Green Party in Brighton and Hove faces no confidence vote

Jason Kitcat Green Party council leader Jason Kitcat said he was "not going anywhere"

Related Stories

A vote of no confidence in Brighton's Green Party administration has been passed as the controversy over its proposed council tax rise intensifies.

The Green Party wants to raise council tax by 4.75%, which would need a majority yes vote in a referendum.

The Labour and Tory groups called on leader Jason Kitcat to stand down, but he said he was "not going anywhere".

Both the Labour and Conservative groups said they planned to oppose the Green Party budget next month.

'Crisis looming'

The Greens had put forward a tax rise of 4.75% to fund adult social care services and said the city would hold a referendum on the issue.

Analysis

The UK's first Green council promised to be different and it hasn't disappointed. This latest chapter could have big repercussions in the coming weeks.

Although the Conservatives backed Labour's no confidence amendment it's by no means an alliance. During the debate Tory councillors directed much of their criticism towards the Labour group, accusing it of having no viable alternative to the Greens' referendum proposal.

The no confidence motion has no force and Green leader Jason Kitcat says he'll simply ignore it. What he won't be able to ignore is another Labour-Conservative union on 13 February when the budget needs to be voted through.

What might work in the Greens' favour is that the two opposition parties have dramatically different ideas on what to do instead. While Labour favours a council tax increase of just under 2%, the Conservatives want a freeze.

Mr Kitcat said there was "widespread consensus" among reputable charities that there was a crisis looming for social care.

He claimed by 2020 there would be no government funding for councils.

"We need to make a choice," he said. "Do we either pay some more through council tax to protect care for the vulnerable, or not?"

Mr Kitcat also said the Tory group wanted to freeze council tax while Labour wanted a 2% rise, and while those two groups could not agree, the Green Party's position would "hold true".

He said: "If the people come back through a referendum and say we don't want to pay more, absolutely fine, that will be democracy in action. But we think we should let the people decide."

Labour group leader Warren Morgan said his party wanted a 2% increase because a freeze would mean more cuts being forced on the council.

He said residents could not afford another £6 a month on top of all the other bills that were going up.

'Political squabbling'

Mr Morgan said he had called for a "caretaker" administration that would see all three parties governing on a consensus basis with a 2% tax increase.

"It would focus on getting those basic services like refuse collection right, instead of all this political squabbling and point scoring and gestures that people are coming up with - that is what residents are telling us they want," he said.

The city faced disrupted rubbish collections last summer and this month - the council later said it had made changes to the service but the transition period had not been as smooth as hoped for.

Uncollected rubbish in Brighton Labour group leader Warren Morgan said a "caretaker" administration would focus on getting services right, such as refuse collection

Conservative group leader Geoffrey Theobald said: "We believe there should be a council tax freeze, and that there is no necessity for a council tax rise if the council is run more efficiently."

He added: "You've got two left-wing parties both posturing ahead of next year's elections, desperately trying to outbid each other for the far left vote in the city.

"I don't believe that's the way to run a city and the vast majority of our residents are just getting caught in the crossfire of their personal battle."

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Sussex

Weather

Brighton

Min. Night 13 °C

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.