EE manager's office kicking case sacking unfair, tribunal rules

Fay Hand Fay Hand worked for EE for 17 years before the sacking over alleged office bullying

Related Stories

A manager sacked from a call centre after a member of her staff kicked a colleague unconscious was unfairly dismissed, a tribunal has ruled.

Fay Hand was dismissed from EE in Darlington, where she had worked for 17 years, amid accusations of failing to tackle alleged bullying in the office.

The tribunal judge ruled her sacking had been "pre-judged".

Mrs Hand said she fought the sacking to restore her reputation and said the dismissal damaged her career.

The mother-of-two, from Wynyard Village near Stockton, said: "The whole thing was handled so badly, that's why I had to fight it.

"It was 17 years of my life, I loved my job and was devastated when I was dismissed."

Car keys stolen

The tribunal concluded Mrs Hand had an unblemished record and was "clearly a highly-regarded and valued employee".

The hearing was told the member of staff who attacked a colleague had grown angry when a colleague stole his car keys and took a Fifa video game from the car as ransom.

A month later when his security pass was defaced with a permanent marker he "flipped" and kicked his victim at his desk, knocking him unconscious.

The attacker was immediately suspended and the next day came to work with a three-page statement, setting out what had been happening, and claiming the security pass incident was the "last straw".

He claimed his team leader and operations manager Mrs Hand did not take his complaints seriously.

Mundane and repetitive

EE sacked seven employees, including the victim, the kicker, the team leader and Mrs Hand. The firm said she failed to protect the employee and breached its policy on harassment and bullying.

Tribunal judge Mr Johnson wrote that call centre work could be "somewhat mundane and repetitive" and that there were "occasional incidents of banter".

He ruled managers held a wholly inadequate investigation into Mrs Hand's actions and that her dismissal was pre-judged.

Mrs Hand, who has now found new employment, is adamant she missed out on other jobs because of the sacking on her record.

She said: "It did make it much harder to find another job.

"I do believe that while I was speaking to potential employers about the reasons for me leaving EE it was hard for people to appreciate my side of the story."

EE has not responded to BBC requests for a comment.

More on This Story

Related Stories

BBC Tees

Weather

Middlesbrough

19 °C 14 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    Your pictures: View from monument 11:10:

    Chris Farish from Gateshead went up on top of Grey's Monument in Newcastle and sent us this picture of his view.

    View from monument

    You can send your pictures by email or tweet @BBCNewsNE.

     
  2.  
    News on the hour 10:59:

    The top local headlines at 11:00 include:

     
  3.  
    Leadbitter to return 10:48:

    Middlesbrough will move into a play-off spot if they can take three points against Blackpool at the Riverside tonight.

    Boro will be without midfielder Dean Whitehead who completes a three-game ban, while Albert Adomah also serves a suspension.

    Midfielder and top scorer Grant Leadbitter, who was rested against Charlton, is likely to return; striker Jelle Vossen is struggling with a hamstring problem.

     
  4.  
    How did you learn about sex? 10:31: Jonathan Miles BBC Newcastle

    When it comes to sex education for children, should it be on the school curriculum, or should it be up to parents?

    Call BBC Newcastle on 0191 232 6565 or join the conversation on Facebook. Tina Palmer writes: When I was 12 I found a book under my pillow that my mother had left. It was about how babies were made.

     
  5.  
    Roker Riviera 10:21: Martin Emmerson BBC Newcastle

    It's a beautiful morning on the "Roker Riviera" this morning, it's really warm too. An Indian summer perhaps?

    Roker marina in Sunderland
     
  6.  
    'No NUFC crisis talks' 10:15:

    Press Association Sport reports there will be no "crisis" talks between Newcastle owner Mike Ashley and Alan Pardew this week and that the manager will remain in charge for Saturday's trip to Swansea, "and beyond whatever happens at the Liberty Stadium".

     
  7.  
    Give us your feedback 10:11:

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? We'd like your feedback about this service.

     
  8.  
    News on the hour 10:00:

    The top local headlines at 10:00 include:

     
  9.  
    Sunderland cannabis farm 09:47:

    Up to 50 cannabis plants have been found in Ryhope Road in Sunderland.

    The farm was discovered at about 01:40 after police received a report of "suspicious men" in the area. No-one was in the address at the time and officers are trying to trace the occupants.

    Sgt Mark Thompson said: "Reporting suspicious activity is exactly the right thing to do and in this case officers made inquiries and recovered cannabis plants."

