World War One: Scientist John Haldane tested gas on himself

French troops wearing the primitive veil respirators Scientist John Haldane developed the veil respirator, but troops said it left them unable to breathe

Related Stories

When the Germans launched the first gas attacks in 1915, the allies were desperate to find out what chemicals were used and how they could protect troops in the front line. The War Office called in an Oxford academic to help - a man who was prepared to put his own life at risk to produce the first gas mask.

Not many of today's scientists would be prepared, let alone permitted, to test dangerous gases on themselves at home, relying on their teenage daughter to break in and revive them if they passed out from the effects.

But, John Scott Haldane was anything but orthodox, according to Dr Steve Sturdy from the University of Edinburgh.

World War One at Home

John Haldane

BBC Local Radio stories of a global conflict

"Haldane was a great self-experimenter - he thought the human organism was the best animal to experiment on because it could report on what it was experiencing."

Lord Kitchener himself called on Mr Haldane for help, after the Germans released clouds of chlorine gas across the front line around the Belgian city of Ypres, on 22 April 1915.

Urine-soaked socks

In an Imperial War Museum podcast, Bert Newman of the Royal Army Medical Corps describes seeing the effects on Canadian troops of a second gas attack two days later.

Soldiers had been told to improvise primitive protection, including soaking socks in their own urine and tying them around their faces.

"[But] in the end, you could see all these poor chaps laying on the Menin Road, gasping for breath," Mr Newman recalled.

"And the thing was it was no gas masks then, you see, and a lot of these chaps just had to wet their handkerchiefs and put it over their mouth or do what they could."

Machine gunners at the Battle of the Somme in 1916 wearing a later form of gas mask By 1916, the gas masks available had become more effective and easier to use

Mr Haldane already had a wealth of experience in working with dangerous gases from his pre-war work in the mining industry.

"He'd been visiting collieries after coal mine explosions and other disasters, determining the cause of death, much of which was due to poison gases that were present in the mine," according to Dr Sturdy.

"He'd also been involved in breathing apparatus that could be used in mines after explosions."

After the Ypres attacks, Mr Haldane and a colleague were rushed to Belgium, to find out what gas the Germans were using.

Start Quote

I found using it in the gas cloud that after a couple of minutes one couldn't breathe and so it was pushed up over the forehead and we swallowed the gas”

End Quote Stretcher bearer William Collins

They identified chlorine from the way it had discoloured brass buttons on dead soldiers' uniforms.

Daughter stationed outside

Back at his home laboratory, Mr Haldane set about looking for a quick counter measure troops could be given, unconcerned about the effects it would have on him.

"He'd always experimented on himself and so in the urgency of warfare, and the fact that these were gases that were being used for deliberately harmful purposes, he did end up exposing himself to far more harmful levels of gas than he would have done in peacetime," said Dr Sturdy.

"Naomi [his eighteen-year-old daughter] was stationed outside the door, which had a window in it, with instructions that if he were incapacitated she should get him out as soon as possible."

Mr Haldane's quick fix was a small step forward from the wet handkerchiefs and urine-soaked socks.

"They were called veil respirators, and it was basically pads of cotton waste that were wrapped in gauze soaked in a solution of sodium thiosulphate, which neutralised the effects of low concentrations of chlorine gas," Dr Sturdy explained.

"These could be bound over the face, nose and mouth [but] he recognised that these were very much a stop gap."

American soldier wearing a box respirator in 1917 The box respirator became the design of choice, but it was not available until 1917

Stretcher bearer William Collins, in another Imperial War Museum podcast, described how he was one of the first to use a veil respirator.

"About midday that day, supplies of the first so-called gas masks came up, and all it consisted of was a pad of wool covered by gauze with an elastic band running right round and about four inches by two.

"But, I found using it in the gas cloud that after a couple of minutes one couldn't breathe and so it was pushed up over the forehead and we swallowed the gas.

"It was not a practical proposition at all."

Mr Haldane went on to help with the development of the much more effective box respirators, which were used during the rest of the war.

Anti-German feeling

However, the Edinburgh-born academic and fellow of New College Oxford could have found reasons not to help the British war effort at all.

His brother Richard, who was Secretary of State for War and then Lord Chancellor, suffered from the wave of anti-German feeling that swept the country at the start of World War One.

"[Some] newspapers launched attacks on him because he'd studied in Germany, he spoke very good German and had close relations with German colleagues," according to Dr Sturdy.

"He was hounded out of office, and I think John Haldane suffered from that as well."

But, Mr Haldane continued his work throughout the war, and continued to experiment on himself.

He also used his son, who was in his 20s, in some experiments - it seemed to do him no harm, nor did it put him off science, as he went on to become a professor of genetics.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Oxford



5 °C 0 °C

BBC Local Live

    11:09: The cost of care Phil Gayle Breakfast presenter, BBC Radio Oxford

    BBC Radio Oxford has learned that more than 14,000 people visited accident and emergency departments in Oxfordshire last year, but left without being treated.

    Hospital ward

    Our Health reporter David Fenton explained to me what effect this had on the Horton and John Radcliffe: "A £64 cost is incurred the moment a person registers at A&E, and is paid by the hospital to the local doctors groups, the CCG, who pay for care for all of us and are in charge of the budgets.

