Hillsborough safety certificate 'breached ahead of disaster'

Terraces on the Leppings Lane end Despite changes to the terraces on the Leppings Lane end, the capacity on the safety certificate remained at 10,100

Safety concerns at Sheffield Wednesday's stadium were raised by an official a year before the Hillsborough disaster, an inquest jury has heard.

But ex-council safety officer Paul Jackson was told by bosses in 1988 to "keep his nose out" of such concerns, the Warrington hearing was told.

Graham Mackrell, club safety officer at the time, also said he could not count fan-numbers at full capacity games.

Ninety-six fans died as a result of a crush at the 1989 FA Cup semi-final.

'No emergency plan'

Who were the 96 victims?

Eight of the Hillsborough victims, CW from top left: Paul Clark, Stephen Copoc, Tracey Cox, Jon-Paul Gilhooley, Steven Fox, Vincent Fitzsimmons, Christopher Edwards

The jury heard two conditions on the club's safety certificate had not been met.

One condition required the club to count the number of spectators going into different parts of the ground.

Christina Lambert QC, the lead counsel to the inquests, said "that condition could not have been satisfied" on 15 April 1989 and Mr Mackrell replied "correct".

She said the condition that required the club to keep records of the numbers of spectators admitted to the different areas of the ground, also "couldn't be satisfied."

Mr Mackrell said the club could only record a "global figure".

Ms Lambert said: "That would be a breach of the safety certificate."

Mr Mackrell said: 'Yes.'

Ahead of the Liverpool and Nottingham Forest game on 15 April, Mr Jackson wrote a report about the stadium's safety because he had not seen the club's emergency response plan to deal with major incidents.

He said he had been made aware of "problems" over the height and spacing of the barriers on the terraces, the inquests heard.

Paperwork shredded

He said: "I had been told there was problems with the barriers and I had been told not to get involved with it."

Before a stadium visit in 1988, Mr Jackson claimed his line managers said: "Just don't go into that area. Not to stick my nose in."

"There had been previous concerns over them," he added.

The jury was told Mr Jackson later made his own visit to the stadium to look at the barriers.

The Hillsborough disaster A council safety officer had not seen Sheffield Wednesday's emergency response plan to deal with major incidents

He said he had not seen a plan for an emergency response but added "there may have been one, but they wouldn't show it to me".

Mr Jackson said: "[The report] said that there was not an emergency response plan and 'we recommend that there shouldn't be a safety certificate granted'."

The coroner heard the report had never been found at Sheffield City Council and Mr Jackson did not mention it in a statement given to West Midlands Police in 1989.

About 50 lever arch files of paperwork from the Environmental Services department had been shredded in the 1990s, the jury was told.

A statement from Stephen Webster, a manager at the council's Health Protection Services department, said: "No doubt the paperwork involved, which was destroyed, included paperwork relating to Hillsborough."

Mr Jackson said he met Sheffield Wednesday's Mr Mackrell, also club secretary at the time, during an inspection of Hillsborough in 1988.

He told the inquest: "My impression then was that Mr Mackrell was more or less a token safety officer.

"Someone who had been appointed because of the need to appoint someone to that position."

The inquest continues.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Liverpool



Min. Night 7 °C

BBC Local Live

    16:23: Community's 'confidence in police

    Merseyside's gay and lesbian community have a growing confidence in the way police tackle hate crime, a senior officer said as figures show there were more violent attacks in the last year.

    The number of homophobic incidents has gone up by more than a fifth.

    Ch Supt Rowley Moore said Merseyside is "one of just a few forces to have a dedicated investigation team" to deal with hate crime.

    16:09: Sefton Meadows plan on hold Claire Hamilton Political reporter, BBC Radio Merseyside

    Plans to build housing on Sefton Park Meadows are on hold.

    Sefton Park

    Liverpool Council says it's waiting for independent panel to report before taking plans to build 15 villas any further.

    The Green Spaces Review Panel isn't expected to report until next summer.

    15:59: News on the hour Alex Dibble BBC Radio Merseyside

    An investigation's begun into how a train driver suffered a severe electric shock on the tracks in Runcorn.

    It happened in September when power cables were damaged and fell onto the rails.

