PCC: South Yorkshire candidates fear low turnout

Five candidates David Allen, Jonathan Arnott, Nigel Bonson, Robert Teal and Shaun Wright

The five men standing for the post of South Yorkshire's first Police and Crime Commissioner (PCC) said a low voter turnout would not affect their mandate to do the job.

At a BBC Radio Sheffield debate they were asked whether they would accept the post if fewer than 10% voted.

It follows warnings that there could be the lowest election turnout ever.

Conservative candidate Nigel Bonson said if that happened the government should "rethink the situation".

Audience members The candidates took questions from BBC Radio Sheffield listeners

He added: "I've stood as a candidate and I am committed to doing the job, and I would do it just as well if there was a 90% turnout or a 5% turnout."

Labour candidate Shaun Wright said he would be "disappointed" but not "surprised".

He said: "I wouldn't be surprised given the approach the government has taken. They've not funded these elections like they do with general elections, they've called it at an inappropriate time of year and they've not publicised it as much as they should have done.

"There is going to be a low turnout regardless but whoever gets the majority on the day will take up the role, it's as simple as that."

Jonathan Arnott, of UKIP, agreed that the elections were badly timed, and said the government had arranged the elections "on the cheap".


The problem with debating with police commissioner candidates is that they are all essentially saying the same things. More bobbies on the beat and less red tape are common phrases leaving the lips of would-be police bosses.

Voters seem to be having a hard time telling some of the parties apart, especially when the candidates are promising to run their office without political interference, despite having a party name next to theirs on the ballot.

A lot has been made of the lack of awareness of the PCC elections and that extends to their role as well. People have asked them questions like, what are they going to do to toughen up sentences and prisons? Things a PCC will have no control over whatsoever.

The big question is, will people vote for their usual favourite party, no matter who is the candidate? Or will they be looking at this as more of a job interview, and look for a CV that suits an £85k a year job?

The big fear is that the interview panel - the electorate - might not be very big at all.

He added: "If there's a tiny turnout and you get only a few per cent of the population who have voted for the new police and crime commissioner, you've still got a police and crime commissioner.

"You'll still have a police and crime commissioner everywhere else in the country, so if you say 'oh well I won't take the job' they'll just hold a by-election with an even smaller turnout."

David Allen, from the English Democrats, said he would still do the job, but added: "I think it's very sad really. At least you can change (the position of PCC) after four years or after a period of time."

While Liberal Democrat Robert Teal responded: "The question seems to ask me to respect those who don't vote more than those who do vote. I would respect those who have voted and those who've voted for me so yes I would take the job."

Several members of the public asked questions about political independence.

The candidates each represent a political party, but insisted they would not take direction from their party leaders.

Leaflets from the Electoral Commission were sent to 21 million households last month, explaining what the police and crime commissioners will do.

Duties include agreeing budgets, setting strategic priorities and recruiting or dismissing chief constables.

The election takes place on 15 November.

More on This Story

Related Stories

BBC Sheffield & South Yorkshire



8 °C 5 °C


Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.