Hillsborough capacity figure 'too high', inquests told

Terraces on the Leppings Lane end Fences were meant to give more control over the numbers of fans in central pens

Allowing fans unrestricted access to Hillsborough's standing terraces at the time of the stadium disaster would have been "ridiculous", a jury has heard.

The official capacity figure for the Leppings Lane terrace was too high, the Hillsborough inquests have been told.

The jury was hearing evidence from Sheffield Wednesday's consultant engineer, Dr Wilfred Eastwood.

"When you start penning there must be control," he told the 1989 inquiry into the disaster, in which 96 people died.

They were killed following a crush at the Liverpool v Nottingham Forest FA Cup semi-final at the Sheffield stadium on 15 April 1989.

Legal representatives at fresh inquests in Warrington are reading out transcripts of Dr Eastwood's evidence as he is too ill to attend the inquests.

Dr Eastwood said "with hindsight" the figure of 10,100 for the capacity of the standing part of the Leppings Lane end was "too high".

The jury heard the capacities of pens three and four, where the crush that led to the deaths of 96 Liverpool fans happened, were not arrived at "scientifically or mathematically".

Who were the 96 victims?

Eight of the Hillsborough victims, CW from top left: Paul Clark, Stephen Copoc, Tracey Cox, Jon-Paul Gilhooley, Steven Fox, Vincent Fitzsimmons, Christopher Edwards

Dr Eastwood said the fences put in to create the pens were meant to give more control over the numbers of fans in the central pens.

He said there was no way of keeping the crowd density to within levels set by guidelines because "there was no means of counting" the number of fans entering individual pens.

The inquests heard Dr Eastwood told the original inquiry Hillsborough would be "absolutely safe" with the proper controls in place.

He said there was "no safer ground" if the spectators had been "properly controlled".

But Dr Eastwood said: "There was an enormous increase in the number of people there and that is why they became unsafe."

"With those numbers, it was inevitable - whatever the configuration of barriers - that people would be crushed," he added.

Last week the inquests heard the Hillsborough stadium had "no significant defects" when it was last inspected 11 months before the disaster.

The inquests continue.

More on This Story

Hillsborough Inquests

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Liverpool

Weather

Liverpool

21 °C 16 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    Liverpool's European victory 10:35: BBC Sport
  2.  
    Police 'sorry' for shortfalls 10:30:

    Merseyside Police "fully accepts" a watchdog's recommendations after an investigation found it "failed" a domestic violence victim murdered by her estranged husband.

    Becky McPhee was stabbed to death by Paul Holmes in 2012. The force has held dedicated training sessions for officers but said it was "determined... to improve the service".

    Responding to the Independent Police Complaints Commission's report, Assistant Ch Con Ian Pilling said: "In relation to Rebecca's death, there were shortfalls on the part of Merseyside Police, in particular, there was a failure to recognise the risk posed to the victim by her killer, who had threatened to commit suicide.

    "The force fully accepts all the recommendations of the IPCC report and will do all we can to ensure that they are implemented in their entirety."

     
  3.  
    Frustration for Tranmere 10:24: Phil Kinsella BBC Merseyside Sport

    In League Two there was more frustration for Tranmere who were held to a 0-0 draw at home by Newport.

    The result leaves Rovers without a win in their last three games and 15th place in the table.

    Rovers will be checking on the extent of the injury to Matt Hill this morning, the full back had to leave the field after just 10 minutes last night, it's feared he may have ruptured his Achilles tendon.

     
  4.  
    An amazing city 10:17:

    Liverpool Chamber tweets: What an amazing city we live in pic.twitter.com/5JF74kgFOR

    Liverpool view
     
  5.  
    No action for police 'failing' 10:12:

    A former Merseyside Police inspector in charge of the "poor" search for an estranged husband who murdered his wife will not face a misconduct hearing because he has retired, a police watchdog said.

    Insp Grahame Abram, who led the search for Paul Holmes, has a misconduct case to answer for "a serious failure" but he has since retired after serving 30 years in the force, the Independent Police Complaints Commission (IPCC) said.

    Becky McPhee was stabbed to death in 2012.

    Another inspector acting as Critical Incident Manager for part of the search, was criticised by the watchdog for a series of failings. He was dismissed from Merseyside Police for an unrelated matter.

     
  6.  
    Angels on Merseyside 10:06: Helen Jones BBC Radio Merseyside

    This morning I want to find the Angels of Merseyside. The people who've gone out of their way to help you.

    A man has emailed in to thank a group of women who comforted him while he was upset in New Brighton. They gave him a cuppa and chatted with him for 10 minutes.

    "It was on of the kindest acts I have ever encountered in my life. I will always remember it and will always be grateful. Liverpool and Merseyside is still populated by caring people."

