Ex police chair Dave McLuckie dismisses 'wasteful' probe

Dave McLuckie Dave McLuckie was jailed for perverting the course of justice

A former police authority chairman has branded a probe into alleged expenses corruption as misleading and a "waste of money".

Dave McLuckie, ex-chairman of Cleveland Police Authority, was investigated along with nine others as part of Operation Sacristy.

No-one was ever charged, although he was jailed as part of another inquiry into perverting the course of justice.

Cleveland Police said that senior posts should undergo "public scrutiny".

Details of expenses claimed by Mr McLuckie and others have been published on the website of Cleveland Police.

But Mr McLuckie said the majority of the £123,000 he spent over five years, listed in the expenses sections, was the allowance to which he was entitled as the chairman of the police authority.

The former Labour councillor said his actual expenses during that period were £25,000, for mileage and subsistence.

"I have no problem with making public the allowances and expenses I received as a member of the police.

"But the manner in which information has been presented by the force is totally misleading," he said.

The 52-year-old, of Great Ayton, North Yorkshire, was jailed last year for perverting the course of justice because he persuaded a friend to take speeding points to avoid a driving ban.

The offence - unrelated to Sacristy - came to light during its investigation.

'Smear tactics'

Operation Sacristy, which cost £4.6m, came to an end last week with the announcement that no-one would face criminal charges.

Those behind the investigation said it was justified because it led to the dismissal of the Chief Constable Sean Price and his deputy Derek Bonnard.

Mr McLuckie said: "This report was supposed to be about conduct issues relating to Mr Price and Mr Bonnard, but a large element of it had nothing to do with that and was in fact a blatant attempt to use smear tactics to deflect from the fact that Operation Sacristy was a disastrous waste of time and money and to protect those who bear responsibility for its failure."

Sean Price and Derek Bonnard Sean Price and Derek Bonnard were both dismissed

A spokesman for Cleveland Police said: "The material has been published under a Freedom of Information Publication Scheme and not as Mr McLuckie suggests, as part of a 'catalogue of smears and innuendo'.

"Two chief officers were dismissed, one chief officer and a senior police officer resigned, and Mr McLuckie served a prison sentence for matters investigated by the IPCC and Operation Sacristy."

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Tees



2 °C -1 °C

BBC Local Live

    11:43: Road reopens Danny Savage North of England Correspondent, BBC News

    The A66 has just reopened eastbound between Brough and Bowes. No sign of anything going west yet.

    11:30: Truck catches fire after skid Lloyd Watson BBC News

    David Parry took this photo of a fruit and vegetable truck getting into trouble in Hunwick, County Durham.

    He said: "The driver got into trouble with the snow and ice, almost reaching the top of the hill, before sliding backwards down it again. Then in trying to drive out of the position he had got stuck in, two tyres set on fire - and the fire then spread to the truck itself."

    Truck on fire in Hunwick, County Durham

    He tells us the driver is fine and the fire was put out by the fire brigade before it reached the petrol tank.

    11:22: A66 reopens

    Durham Police says the A66 is now open in both directions.

    11:11: Snow in Consett Anthony Day BBC Newcastle

    Depending on where you are in the North East this morning, you'll either have lots of snow or just a dusting.

    I've been in Consett in County Durham and I believe this video reflects the situation here.

    Snow in

    You can send your pictures by email to northeast.locallive@bbc.co.uk or tweet @BBCNewsNE.

    11:06: Roads still closed by snow

    The A68 High Street is still closed between the B6297 Wolsingham Road junction in Tow Law and the Drover Road junction in Rowley, because of snow.

    The B6275 closed between the A68 junction in Bildershaw and the A67 junction in Piercebridge, because of snow. More on BBC Travel News for Teesside and Tyne and Wear.

    10:58: Your photos: Weardale in snow

    St John's Chapel in Weardale has had its fair share of snow this morning. Sarah Lee sent us this picture of a memorial covered in snow.

    Memorial coveredin snow

    You can send your pictures by email to northeast.locallive@bbc.co.uk or tweet @BBCNewsNE.

    10:49: Your photos: dog in snow

    Bella the dog doesn't let a bit of snow get in the way of a morning walk in Tow Law, County Durham.

