Liverpool's Welsh Streets residents protest at inquiry opening

Welsh Streets campaigners Those supporting the plan protested outside the opening of the public inquiry

Related Stories

Campaigners supporting a £15m plan for Liverpool's Welsh Streets have protested outside the opening of a public inquiry into it.

The plan would see 150 homes built, 37 refurbished and about 280 demolished.

The Department for Communities and Local Government ordered the hearing after deciding the plan for Toxteth "may conflict with national policy".

Liverpool mayor Joe Anderson said it was "patronising" for the government to tell residents what they need.

The three-week inquiry will hear from the city council, residents, the housing association Plus Dane and the charity Save Britain's Heritage (SBH).

A site visit will then take place to look at the extent to which the proposed development "is in line with Government policy on good design, enhancing the historic environment, bringing back empty homes and supporting healthy communities".

Following the decision to delay the planning process, Mr Anderson said it was "hugely frustrating and bitterly disappointing for the local community".

Welsh Streets CGI The plan would see 150 homes built, 37 refurbished and about 280 demolished

"Residents made clear in no uncertain terms that they backed what has been put forward," he said.

Start Quote

It seems absolutely insane that you'd knock these type of houses down”

End Quote Tilly Hemingway Designer

City councillor Ann O'Byrne said "the evidence was overwhelming to show that the condition of these properties is such that it would cost more to refurbish them than it would to build new ones".

The current proposal, which will see a small number of the houses saved from demolition, has been backed by residents organisation, Welsh Streets Homes Group (WSHG).

A spokesman for WSHG said that for "further houses to be spared, it would take a leap of faith", including a "change of heart" by the council and Plus Dane and the "approval of residents on the south end of the site [whose] existing walls are crumbling around them".


"WSHG wanted to avoid a public inquiry but since it is happening, we will be asking the inspector to encourage all parties back to the negotiating table in search of an agreement that would allow work to begin on site in 2015."

The housing association Plus Dane has previously warned that any delays to the scheme would "seriously jeopardise" the available funding.

Madryn Street
  • The properties are nicknamed the Welsh Streets as they were built and lived in by Welsh workers in the late 19th Century
  • They are named after Welsh towns, villages and valleys
  • Beatles drummer Ringo Starr was born at 9 Madryn Street, one of the 37 homes to be restored if the plan is approved

Save Britain's Heritage, which owns a house in one of the streets, campaigned for the inquiry and wants more of the houses to be renovated, instead of demolished.

Jonathan Brown, from the group, said structural engineers had said the houses were "still solid and viable and estate agents still say that they could sell them".

Designer Tilly Hemingway, who is working on one of the houses in Madryn Street, said the homes had a lot of potential, which would be lost if they were demolished.

"It seems absolutely insane that you'd knock these type of houses down when they are perfect in terms of space standards and they're beautiful," she said.

The inquiry, which is set to run until 4 July, is due to deliver its findings in a report later in the year.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Liverpool



8 °C 5 °C

BBC Local Live

    09:37: Talking health and safety Tony Snell BBC Radio Merseyside

    Safety at work is still an issue, despite the number of deaths in the workplace at its lowest ever level last year. That's according to the Health and Safety Executive, which is based in Bootle.

    Building site generic

    All this week on Breakfast, we're taking a look at the work they do there, as this year marks the HSE's 40th anniversary.

    Join me, and do let me know your views on health and safety. Get in touch via email, Facebook or Twitter

    09:15: Severe delays due to accident

    BBC Travel is reporting severe disruption due to an accident at Menlove Gardens in North Childwall, Liverpool. Traffic is queuing around the area.

    09:00: News on the hour Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    The Victims' Commissioner has criticised justice agencies for their lack of compassion when dealing with complaints from people affected by crime.

    Baroness Newlove, of Warrington, whose husband Garry was murdered outside their home, has looked at the experiences of 200 victims who have been unhappy with the way their concerns have been treated.

    Listen live to the 09:00 bulletin.

    08:45: Reds back in action tonight BBC Sport

    Liverpool face Chelsea tonight as the League Cup semi-final tie resumes at 1-1 after that entertaining first game at Anfield.

    Liverpool vs Chelsea

    And, in case you missed it, Liverpool were last night drawn to play at Crystal Palace in the fifth round of the FA Cup, if they win their replay with Bolton Wanderers.

    Five live Sport with Mark Pougatch will be live from Stamford Bridge from 19:00 GMT ahead of the 19:45 GMT kick-off.

    08:33: Station on the agenda Liverpool Echo

    Controversial plans for an electricity substation to service the new Liverpool FC stadium are among items due to be discussed by councillors today.

    08:20: Light rain or drizzle Charlie Slater Weather Presenter

    It's looking like a largely cloudy day with some patchy light rain or drizzle possible at times, especially over higher ground.

    BBC weather

    There's no sign of snow yet, but it may become increasingly windy through the evening with rain becoming more persistent in the north. Top temperatures of 9C (48F).

    08:15: Accident causing delays

    One lane is closed heading out of the city along Leeds Street in Liverpool, due to an accident, according to BBC Travel.

    BBC Travel

    The same accident is causing disruption at the Vauxhall Road junction. A traffic light failure on Speke Boulevard is also causing hold-ups this morning.

    08:08: Fans 'stopped from escaping crush' Emma Stanley BBC News

    A Liverpool fan who survived the Hillsborough disaster has described watching as a police officer tried to push his brother back into the crush.

    Hillsborough 1989

    Terence Mills was at the 1989 FA Cup semi-final with his brother George, who was trying to escape from pen four.

    Stephen Ellis, Sheffield Wednesday's photographer, said police stopped fans climbing over the front of the pens.

    Both men gave evidence on Monday at the new inquests into the disaster, held in Warrington.

    08:00: Tuesday hello Tom Mullen BBC News

    Good morning and welcome to Tuesday's Local Live service from our Merseyside offices. Join us for a day of live news, sport, weather and travel updates from across the region.

    We can't do it without your help. Send us your comments, news, tip-offs or pictures - or just stop by and say hello. You can contact us via email, Facebook or Twitter.



Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.