    "So in one way it is one part of the NHS paying another, but the point is that it is payment for people who have had no treatment so is wasted money."

    10:59: News on the hour Sue Kinnear Newsreader, BBC Radio Oxford

    A project to make Oxfordshire a leading area for internet businesses and technology has been launched.

    Digital Oxford hopes to make the county more appealing for investors and employees in the digital sector.

    I'll have more on this at 11:00.

    10:48: Thousands sign grave petition Andrew Humphrey BBC Local Live

    Yesterday we reported that a Kidlington mother had been told to remove decorations from her daughter's grave.

    Tanya Beadle's grave

    Jane Beadle started an online petition calling for parents to be allowed to decorate graves. It now has over 4,000 signatures.

    You can watch BBC South Today's Adina Campbell's report on the story on our Facebook page.

    10:40: Benefits cheat had £50,000 Thame Gazette

    A benefits cheat who claimed £34,000 from the state despite having £50,000 in the bank has been given a suspended prison sentence.

    10:28: Need to use NHS 'wisely' BBC Radio Oxford

    More than 14,000 people made unnecessary visits to the Horton and John Radcliffe hospitals in Oxfordshire last year.

    Each visit cost the NHS £64.

    Rachel Coney from Healthwatch Oxfordshire told BBC Radio Oxford that it is time patients questioned their own actions.

    She said: "Patients need to take some responsibility for the problems we see in hospitals. We all need to be using the NHS wisely if we want it to be there for us and working when we do need it."

    10:13: Sir Winston Churchill's funeral marked 50 years on Alex Morrison BBC News

    The boat which carried Sir Winston Churchill's coffin along the Thames will make the journey again later to mark 50 years since his funeral.

    Winston Churchill making a speech

    The Havengore will carry members of his family to Westminster, as part of a day of events in central London.

    Remembrance services will be held at the Houses of Parliament and Westminster Abbey.

    09:59: News on the hour Sue Kinnear Newsreader, BBC Radio Oxford

    One in every 10 people who went to A&E in Oxfordshire left because they got bored waiting, didn't need treatment or were drunk.

    For more on this, join me at 10:00.

    09:48: Remembering Churchill Howard Bentham Presenter, BBC Radio Oxford

    Today we are remembering Sir Winston Churchill's funeral, broadcasting from Bladon where he is laid to rest.

    Winston Churchill's grave in Bladon

    We are going to tell the stories of those people who were there on the day, the handful of relatives and villagers who were the last to see Churchill before he was committed to the earth.

    Join us for this special programme from 10:00.

    09:42: Substation home price may shock Oxford Mail

    Whoever snaps up a former Second World War sub-station is set for a blast of a time in a £500,000 luxury, three-bedroom pad.

    09:30: Any snow? Andrew Humphrey BBC Local Live

    Did you have any snow? If so it probably wasn't as complete a covering as Oxford received in January 2013, as pictured here, at the canal in Jericho.

    Snowy Oxford Canal

    It was taken by Antony Steele and you can see more of his pictures on flickr. If you did get any of the white stuff, why not send in a picture to Local Live?

    09:19: Selma star disappointed by Bafta snub Tim Masters Entertainment correspondent, BBC News

    Oxford-born former Spooks star David Oyelowo has expressed disappointment at the way Bafta has snubbed his new film Selma.

    David Oyelowo

    The British actor plays Martin Luther King in the film about the 1965 campaign in Selma, Alabama, for equal voting rights for African-Americans.

    The film, out in the UK next week, has been lauded by critics and has two Oscar nominations, but received no Bafta nominations.

    09:08: Botley problems Sara Dumbell Travel presenter, BBC Radio Oxford

    There is a slow crawl on the A420 in both directions in Botley at the B4044 junction, because of an accident involving a lorry and a car.

    Congestion going back to the Botley Interchange and to the B4017 Abingdon Road junction.

    08:58: News on the hour Danny Cox Presenter, BBC Oxford

    One in every 10 people who went to A&E in Oxfordshire last year left without being treated, costing the NHS almost a £1m.

    I'll have the full details at 09:00.

    08:44: Arson accused to appear

    The man accused of causing three major fires in south Oxfordshire is due to appear at Oxford Crown Court.

    Council office fire

    Andrew Main, 47 from Rokemarsh Farm in Rokemarsh, is facing four charges including arson with intent to endanger life.

    The main offices of South Oxfordshire and Vale of White Horse District Councils were gutted by the fire two weeks ago.

    08:25: Collapsing wall Sara Dumbell Travel presenter, BBC Radio Oxford

    At Bloxham there are emergency temporary lights due to a collapsing wall on the A361, Church Street just around Hawke Lane.

    08:10: Sunny but cold Bee Tucker BBC Weather

    There could be a bit of ice on the roads first thing and any occasional showers will gradually ease as we go through the morning.

    Bee Tucker

    We should see some decent spells of sunshine despite this, winds coming down from the north will keep it feeling raw with highs of 6C (43F).

    08:00: Good morning Andrew Humphrey BBC Local Live

    Good morning and welcome to BBC Local Live for Oxfordshire this Friday morning.

    I'm in the BBC Oxford newsroom bringing you the latest news, sport, travel and weather from across the county.

    You can get in touch throughout the day and tell us what you're up to via email, Facebook or Twitter.



Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.