Karl Doran death: No further action against Beamish Museum

Karl Doran Karl Doran suffered head injuries

Related Stories

No further action will be taken against a County Durham museum following the death of seven-year-old boy.

Karl Doran, from Darlington, died when he fell under the trailer of a steam traction engine driven by his father Philip at Beamish Museum in July 2012.

An inquest into his death in December recorded a verdict of accidental death.

The Health and Safety Executive (HSE) said it will be taking "no further enforcement action" following a two-year investigation into the incident.

The open air museum was issued with an improvement notice by the HSE to ensure steam engines driven by volunteers were properly risk-assessed.

Chris Gillies, HSE principal inspector, said they were "satisfied" that the risks from the use of steam traction engines at Beamish Museum were now "properly controlled".

The regulator said it would "not be in the public interest" to take further enforcement action against the museum.

Philip Doran, a volunteer at the museum, had been driving the vintage vehicle around the attraction on 22 July, with his son sitting on the tow bar. Karl went under the trailer and died of head injuries.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Tees



Min. Night 15 °C

BBC Local Live

    Cheryl parties with friends 17:40:

    Cheryl Fernandez-Versini has celebrated her surprise wedding with a party for her Girls Aloud bandmates, friends and family in London.

    Cheryl Fernandez-Versini (left)

    She married French restaurateur Jean-Bernard Fernandez-Versini two weeks ago on the Caribbean island of Mustique.

    On the programme tonight 17:27: BBC Look North

    We'll be live at the scene by the River Tees where David Zikhali was last seen swimming in the water.

    The search for the 20-year-old has been called off for the night and will start again in the morning.

    Earlier reports of a body being found proved to be incorrect. Watch Look North on BBC One at 18:30 or catch up here.

    Search called off for man 17:15: Francesca Williams BBC News

    The search for the body of a man believed to be in the River Tees has been called off for the night.

    Cleveland Police said the dive team from a neighbouring force could only spend a certain amount of time in the water and will resume the search in the morning.

    A force spokeswoman said the were now running a "recovery operation" but stressed this did not mean they had actually located a body.

    News on the hour 17:00:

    The top headlines at 17:00 include:

    • BBC Tees: A search is continuing for a missing man who got into difficulties while swimming in the River Tees
    • BBC Newcastle: Jon Harle and Anne Leuchars have a round-up of the day's news
    Digging the dirt 16:41: David MacMillan BBC Tees

    Is this the Pompeii of the North?

    Dr David Petts

    Roman Binchester Project near Durham is as hot as Southern Italy today! Hear from Dr David Petts on Neil Green's show on BBC Tees from 16:00.

    Family devastated by death 16:27:

    The family of a man who died when he fell from a cliff said they are "devastated" by his "sudden and tragic" death.

    Malcolm Hall, 51, from Skelton near Saltburn fell from cliffs at Kettleness Point near Runswick Bay, north of Whitby, on Friday morning.


    His family said he was "a friend who was there whenever they needed him". His climbing partner, a man in his 20s, was arrested on suspicion of manslaughter over the death and later bailed.

    Geordie Shore cast 'hated' rivals 16:12:

    Charlotte Crosby has told Newsbeat she and her Geordie Shore cast mates "hated" the stars of rival reality show The Valleys so much that MTV had to keep them apart, otherwise they would fight.

    Charlotte Crosby from Geordie Shore

    The eighth series of Geordie Shore starts on Tuesday, but in June it was announced The Valleys had been cancelled after three series.

    News on the hour 15:58:

    The top headlines at 16:00 include:

    • BBC Tees: A search is continuing this afternoon despite reports a body's been recovered from the River Tees in Stockton after a student entered the water last night
    • BBC Newcastle: Jon Harle and Anne Leuchars have a round-up of the day's news
    Poyet hints Nacho is off the menu 15:45:

    Sunderland head coach Gus Poyet has admitted striker Ignacio Scocco's future is likely to lie away from the club.

