Hillsborough police statement 'sanitised' by third party

Leppings Lane turnstiles Sheffield Wednesday said turnstile procedures were tightened up four years before the Hillsborough disaster

A statement given by a police sergeant on the day of the Hillsborough disaster was "sanitised" by a third party, an inquests jury has heard.

Sgt David Batty said the wording of a sentence had been changed and a further line had been removed completely.

The inquests also heard from an ex-turnstile worker who said he took cash to allow ticketless fans into FA Cup ties in the years before the disaster.

Dr James Gauntlett said other stewards allowed fans in while he worked there.

In April 1989, 96 Liverpool fans were fatally crushed at the FA Cup semi-final held at the stadium.

Sgt Batty, giving evidence via video link due to poor health, wrote in May of 1989 that he had overheard a radio message at Hillsborough in which an officer was "pleading" for gates to be opened.

In his official statement that went before the Lord Taylor public inquiry, the wording was changed to "requesting".

A sentence in which he said a message over the public address system was a "garbled noise" was also removed, the jury heard.

Sgt Batty said he heard "pleadings for the gate to be opened" on the radio while dealing with youths who had been arrested for being drunk at a sporting event.

He said: "The word was crossed out and somebody put 'asked' in and first that went, and put 'requested' in. It was fair enough, it was a request".

'Corrections taken out'

The jury was shown two versions of his statement, but with one with the word 'amend' written on it.

Sgt Batty agreed that it was "very unusual" for a third party to amend an officer's statement and he did not know who had crossed out his sentence.

Mark George QC, representing some of the Hillsborough families, said Sgt Batty's statement had been "sanitised".

He said: "All of these corrections have been taken out so it now reads as if those passages never appeared in your statement".

Sgt Batty was also questioned by Chris Daw QC, representing Chief Supt Donald Denton and Chief Supt Terry Wain.

The two were involved in evidence gathering by South Yorkshire Police after the disaster in 1989.

He agreed with Mr Daw that the changes to his statement had not affected the evidence he gave to the new inquests.

'Extremely dirty look'

The jury earlier heard from Dr Gauntlett, who worked as a turnstile operator at the club from 1979 to 1985.

He said during FA Cup semi-final matches at the stadium in 1980 and 1981, 10% of his fans at his turnstile did not have a ticket or were at the wrong end.

Dr Gauntlett added in 1981 he was told to allow fans "without a valid ticket" into the stadium to avoid a crush at the turnstiles.

By 1985 the club had tightened up procedures, the inquests heard.

Leppings Lane entry Dr Gauntlett said he "made £100" from fans through his turnstile in 1981

Dr Gauntlett told the Warrington court that the "lessons to be learned" from 1980 and 1981 had motivated him to write to the Taylor Inquiry, which investigated the causes of the disaster.

He said at league games fans could buy tickets on the door. At those matches, there was an expectation the cash he had taken, along with the ticket stubs, would tally with the number of fans passing through the turnstiles.

He said a supervisor, Basil Jones, would give turnstile operators an "extremely dirty look" if their cash and count did not match and could eventually be dismissed.

But as FA Cup semi-final games were sell-outs, no tickets were sold on the door so they only collected ticket stubs.

Dr Gauntlett said: "We were explicitly told in 1981 by Basil Jones that our job was to get people through the turnstiles to avoid any crush in the turnstiles and if somebody arrived at the turnstiles without a valid ticket, you should allow them in."

Who were the 96 victims?

Eight of the Hillsborough victims, CW from top left: Paul Clark, Stephen Copoc, Tracey Cox, Jon-Paul Gilhooley, Steven Fox, Vincent Fitzsimmons, Christopher Edwards

He said that police would check tickets outside and his job was to "get them in to the ground as quickly as possible".

At each semi-final, he estimated 20 people went through his turnstile without tickets and "probably 60 or 70" went through with a ticket for a different section of the stadium.

Following a question by Jonathan Hough QC, junior counsel to the inquests, Dr Gauntlett said he took £70 in cash on top of his £10 shift payment in 1980. In 1981, he made "over £100".

Andrew Waters, representing Sheffield Wednesday, said taking money from ticketless fans was "stealing from the club".

Dr Gauntlett replied: "Nobody had a claim on that money. The club did not want the money. The club just wanted the ticket stubs."

'Capacity exceeded'

Mark George QC asked Dr Gauntlett about what effect taking money from ticketless fans would have on the numbers inside the ground.

He asked: "The net result of that would be that the capacity of the Leppings Lane would almost inevitably be exceeded if everyone turned up."

Dr Gauntlett replied: "Yes."

Mr George continued: "And it follows from what you have said that this would have been completely obvious both to the club and to the police?"

"Yes, it should have been," Dr Gauntlett replied.

The inquests continue.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Liverpool



7 °C 6 °C

BBC Local Live

    10:47: Warning of heavy snow Tom Mullen BBC News

    The Met Office has issued a weather warning for the North West region - with heavy snow expected later in the week.

    Snow generic

    As well as snow, forecasters are expecting string winds and poor visibility on the roads throughout Wednesday and Thursday.

    10:36: More 20mph speed limits St Helens Star

    A series of new 20mph zones could be rolled out across a number of roads in St Helens in an attempt to increase rates of walking and cycling.

