Hillsborough capacity 'too high' ahead of disaster

The Hillsborough disaster An expert structural engineer has said the capacity of Hillsborough's west terraces - where fans were crushed - should have been lower.

The capacity of the Leppings Lane end of Hillsborough was overestimated by more than 1,700 before the 1989 disaster, an inquests jury heard.

A structural engineer said the capacity of the west terraces should have been 5,425, rather than the 7,200 stated on the ground's safety certificate.

John Cutlack also said the way barriers were arranged did not meet guidelines.

Ninety-six Liverpool fans died following a crush in the stand during the 1989 FA Cup semi-final.

Giving evidence at the Warrington inquests, Mr Cutlack said "some of the seeds of this disaster" were sown as early as 1979, when the ground's safety certificate was first issued.

'Safety failings'

He said pens 3 and 4, where the victims were standing, should have had capacities of 680 and 780 respectively.

Who were the 96 victims?

Eight of the Hillsborough victims, CW from top left: Paul Clark, Stephen Copoc, Tracey Cox, Jon-Paul Gilhooley, Steven Fox, Vincent Fitzsimmons, Christopher Edwards

That compared to the limits of 1,000 and 1,200, which were informally enforced in those pens.

Mr Cutlack is a chartered structural engineer who has worked on football grounds including the home grounds of Tottenham Hotspur and Newcastle United.

He also worked on the London 2012 Olympic Stadium and the retractable roof at Wimbledon's Centre Court.

Hillsborough Memorial Ninety-six Liverpool fans died as a result of a crush at Hillsborough Stadium during the 1989 FA Cup semi-final

He said that the capacities at Hillsborough should have been changed because the heights of four of the 13 crush barriers in pens 3 and 4 were "substantially too low".

Another three were "marginally too high", while the remainder were within the safety guidelines.

The government had issued guidelines for maintaining safety at sports grounds in a book called the Green Guide. The first edition was published in 1976 and it was updated in 1986.

Hillsborough was designated as a ground needing a safety certificate in January 1979.

That certificate was granted in December that year, stating the capacity of the Leppings Lane terraces as 10,100. That included 7,200 on the west terraces and a further 2,900 in the north west corner.

Fence gates 'too narrow'

Mr Cutlack said the north west corner's capacity was about 600 higher than was safe and the gates in the perimeter fence at the ground were not wide enough.

"It's important to go back to 1979 because some of the seeds of this disaster were sown in 1979. One of these is the height of the barriers," he said.

"I will show you later on that these barriers did not comply with guidance given either with the 1976 or 1986 Green Guides in relation to height and that had a major impact on the capacity of the terrace."

Later during Tuesday's hearing, Mr Cutlack said a crush barrier which collapsed during the disaster did so because of the weight applied to it, not because it was faulty.

The force that made parts of barrier 124a collapse was '8 to 9 kilonewtons per metre' - equivalent to dropping a 500kg bench press on to someone's chest.

More on This Story

Hillsborough Inquests

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Liverpool

Weather

Liverpool

19 °C 15 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    Overturned lorry 10:32:

    There's delays on the A57 in Widnes due to an overturned lorry, BBC Travel reports.

    It's causing slow traffic in both directions at Rainhill Stoops and a section of Warrington Road has had to be closed.

     
  2.  
    Remembering the send-off of 700 10:23:

    Nearly 100 years ago, 700 Lever Brothers employees travelled from Port Sunlight to Chester to enlist in the 13th Battalion of the Cheshire Regiment.

    Port Sunlight volunteers

    All 700 places have now been filled for a re-enactment of the send-off, which is due to take place on 7 September, the centenary of the event.

     
  3.  
    Special Sundays 10:09: Helen Jones BBC Radio Merseyside

    On this date 20 years ago, new legislation came in which relaxed the rules on Sunday trading.

    Shopper

    Completely closed high streets on a Sunday are now a thing of the past, so we are asking: should Sundays be kept special?

    You may think Sunday trading laws should be relaxed even further. Get in touch by emailing merseyside.locallive@bbc.co.uk, tweeting @bbcmerseyside or posting a message on Facebook.

     
  4.  
    News on the hour 10:00: Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    A plane due to fly from Liverpool John Lennon Airport to Naples has had to make an emergency landing after smoke was detected in the cockpit.

    The Easyjet flight, carrying 157 passengers, had to land at London Gatwick after encountering problems.

    Listen to the bulletin here.

     
  5.  
    MOT for your dog 09:55:

    The PDSA animal charity are holding health checks for dogs in Merseyside next month.

    Dog

    Vets will examine canine weights, body shapes, teeth, eyes, coats and general fitness.

    The first date is on 9 September at Croxdale Road West, Stockbridge Village, Liverpool. The other dates can be found here.

     
  6.  
    Happy birthday Liverpool 09:48:

    Many happy returns to the borough of Liverpool, which celebrates its 807th birthday today.