    15:45: Students' course fears Liverpool Echo
    Train electric shock 15:35: Tom Mullen BBC News Online

    I've read the Rail Accident Investigation Branch's findings into an incident where a train driver suffered a severe electric shock in Runcorn.

    The driver was treated by a doctor travelling on the train after power cables fell onto the tracks in September.

    He was injured after getting out of the train to check for a marker on the track, in order to report his location.

    15:15: Boyfriend stabbing charge BBC Radio Merseyside

    A 21-year-old woman has appeared in court charged with stabbing her boyfriend Kyle Farrell to death in Dingle, Liverpool, last week.

    14:58: News on the hour Alex Dibble BBC Radio Merseyside

    The gay rights charity Stonewall says homophobic hate crime remains a "real issue" after new figures revealed an increase in the number of reported offences in Merseyside.

    Sixty five attacks on people because of their sexuality were reported from the start of 2014 to October - up from 51 for the whole of 2013.

    Emergency pothole repairs 14:52:

    BBC Travel reports slow traffic and one lane closed on the M53 northbound after a large pothole caused problems.

    Emergency repairs to the road service are underway between Junction 8 for Ellesmere Port Docks and Junction 7 at Overpool.

    14:40: On air later

    Jo Harrop tweets: On @bbcmerseyside 4-6pm today talking about @DPMoffice plans we've inputted into to increase use of empty buildings ow.ly/EURpZ

    14:30: Boss backs Gerrard Phil Kinsella BBC Merseyside Sport

    Ahead of the crucial Champions League tie against Ludogorets in Bulgaria tonight, the Liverpool manager Brendan Rodgers has defended captain Steven Gerrard following criticism.


    Rodgers says Gerrard is the "best player he has ever worked with" and there is no sentimentality in his selection.

    The Reds go into tonight's game 3rd in Group B with just two group games left.

    14:22: Tiny turacos Tom Airey BBC News

    Two tiny Firscher's turacos are being hand-reared at Chester Zoo after they were rejected by their mother.

    Two turacos

    Curator of birds Andrew Owen has stepped into the role of parent by taking them home and feeding them every few hours.

    Due to their size, he has been using tweezers to carefully feed them small pieces of chopped fruit. The turacos are native to Kenya, Somalia and Tanzania.

    14:17: Motorist jailed Runcorn & Widnes Weekly News
    14:00: News on the hour Alex Dibble BBC Radio Merseyside

    The gay rights charity Stonewall says homophobic hate crime remains a "real issue" after new figures revealed an increase in the number of reported offences in Merseyside.

    Sixty five attacks on people because of their sexuality were reported from the start of 2014 to October - up from 51 for the whole of 2013.

    13:54: The making of John Lennon

    A new book claims John Lennon was a depressive tormented by an unhappy childhood, with the Beatles saving him.

    John Lennon

    Social researcher and academic Francis Kenny says the band wouldn't have formed without those early days. The book is published on Friday.

    13:37: Inquests not sitting Ben Schofield BBC Radio Merseyside

    The Hillsborough inquests in Warrington are not be sitting today, with the hearing expected to continue tomorrow.

    Hillsborough disaster

    On Tuesday, former sergeant Michael Goddard told the jury the "deletion" of a note about a radio conversation heard in the control box at Hillsborough showed someone there was "trying to cover things up".

    13:20: Coming up Annabel Tiffin Presenter, North West Tonight

    Liverpool need a repeat of City's heroics tonight if they are to stay in the Champions League.

    Watch more on BBC One at 13:30.

    13:10: Return of Educating Rita

    Willy Russell's Educating Rita is to have its first professional production in Liverpool in 13 years to mark the 35th anniversary of the 1980 premiere.

    Willy Russell and Julie Walters, pictured in 2003 and 1980 respectively

    The play, about a university lecturer who tutors a working class hairdresser, will run at the Liverpool Playhouse from 6 February to 7 March.

    Russell said he was "really delighted" to return to a venue with which he had "such a... fulfilling association".

    13:00: News on the hour Alex Dibble BBC Radio Merseyside

    The number of violent homophobic attacks recorded by Merseyside Police has gone up by more than a fifth.

    The latest figures show 65 offences have been reported so far this year, compared to 51 in 2013.