    Ignacio Scocco celebrating a goal during a previous spell at Newell's Old Boys

    "Nacho" was bought for £3.2m in January as Poyet tried to keep the team in the Premier League, but the 29-year-old Argentinean made only eight appearances and failed to score.

    Give us your feedback 15:30:

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? We'd like your feedback about this service.

    Family watch river operation 15:17: Adrian Pitches BBC Look North

    I'm at the riverside in Stockton where the family of missing student David Zakhali are watching as the operation to find the 20-year-old continues.

    Police at the River Tees

    There is a boat six feet off the walkway cruising slowly in one area of the river and there are still police vehicles at the scene and divers on board the boat.

    A66 in Greta Bridge closed 15:05:

    A66 in Greta Bridge is closed and there's queuing traffic westbound between The Street junction and the B6277 junction because of an accident involving a motorcycle, reports BBC Travel News.

    News on the hour 15:00:

    The top headlines at 15:00 include:

    • BBC Newcastle: The two Newcastle United fans killed on flight MH17 have been remembered at the very match they were travelling to watch in New Zealand
    • BBC Tees: A search is continuing this afternoon despite reports a body's been recovered from the River Tees in Stockton after a student entered the water last night
    Dry afternoon with light winds 14:42: Sara Thornton Weather Presenter, BBC Look North

    Everywhere will have a dry afternoon with light winds, and warm sunny spells. However, coastal areas such as Berwick will be cooler due to an onshore breeze.

    Weather forecast

    Maximum temperature: 24C (75F). Check the forecast near you.

    'No top option' for England captain 14:30:

    Former Middlesbrough player and manager Bryan Robson believes there is not a standout candidate to replace Steven Gerrard as England captain.

    Bryan Robson

    Robson, who was also assistant to Terry Venables during his spell in charge of the national team, says Man Utd striker Wayne Rooney, Man City goalkeeper Joe Hart or Chelsea defender Gary Cahill are the best options.

    Police 'deny body find' 14:09: Lloyd Watson BBC News

    We've spoken to Cleveland Police and they "categorically deny" that a body has been found in the River Tees and say that the search for a man missing in the river is continuing.

    News on the hour 13:59:

    The top headlines at 14:00 include:

    • BBC Newcastle: The Newcastle captain and manager have laid wreaths on the chairs two fans would have sat in at their match in New Zealand after they were killed on their way to watch them play
    • BBC Tees: A body is being recovered from the River Tees in Stockton after a student entered the water last night
    Body found in River Tees 13:33: BREAKING NEWS

    A body is being recovered this lunchtime from the River Tees in Stockton after a 20-year-old student entered the water last night.

    Boot camp training 13:21: Catherine Lee BBC News

    Early-risers were taking part in a boot camp at Longsands beach in Tynemouth this morning.


    You can send your pictures by email or tweet @BBCNewsNE.

    Three-parent IVF moves closer 13:07:

    A pioneering technique backed by Newcastle University which could see the creation of babies using sperm and eggs from three people has moved a step closer in the UK.

    A Department of Health public review into the three-person IVF technique has been broadly supportive.

    News on the hour 12:58:

    The top headlines at 13:00 include:

    Car hope in missing man search 12:45:

    Police searching for a missing Sunderland man they fear may have been murdered have urged anyone who recognises his car to get in touch.

    Nissan Micra

    Robert Hutchinson, 56, drove away from his home in Corporation Road, Hendon, on 23 June and was reported missing by his family three days later.

    His Nissan Micra was later recovered at the end of Stewart Street, just off Chester Road. Two men, aged 39 and 55, have been arrested on suspicion of murder and bailed.

    More on missing student search 12:33: Adrian Pitches BBC Look North

    I'm at the search for a missing student in the River Tees in Stockton. There's more on Look North at 13:30 and 18:30 tonight or catch up here.

