World War One: Scientist John Haldane tested gas on himself

French troops wearing the primitive veil respirators Scientist John Haldane developed the veil respirator, but troops said it left them unable to breathe

Related Stories

When the Germans launched the first gas attacks in 1915, the allies were desperate to find out what chemicals were used and how they could protect troops in the front line. The War Office called in an Oxford academic to help - a man who was prepared to put his own life at risk to produce the first gas mask.

Not many of today's scientists would be prepared, let alone permitted, to test dangerous gases on themselves at home, relying on their teenage daughter to break in and revive them if they passed out from the effects.

But, John Scott Haldane was anything but orthodox, according to Dr Steve Sturdy from the University of Edinburgh.

World War One at Home

John Haldane

BBC Local Radio stories of a global conflict

"Haldane was a great self-experimenter - he thought the human organism was the best animal to experiment on because it could report on what it was experiencing."

Lord Kitchener himself called on Mr Haldane for help, after the Germans released clouds of chlorine gas across the front line around the Belgian city of Ypres, on 22 April 1915.

Urine-soaked socks

In an Imperial War Museum podcast, Bert Newman of the Royal Army Medical Corps describes seeing the effects on Canadian troops of a second gas attack two days later.

Soldiers had been told to improvise primitive protection, including soaking socks in their own urine and tying them around their faces.

"[But] in the end, you could see all these poor chaps laying on the Menin Road, gasping for breath," Mr Newman recalled.

"And the thing was it was no gas masks then, you see, and a lot of these chaps just had to wet their handkerchiefs and put it over their mouth or do what they could."

Machine gunners at the Battle of the Somme in 1916 wearing a later form of gas mask By 1916, the gas masks available had become more effective and easier to use

Mr Haldane already had a wealth of experience in working with dangerous gases from his pre-war work in the mining industry.

"He'd been visiting collieries after coal mine explosions and other disasters, determining the cause of death, much of which was due to poison gases that were present in the mine," according to Dr Sturdy.

"He'd also been involved in breathing apparatus that could be used in mines after explosions."

After the Ypres attacks, Mr Haldane and a colleague were rushed to Belgium, to find out what gas the Germans were using.

Start Quote

I found using it in the gas cloud that after a couple of minutes one couldn't breathe and so it was pushed up over the forehead and we swallowed the gas”

End Quote Stretcher bearer William Collins

They identified chlorine from the way it had discoloured brass buttons on dead soldiers' uniforms.

Daughter stationed outside

Back at his home laboratory, Mr Haldane set about looking for a quick counter measure troops could be given, unconcerned about the effects it would have on him.

"He'd always experimented on himself and so in the urgency of warfare, and the fact that these were gases that were being used for deliberately harmful purposes, he did end up exposing himself to far more harmful levels of gas than he would have done in peacetime," said Dr Sturdy.

"Naomi [his eighteen-year-old daughter] was stationed outside the door, which had a window in it, with instructions that if he were incapacitated she should get him out as soon as possible."

Mr Haldane's quick fix was a small step forward from the wet handkerchiefs and urine-soaked socks.

"They were called veil respirators, and it was basically pads of cotton waste that were wrapped in gauze soaked in a solution of sodium thiosulphate, which neutralised the effects of low concentrations of chlorine gas," Dr Sturdy explained.

"These could be bound over the face, nose and mouth [but] he recognised that these were very much a stop gap."

American soldier wearing a box respirator in 1917 The box respirator became the design of choice, but it was not available until 1917

Stretcher bearer William Collins, in another Imperial War Museum podcast, described how he was one of the first to use a veil respirator.

"About midday that day, supplies of the first so-called gas masks came up, and all it consisted of was a pad of wool covered by gauze with an elastic band running right round and about four inches by two.

"But, I found using it in the gas cloud that after a couple of minutes one couldn't breathe and so it was pushed up over the forehead and we swallowed the gas.

"It was not a practical proposition at all."

Mr Haldane went on to help with the development of the much more effective box respirators, which were used during the rest of the war.

