Oxfordshire toddler's death review reveals 'missed chance'

Oxfordshire County Council Oxfordshire County Council admitted the child died amid "a tragic set of circumstances"

A 22-month-old boy's death may have been prevented if organisations had worked more effectively together, a report concluded.

Child Y, from Oxfordshire, died from a fractured skull in November 2010. His father was jailed for 15 months in May, after admitting child neglect.

Oxfordshire Safeguarding Children Board's serious case review found a concern raised over his condition five months earlier was not acted upon.

The NSPCC called it "an awful tragedy".

Oxfordshire County Council expressed its sorrow, calling it "a tragic set of circumstances".

'Missed opportunity'

The report showed eight different agencies, including the county council, the former Oxfordshire Primary Care Trust and Thames Valley Police, had an involvement with Child Y and his family.

It concluded there was a "missed opportunity" to address the child's circumstances.

The serious case review found an anonymous tip-off was received in June 2010 by social services over the boy's condition.

It said he displayed signs of developmental delay and possible bruising from falling over.

But, the report found, it was not fully recorded or investigated and only came to light following his death.

In September 2009, a visit to a GP for a routine vaccination saw a nurse examine a number of injuries and bruises.

A visit to a hospital later the same day, following visits from police and social services, resulted in a paediatrician accepting the parents' explanation the injuries were sustained accidentally.

Child Y's mother suffered from mental health issues and was being harassed by a former partner, as well as being in debt.

Furthermore, on New Year's Day 2008, police were called to her house after she had taken an overdose and cut her wrists, for which she later received hospital treatment.

She gave birth to Child Y in early 2009, at a time when she continued to face housing and financial problems.

In November 2010, Child Y's parents took him to their local hospital. He was found to have extensive serious head injuries, including a fractured skull, as well as bruising to his abdomen and skull.

He died a week later. His mother has since moved to Ireland.

'Capacity to parent'

David Tucker, head of policy at the NSPCC, admitted it was distressing to hear better co-ordination could have saved the infant's life.

He said: "There is evidence that multi-agency structures are being developed across the country to allow better sharing of information.

"It's really important information is joined-up to ensure a holistic view of a mother's capacity to parent a child."

In a statement, Oxfordshire County Council said: "Organisations involved have rightly been called upon to explain their role.

"The council makes it the highest priority to act swiftly on recommendations made in a serious case review, as we have done in this case."

Thames Valley Police, Cherwell District Council and Oxford University Hospitals NHS Trust said they all acknowledged the review's recommendations, extending their sympathies to the child's family.

Child Y's father later had his sentence reduced to 10 months after an appeal.

  • This article was amended on 16 December to reflect the reduction in Child Y's father's prison sentence.

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Oxford

Weather

Oxford

Min. Night 3 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    18:00:

    That's all from the BBC Local Live service for today, the service will return from 08:00 on Saturday.

     
  2.  
    Coming up 17:57: BBC South Today

    Coming up at 18:45, South Today will be investigating how Christian groups on Oxford's Cowley Road have come together in a show of faith despite being prevented from putting on a religious play.

     
  3.  
    Donations in runner's memory reach £1.15m 17:53: Oxford Mail

    About £1.15m has been raised by the Claire Squires Fund in memory of the runner who died after collapsing one mile from the finishing line of the London Marathon two years ago.

    Ms Squires, 30, a hairdresser, was raising money for the Banbury and District Samaritans, a charity with which her mother was involved.

     
  4.  
    Bin day details 17:47:

    Unsure when your bin days are due to the Easter break? Oxford City Council has a page of information here.

     
  5.  
    Magdalen battle for uni title 17:38:

    On Sunday night, University Challenge is hosting a special match with teams representing Magdalen College in Oxford and Manchester University battling to become the Champion of Champions.

    They have each won University Challenge on four occasions - more than any other institution. The sides include a member from each of the four champion Magdalen and Manchester teams.

    Will Magdalen survive the wrath of Paxman to make it five wins?

    Jeremy Paxman
     
  6.  
    Oxford lose 1-0 to York 17:21:

    Oxford United have lost 1-0 to York despite having 61% of the possession. The result sees them drop a place to 8th in the league.

     
  7.  
    Tour of Oxfordshire 17:07:

    C and W Railway tweets: Hear us on @BBCOxford 95.2FM tomorrow morning live from Cholsey Station at 0930 & 1015 as part of their 'Grand tour of Oxfordshire'

     
  8.  
    Twins sent to different schools 16:43: Oxford Mail

    A mother is angry because her twin daughters - one of whom has special needs - face being sent to different secondary schools.

     
  9.  
    Oxford still trailing York 16:30:

    With 20 minutes left to play, Oxford United are 1-0 down against York. U's head coach Gary Waddock will be hoping they can turn it around and continue the play-off push.