    We're not sure if David Bartles-Smith, who sent us this picture, agrees or not.

    Dog in snow

    You can send your pictures by email to northeast.locallive@bbc.co.uk or tweet @BBCNewsNE.

    10:43: Your photos: Snowy park

    John Chambers took this photo at his local park in South Moor in Stanley, County Durham.

    Snow in Stanley

    You can send your pictures by email to northeast.locallive@bbc.co.uk or tweet @BBCNewsNE.

    10:34: Foot deep of snow... Anthony Day BBC Newcastle

    I couldn't resist putting my foot in it. It's a good job I brought my wellies with me to work today.

    Snow in Consett
    10:27: Lane closed on A1

    Still some problems on the roads across the North East - One lane is closed and there's queuing traffic on the A1 Western Bypass southbound in Newcastle before the Kenton Bar Roundabout because of an accident involving two cars and recovery work. Congestion is back to Gosforth Park.

    And one lane is closed on the A689 Stockton Road eastbound in Greatham between the Dalton Back Lane junction and the High Street junction because of an accident involving car and lorry.

    Get more on BBC Travel News for Teesside and Tyne and Wear.

    10:17: Your photos: Snowy footsteps

    Tracey Laing sent us this picture of footprints in the snow in Consett, County Durham.

    Snow in Consett

    You can send your pictures by email to northeast.locallive@bbc.co.uk or tweet @BBCNewsNE.

    10:10: Redcar Beacon closed due to ice

    Redcar and Cleveland Council tweets: Due to the amount of ice on the stairs and viewing platform, the Beacon is unfortunately closed.

    10:05: Snow on the fields

    Martin tweeted our weather forecaster Kay Crewdson with this photo of Easington in County Durham.

    Easington in the snow
    09:59: Snow starts again on A66

    Durham police tweets: The Big Push to clear the A66 however it's just started to snow again. We'll keep trying to get the road clear

    Gritters on the A66
    09:51: Snow closes runway

    We know some people go from Manchester Airport too, and there's been real problems there - snow has closed the runway and there'll be no flights before 10:30. Our BBC colleagues in the North West have the latest.

    09:48: Some Newcastle flights cancelled

    There's a few delays and cancellations at Newcastle Airport today.

    Arrivals: Flight EZY548 from Belfast was due to land at 09:10 but has been delayed to 10:21, while flight 4U9338 from Dusseldorf has been cancelled.

    Departures: Flight 4U9339 to Dusseldorf has also been cancelled. Get the latest here.

    09:38: Your photos: Town moor

    Jeff Douglas sent us this picture of Newcastle's Town Moor with blue sky being revealed as the morning continues.

    Newcastle's Town Moor

    You can send your pictures by email to northeast.locallive@bbc.co.uk or tweet @BBCNewsNE.

    09:28: A66 in snow Lloyd Watson BBC News

    Here is how the A66 was looking this morning. Police are advising motorists to take care. Check the forecast near you.

    Snow on A66
    09:23: Preparing for the show... Jonathan Miles BBC Newcastle

    Well I didn't expect to be pelted with snowballs as "preparation" for my show today on BBC Newcastle.

    That's how it was sold to me anyway, I think they just wanted to throw snow at me.

    Jonathan Miles being hit with snow
    09:13: Crash on A1 Gilly Hope BBC Newcastle

    We're getting reports that a car has hit the central reservation at the Angel of the North in Gateshead. We'll have more on this once we have more details.

    09:07: A68 section closed

    The A68 High Street is closed between the B6297 Wolsingham Road junction in Tow Law, County Durham, and the Drover Road junction in Rowley because of snow.

    There's queuing traffic on the A1 southbound between Hexham turn off in Newcastle and Dunston Interchange in Gateshead in the roadworks area. And Northumbria Police says there's been crashes on the A1 Western Bypass around Gosforth with traffic tailbacks - motorists should avoid the area if possible.

    More on BBC Travel News for Teesside and Tyne and Wear.

    09:01: Take care warning after car flips

    Police in Durham say roads are still dangerous and advise motorists to take care. Keep your distance and use your gears to help control your speed.