    12:52: M56 slip open

    NWmwaypolice tweets: UPDATE M56 - J12 M56 EB entry slip is open. The only closure is lane 1 running past the scene J11/10.

    12:43: Full police horse report

    Earlier, we ran a story about a police horse in Merseyside as a study shows people trusted mounted officers more.

    Leanne Harper went out to meet a police horse named after Sir Jon Murphy, the chief constable.

    You can read the full Oxford University report here.

    12:34: Cheque for Cech? BBC Sport

    The Gossip column reports Liverpool are ready to sign a trio of big names to strengthen their squad in the January transfer window.

    Petr Cech

    Chelsea goalkeeper Petr Cech, Porto striker Jackson Martinez and Norwich winger Nathan Redmond are the targets, according to the Metro.

    12:24: Man held over 'threats to kill' Tom Mullen BBC News

    Here's our full story after a 35-year-old man was arrested by armed police on suspicion of making threats to kill at a house in Liverpool.

    Moscow Drive, Tuesbrook

    Police surrounded the house in Moscow Drive, Tuesbrook, on Tuesday evening amid reports of a man armed with a knife.

    12:17: Scouse of the Antarctic Helen Jones BBC Radio Merseyside

    I met Lindzi Germain, Michael Fletcher and Mick Ledwich who're all starring in this year's Liverpool Royal Court Christmas Show Scouse of the Antarctic.

    Helen Jones with cast of play Scouse of the Antarctic
    12:11: What do you think? Tom Airey BBC News

    We've introduced BBC Local Live from our base in Liverpool to bring you the latest news, sport, travel and weather all in one place. Tell us what you think.

    12:00: News on the hour Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    The number of violent homophobic attacks recorded by Merseyside police has gone up this year.

    In 2012 there were 57 incidents. Last year, there were 51 but up to October this year there were 65 such crimes.

    11:56: Writing Christmas cards Helen Jones BBC Radio Merseyside

    Have you started writing your Christmas cards yet?

    Or are you planning to go all technical and send an e-card?

    The new Anglican Bishop of Liverpool is urging people to put pen to paper and send one the old fashioned way to help charities in the festive season.

    So will you be writing and sending cards this year? Get in touch on Facebook.

    Champions League news 11:49: BBC Sport

    Injured Italy striker Mario Balotelli has not travelled to Bulgaria for Liverpool's Champions League tie with Ludogorets tonight.


    It means England forward Rickie Lambert is expected to retain his place in the team.

    Manager Brendan Rodgers is likely to make changes from Sunday's 3-1 defeat at Crystal Palace, with defender Alberto Moreno expected to start at left-back.

    11:41: M56 moving Tom Airey BBC News

    Traffic is beginning to move on the M56 and on adjoining A roads in and around Runcorn after a lorry fire caused severe disruption this morning.

    Lorry fire

    Cheshire Police said it will still take two to three hours to clear completely, so alternative routes may be quicker.

    11:32: Service for teenager Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    There will be a service of thanksgiving in Anfield later in memory of a Merseyside teenager who was found hanged at his home.

    Erick Maina

    Erick Maina, 15, died earlier this month and hours later offensive racist graffiti was discovered at his school in Maghull.

    Relatives are gathering at the Temple of Praise church, which has also launched a fundraising appeal to help other members of the family make it over from Kenya for his funeral.

    11:09: More on indecent image arrests

    Thirteen suspects, aged from 20 to 68, have been arrested following morning raids across Cheshire.

    Det Supt Geraint Jones said they take the issue of indecent images of children "very seriously and we will do everything possible to bring them to justice."

    10:58: News on the hour Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    Two lanes have now reopened on the M56 in Cheshire after a lorry fire caused chaos during this morning's rush hour.

    Queues were backing up for five junctions as crews deal with the huge blaze.

    10:49: Increase in homophobic attacks BBC North West Tonight

    There's been an increase in the number of violent homophobic attacks reported to Merseyside Police.

    10:38: M56 update Tom Airey BBC News

    Traffic officers have opened lanes two and three on the eastbound side of the M56 in Cheshire after a lorry fire, but there's still major disruption in the area.

    Police said the incident, between Junctions 11 and 10, is still causing some congestion in Ellesmere Port, Chester, Runcorn and Warrington.

    Junction 12 and 14 slip roads remain closed to stop traffic joining the motorway.