    Liverpool

    It was granted a royal charter in 1207, though it took several centuries to get to the size it is today.

    In fact, it only became a city in the 1880s.

     
  7.  
    Champions League draw 09:40:

    Liverpool will find out who they will be playing in the Champions League group stages later.

    Brendan Rodgers

    Teams they could face include Real Madrid, Paris Saint-Germain, Roma, Benfica, Basel and Maribor.

    They find out their fate when the draw takes place in Monaco at 16:45 BST.

     
  8.  
    Cigarette causes basement fire 09:33:

    Cheshire Fire tweets: Fire in basement caused by discarded cigarette. Two men treated for smoke inhalation #putitoutrightout bit.ly/1mVJnyG

     
  9.  
    New Lennon film 09:24:

    A new film is being made in New York looking at the events that took place on the night John Lennon was shot in 1980.

    Lennon and Ono

    The Lennon Report looks at the efforts of several passers-by at the site of the shooting in Manhattan.

     
  10.  
    Passengers 'remained calm' 09:15: Clark Ainsworth BBC News

    An Easyjet plane from Liverpool carrying 157 passengers has made an emergency landing after smoke was detected in the cockpit.

    An Easyjet spokesman said the plane, en route to Naples, landed safely at Gatwick and the passengers "remained calm".

    "At no point was the safety of passengers threatened," he said.

     
  11.  
    What is a Liver Bird? 09:07: Chris Long BBC News

    In the course of researching the story about the new Liver Bird, I delved into the mystery of what it actually is.

    Seal of Liverpool

    Its origins are in the seal was used by Liverpool in the 14th Century - which is thought to be an eagle - but did not take the Liver Bird name until a couple of centuries later.

    I would like to know more though, so help me out by telling me what you think a Liver Bird is. Send your thoughts via email, Facebook or Twitter.

     
  12.  
    News on the hour 09:00: Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    A plane from Liverpool carrying 157 passengers has had to make an emergency landing after smoke was detected in the cockpit.

    The Easyjet flight was on its way to Naples when it encountered problems and had to land at London Gatwick.

    Listen to the bulletin here.

     
  13.  
    Scouse Nous 08:55: Tony Snell BBC Radio Merseyside

    Today's Scouse Nous is: Arrived in Liverpool in 1931, disappeared and reappeared many years later, disappeared and reappeared again. What or who?

    Bob in Garston guessed the Liverpool Show, which isn't what we are looking for. The Liver Birds is proving a popular guess, but I'm afraid that's also wrong.

    Do you know the answer? Let us know via Twitter, Facebook or email merseyside.locallive@bbc.co.uk

     
  14.  
    Talk to the animals 08:49:

    Warrington Borough Council tweets: Bring the kids to see Dr Zoolittle's zoo animals and reptiles at #Warrington Market today from 11am!

     
  15.  
    Plane diverted due to smoke 08:41:

    An Easyjet plane from Liverpool carrying 157 passengers has had to make an emergency landing after smoke was detected in the cockpit.

    The Airbus A320, en route to Naples, touched down safely at Gatwick at around 07:20 BST.

     
  16.  
    John, Paul, George and Mario? 08:35:

    As predicted, Mario Balotelli has made his mark on Merseyside before he has even kicked a ball.

    The Balotells

    The new Liverpool striker was sent an altered image of the Fab Four, which he liked so much, he reposted it on his official Instagram account.

    It currently has 131,000 'likes' and counting.

     
  17.  
    Top headlines
     
  18.  
    New Liver Bird 08:24:

    It has been announced this morning that Liverpool is to get a new Liver Bird sculpture.

    Liver Bird

    A 6ft (1.8m) statue will welcome people at the entrance to Liverpool Central Station in 2015.

     
  19.  
    M62 hold-ups 08:16:

    BBC Travel reports it's busy on the M62 westbound on Merseyside due to a broken down vehicle.

    It's causing delays near junction 7 for the A57 (Rainhill Stoops) and a lane has been closed on the exit slip road.

     
  20.  
    Sunny spells 08:09:

    BBC Weather says we can expect some sunny spells this morning, but showery rain will spread from the west through the middle part of the day, with the odd heavier burst possible.

    weather

    It should then clear again during the afternoon and evening.

     
  21.  
    News on the hour 08:01: Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    Five thousand jobs will be created by the construction of the huge, deep-water terminal Liverpool2, it has been revealed.

    The £300m pound development at Seaforth is due to be completed next year.

    To listen to the bulletin, click here.

     
  22.  
    Thursday hello 08:00: Tom Airey BBC News

    Morning folks, I'm here to bring you Merseyside's news, sport, weather and travel updates for Thursday.

    If you'd like to share your pictures and comments, email merseyside.locallive@bbc.co.uk, tweet @bbcmerseyside or post a message on Facebook.

     

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.