Anti-German feeling

However, the Edinburgh-born academic and fellow of New College Oxford could have found reasons not to help the British war effort at all.

His brother Richard, who was Secretary of State for War and then Lord Chancellor, suffered from the wave of anti-German feeling that swept the country at the start of World War One.

"[Some] newspapers launched attacks on him because he'd studied in Germany, he spoke very good German and had close relations with German colleagues," according to Dr Sturdy.

"He was hounded out of office, and I think John Haldane suffered from that as well."

But, Mr Haldane continued his work throughout the war, and continued to experiment on himself.

He also used his son, who was in his 20s, in some experiments - it seemed to do him no harm, nor did it put him off science, as he went on to become a professor of genetics.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Oxford



25 °C 14 °C

BBC Local Live

    Good evening 18:00:

    Local Live has finished for the day. We'll be back with more news, sport, travel and weather from 08:00 on Tuesday.

    tv tonight 17:50: Geraldine Peers Presenter, BBC South Today

    Tonight from 18:30, work on a £6m scheme to create a hamburger roundabout at Kennington caused traffic misery for motorists this morning.

    And hundreds of people lined the roads of Bicester to witness the last ever parade by 23 Pioneer Regiment.

    Thundery showers risk 17:39: Alexis Green Weather presenter, BBC South Today

    This evening and tonight there is still the risk of heavy, thundery showers although these will tend to ease and most places will become dry through the night with lows of 14 to 15C. (59F).

    Weather chart
    'Get the bus' 17:30: Emma Harrison BBC News Online

    Motorists were stuck in traffic for up to three hours this morning after a new contraflow system began on the A423 between Hinksey Hill and Heyford Hill interchanges. The system will remain in place until November 2014.

    Oxfordshire County Council's deputy leader Rodney Rose said: "If you are not used to using public transport perhaps for this period it would be useful.

    Councillor Rodney Rose

    "One bus can take 70 cars off the road for example and a train can take an awful lot more. So if a train journey is possible, even if it is until the end of November, perhaps you would think about it."

    Blooming lovely 17:18:

    Becca Collacott from Abingdon has emailed in these pictures of colourful flowers.


    Email us to share your pictures of Oxfordshire.

    Didcot towers picture 17:07:

    Mel Gigg has sent in this great image of Didcot Power Station taken from the ridgeway to the south of Didcot.

    Didcot Power Station

    Mel said: This was a few hours before the demolition but to me is a far more personal and fitting reminder of them as the shadow of the floodlights point the way to the sky.

    Do you have a picture you would like to share? Email us now.

    In the news 17:00: Bethan Phillips Newsreader, BBC Radio Oxford

    Drivers are being warned to expect more congestion tonight - because of roadworks that caused delays of up to three hours this morning on Oxford's southern bypass.

    We will hear from transport boss Rodney Rose after 17:00.

    Charity money debate 16:50: via Facebook

    Today Kat Orman asked whether the RSPCA spending more than £320,000 on fighting a court case is an acceptable use of charity money? Should there be more transparency from charities about how donated money is spent?

    Sarah Needle wrote: £326k is a lot of money to spend prosecuting one group. Surely that money could be better spent else where, helping more animals...?!

    Rosie Wilkins wrote: People donate to the RSPCA because they are animal lovers. I don't think many of them would mind too much that their donation was being used to protect animals.

    New Healthwatch CEO 16:42:

    Healthwatch Oxfordshire has appointed Rachel Coney as its new chief executive officer.

    She joins the watchdog after nine years spent working within the NHS.

    Rachel Coney

    Her last role was as assistant director at the Oxfordshire Clinical Commissioning Group (OCCG).

    Ms Coney said: "I look forward to working with patients, social care recipients, carers, commissioners, providers and the voluntary sector, to make a significant difference to the quality of health and social care in the county."

    Flytipper fined 16:31: Emma Harrison BBC News Online

    A 22-year-old man who dumped several rubbish bags at the end of his own street was fined after council officers found his address among the waste.

