Karl Doran Beamish Museum crush death: Accidental verdict

Karl Doran Karl Doran suffered head injuries

Related Stories

A museum where a seven-year-old boy was crushed to death under a ride has been told to improve safety, an inquest has heard.

Karl Doran, from Darlington, died when he fell under the trailer of a steam traction engine driven by his father Philip at Beamish Museum in July 2012.

The open air museum has since been issued with an improvement notice by the Health and Safety (HSE) executive.

Durham coroner Andrew Tweddle recorded a verdict of accidental death.

The hearing at Crook Civic Centre was told that Mr Doran, a volunteer at the museum, had been driving the vintage vehicle around the attraction on 22 July, with his son sitting on the tow bar.

Mr Doran had told Karl to join him on the engine after he began dragging his feet, but he then felt the trailer wobble and saw his son lying dead in the road.

'Incredibly tragic'
Traction engine and trailer The vintage vehicle and trailer were being driven around the attraction by Karl's father Philip Doran

Beamish was issued with an improvement notice to make sure steam engines driven by volunteers were properly risk-assessed.

Mr Tweddle said: "This is a very simple case but an incredibly tragic one at the same time.

"No-one, particularly Karl's dad, would have expected things to turn out in the way that they did that day.

"I hope through the evidence being given there will be lessons learned which will reduce similar fatalities in the future."

Richard Evans, director of the museum, said the safety of visitors was a top priority and they wanted to exceed existing standards.

The Health and Safety Executive is investigating the circumstances surrounding the youngster's death.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Tees



7 °C 5 °C

BBC Local Live

    13:13: Pressures on A&E units

    Pressures in England's A&E units have hit record levels, with the lowest percentage of patients seen within four hours since monitoring began in 2010.

    Ambulance, Liverpool

    Data showed just under 90% of patients were seen within four hours in the seven days up to December 14.

    Find out how your nearest hospital is doing with this link.

    12:59: News on the hour

    The top local headlines at 13:00 include:

    • BBC Tees: One of the senior Redcar Labour councillors who has been deselected by the party says he's not going to resign as member of the cabinet.
    • BBC Newcastle: The region's ambulance service is warning people they face prosecution if they make inappropriate calls.
    12:48: Restored Churchill funeral locomotive unveiled

    The locomotive that pulled Sir Winston Churchill's funeral train has been restored and will be unveiled by the fireman who manned the service in 1965.

    Funeral train of Sir Winston Churchill passing Staines

    James Lester will unveil the nameplates as they are reunited with the 34051 Winston Churchill. The engine and its carriages are being restored for the 50th anniversary of Sir Winston's funeral on 30 January. The carriage is being restored in Shildon, County Durham.

    The train will go on display in the Great Hall of the National Railway Museum in York as part of its Churchill's Final Journey exhibition.

    12:38: Hundreds of 'unnecessary calls' made

    More than 2,000 inappropriate calls have been made to the North East Ambulance Service over the last three months, the service said.

    In November, the trust received 805 inappropriate calls. In October, the figure was 758 and in September it was 668 - altogether totalling 2,231.

    Yvonne Ormston, from the service, said: "As well as wasting the time of call-handlers, inappropriate calls result in the unnecessary dispatch of emergency, non-emergency and patient transport ambulances - preventing them from getting to those patients genuinely in need.

    "Before you make that call, think to yourself 'is this an emergency?' If the answer is no, please find an alternative way of getting help. An ambulance will not guarantee you will be seen any quicker."

    12:24: Betting on baby's birthday Sunderland Echo
    12:08: Give us your feedback Lloyd Watson BBC News

    We've introduced BBC Local Live, which is written by reporters across the North East, to bring you the latest news, sport, travel and weather all in one place. Tell us what you think.

    11:57: News on the hour

    The top local headlines at 12:00 include:

    • BBC Tees: A second arrest has been made in an investigation into an alleged multimillion-pound fraud at Duncan Bannatyne's business in Darlington.
    • BBC Newcastle: The region's ambulance service is warning people to think before calling for help.
    11:50: Prison staff cover shortages Cara Thorpe BBC Newcastle

    It's been revealed that staff from a number of North East prisons are being bussed across the country to fill gaps at other jails because staff shortages are so acute this Christmas, according to leaked documents.

    Campaign group the Howard League for Penal Rerform says that 230 staff are having to move around the UK and that the shortage of prison officers means some inmates are being kept in their cells for up to 23 hours a day.

    The Ministry of Justice insisted "most prisons are appropriately staffed".

    11:39: Street decorations from the past

    From balloons and horses to traditional crowns and stars, Christmas decorations in all shapes, sizes and colours have brightened up England's streets over the years.

    Enjoy taking a look at some examples of the past here including some from Newcastle's Northumberland Street in 1987.

    Northumberland Street, Newcastle in 1987
    11:21: North East Party win by election Mark Denten Political Correspondent, BBC North East & Cumbria

    The North East Party win by-election on Peterlee Town Council. Mary Cartwright takes Eden Hill ward.

    It's the first election the North East Party have fought. The party was formed six months go.

    However, only 335 people voted in the election.

    11:08: Your pictures: Seal in Chester-le-Street Lloyd Watson BBC News

    Robert Wells sent us this picture of a seal in the River Wear in Chester-le-Street. I've been finding out if this is unusual.