    Car on its side
    08:50: Amber warning from the Met Office

    The Met Office has an amber warning in place for parts of the north-east of England until 11:00 and a yellow warning elsewhere and for later on.

    It says snow amounts will be very variable but more than 5cm (2in) will accumulate at lower levels in places with over 15cm (5in) on high ground. Strong and gusty winds will lead to drifting and blizzard conditions at times, especially over higher routes.

    There's more information on the Met Office website.

    08:42: Jack-knifed lorries Lloyd Watson BBC News

    Durham Road Policing Unit is tweeting a warning of several jack-knifed HGVs on the A66, which was closed east and west.

    Police car in snow

    They say it's the "less glamorous side of roads policing". We hope they've got a flask of something hot with them.

    08:34: A19 moving all right David Rhodes Politics Reporter, BBC North East and Cumbria

    I've just driven down the A19 from Newcastle to Middlesbrough and the roads were reasonably clear of snow and traffic was moving at the usual rush-hour pace, so hopefully it'll stay like that for the rest of day.

    More on BBC Travel News for Teesside and Tyne and Wear.

    08:24: 'Thundersnow' predicted Sunderland Echo

    People in the region have been warned to brace themselves for 'thundersnow storms', with snowfall up up to 6in predicted tonight.

    Traffic in snow
    08:11: A697 reopens

    The A697 has reopened in both directions between the A698 Main Street junction in Cornhill-on-Tweed and Longhorsley turn off in Espley Hall. It was closed earlier because of snow. More on BBC Travel News for Teesside and Tyne and Wear.

    07:59: News on the hour

    The top local headlines at 08:00 include:

    • BBC Newcastle: Snow has fallen across the North East but depending on where you are you'll have a dumping or a dusting.
    • BBC Tees: New figures suggest North Tees and Hartlepool NHS Trust is one of the worst performing in the country with more people dying in hospital than expected.
    07:53: Car and lorry block road

    The A689 Stockton Road in Greatham is blocked in both directions between the Dalton Back Lane junction and the High Street junction because of an accident involving a car and lorry.

    One lane is blocked on the A66(M) eastbound between A1(M) J57 Darlington and A66 Bridge Road because of an accident and recovery work.

    The A68 in Corbridge closed to high sided vehicles in both directions. More on BBC Travel News for Teesside and Tyne and Wear.

    07:45: Drifting snow

    Mark Litt has emailed us to say the road from Consett to Tow Law is only passable with a 4x4. He says there's drifting snow and abandoned cars on the route.

    Three tractors are currently clearing the road but Consett's main roads are black, he tells us.

    He also thinks the Weardale main roads are ploughed and passable with plenty of gritters and tractor ploughs out.

    07:34: Scattered wintry showers Kay Crewdson Weather Presenter, BBC Look North

    Staying cold and breezy with scattered wintry showers which could be rather heavy at times. Most of the showers will affect the Dales, North Pennines and Cheviots where some accumulations are likely. Winds will be quite gusty in the showers.

    Kay Crewdson

    Maximum temperature: 2C (36F). You can find a full forecast on the BBC Weather website.

    07:26: School closures

    The headteacher of Wolsingham School and Community College, in County Durham, has called to say the school is closed to all because of snow but is expected to reopen tomorrow.

    Whitfield Primary School and Herdley Bank Primary School, both in Northumberland, are closed today due to snow. They're also hoping to reopen tomorrow but it depends on the weather.

    Parents and students are being advised to check the schools' websites for updates.

    07:21: Snow causing some road problems

    The A697 is closed in both directions between the A698 Main Street junction in Cornhill-on-Tweed and Longhorsley Turn Off in Espley Hall because of snow.

    And the A66 is closed in both directions between the A685 junction in Brough and the A1 Scotch Corner because of snow.

    Take a look at the BBC Travel website for more updates for Tyne and Wear and Tees.

    07:15: Good morning

    Good morning and welcome to Local Live in the North East. We're starting a little earlier this morning to bring you weather and travel updates.

    There have been varying amounts of snow across the region - a dusting in some areas and more substantial quantities elsewhere.

    If you'd like us to feature your comments or pictures, send them to us by email, tweet us @BBCNewsNE or join our Facebook page.



Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.