Clive Mantle: Ear-bite attackers 'like hyenas'

Clive Mantle Clive Mantle appeared in the TV series Casualty and later Holby City

Related Stories

Former Casualty actor Clive Mantle has told a court how his ear was partly bitten off in an attack by two men who felled him "like two hyenas bringing down an old water buffalo".

Giving evidence at Newcastle Crown Court, he said it happened in a hotel corridor after Philip McGilvray, 33, and Alan French, 32, had woken him up.

He said a "melee" ensued as he tried to push past them to take his complaint to Newcastle Quayside Travelodge staff.

The pair deny wounding with intent.

'Absolute pearlers'

The 56-year-old Game of Thrones star, who was working locally, told the court his ear was bitten three times outside his room in the attack on 24 March.

Clive Mantle leaving Newcastle Crown Court Clive Mantle has been left permanently disfigured

He said he had twice asked the men to be quiet and was on his way to the hotel's reception when they laid into him.

Mr Mantle said the pair threw many punches, landing "four absolute pearlers".

"I remember being attacked by two men with every blow they had in their armoury," he told the court.

The actor told the jury his ear was bitten while he was pinned to the floor.

But Robin Patton, defending Mr McGilvray, accused Mr Mantle of losing his temper and running at the two men, who are both from Hamilton.

He said the actor knocked Mr McGilvray to the ground and ended up on top of him.

"You took out Philip McGilvray, he did not stand a chance and with your weight, you took him to the ground," Mr Patton said.

The actor replied "absolutely not" and said he was "flabbergasted" at this claim.

'Ear on carpet'

On Tuesday, Mr Mantle told the court that his "guardian angel" Alice Klenk, a nurse who was staying at the hotel, had heard the fighting and came out of her room.

She grabbed the drunken defendants by the scruff of the neck to stop the attack, the jury heard.

Mr Mantle told the court that after her intervention he "looked down on the floor and there was my ear lying on the carpet".

The prosecution has said there is no dispute about what Mr McGilvray did and that Mr French faces the same charge because of his joint responsibility.

The trial continues.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Tyne & Wear


Newcastle upon Tyne

20 °C 15 °C

BBC Local Live

    Bus fare 'could be £1,000' 11:31: Fergus Hewison BBC Newcastle political reporter

    At a meeting about Northumberland County Council's plans to charge over-16s for school and college transport, one mother has said sending her daughter to school on public transport could now cost her £1,000.

    Strike a pose... 11:21: Jonathan Miles BBC Newcastle

    Ahead of a big event in Newcastle city centre tomorrow and Sunday, I've been "expressing myself" through the medium of dance...

    It's all part of The Big Dance Weekend coming our way. You can watch the video here.

    Jonathan Miles
    Give us your feedback 11:10:

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? We'd like your feedback about this service.

    News on the hour 10:59:

    The top headlines at 11:00 include:

    Show me the way to go home... 10:51:

    More details are coming out this morning about a government geography blunder we told you about yesterday.

    Google map

    After first saying Northumberland was in the North West, it turns out the Department for Transport also thought Warrington was in the North East.

    Police searching for flasher 10:42: The Gazette Newspaper

    Police are still hunting for a man who exposed himself to two young girls in Coulby Newham, Teesside.

    Head faces retrial on child sex allegations 10:30:

    A County Durham head teacher will face a retrial over allegations she had sex with a 13-year-old boy in the late 1980s.

    Anne Lakey, 54, had denied four counts of indecent assault and two of indecency with a child. A jury at Durham Crown Court last week failed to reach any verdicts.

    Anne Lakey

    Mrs Lakey, a married mother-of-one from Stanley, was a history teacher in Sunderland at the time of the allegations. Prosecutor Caroline Goodwin said the retrial will start on 19 January.

    Meeting 'has cost £80,000' 10:19: Fergus Hewison BBC Newcastle political reporter

    The Labour leader of Northumberland County Council, Grant Davey, claims today's special meeting on post-16 transport charges has cost £80,000. He added he hopes the £600 charge for school and college transport will stay "as it is".

    Girl out of coma after smash 10:09: Newcastle Chronicle

    A four-year-old girl is shining brighter than ever just weeks after coming out of a coma from a car crash which almost killed her.