    Jim Cokill, from the Durham Wildlife Trust, says: "It is unusual but not unheard of. They're chasing salmon and fish. They've also been spotted on the Tyne when they're looking for food."

    Seal in Chester-le-Street

    You can send your pictures by email: northeast.locallive@bbc.co.uk or tweet @BBCNewsNE.

    10:59: News on the hour

    The top local headlines at 11:00 include:

    10:50: ‘Pressure is for wimps’ Hartlepool Mail

    Ronnie Moore has demanded his Hartlepool United side thrive on a bumper Victoria Park crowd saying pressure is for "wimps".

    10:40: Llambias new chief executive at Ibrox

    Former managing director of Newcastle United Derek Llambias has been appointed Rangers' new chief executive.

    The Scottish Championship club made the announcement to the Stock Exchange ahead of Monday's annual meeting.

    Derek Llambias

    Englishman Llambias, 58, a former managing director of Newcastle United, joined Rangers' board as a non-executive director in November. The Scottish FA announced last week that it was investigating Newcastle owner Mike Ashley's role at Ibrox.

    10:26: Derby arrangements 'recipe for disaster’ Sunderland Echo

    The Sunderland fan, who inspired a huge fund-raising drive in memory of two Newcastle supporters killed in an air tragedy, admits he is sceptical that the Sunday Tyne-Wear derby will be trouble-free.

    10:11: Inside a nuclear plant Lee Johnson BBC Tees

    A nuclear power station in Hartlepool which shut down after a crack was found in a boiler at its sister site is up and running again.

    Electricity firm EDF temporarily closed down two of its nuclear power stations in Lancashire and Hartlepool in August.

    Hartlepool nuclear power station

    The problem was detected at Heysham 1 during a routine boiler inspection. EDF shut all four reactors at the two stations as a "precautionary measure". The plant is expected to be back up and running at full capacity next year. I had access inside the plant, watch my video here.

    09:58: News on the hour

    The top local headlines at 10:00 include:

    09:51: Relying on medication? Jonathan Miles BBC Newcastle

    All week Stephanie Finnon has been exclusively looking into the issue with poisonings and the sheer number of cases facing our hospitals. This morning I'm going to be taking a closer look into the region's biggest cause - paracetamol.

    Do we rely too heavily on medication, without really knowing how much we are putting into our bodies?

    Call BBC Newcastle on 0191 232 6565 or join the conversation on Facebook.

    09:43: Today's front page Northern Echo editor Peter Barron
    09:31: North East prison staff help plug gaps

    Nearly 250 prison officers are being bussed across the country to fill gaps at other jails because staff shortages are so acute this Christmas, according to leaked documents.


    Thirty-two officers are being sent to maximum security Woodhill prison, in Milton Keynes, the documents show, including from Frankland, in County Durham.

    The Ministry of Justice insisted "most prisons are appropriately staffed".

    09:19: Today's front page The Gazette
    09:09: Watchdog investigates death Richard Thomas BBC News

    The Independent Police Complaints Commission's looking into the death of a man in Sunderland. It's after the police received a report of men with guns inside an address.

    That report was false. The call had come from an address in Wetherby Road in the city. After officers arrived there the caller, a 36-year-old man, became unwell and he was taken to Sunderland Royal Hospital where he died.

    08:59: News on the hour

    The top local headlines at 09:00 include:

    08:50: Two councillors deselected

    Two senior Redcar Labour councillors have been deselected by the party as candidates in May's local elections.

    Steve Goldswain and Norman Pickthall, members of Redcar and Cleveland Council cabinet, will not be allowed to seek re-election as Labour councillors.

    The BBC understands they were told that they had not "demonstrated a commitment to campaigning for the Labour Party". The pair deny the allegation.

    Leisure centre

    The Labour Party says it does not comment on individual selection cases. Both councillors said they refuted such an allegation and that they were "extremely disappointed" by Labour North's decision.

    08:39: Broken down bus in Gateshead

    The A167 Durham Road in Gateshead is closed northbound and there's queuing traffic between the Albert Drive junction and the Cross Keys Lane junction, because of a broken down bus. More on BBC Travel News for Teesside and Tyne and Wear.

    08:30: Windy with showers Alina Jenkins Weather Presenter, BBC Look North

    Very windy with scattered showers, mainly over the North Pennines, where they may be wintry at times. Some sunny spells are also expected, mainly in more sheltered eastern areas. Feeling noticeably colder.

    Weather forecast

    Maximum temperature: 6C (43F). Check the forecast near you.

    08:19: Accident on Sunderland A1231

    One lane is blocked and there's slow traffic on the A1231 Sunderland Highway westbound in Washington between the Windlass Lane junction and the A182 Washington Highway junction because of an accident involving a motorcycle.

    08:07: Heavy traffic near Darlington

    There's heavier than usual traffic on the A167 North Road inbound in Darlington at the Whessoe Road junction.

    The A1 in Berwick is closed in both directions between the A6105 Duns Road junction and the A1167 North Road junction because of roadworks during the night. Diversion in operation - Northbound via A6105, B6355 and back to the A1. Southbound via A1167 and A6105.

    More on BBC Travel News for Teesside and Tyne and Wear.

    08:00: Good morning Lloyd Watson BBC News

    Welcome to BBC Local Live. I'll be bringing you news, sport, weather and travel updates from across the North East.

    If you'd like us to feature your comments or pictures, send them to us by email, tweet us @BBCNewsNE or join our Facebook page.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.