    10:28: Eto'o switch to Sampdoria BBC Sport

    Everton striker Samuel Eto'o is due to complete his move to Sampdoria later today.

    Samuel Eto'o

    The 33-year-old passed a medical on Sunday, posting a picture on Twitter with the message: "Successful medical. Ready for a new challenge!!!"

    Eto'o joined the Toffees on a free transfer in August 2014, and has scored four goals in all competitions so far this season.

    10:18: Resident escapes chip pan blaze

    A smouldering chip pan left unattended started a fire at a flat in Liverpool.

    Stanley Road

    Firefighters were called to the property in Stanley Road, Bootle, at about 06:15 yesterday.

    The kitchen was badly damaged but the occupant escaped unhurt after being alerted by a smoke alarm.

    10:08: Reds face cup semi-final

    There's more football action tomorrow night when Liverpool face Chelsea in the semi-final decider in the Capital One Cup.

    Brendan Rodgers

    Manager Brendan Rodgers is holding a press conference today ahead of the game.

    You can watch it live from 10:00 on the club's official website.

    09:59: News on the hour Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    A child protection expert has called it "very worrying" that one of James Bulger's killers has been able to sign up to an online dating agency.

    Newspaper reports say Jon Venables, 32, who was jailed for a second time in 2010 after downloading child abuse images, has joined the website under a new name

    Listen live to the 10:00 bulletin.

    09:52: Coming up Sean Styles BBC Radio Merseyside

    Anyone appearing on Dragons Den must dread the words "I'm Out" coming out of Duncan Bannatyne's mouth.

    Duncan Bannatyne

    But a Wirral company is celebrating after getting an "I'm In" from not only Duncan, but fellow Dragon Piers Linney too.

    Listen to the show as I chat to owner Nicky Fletcher after 10:00.

    09:41: Punter misses £1m payout

    One unlucky punter could have won £1m from a £10 bet if Bolton had beaten Liverpool, according to the Daily Mail.


    The football fan even turned down a £15,000 cash out option, the newspaper says. The unnamed gambler had bet £10 on five teams to win during Saturday's FA Cup 4th round.

    09:29: Bus timetable shake-up

    Merseytravel tweets: Lots of bus timetables changed yesterday, pls check before you travel merseytravel.gov.uk/buschanges

    09:15: Talking health and safety Tony Snell BBC Radio Merseyside

    Morning folks. Don't try this at home! We're talking about health and safety regulations on today's show.


    This year marks 40 years since the Health and Safety Executive was set up so all this week on Breakfast we're going to be taking a closer look at the work they do, how important it is to the safety of British workers and busting some of the myths that surround health and safety.

    Listen to the show live by clicking here.

    09:07: Reds relishing cup draw BBC Sport

    Liverpool are among the clubs eagerly awaiting the results of tonight's FA Cup fifth-round draw.

    Liverpool vs Bolton

    The Reds were held to a 0-0 draw by Bolton on Saturday, with Wanderers failing to repeat their famous 1993 upset when they beat Liverpool 2-0.

    The draw will be shown on BBC One from 19:00.

    08:59: News on the hour Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    Reports that one of James Bulger's killers had joined an online dating website are "disgusting," the toddler's mother has said.

    Jon Venables has subscribed to the agency under his new identity, and Denise Fergus now fears for the women he could contact who won't know about his past.

    Listen live to the bulletin.

    08:48: 'Clare's Law' disclosures made Alex Morrison BBC News

    A scheme allowing people to find out if their partner has a history of domestic violence has been used more than 1,300 times in less than a year.

    Clare Wood and killer George Appleton

    Clare's Law - named after Clare Wood, who was murdered by her ex-boyfriend in 2009 - came into force across England and Wales in March 2014.

    However, the scheme shows huge variation between forces. On Merseyside, just 11% of requests led to information being released compared to more than 60% in Greater Manchester.

    08:35: Man, 67, stabbed in burglary Liverpool Echo

    A heroic pensioner was stabbed as he wrestled a knife-wielding intruder to the ground during a terrifying late-night break-in.

    08:25: Minor delays

    There roads seem fairly clear this morning with no major delays developing, according to BBC Travel. However, there is some minor congestion in both directions along Copy Lane in Netherton.

    08:15: Sunny with scattered showers Charlie Slater Weather Presenter

    Today should be mainly dry with sunny spells, the best of which will be in the south and east of the region.

    BBC weather

    However, some scattered showers could develop, although these should be restricted to the morning. Top temperatures of 7C (44F).

    08:06: Bulger killer joins dating site BBC Radio Merseyside

    The mother of murdered toddler James Bulger says it is "frightening" that one of her son's killers has been allowed to join an online dating website.

    Denise Fergus

    The weekend saw reports that claimed Jon Venables has signed up under his new identity - 22 years after two-year-old James was taken from a shopping centre in Bootle and killed by Venables and Robert Thompson, who were both aged 10.

    James's mum Denise Fergus fears some women will have come into contact with Venables without knowing his past.

    08:00: Monday hello Tom Mullen BBC News

    Good morning and welcome to Local Live for Merseyside. The team are back at the helm and ready to bring you all this week's news, sport and weather updates from across the region.

    We'd love you to get involved. Send us your pictures, comments, tip-offs or anything else via email, Facebook or Twitter.



Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.