Horden shootings: IPCC highlights Durham Police failings

(Left to right) Susan McGoldrick, Alison Turnbull, Tanya Turnbull (Left to right) Susan McGoldrick, 47, Alison Turnbull, 44 and Tanya Turnbull, 24, were killed

Related Stories

An inquiry has found "unacceptable" and "inexcusable" failings in how Durham Police dealt with a man who shot dead three family members and then himself.

Michael Atherton, 42, shot his partner Susan McGoldrick; Alison Turnbull, her daughter Tanya then himself after a row at his Horden home on New Year's Day.

Atherton legally owned six weapons, including three shotguns.

But the Independent Police Complaints Commission (IPCC) said his violent past had not been properly investigated.

While the IPCC said it found no evidence to warrant criminal or disciplinary action against any member of Durham Police, it said the force knew of "a number of incidents" which "should have cast doubt" on Atherton's suitability to hold firearms.

Michael Atherton Atherton had a history of domestic and drink-related violence

Durham Police said that since the shootings it had carried out a full review of policy and procedures.

A copy of the IPCC report, seen by the BBC's Inside Out, revealed Atherton was given three police warnings between 2007 and 2008, because of incidents of domestic violence and claims he threatened to "blow his head off" while drunk.

The force was also aware of several domestic violence and drink-related incidents dating back to 2002, the IPCC said - although Atherton only ever received a caution.

The report said Durham Police failed to properly scrutinise Atherton's 2006 application for a shotgun certificate and an application for a firearms licence two years later in 2008. It concluded that decisions were taken with only "partial facts".

Start Quote

The IPCC concluded that no criminal or misconduct action should be taken against any member of Durham Constabulary involved in this decision-making, and we concur with this finding”

End Quote Michael Banks Deputy chief constable of Durham

It has described the failure of senior staff to follow up on concerns voiced about Atherton's emotional state by subordinates as "unacceptable" and concluded the resulting lack of consideration given to the "welfare of the family and wider public" was "inexcusable".

The report highlighted Durham Police's assessment of Atherton for his first shotgun certificate in 2006, in which a member of staff added a handwritten post-it note to his file which read: "4 domestics - last one 24/4/04 - was cautioned for assault. Still resides with partner & son & daughter. Would like to refuse - have we sufficient info - refuse re public safety."

But the recommendation was overruled by two more senior members of the Firearms Licensing Unit, who, the report said, feared the force would lose any subsequent appeal by Atherton as he had never been convicted of an offence.

The IPCC said further opportunities to reassess Atherton were missed when he applied for a firearms licence in 2008, which allowed him to own more powerful weapons.

Shortly after being granted the firearms licence his weapons were seized after a further domestic incident at Atherton's home.

Full inquest

But the IPCC found it "unacceptable" and "inconceivable" that they were returned without Atherton or his family being formally interviewed by licensing staff.

Alison Turnbull's son Bobby, who has seen a copy of the report, said he was angered by its findings.

Mr Turnbull, who has started a campaign urging tougher restrictions on the issuing of gun licences, said: "The police had a number of opportunities to refuse the licences. If people did their jobs in the first place lives would never have been taken."

Durham's deputy chief constable Michael Banks said: "We continue to extend our sympathies to the families of those who died in Horden on the night of January 1, 2012.

The family recall the night the three woman were shot dead before Atherton turned the gun on himself

"We are aware that the IPCC has updated the victims' families on the outcome of their investigation into firearms licensing decision-making in the case of Michael Atherton, and supplied them with their report.

"We've been informed by the IPCC that it is their recommendation that there are no criminal or misconduct cases to answer for any member of Durham Constabulary.

"The report into the investigation will not be made public until HM Coroner holds a full inquest into the deaths. This is not likely to be before the spring of next year.

"We feel that at this stage it is entirely appropriate that members of staff who made decisions within relevant guidance are not identified, as it is the coroner who addresses issues of anonymity.

"Since the tragic events in January, we have carried out a full review of policy and procedures. It would be wholly inappropriate to comment further."