    River Tees search
    NUFC fans remembered 12:22:

    William Gibney tweets: Quality stuff @NUFC to lay wreaths in name of the two supporters who died on #MH17 and supposed to sit in them seats

    Wreaths on seats
    Riviere scores on debut 12:11: Matthew Raisbeck BBC Newcastle

    Emmanuel Riviere (pictured left) marked his debut with a goal as Newcastle cruised to a 4-0 victory over Sydney FC in Dunedin. The striker, a £5m summer signing from Monaco, needed just 26 minutes to open his account with the Magpies taking the game by the scruff of the neck.

    Emmanuel Riviere (left)

    Newcastle scored three times in the space of 14 first-half minutes as Siem de Jong took full advantage of goalkeeper Ivan Necevski's 19th-minute error before Riviere and then defender Mapou Yanga-Mbiwa struck.

    Newcastle keeper Rob Elliot had only one save to make to deny Corey Gameiro after the break, and substitute Adam Armstrong rounded off the scoring seven minutes from time.

    News on the hour 11:59:

    The top headlines at 12:00 include:

    Man found dead in house 11:54: Stephanie Finnon BBC Newcastle

    Police are warning people about the dangers of taking illegal drugs after a man died in Gateshead.

    A man has been found dead in a house at Longhirst in the Leam Lane Estate yesterday morning. At this stage it's believed the man, aged in his 30s, had taken a drug suspected to be heroin.

    Det Insp Sharon Chatterton said: "We're carrying out inquiries to establish whether there has been drug involvement, if there has been an overdose or if there is a bad batch of drugs in circulation."

    Northumbria Taser use 'low' - PCC 11:45:

    Northumbria's Police and Crime Commissioner says Tasers are only used in "exceptional circumstances" after the police watchdog raised concerns over officers in England and Wales using Tasers at point-blank range, despite no longer being trained to do so.

    PCC Vera Baird said: "Tasers have been used very few times and official figures show that Taser use per 100 officers in our force area is one of the lowest in England and Wales.


    "There will always be a rationale for Taser use in Northumbria and I will continue to closely monitor each use of Tasers to ensure officers continue to follow the guidelines set down for their usage."

    Overflowing bins 'health risk' 11:33: Hartlepool Mail Newspaper

    A group of pensioners fear the area where they live could be turned into a health risk after bins were left overflowing following the recent council strike.

    Final day in the cricket 11:21: BBC Tees

    Listen to live Yorkshire v Middlesex commentary in the LV County Championship. On the last day of play, Middlesex are currently 13 for 0 chasing a target of 408.

    Share your views 11:11:

    We've introduced BBC Local Live to bring you the latest news, sport, travel and weather all in one place. Tell us what you think.

    News on the hour 10:59:

    The top headlines at 11:00 include:

    Head grab left-back Wilson 10:50: Matthew Raisbeck BBC Newcastle

    Gateshead FC have agreed to sign left-back Ryan Wilson from Ilkeston Town after a successful trial. The deal will be confirmed later.

    NUFC win 4-0 in New Zealand 10:40: Lloyd Watson BBC News

    Newcastle United have won 4-0 against Sydney FC in a pre-season friendly.

    A minute's silence was held before the game for two fans who were killed in the MH17 plane crash.

    Tasers used in North East 10:31:

    The Independent Police Complaints Commission has raised concerns over police officers in England and Wales using Tasers at point-blank range, despite no longer being trained to do so.

    In the North East during 2013, Northumbria Police's 3,852 officers used Tasers 132 times. Durham's 1,365 strong force used it 95 times, while Cleveland Police's 1,490 officers used it 108 times.

    Graph of Taser uses

    Tasers were deployed 10,380 times across England and Wales last year and there were 154 complaints - a rate that has remained consistent over 10 years.

    Smuggled cigarettes 10:20: Colin Briggs BBC Look North

    One in every three packets of cigarettes bought in some parts of the North East this year were smuggled, according to a report by the tobacco industry.

    It suggests that from April to June this year, over a third of cigarettes bought in Middlesbrough were bootleg - nearly three times as many as last year.

    And, it's claimed the figure in Darlington has tripled to one packet in four. But HM Revenue and Customs disputes these figures, saying that nationally, the figure has dropped by nearly a 10th over the past decade.