     
  10.  
    Wigan ease further ahead 16:22:

    It's now Wigan 3, Reading 0, with the Latics putting further distance between themselves and the Royals as both teams battle to secure a Championship play-off place.

     
  11.  
    Eggstraordinary exploring 16:14:

    If you're looking for something to do tomorrow, why not eggsplore the Oxford University Museum of Natural History's eggciting egg-hunter's trail.

    Eggs

    It's free to take part and there's more information here.

     
  12.  
    Wigan v Reading 15:59:

    Reading fans might want to look away now. The Royals are currently 2-0 down at half-time away at Wigan Athletic. They've been dominated in the possession stats with the Latics having 65% of the ball.

    Follow the match live.

     
  13.  
    Your views 15:40:

    We've introduced BBC Local Live to bring you the latest news, sport, travel and weather all in one place. Tell us what you think.

     
  14.  
    Listen: The 'perfect beat' 15:20:

    Scientists believe they have found the perfect beat to make people want to dance.

    Researchers at Oxford and Aarhus universities asked people around the world what they made of 50 varying drum rhythms.

    Music professor Eric Clarke, who co-authored the study, said regular rhythms with some unexpected beats made those surveyed want to dance, but highly syncopated music such as free jazz put them off.

     
  15.  
    Sunny spells to continue 15:05:

    The weather for the rest of the day: Dry and sunny spells will continue and feel pleasantly warm with just a light breeze. Patchy cloud may bubble up this afternoon. Maximum temperature: 17C (63F).

     
  16.  
    Two hurt in bike collision 14:45:

    Two men were injured when a red Ducati motorcycle and a bicycle collided on the southbound carriageway of the B4494, Wantage Road, near the Ridgeway crossing just before 07:00 yesterday.

    Crash scene

    The rider of the motorcycle, a 49-year-old man, received injuries to his wrist, while the bicycle rider, a 42-year-old man, received leg and rib injuries.

    Both were taken to the John Radcliffe Hospital, Oxford.

     
  17.  
    Dog fouling targeted 14:25: Banbury Guardian

    Dog owners who fail to pick up after their pets are being targeted by undercover enforcement officers as part of an initiative to catch culprits in the act.

     
  18.  
    Slow on M40 due to getaway 14:10:

    In the M40 in Oxfordshire there's slow traffic northbound between J9, A34 (Bicester) and J10, A43 (Brackley). Get the latest here.

     
  19.  
    Turning Japanese? 13:56:

    Oxford Brookes tweets: Interested in Japanese culture? Hear readings to music from Motoki Hirai. Part of #Outburst2014! Book at http://goo.gl/JpNC78

     
  20.  
    Big match preview 13:40: BBC Radio Oxford

    Oxford United are set to kick off the first of their Bank Holiday fixtures. This afternoon the U's entertain York City at the Kassam Stadium and their push for a place in the play-offs is well and truly back on track.

    Last weekend's win at Plymouth has lifted them back into the top seven. Hear our sports editor Jerome Sale who is gearing up at the Kassam Stadium.

     
  21.  
    City traders to get new champion 13:25: Oxford Times

    An empty traders' champion post will be filled, council bosses have said, following fears the under-review role will be axed.

     
  22.  
    Coming up 13:06: BBC South Today

    On South Today at 13:14pm: We'll have coverage of a walk which took place in Oxford this morning.

    About 40 people from various Christian groups in the city took part in the event which represented the journey Christ made to the crucifixion.

    However it was much smaller than the event organisers had originally planned - a full scale Passion play re-enacting the last few days of Jesus's life.

     
  23.  
    Kitchen fire escape 12:51: Banbury Cake

    A mum and baby escaped a kitchen fire after a warning from the smoke alarm going off.

     
  24.  
    Why is today called Good Friday? 12:36:

    It is the day when Christians commemorate Jesus Christ's crucifixion. So why is it called Good Friday? BBC Magazine Monitor has the answer here.

    Reverend Alistair Prince walks through Croxteth Country park, Liverpool
     
  25.  
    Emotional reunion 12:15: Thame Gazette

    Two brothers who live just outside Thame have met their long-lost sister for the first time in an emotional television reunion.

     
  26.  
    News headlines 11:57: BBC Radio Oxford

    The top stories at 12:00:

    • Enforcing the deal to ease the crisis in Ukraine will be tricky according to an Oxford expert in international relations
    • An avalanche on the world's highest mountain, Everest, has killed 12 people in what's thought to be the single biggest loss of life on its slopes
    • Scientists in Oxford are hoping to use three dimensional printing to create synthetic tissues for organ repair
     
  27.  
    Your views 11:35:

    Tell us what you think of BBC Local Live. We'd like your feedback about this service.