Watch more on this story on Inside Out North East and Cumbria on BBC One at 19:30 GMT on Monday, 19 November, 2012.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Tees

Weather

Middlesbrough

21 °C 15 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    Silver for Laura Weightman 14:29:

    BBC Newcastle's Jo Lonsdale tweets: Absolutely delighted for #LauraWeightman winning a silver in the Commonwealth Games. Lovely family, fantastic for Northumberland.

     
  2.  
    Here comes the... 14:15: Jonathan Miles BBC Newcastle

    I like to surprise people at work. You can see Alfie and Charlie's reaction here when I walked into their studio wearing a wedding dress live on air.

    If you don't know me that well, you may ask "why?".

    Jonathan Miles wearing a wedding dress

    Well, on my show I spoke to Lauren and Charlie who had a sci-fi themed wedding at the Discovery Museum. It was all thanks to the Bafta award-winning series Don't Tell the Bride. Listen again here.

     
  3.  
    News on the hour 13:59:

    The top local headlines at 13:00 include:

     
  4.  
    Hunt for graffiti vandals 13:54: Russell Ward

    Vandals have daubed graffiti on this Sunderland monument. Hear more on BBC Newcastle.

    Graffiti on monument
     
  5.  
    'Enjoy your youth' 13:39: Ingrid Hagemann BBC Newcastle

    Singer Amelia Lily tells me that being on X Factor when she was 16 "feels like a decade ago".

    Ingrid Hagemann with Amelia Lily

    She said: "I forget how old I am sometimes, you need to enjoy your youth. I didn't want to come across as an aggressive teenager, I like to have a laugh and (new single) California shows that."

     
  6.  
    First look at hospital 13:32: Rebecca O'Neill BBC Newcastle

    I've been having a first look around the new hospital in Hopewood Park on Wearside. Next month it will open its doors to its first patients.

    The 122-bed hospital has six wards, each with 18 individual en-suite rooms. It will replace services provided by the Cherry Knowle Hospital.

    New hospital in Wearside

    Patients will include those who have complex needs and require rehabilitation. It also includes a 14-bed psychiatric intensive care unit.

     
  7.  
    Amelia Lily live 13:18: Ingrid Hagemann BBC Newcastle

    I'm having a chat with X Factor star and Teessider Amelia Lily on BBC Newcastle now.

    Amelia Lily
     
  8.  
    Identical triplets arrive home 13:12: Stuart Whincup BBC Look North

    I'll be catching up with these happy and healthy identical triplets born at 28 weeks.

    Freya, Lily and Eleanor spent seven weeks in hospital and throughout the pregnancy their parents had been told their daughters had a high risk of health problems.

    Triplets

    But now they've all arrived home and are fast becoming celebrities on the streets of Guisborough. See my report on BBC Look North at 13:30 and 18:30 on BBC One.

     
  9.  
    News on the hour 12:59:

    The top local headlines at 13:00 include:

     
  10.  
    Former Hartlepool mayor dies 12:48:

    Former Hartlepool mayor Gwynneth Hanson, 83, has died surrounded by family at her home in the Northumberland village of Shilbottle, Hartlepool Council says.

    Her husband Bryan, himself a former mayor who also served as leader of the council, died last year aged 81.

    The current mayor, Stephen Akers-Belcher, said: "I always think that Gwynneth was responsible for important developments in the town such as Summerhill Country Park which she pushed forward, and she was a great champion of culture and leisure facilities generally."

     
  11.  
    Road in Gateshead still closed 12:34:

    Ravensworth Road in Dunston is still closed in both directions between the Ellison Road junction and the Wellington Road junction because of a building fire earlier.

    One lane is closed on the A19 southbound in Thornaby-on-Tees between the A1130 Levick Crescent junction and the A174 junction because of a broken down vehicle.

    More on BBC Travel News for Teesside and Tyne and Wear.

     
  12.  
    Greggs sees profits rise 12:22:

    Newcastle-based pasty and sausage roll firm Greggs revealed higher profits today. Here we take a look at some of the figures:

    Greggs figures graphic
     
  13.  
    'Happy coincidence' 12:13: Matt Newsum BBC Sport

    Keith Nobbs has never seen his daughter Jordan play for England in the flesh.