    Mitchell Brash, of Deacon Way, Banbury, was ordered to pay a total of £370 in fines and legal costs after pleading guilty to one charge of flytipping at Banbury Magistrates' Court.

    Rape case dropped 16:21: Eleanor Williams BBC News

    A 22-year-old man accused of raping a teenage girl in an Oxfordshire town last year has had the charge against him dropped.

    The 15-year-old girl reported that she was attacked while walking in Shilton Park in Carterton after a night out on 21 September.

    Upside down rainbow 16:12:

    Rob Horne tweeted this picture of an upside down rainbow spotted above Banbury yesterday.

    Upside down rainbow

    If you have a picture you'd like to share, get in touch on Twitter.

    In the news 16:00: Bethan Phillips Newsreader, BBC Radio Oxford

    The redevelopment of the Didcot cooling towers site is set to bring jobs to the area, according to the company behind the plans.

    We'll hear from Neil Harvey from Clowes Development UK limited on BBC Radio Oxford after 16:00.

    Heavy traffic 15:51: Emma Harrison BBC News Online

    BBC Radio Oxford heard from motorists sat in traffic for up to three hours earlier on the A423 and A34 because of roadworks on the southern bypass at the Kennington Roundabout.

    This afternoon there is still heavy traffic in both directions on the A423.

    Commonweath Games final 15:38: Ross Heaton Sports reporter, BBC Radio Oxford

    Oxfordshire 1500m runner Hannah England has qualified for the final on Tuesday after finishing 4th in the semi-final.

    Dead fish 15:28: Alex Therrien BBC News Online

    The Environment Agency is investigating what caused the deaths of about 250 fish in Oxfordshire.

    The fish were found at the Moor Ditch in Didcot on Saturday.

    Didcot towers conversion? 15:19:

    Architects ADP tweets: Didcot's cooling towers are down. Didn't go for our conversion ideas then... via @BBCOxford

    Didcot towers
    In the news 14:59: Bethan Phillips Newsreader, BBC Radio Oxford

    Drivers are being warned to avoid the southern bypass in Oxford - after roadworks caused chaos there this morning.

    A contraflow has been set up on the A423, reducing it to one lane in each direction.

    Deputy leader of Oxfordshire County Council Rodney Rose says people should think about other means of travel.

    WW1 photographs 14:44:

    A library is calling for the donation of First World War photographs.

    Abingdon library is working with the Abingdon Area Archaeological and History Society to build up a photographic display of the town's soldiers.

    Kat and Co 14:28: Kat Orman Afternoon presenter, BBC Radio Oxford

    On today's show, we are talking about charity spending. The RSPCA spent more than £320,000 prosecuting members of the Heythrop Hunt in David Cameron's constituency in Oxfordshire two years ago.

    A review of the prosecution has provoked fierce criticism. Is this an acceptable use of charity money? Would you be happy for your monetary donations to be spent on fighting court cases?


    Should there be more transparency from charities about how donated money is spent?

    Join the discussion on our Facebook page.

    In Connor's memory 14:15: Oxford Mail

    A fundraising event will be held at a city nightclub tomorrow night for a campaign over the death of a teenager at an NHS facility.

    In the news 14:01: Bethan Phillips Newsreader, BBC Radio Oxford

    Major roadworks on Oxford's southern bypass have caused delays of up to two hours on the A34.

    A contraflow has been set up on the A423, reducing it to one lane in each direction.

    We'll hear from Emma Wilberforce from Stagecoach at 14:00, who says buses have been experiencing problems as a result.

    Hot pets 13:43:

    Becca Collacott from Abingdon has sent us this picture of her cat Ebony enjoying the recent hot weather.

    Send us in your pictures via email, Facebook or Twitter.

    Cat in the sun

    Take a look at BBC South Today's Facebook photo album of pets enjoying the sunshine.

    quarterstaffer's plea 13:28: Oxford Times

    A lone quarterstaffer is trying to teach Oxford about the little-known British tradition, despite the fact no one showed up to his first training session this week.