    10:28: Steven Naismith interview BBC Sport

    Charitable and down to earth, Everton's Steven Naismith seems to buck the trend of self-centred footballers - except perhaps to Rangers fans.


    Matt Smith interviews the man who often seems to be on a solo mission to prove that footballers can still see what real life is like through their blacked-out windows.

    10:19: Phone rage incident Chester Chronicle
    10:13: Indecent image investigation Tom Airey BBC News

    Thirteen men have been arrested after a Cheshire Police investigation into the distribution of indecent images of children online.

    Computers and other devices were seized during raids this morning. Arrests were made in locations including Chester, Widnes and Ellesmere Port.

    10:05: Construction workers' demo Marc Gaier BBC Radio Merseyside

    I've been to Alder Hey Hospital where construction workers demonstrate against so-called "umbrella" companies.

    picket line
    09:58: News on the hour Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    There continues to be traffic problems this morning because of a huge lorry fire on the M56 in Cheshire.

    Queues are backing up for at least five junctions with the motorway closed on the eastbound side between Junction 11 and Junction 10.

    09:47: Traffic at a standstill

    Cllr Mike Jones tweets: Traffic at a standstill on M56 East bound, best to avoid

    Traffic at a standstill
    M56 delays 09:33: Tom Airey BBC News

    Cheshire Police warns it will take "some time" to deal with the lorry fire on the M56, with drivers advised to find alternative routes.

    The incident, on the eastbound side between Junction 11 and Junction 10, has forced the closure of the carriageway.

    Motorists are being advised to leave the motorway before Junction 12 at Runcorn and follow diversion signs.

    09:26: With the horses Leanne Harper Reporter, BBC Radio Merseyside

    I've been to Merseyside Police's stables to meet the horses and their riders as a study finds people trust the police more when they're on horseback.

    Murphy's Law police horse

    One's called Murphy's Law, after Chief Constable Sir Jon Murphy.

    Homophobic attacks 09:14: Liverpool Echo
    08:59: News on the hour Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    There's traffic chaos because of a huge lorry fire on the M56 in Cheshire.

    Queues are backing up for at least five junctions with the motorway closed on the eastbound side between junction 11 for Preston Brook and junction 10 at Stretton.

    08:55: M56 problems

    @NWmwaypolice tweets: There is no eta for the M56 J11/10 to be reopened. All traffic is being taken off at J11 and trapped traffic is currently being released.

    08:51: Suarez strikes BBC Sport

    Former Liverpool striker Luis Suarez scored his first goal for Barcelona last night - but he was overshadowed by another forward.


    Lionel Messi became the Champions League's all-time top scorer after three goals against Apoel Nicosia.

    08:41: Arrest after stand-off Tom Airey BBC News

    A 35-year-old man has been arrested after a house in Tuebrook was surrounded by armed police for several hours last night.

    Moscow Drive

    Officers entered a house on Moscow Drive after reports a man had been threatened with a blade.

    The man is being held on suspicion of making threats to kill and remains in custody for questioning.

    Sunset 'UFO' 08:30: Tony Snell BBC Radio Merseyside

    We've been talking about UFOs on Breakfast. Tris Brown from Liverpool City Council has got in touch to share this great shot of the sunset over the Mersey last night.


    The "UFO" in the picture turned out to be a reflection from a hallway light!

    08:20: Lorry fire

    BBC Travel reports the M56 is closed between Junction 11 at Preston Brook and Junction 10 for Stretton on the eastbound side, heading into Manchester.

    It's due to a lorry fire, which has caused significant congestion on the Runcorn Widnes Bridge.

    Cloudy and murky 08:09: Sara Blizzard Weather Presenter, BBC

    It's going to be a cloudy and murky day with widespread hill fog and outbreaks of rain.

    BBC weather

    The rain will generally be fairly light, but it will feel quite cold under the cloud.

    08:00: News on the hour Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    There's traffic chaos this morning because of a huge lorry fire on the M56 in Cheshire.

    Queues are backing up for at least five junctions in and around Runcorn.

    08:00: Good morning Tom Airey BBC News

    Welcome to Wednesday on BBC Local Live in Merseyside. I'm here with all your news, sport, travel and weather.

    You can get in touch by email, Twitter or Facebook.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.