    It is then a happy coincidence that he could do so for the first time on the very pitch he graced as a Hartlepool United player, for whom he played 327 times.

    Jordan Nobbs

    England's women play Sweden in a friendly at Victoria Park on 3 August as a prelude to their World Cup qualifier against Wales, and Jordan is in the 23-strong squad.

     
  14.  
    News on the hour 12:00:

    The top local headlines at 12:00 include:

     
  15.  
    'Tears in my eyes' 11:44: Jonathan Miles BBC Newcastle

    I've been speaking to Diana Weightman, mum of Commonwealth silver medallist and Alnwick lass Laura Weightman.

    She told me: "It's an unbelievable experience and feeling when you're in the stadium. [When she won] I had tears in my eyes. I knew she had the endurance and the stamina in her to go, and she went and it was unbelievable. I think she'll be celebrating with battered sausage and chips."

    The medal ceremony is due to take place at about 19:45.

     
  16.  
    Give us your feedback 11:33:

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? We'd like your feedback about this service.

     
  17.  
    Writing with Journey South 11:21: The Gazette Newspaper
  18.  
    'Trying to be positive' 11:12:

    International monitors have once again failed to reach the crash site of flight MH17 in eastern Ukraine.

    Newcastle United fans Liam Sweeney and John Alder were both killed in the tragedy almost two weeks ago.

    Barry Sweeney

    Liam's father Barry Sweeney said: "At the moment we don't know what's happened to Liam. There's still bodies that haven't come home. So hopefully, trying to be positive, he'll be inside one of the coffins that were brought back into Holland."

     
  19.  
    News on the hour 10:58:

    The top local headlines at 11:00 include:

    • BBC Newcastle: Liam Sweeney's dad, Barry, says he is still no closer to finding out where his son's body is.
    • BBC Tees: Two Durham Police officers are being investigated after they allegedly used a crowbar to kill an injured deer.
     
  20.  
    Pre-tax profits up at Greggs 10:41: The Journal Newspaper
  21.  
    On today's show 10:34: Jonathan Miles BBC Newcastle

    I'll be speaking to the most excited woman on the planet - Diana Weightman, the mum of Commonwealth Games silver medallist Laura Weightman.

    Jonathan Miles in a wedding dress

    But first... I know you are aghast at my fabulous countenance right now as I am in a wedding dress. Well all will be revealed after 11:00 on BBC Newcastle.

     
  22.  
    More on Dunston fire 10:22:

    A "large-scale" fire which was tackled by 40 firefighters at the former Metz Public House on Ravensworth Road in Dunston, Gateshead, has been extinguished.

    Mark Gerrard from Tyne and Wear Fire and Rescue Service said: "The fire appears to have started in the roof space of the building.

    Aftermath of fire in Gateshead

    "Due to the size, location and extent of the fire, crews faced difficult conditions and acted quickly to get the fire under control and to prevent it from spreading."

     
  23.  
    Police 'kill deer using crowbar' 10:10: BBC Tees

    Two police firearms officers from Durham Constabulary are being investigated after they allegedly used a crowbar to kill an injured deer in Tanfield Lea, Durham.

    They were dispatched to destroy the stricken animal in June, which had been injured on a road, but it has been reported that instead of using their firearms, the two officers used a crowbar to kill the large animal.

    The force confirmed the pair are now being investigated after the deer was "apparently not destroyed in the approved, humane manner" and said they have been moved to other duties.

     
  24.  
    News on the hour 09:59:

    The top local headlines at 10:00 include:

     
  25.  
    'Laura puts effort in' 09:50: Steve Cram BBC athletics expert & former CWG champion

    I am so proud of Laura. There are a lot of athletes who have so much talent and don't have to work so hard. But Laura really puts the effort in and is so easy for me to coach from that perspective.

    Watch the closing moments of the race.

    England's Laura Weightman stuns with silver in 1500m

    The two Kenyans are the best in the world, but if they have an off day you have to be ready to take that opportunity. Laura is a real scrapper.