    Lunchtime television 13:15: BBC South Today

    Coming up from 13:30, with Tom Hepworth, after dominating the landscape for more than forty years three cooling towers at Didcot A power station are no more and troops from 23 Pioneer Regiment - the Royal Logistic Corps - have marched through Bicester for the final time ahead of the unit being disbanded.

    In the news 13:00: Bethan Phillips Newsreader, BBC Radio Oxford

    Roadworks on the A423 that caused severe traffic delays this morning are expected to last until November.

    We'll hear more from the deputy leader of Oxfordshire County Council, Rodney Rose, after 13:00.

    He says they've been trying to work outside of rush hour as much as possible.

    Commonwealth games 12:51:

    Didcot shooter Dan Rivers has missed out on place in the final of the 50m prone event after finishing 20th in today's qualifying event.

    He won bronze in the 10m air rifle shootout on Friday.

    Dan Rivers
    Dead fish 12:37:

    The Environment Agency tweets: 1/2 1) We are busy investigating the cause of pollution to Moor Ditch in #Didcot with has resulted in dead fish.

    It added: 2/2 This incident isn't related to recent demolition of the #Didcot cooling towers. Please call with any info on the pollution 0800 807060.

    A34 congestion 12:20:

    Stagecoach Oxford tweets: SERVICE UPDATE:A34 is heavily congested due to Kennington r/works. S5's experiencing delays of up to 35 mins.

    Final march 12:09: Oxford Times

    Bicester's 23 Pioneer Regiment passed through the town on Sunday for the last time.

    In the news 12:00: Paul Jenner Newsreader, BBC Radio Oxford

    A contraflow system installed on Oxford's southern bypass has been causing huge problems on the A34 this morning.

    The A423 was down to one lane in each direction between Hinksey Hill Interchange and Heyford Hill Interchange.

    We'll hear from the county's transport boss Rodney Rose after 12:00.

    Benefit Fraud 11:42:

    A 48-year-old man who dishonestly claimed more than £8,800 in benefits has been given a 12-month community order of 120 hours unpaid work.

    Yawahab Badmus, of Hockmore Tower, Cowley, who was also told to pay £120 costs, will have to pay back the overpaid benefit to Oxford City Council.

    New Oxford United signing 11:31:

    Oxford United have signed defender Joe Riley on loan from Bolton Wanderers.

    Riley 22, joins the team until January after passing his medical this morning.

    Joe Riley

    Head coach Michael Appleton said: "He is 6ft tall, he has pace and he uses the ball well.

    "A lot of clubs have been monitoring his career and he has a chance to come here, play games and show everyone what a good player he is."

    Arson attack 11:21: Oxford Mail

    A tyre business owner has spoken out after his workshop was destroyed in a suspected arson attack at Faringdon Business Park in the early hours of Saturday.

    Pictures: Didcot demolition 11:11:

    Thanks to Damien Dyer who emailed these fantastic aerial shots of where the Didcot cooling towers once stood.

    Demolished Didcot towers
    Demolished Didcot towers
    In the news 10:59: Paul Jenner Newsreader, BBC Radio Oxford

    Motorists have been stuck in traffic this morning because of roadworks in Oxford.

    The A423 has been reduced to one lane in each direction between Hinksey Hill Interchange and Heyford Hill Interchange.

    We'll hear from someone who was in the jam earlier on BBC Radio Oxford after 11:00.

    Stuck in traffic? 10:49: Malcolm Boyden Mid-morning presenter, BBC Radio Oxford

    We want to hear from you if you've been stuck on the A34 this morning. Give us a call on 03459 311666.

    Feedback 10:41:

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? Tell us what you think.

    A34 traffic 10:29:

    Dani Dixey tweets: @dizzy_360 @BBCOxford it's taken me over an hour from Abingdon and I've moved maybe 3 miles! Turn off where you can!