    News on the hour 09:59:

    The top headlines at 10:00 include:

    School travel cuts 'could save £2.5m' 09:50: BBC Newcastle

    From September, Northumberland County Council wants to start charging students and pupils who are over 16 to travel to and from school and college. It could save the Labour-run authority almost £2.5m a year.

    There are exceptions, but many students will have to pay for public transport or pay a flat fee of £600 a year. But the council has been forced to call an extraordinary meeting to hear from those against the plans.

    School transport charges protest 09:40: Fergus Hewison BBC Newcastle political reporter

    I'm at a protest against plans to charge for post-16 transport to school and college in Northumberland.


    No filming is allowed, but imminent legislation will change this.

    Top Headlines
    Arsenal set for NUFC moves 09:30:

    Arsenal have often had a Gallic flavour, but now it seem that's set to increase with bids for current and former Newcastle United players.

    BBC Sport reports they are still on course to sign French right-back Mathieu Debuchy, 28, from the Magpies, plus The Independent says they are also in negotiations for the £8m transfer of striker Loic Remy, who's now back at QPR.

    Newcastle striker Loic Remy

    There's more transfer talk in the Gossip Column.

    Nice and easy does it 09:19:

    There doesn't seem to be much to get commuters stressed this morning. Traffic on the roads is mostly running smoothly, as is the Tyne and Wear Metro.

    You can check out the latest on the BBC Travel News website.

    Weight surgery 'last resort' 09:10:

    A specialist at Newcastle University says surgery is effective in tackling type 2 diabetes but should be a last resort.

    Draft guidelines from the National Institute of Health and Care Excellence say there should be an expansion of weight loss surgery in England to tackle an epidemic of the condition.

    Professor Roy Taylor says: "We've been able to show that this is purely a matter of reducing the body fat - specifically the fat in liver and pancreas. Now this can be done with diet. Some people are able to do this, and if they can do it, then that's by far the best way, even though this is quite a safe operation. You really don't want an operation unless you can avoid it."

    News on the hour 08:59:

    The top stories at 09:00 include

    North Sea oil 'worth less' 08:51: David Rhodes Politics Reporter, BBC North East and Cumbria

    This will be of interest to the 50,000 North East England oil and gas workers. North Sea oil 'worth billions less than expected'.

    On the air right now 08:40: BBC Newcastle

    In a few minutes we'll be hearing from the transplant co-ordinator at the Freeman Hospital about the remarkable story of a family who donated their son's heart to a man from North Shields - and then met him and felt it beating five years later.

    Break is as good as a rest 08:32:

    Olympic lightweight double sculls champion Kat Copeland has said a break from competition helped to keep her focused on the Rio Games in 2016.

    Kat Copeland

    Ashington-born Copeland, who trained at Tees Rowing Club, took the sabbatical after winning gold at London 2012 with now retired team-mate Sophie Hosking.

    Wonga no longer as church ends interest 08:21:

    The Church of England has ended its investment in Newcastle United sponsor and payday lender Wonga.

    Wonga logo

    The Archbishop of Canterbury, Justin Welby, last year pledged to try to put Wonga out of business, but it later emerged that the church had indirectly staked about £75,000 in the company.

    Fire calls during strikes 08:11:

    Tyne and Wear Fire and Rescue Service was called out 23 times during yesterday's strike action, bosses have announced.

    There were 10 incidents involving alarms, two building fires, one road accident and 10 rubbish fires. Cover was provided by people who were successful in interviews but for whom there were no vacancies, as well as former military and specialist personnel.

    Chief Fire Officer Tom Capeling said: "The FBU is planning further discontinuous strike action over an eight-day period between Monday 14 and Monday 21 July, so I am asking the public and business owners to continue to take extra care with fire safety during these latest periods of strike action."

    Cloudy with showers 08:06: Kawser Quamer Presenter, BBC Weather

    After a cloudy start there could be one or two showers before becoming dry later.

    Weather map

    That could will keep temperatures down a degree or two at 20C (68F). Check the forecast where you live.

    Good morning 08:00: Francesca Williams BBC News

    Welcome to BBC Local Live this morning. I'll be bringing you news, sport, weather and travel updates from across the North East.

    If you'd like us to feature your comments or pictures, send them to us by email, tweet us @BBCNewsNE or join our Facebook page.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.