     
  26.  
    Weightman wins first senior medal 09:37: Tom Fordyce Chief sports writer

    Morpeth Harrier Laura Weightman, from Alnwick in Northumberland, capped a night of silver celebration for English athletes as her gutsy 1500m run brought her a first senior medal.

    The 1500m had been billed as one of the races of the Games, and of the home athletes it was Weightman who dealt with the pressure best.

    Laura Weightman celebrates

    Although Faith Kipyegon came past her on the back straight and went away for gold, Weightman dug in again over the closing 60m to hold off the fast-finishing Kate van Buskirk of Canada in 4:09.24.

     
  27.  
    More on Dunston fire 09:25:

    About 40 firefighters and seven appliances have been tackling what was originally a "large-scale" fire at a disused pub in Dunston, Gateshead, since about 03:20.

    The operation has since been scaled back, Tyne and Wear Fire and Rescue said. It has not yet been established how the fire started.

    Ravensworth Road in Gateshead is still closed in both directions between the Ellison Road junction and the Wellington Road junction.

     
  28.  
    Man charged over sex offences 09:15:

    A man has been charged after two incidents of indecent exposure in Ormesby and Coulby Newham.

    The 39-year-old has been charged with exposure, two counts of inciting a child to engage in sexual activity and two counts of breaching a Sexual Offences Prevention Order. He will appear at Teesside Magistrates' Court today.

     
  29.  
    Do you care if people swear? 09:06: Lisa McCormick BBC Tees

    Do people still care if you swear? Channel 4 had to apologise after broadcasting an episode of The Simpsons which featured Krusty the Clown swearing. Seven people complained to Ofcom about the cartoon, which was shown at 18:00.

    They've said it was down to human error. Let us know your thoughts by calling me on 01642 225511 or join the conversation on Facebook.

     
  30.  
    News on the hour 08:55:

    The top local headlines at 09:00 include:

     
  31.  
    Top headlines
     
  32.  
    Man dies from suspected drug reaction 08:42:

    A man has died from a suspected "fatal reaction" to a drug taken at a party in Newcastle, police have said.

    The 18-year-old was found disoriented in the street by police, who were called to Pinewood Close in Kingston Park at 13:40 yesterday after concerns were raised for his welfare.

    He was taken to hospital by ambulance where he later died. Police believe his death may be linked to a drug he may have taken at a party on Monday night.

     
  33.  
    First flamingo egg in eight years 08:31:

    The first flamingo egg in eight years has been laid at a wildlife centre in Wearside, according to the charity that runs it.

    Staff at the Washington Wetland Centre spotted the egg on Monday in one of the bird's nests.

    Flamingo

    It follows a project in which Chilean flamingo eggs were brought into the centre and humans reared the chicks. They were then integrated into the existing flock in the hope it would encourage natural breeding.

     
  34.  
    Fire being tackled in Gateshead 08:19:

    A fire at the derelict Cross Keys pub in Dunston, Gateshead, is being tackled by firefighters. Ravensworth Road in Gateshead closed in both directions.

    Paul McNeill tweets: @gillyhope1 cross keys in dunston, ravensworth rd closed

    Tackling fire in Gateshead
     
  35.  
    Pub building on fire 08:11:

    Ravensworth Road near the A1 in Gateshead is closed in both directions between the Ellison Road junction and the Wellington Road junction because of a fire at the Cross Keys pub, reports BBC Travel News.

     
  36.  
    Breezy and cloudy 08:06:

    It'll be breezy with variable amounts of cloud and some sunny spells, with the best of these in the east. Cloud should be most abundant over the Pennines where occasional showers will occur, with these more likely to run eastwards during the afternoon with the odd heavier one possible.

    Weather forecast

    Maximum temperature: 21C (70F). Check the forecast near you.

     
  37.  
    Good morning 08:00: Lloyd Watson BBC News

    Welcome to BBC Local Live, I'll be bringing you news, sport, weather and travel updates from across the North East.

    If you'd like us to feature your comments or pictures, send them to us by email, tweet us @BBCNewsNE or join our Facebook page.

     

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.