     
  10.  
    101 only non-emergency number 09:35:

    From 1 October the only number to call to contact the police in a non-emergency will be 101, Cleveland Police said.

    The 326326 number will be de-activated and a recorded message will advise the caller to contact 101.

    This date coincides with the introduction of all local landline calls in the area requiring the addition of the area code 01642 preceding the telephone number.

     
  11.  
    Stab death: Man charged 09:22:

    A man has been charged with the murder of a man stabbed on North Tyneside.

    The 43-year-old victim was found with a single stab wound in Aldwych Drive, North Shields, early on Saturday but died in hospital shortly afterwards.

    A 22-year-old man will appear at North Tyneside Magistrates' Court later. Two men aged 27 and 21 who were arrested on suspicion of grievous bodily harm and a woman, 22, held on suspicion of murder have been released on bail.

     
  12.  
    Stoke 1-0 Newcastle 09:13:

    Peter Crouch's early header secured Stoke a first home Premier League win of the season and increased the pressure on Newcastle boss Alan Pardew.

    Crouch rose to meet a Victor Moses cross from the left in the 15th minute. Newcastle were fortunate not to concede a penalty when Moses was bundled over in the area by Yoan Gouffran.

    Stoke v Newcastle

    Marko Arnautovic was denied by a post before Newcastle's Jack Colback thumped against the bar late on to leave the visitors second bottom of the table.

     
  13.  
    News on the hour 08:59:

    The top local headlines at 09:00 include:

     
  14.  
    How to prevent tooth decay 08:52: Nicki Hornby BBC Newcastle

    One in 10 three-year-olds in the North East has tooth decay and Public Health England found that much of that decay was caused by sugary drinks.

    This is totally preventable. Why are children consuming so much sugar?

    Call BBC Newcastle on 0191 232 6565 or join the conversation on Facebook.

     
  15.  
    'If we lose he's gone' 08:44:

    Vivek Chaudhary, journalist for The Independent, describes his chance meeting with Mike Ashley where the Newcastle owner suggested manager Alan Pardew had "one more game", adding "If we lose against Stoke on Monday night then he's gone. I have had enough."

    Mike Ashley

    The quotes were downplayed on Friday by Ashley's lawyer as a joke "intended to be tongue-in-cheek". However the journalist insisted "at no time did I get a sense it was tongue-in-cheek". Newcastle lost 1-0 against Stoke on Monday night.

     
  16.  
    Bridge work to cost 'extra £200k' 08:33: Lisa McCormick BBC Tees

    Commuters using the A19 have told BBC tees they remain frustrated by the ongoing closure of the Newport Bridge.

    The bridge - which has been closed for repainting and repair work - was originally supposed to reopen at the start of this month.

    That's been pushed back to the end of October, costing the council an extra £200,000.

     
  17.  
    Spider bite woman loses finger 08:19:

    A story you might have missed from yesterday was the tale of a woman who has had a finger amputated - and who was told she was within hours of death - after being bitten by a false widow spider.

    Andrea Wallace, from Seaham, County Durham, was bitten in a Sunderland park and described the result as "like something out of a horror movie".

    Woman with missing finger

    The attack left her with the flesh-eating bug necrotising fasciitis, which required 10 weeks in hospital. False widows are the UK's most venomous spider but extreme reactions are rare.

     
  18.  
    Dry with sunny spells 08:11: Lisa Gallagher Weather Presenter, BBC Look North

    Many places will have a dry day, with warm bright or sunny spells, especially across eastern areas once early mist, fog or low cloud clears. Although later in the day outbreaks of rain will cross from the northwest, mainly over the Pennines.

    Weather forecast

    Maximum temperature: 20C (68F). Check the forecast near you.

     
  19.  
    Top headlines
     
  20.  
    Broken down car 08:03:

    One lane is blocked on the A19 northbound in Middlesbrough between the A66 junction and Portrack Interchange because of a broken down car.

    There's also very slow traffic on the A1 Western Bypass southbound between the Hexham turn off in Newcastle and the Dunston Interchange in Gateshead. More on BBC Travel News for Teesside and Tyne and Wear.

     
  21.  
    Good morning 08:00: Lloyd Watson BBC News

    Welcome to BBC Local Live. I'll be bringing you news, sport, weather and travel updates from across the North East.

    If you'd like us to feature your comments or pictures, send them to us by email, tweet us @BBCNewsNE or join our Facebook page.

     

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.