A194 Leam Lane junction and Testo's Roundabout. More on BBC Travel News for Teesside and Tyne and Wear.

    10:07: More on Franchise takeover

    The East Coast franchise has been in public hands since 2009 but has now been taken over by a consortium made up of Stagecoach and Virgin.

    Mick Cash, RMT general secretary said the contract was "an act of utter betrayal".

    He said: "The government has confirmed that it is bulldozing ahead with the re-privatisation of the East Coast Main Line despite all the figures showing that the current public sector operator is handing over a billion pounds back to the British people while delivering huge improvements in service and customer satisfaction."

    09:59: News on the hour

    The top local headlines at 10:00 include:

    09:44: Mclean wins gong

    England's rugby world cup winning captain Katy Mclean has been named BBC North East Sports Personality of the Year.

    The title was announced at the BBC North East Sports Awards at the Forum Theatre in Billingham last night.

    Katy Mclean

    Other winners included Sunderland Ladies FC, Paralympian Jade Jones and basketball coach Fabulous Flournoy. Rowing coach Graeme Mark won the unsung hero award and will now go forward to the national awards.

    09:32: Bus and car accident

    There's very slow traffic on A184 Newcastle Road eastbound in Washington at the A194 Leam Lane junction because of an accident involving bus and a car. More on BBC Travel News for Teesside and Tyne and Wear.

    09:24: Washington stabbing: Man charged

    A 34-year-old man has been charged with attempted murder after a woman was stabbed in Washington.

    The woman, who remains in hospital in a stable condition, was stabbed at about 06:40 on Wednesday, Northumbria Police says.

    The man will appear at Sunderland Magistrates' Court later.

    09:07: 'Deliver for tax payer'

    Responding to the consortium made up of Stagecoach and Virgin that has won the franchise to run the East Coast mainline rail route, Transport Secretary Patrick McLoughlin said it will deliver for the tax payer.

    He said: "This is a fantastic deal for passengers and for staff on this vital route. It gives passengers more seats, more services and new trains.

    "We are putting passengers at the heart of the service. I believe Stagecoach and Virgin will not only deliver for customers but also for the British taxpayer."

    08:59: News on the hour

    The top local headlines at 09:00 include:

    08:51: Woman criticises ambulance chiefs The Shields Gazette
    08:41: Drive to arrive

    Cleveland Police tweets: Heavy rain and lots of surface water about, so give yourself extra time for your journey this morning #drivetoarrive

    08:24: Rail route bid winners revealed

    A consortium made up of Stagecoach and Virgin has won the franchise to run the East Coast mainline rail route.

    The firms promised to invest £140m in the route over eight years, and will pay the government £3.3bn for the contract.

    East Coast franchise

    The franchise, which covers the North East routes between London and Edinburgh, has been publicly run since 2009. The RMT union called the return of the franchise to the private sector "a national disgrace".

    08:15: Cloudy and misty Kay Crewdson Weather Presenter, BBC Look North

    A cloudy and misty day with occasional rain or drizzle, together with extensive low cloud and hill fog. Rain will become more patchy later in the day. Cool with a southeasterly breeze.

    Weather forecast

    Maximum temperature: 9C (48F). Check the forecast near you.

    08:04: Traffic light failure

    There's slow traffic on the A19 westbound between the A1018 junction in Seaton and Herrington interchange in Doxford Park.

    Slow traffic on A172 Stokesley Road in Marton at the B1380 Ladgate Lane junction because of a traffic light failure. More on BBC Travel News for Teesside and Tyne and Wear.

    08:00: Good morning Lloyd Watson BBC News

    Welcome to BBC Local Live. I'll be bringing you news, sport, weather and travel updates from across the North East.

    If you'd like us to feature your comments or pictures, send them to us by email, tweet us @BBCNewsNE or join our Facebook page.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.