     
  28.  
    Passion event goes ahead after error 11:20:

    A Good Friday service and procession will replace a Passion play which was cancelled after a council official did not realise it was a religious event.

    Actors were due to re-enact the Easter story on Cowley Road in Oxford until a mix-up over the event's licence. Organisers said there would now be a procession with prayers and readings but no outdoor performance or costumes.

     
  29.  
    Dementia patient search service axed 11:00: Bicester Advertiser

    A pioneering scheme to locate missing Oxfordshire dementia patients has been forced to close after it found only one lost OAP in 18 months.

     
  30.  
    U's boss on big match 10:45: David Prever Drivetime presenter, BBC Radio Oxford

    There's a massive match going on at the Kassam Stadium this afternoon as Oxford United host play-off rivals York City.

    The win against Plymouth last weekend lifted the U's back into the top seven, but York are hot on their heels as they're a single point behind United in eighth place.

    At 11:20, hear head coach Gary Waddock telling Ross Heaton it's an exciting time to be around the club.

    Gary Waddock
     
  31.  
    Cameron's conservative clothing? 10:29:

    He's the Prime Minister but BBC Politics says sometimes he has been criticised for his conservative dress sense (pun very much intended).

    David Cameron

    The Daily Telegraph has diagnosed David Cameron as being in a "style rut" over his trademark off-duty look - but his Witney constituents are probably more concerned with his work in their area.

     
  32.  
    Cycling manifesto 10:15: Oxford Mail

    Cycling freeways and quiet ways as well as cutting Oxford's remaining 30mph speed limits to 20mph are the cornerstone of a new manifesto from campaigners.

     
  33.  
    'Google pin' mystery 09:59:

    Earlier this week we told you how a mysterious "Google pin" had appeared on a roundabout in Oxfordshire.

    "Google pin" in roundabout

    The origin of the giant 'A' at Playhatch Roundabout on the A4155 Reading to Henley road is not yet known, although the BBC understands it may have been put there by an artist. If you know anything about it tweet us or post a comment on our Facebook page.

     
  34.  
    As it happened
     
  35.  
    Hi-tech balloon lost in Oxfordshire 09:45:

    A hi-tech balloon launched in Nottingham to take pictures of the Earth has been lost in Oxfordshire.

    Nottingham University's physics society, PhysNotts, released the balloon on Friday but lost its signal the same day.

    They believe the helium balloon, which was taking photos of the curvature of the Earth, most likely landed around Oxford or Bicester.

     
  36.  
    Radiohead star's triathlon bid 09:32:

    On Monday, we told you about Radiohead bassist Colin Greenwood's decision to enter the Blenheim Palace triathlon.

    Colin Greenwood

    Colin jokingly said he's had to cut down on his "40-a-day Regal King Size smoking habit" and "ration the hard liquor" in preparation for the event.

    He will be supporting his neighbour Scarlett Clarkson, nine, who is battling acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (ALL).

     
  37.  
    Passion play cancellation 'a mistake' 09:17:

    A Good Friday Passion play in Oxford has been cancelled after a council official did not realise it was a religious event.

    Organisers of the outdoor performance, due to be held on the Cowley Road, cancelled it after an "intractable situation" with the city council.

    The authority's licensing team leader has since apologised and admitted making "a mistake".

     
  38.  
    News on the hour 09:01:

    The top stories on BBC Radio Oxford at 09:00:

    • There will be fewer care home places for state-funded elderly people in Oxfordshire, warn the people who provide them
    • The captain of the South Korean ferry which capsized and sank yesterday has said he's deeply ashamed of what happened
    • A new government review into an anti-acne drug has been welcomed by the family of an Oxfordshire teenager who died after taking it
     
  39.  
    Play-off push 08:45:

    Oxford United face a crucial home game against York at 15:00.

    Deane Smalley

    The U's currently sit in the final play-off position in League Two, just one point ahead of the team they face later.

    United look set to be without injured striker Deane Smalley (pictured) but winger Alfie Potter is back to full fitness.

     
  40.  
    Weather looking good for today 08:30:

    It'll be a dry and sunny to start to the Easter weekend, but more unsettled from Sunday.

    After a chilly start to today, it will be dry with sunny spells, and feeling pleasantly warm with just a light breeze. Patchy cloud may bubble up this afternoon.

    Oxford weather

    Get the latest forecast here.

     
  41.  
    Flood walkway built 08:15:

    A new walkway is being built to stop homeowners from being trapped when the area floods.

    People living on the Botley Road found themselves stranded when access to their homes were flooded in January.

    Now a new walkway is being built by affordable housing provider Home Group.

     
  42.  
    08:00:

    Good morning and welcome to today's news, sport, travel and weather updates for Oxfordshire.

     

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.