    Riverside closed over hunt 10:08: Lee Johnson BBC Tees

    Part of the Stockton Riverside remains closed after reports of a man getting into difficulties in the Tees. More on BBC Tees or read our online story here.

    River Tees in Stockton
    News on the hour 09:57:

    The top headlines at 10:00 include:

    BNP leader from County Durham 09:42:

    A BNP activist from Spennymoor, County Durham, has become the leader of the party after Nick Griffin stepped down.

    Adam Walker has been announced as the new leader and is also the president of the independent nationalist trade union Solidarity.

    Nick Griffin

    Mr Griffin (pictured) stepped down as leader of the BNP yesterday saying the decision to go was "mine and mine alone".

    Half-time for NUFC 09:27: Matthew Raisbeck BBC Newcastle

    It's half-time and Newcastle have taken at 3-0 lead at the Forsyth Barr Stadium in New Zealand in their pre-season friendly match against Sydney FC.

    De Jong put the Magpies ahead, Emmanuel Riviere doubled their lead before Mapou Yanga-Mbiwa made it 3-0.

    Applause for NUFC fan 09:20:

    Newcastle United tweets: Lovely touch at @ForBarrStadium as the giant screens show Liam Sweeney in the 28th minute. There's applause throughout the arena. #NUFC

    Omeruo back at Boro 09:12:

    Nigeria defender Kenneth Omeruo has agreed to return for a second loan spell at Middlesbrough.

    The 20-year-old Chelsea centre-back spent the second half of last season at the Riverside and played 14 games.

    Kenneth Omeruo
    News on the hour 08:59:

    The top headlines at 09:00 include:

    Search continues for missing man 08:52:

    A search is continuing for a missing man who got into difficulties while swimming in the River Tees.

    Lifeboat on River Tees

    He is believed to have gone missing at about 19:40 on Monday in an area of water near the Millennium Bridge in Stockton.

    Man charged after shots fired 08:43:

    A teenager has been charged and a third man has been arrested after shots were fired at a door in Middlesbrough.

    The shots were fired at the door of a property in Eglington Road, Grangetown, on Friday afternoon. No-one was injured.

    A 27-year-old remains in police custody awaiting questioning. A 19-year-old man arrested at the weekend has been released on bail and a 19-year-old also arrested has been charged with three firearms offences and is due at court later.

    Top headlines
    Training bomb removed from beach 08:28:

    Part of a Teesside beach which was cordoned off following the discovery of a suspected explosive device has reopened.

    An Army bomb disposal team identified the device as a training mortar before safely removing it from Saltburn beach on Monday.

    Training mortar

    A section of the beach was temporarily closed to the public.

    Minute's silence for dead fans 08:17:

    In memory of Newcastle fans John Alder and Liam Sweeney, who died in the MH17 plane disaster, there will be a minute's silence before the Magpies' pre-season friendly game against Sydney FC.

    Seats with wreaths on them

    Alan Pardew and Fabricio Coloccini laid these wreaths on their seats ahead of kick-off in the match at the Forsyth Barr Stadium, which starts at 08:30 BST.

    Front Street busy but moving 08:07:

    In County Durham, the A181 Front Street in Durham busy but moving inbound around the Dragon Lane junction.

    More on BBC Travel News for Teesside and Tyne and Wear.

    Dry day with light winds 08:04: Sara Thornton Weather Presenter, BBC Look North

    Everywhere will have a dry day with light winds, and many places will have warm sunny spells. However, coastal areas will be cooler due to an onshore breeze, which may also bring areas of mist and low cloud at times.

    Weather forecast

    Maximum temperature: 25C (77F). Check the forecast near you.

    Good morning 08:00: Lloyd Watson BBC News

    Welcome to BBC Local Live this morning. I'll be bringing you news, sport, weather and travel updates from across the North East.

    If you'd like us to feature your comments or pictures, send them to us by email, tweet us @BBCNewsNE or join our Facebook page.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.