    On today's show 10:24: Malcolm Boyden Mid-morning presenter, BBC Radio Oxford

    I'll be talking to Ian Nolan, a relative of Chipping Norton 18-year-old Emma Curtis-Smith, who died while watching her boyfriend on his first parade as an officer cadet at the Royal Military Academy Sandhurt in Surrey in 2005. Ian will be talking about the charity launched in her memory, Emma's Trust.

    I'll also be meeting Witney man Mike Leahy who's sold his house and possessions to live in a double decker bus with a load of scorpions and leeches.

    M40 queuing traffic 10:13:
    In the news 10:00: Paul Jenner Newsreader, BBC Radio Oxford

    Roadworks have caused severe traffic delays in Oxford this morning.

    We will be talking to those caught up in the jams on BBC Radio Oxford after 10:00.

    Didcot demolition 09:44: Phil Gayle Breakfast presenter, BBC Radio Oxford

    This morning I want to know what would you built on the site of the Didcot cooling towers now three of them have been demolished?

    It's the size of 65 football pitches. What does Oxfordshire need?

    Didcot Power Station

    Get in touch and join the discussion on Facebook or Twitter.

    A34 woes 09:36:

    Becky Donaldson tweets: @BBCOxford a34 north been queued from before marcham turnoff not at abingdon yet and sat still, its been 90mins and counting....urgh

    New playground 09:29: Henley Standard

    A £130,000 toddler playground has been officially opened in Henley.

    Replacements for Didcot's towers? 09:19: via Facebook

    Three of Didcot's cooling towers are gone and BBC Radio Oxford listeners have been discussing on Facebook what the site could now be used for.

    Edith Smith wrote: Didcot has nothing special in Didcot for kids. Take a leaf out of Cholsey and make a special play area.

    Didcot Power Station

    Carol Kenny wrote: Out door/indoor leisure centre, with a Glamping site.

    Stephen Shephard suggested a theme park.

    What do you think? Join the debate now.

    M40 traffic 09:09:

    Stop-start traffic has been reported on the M40 London-bound between J6, B4009 (Watlington) and J3, A40 (Loudwater).

    as it happened
    • News, sport, travel, weather for Mon 28 July
    • More updates from 08:00 on Tuesday
    • Listen to BBC Radio Oxford
    in the news 09:00: Paul Jenner Newsreader, BBC Radio Oxford

    We've spoken to Bill McKinnon, who lives just 450m away from where Didcot's closest tower once stood.

    He says there was a huge amount of dust from yesterday's demolition.

    Hear more on BBC Radio Oxford after 9:00.

    Gaza rally 08:44: Oxford Mail

    Opponents of Israel's bombardment of the Gaza strip took to the streets of Oxford on Saturday in support of victims of the conflict.

    Man hit by car 08:33:

    A man was hit by a car following an argument with at least one woman yesterday, police have said.

    The argument happened near the Evenlode Tower in Blackbird Leys, Oxford, at about 01:00.

    The man was then hit by a silver car while he was on the pavement near the tower and the woman got into the car, which drove off.

    He suffered heavy bruising to his leg and was taken to the John Radcliffe Hospital.

    They're gone... 08:24:

    Three cooling towers at Didcot A Power Station were demolished yesterday.

    Didcot Power Station demolition

    Hundreds of people gathered to watch the towers come down at 5:01 BST.

    Relive the moment they were demolished here.

    Roadworks 08:14:

    There is a new contraflow system in place between the A4074 and A34 with traffic reduced to one lane due to junction improvements at the Kennington Roundabout and Hinksey Hill Interchange.

    Long delays are expected.

    Sunny intervals 08:06: Bee Tucker BBC Weather

    There will be sunny intervals and showers today, which will be locally very heavy and thundery.

    Weather forecast

    Generally it will feel warm or very warm in the light winds. Highs of 23C (73F).

    Good morning 08:00: Emma Harrison BBC News Online

    Welcome along to BBC Local Live this Monday morning. I'll be bringing you the latest news, sport, travel and weather for the county.

    Get in touch - on email, Facebook or Twitter.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.