Oxfordshire toddler's death review reveals 'missed chance'

Oxfordshire County Council Oxfordshire County Council admitted the child died amid "a tragic set of circumstances"

A 22-month-old boy's death may have been prevented if organisations had worked more effectively together, a report concluded.

Child Y, from Oxfordshire, died from a fractured skull in November 2010. His father was jailed for 15 months in May, after admitting child neglect.

Oxfordshire Safeguarding Children Board's serious case review found a concern raised over his condition five months earlier was not acted upon.

The NSPCC called it "an awful tragedy".

Oxfordshire County Council expressed its sorrow, calling it "a tragic set of circumstances".

'Missed opportunity'

The report showed eight different agencies, including the county council, the former Oxfordshire Primary Care Trust and Thames Valley Police, had an involvement with Child Y and his family.

It concluded there was a "missed opportunity" to address the child's circumstances.

The serious case review found an anonymous tip-off was received in June 2010 by social services over the boy's condition.

It said he displayed signs of developmental delay and possible bruising from falling over.

But, the report found, it was not fully recorded or investigated and only came to light following his death.

In September 2009, a visit to a GP for a routine vaccination saw a nurse examine a number of injuries and bruises.

A visit to a hospital later the same day, following visits from police and social services, resulted in a paediatrician accepting the parents' explanation the injuries were sustained accidentally.

Child Y's mother suffered from mental health issues and was being harassed by a former partner, as well as being in debt.

Furthermore, on New Year's Day 2008, police were called to her house after she had taken an overdose and cut her wrists, for which she later received hospital treatment.

She gave birth to Child Y in early 2009, at a time when she continued to face housing and financial problems.

In November 2010, Child Y's parents took him to their local hospital. He was found to have extensive serious head injuries, including a fractured skull, as well as bruising to his abdomen and skull.

He died a week later. His mother has since moved to Ireland.

'Capacity to parent'

David Tucker, head of policy at the NSPCC, admitted it was distressing to hear better co-ordination could have saved the infant's life.

He said: "There is evidence that multi-agency structures are being developed across the country to allow better sharing of information.

"It's really important information is joined-up to ensure a holistic view of a mother's capacity to parent a child."

In a statement, Oxfordshire County Council said: "Organisations involved have rightly been called upon to explain their role.

"The council makes it the highest priority to act swiftly on recommendations made in a serious case review, as we have done in this case."

Thames Valley Police, Cherwell District Council and Oxford University Hospitals NHS Trust said they all acknowledged the review's recommendations, extending their sympathies to the child's family.

Child Y's father later had his sentence reduced to 10 months after an appeal.

  • This article was amended on 16 December to reflect the reduction in Child Y's father's prison sentence.

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Oxford



19 °C 13 °C

BBC Local Live

    Stokenchurch accident 10:05: Sara Dumbell Travel presenter, BBC Radio Oxford

    At Stokenchurch there are reports that the A40 Oxford Road is partially blocked Westbound by an accident between Chalk Farm Road and Ibstone Road.

    It's a two car incident on the bridge over the M40 junction 5.

    News on the hour 09:59: Sue Kinnear Newsreader, BBC Radio Oxford

    The University of Oxford has slipped down a place in a prestigious international ranking system - but is still beating its rival Cambridge.

    The institution is now ranked third in the latest Times Higher Education World University Rankings - down from joint second last year.

    More on this and the other headlines with me at 10:00.

    More on Caterham 09:50: Ross Heaton Sports reporter, BBC Radio Oxford

    The items seized by Sheriffs included a 2013 Caterham F1 test car, car parts and steering wheels, pitlane equipment, and TV's and monitors.

    The team insists their preparations for the Japanese Grand Prix this weekend have not been affected.

    Caterham to drive on 09:43: Ross Heaton Sports reporter, BBC Radio Oxford

    The future of the Caterham Formula One team is in question again after bailiffs visited their factory in Leafield near Witney.

    Caterham F1 car

    The team rejected what they say were "uncontrolled rumours" about the team's involvement in F1 and said that the action concerns a supplier to their parent company.

    Fine for pub change couple 09:32: Oxford Times

    A couple who turned their pub into a house without permission have been ordered to pay £17,000, Cherwell District Council said yesterday.

    Fish and chip Thursday 09:24: Andrew Humphrey BBC Local Live

    Following Radio Oxford's discovery that schools may be adjusting their menus to boost school meal take-up today, the Department for Education told us that they expect schools to promote free meals to benefit the pupils.

    They also said a one-day census was "a sound basis for measuring take-up and allocating funding", they did warn that if the data is not properly reflecting take-up they will take action.

    Of course the fact that my daughter's school has switched the menu to include fish and chips today was purely down to an inset day tomorrow, I'm sure!

    Phone fraudster jailed 09:11: Banbury Cake

    Staff at a mobile phone shop rumbled a fraudster's scam which saw him pocket 76 iPhones worth more than £34,000.

    Top headlines
    News on the hour 08:59: Charles Nove Presenter, BBC Radio Oxford

    BBC Radio Oxford has learned an emergency team meeting for all staff at the Caterham Formula 1 headquarters in West Oxfordshire is taking place about now.

    It is to discuss fears for the future of the team and the 300 people who work for it, after bailiffs were sent in the Leafield factory.

    There's more on this at 09:00.

    Broken down coach 08:49: Sara Dumbell Travel presenter, BBC Radio Oxford

    Barry rang me to report delays on the B4027 between Stanton St John and Forest Hill due to temporary lights for broadband works.

    And on the M40 Southbound, just before junction 6 for Watlington, James has called in to report a broken down coach blocking a lane.

    Oxford University still in top 10 08:42: Katherine Sellgren BBC News education reporter

    Three UK universities have lost their place in the top 200 of a global higher education league table, but Oxford remains in the top 10.


    The universities of Reading, Dundee and Newcastle slipped out of the top 200 of the Times Higher Education (THE) World Rankings for 2014-15.

    Schools 'cooking the books' on meal census 08:27: Helen Catt Political reporter, BBC Radio Oxford

    Oxfordshire's primary schools could lose thousands of pounds of funding - if children don't have school meals today.

    School meal being served to pupil

    And it seem's some schools are using unorthodox tactics to boost take-up, including adjusting their menu for one week only or bringing forward their popular Friday meals - often chips - to today.

    Parents have also been directly asked to sign their children up for today, and one school is offering free school meals for all pupils as a one-off special.

    The amount of money schools get to provide the universal free school meals will be based on today's uptake - and on one other day in January.

    Bright and sunny 08:15: Alexis Green Weather presenter, BBC South Today

    A mainly dry start to the day once the mist and fog clears and we'll see some bright and sunny spells.

    Weather graphic

    There is a slim chance of showers, but temperatures doing well with a high of 20C (68F).

    A freshening breeze will turn the afternoon and evening cooler.

    A4095 struggling 08:05: Sara Dumbell Travel presenter, BBC Radio Oxford

    The A4095 is solid from Witney to Long Hanborough - reports that the temporary lights are causing delays by the garage at Long Hanborough.

    Good morning 08:00: Andrew Humphrey BBC Local Live

    Good morning and welcome along to BBC Local Live for Oxfordshire this Thursday morning.

    I'll be bringing you all the latest news, sport, travel and weather from across the county.

    You can get in touch throughout the day and tell us what you're up to via email, Facebook or Twitter.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.