    Call 0151 709 9333 or text 81333 with Mersey before your text.

     
  7.  
    News on the hour 09:59: Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    The Department for Transport is denying rail union claims they want Northern Rail services across Merseyside to scrap conductors.

    Bidders for the new franchises are being asked to use the drivers to operate opening and shutting the doors on the trains - so other staff can be freed up to help passengers.

    Listen live to the bulletin at 10:00.

     
  8.  
    Watchdog's abuse report 09:51:

    Merseyside Police has been urged to consider extra training for officers after a domestic abuse victim was murdered by her estranged husband, a police watchdog said.

    The Independent Police Complaints Commission (IPCC) made a number of recommendations after Becky McPhee was stabbed to death by Paul Holmes in 2012.

    The IPCC's recommendations for the force to consider include:

    • Additional training on the Protection of Harassment Act
    • Look at whether domestic abuse co-ordinators are as effective as they should be
    • Establish action plans for breaches of bail conditions
    • Ensure logs are filled in properly and only by trained staff.
     
  9.  
    Favourite matchday songs 09:41: BBC Sport

    Find out which football matchday songs make the 'Top Of The Kop' charts - as voted for by BBC Sport users.

    Everton's famous "Z-Cars" theme, Leeds United's "Marching On Together" and West Ham's "I'm Forever Blowing Bubbles" all feature as well as Liverpool's "You'll Never Walk Alone".

    There is even a surprise entry from Queen with "We Are The Champions".

     
  10.  
    top headlines
     
  11.  
    Merseyside Police 'fail' abuse victim 09:30:

    Merseyside Police "failed" a domestic violence victim who was murdered by her estranged husband, a police watchdog has found.

    The Independent Police Complaints Commission (IPCC) said Becky McPhee's death "could have been prevented".

    Ms McPhee was stabbed to death by Paul Holmes in 2012. From 12 January 2010 to 5 January 2012, the force recorded 17 separate incidents, including a statement where Ms McPhee believed it was only a matter of time before she would be killed.

    The IPCC found a number of errors including officers' failure to follow the force's domestic abuse policy. The investigation found a lack of understanding or reluctance by Merseyside Police to consider harassment laws - an oversight which it considered to be a serious failing.

     
  12.  
    Police slammed over murder case 09:25: Liverpool Echo

    A catastrophic series of police blunders led to a Merseyside woman being murdered by her violent estranged husband.

     
  13.  
    Reds a work in progress - Rodgers 09:18: BBC Sport

    Liverpool boss Brendan Rodgers is delighted his side won their opening Champions League fixture, a 2-1 victory over Bulgarian champions Ludogorets Razgrad.

    Liverpool boss Brendan Rodgers

    All three goals were scored in the final 10 minutes of the match, with Mario Balotelli's opener cancelled out by Dani Abalo, before a stoppage-time penalty from Steven Gerrard gave the home side the win.

    Rodgers admits his time are still a "work in progress" and feels they are not up to the standards of last season, but will get there in time.

     
  14.  
    News on the hour 08:58: Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    The Department for Transport is denying rail union claims they want Northern Rail services across Merseyside to scrap conductors.

    Bidders for the new franchises are being asked to use the drivers to operate opening and shutting the doors on the trains - so other staff can be freed up to help passengers.

    Listen live to the bulletin at 09:00.

     
  15.  
    Accident on M62 08:56:

    There are reports of two lanes blocked due to an accident on the M62 eastbound between Junction 6 M57 (Tarbock Island) and Junction 7 (Rainhill Stoops).

     
  16.  
    Grow your own food 08:49: Marc Gaier BBC Radio Merseyside

    I'm in Kirkby finding out how these planters will be used to help people learn to grow their own food.

    Activate Ltd UK
     
  17.  
    Fire hit dogs' home takes in strays 08:33: BBC North West Tonight

    Manchester Dogs' Home is to start taking in strays again from today. New animals will be housed in temporary kennels being built in the car park.

    Manchester Dogs' Home fire

    So far, nearly £1.5m has been raised after last week's huge fire.

     
  18.  
    Liverpool 'have a lot to learn' 08:22: BBC Sport

    Captain Steven Gerrard said Liverpool must improve to progress in the Champions League after they needed his late penalty to beat Ludogorets 2-1.

    Steven Gerrard scores a late penalty against Ludogorets

    The 2005 winners looked set to drop points against the Group B underdogs when Dani Abalo cancelled out Mario Balotelli's opener in stoppage time.

    But Gerrard's spot-kick secured victory for Liverpool, who visit Basel next before a home tie against Real Madrid.

     
  19.  
    Trains without conductors 08:15: Tony Snell BBC Radio Merseyside

    We've had conductor-less buses now for years - but there's a growing move towards having drivers-only on our trains.

    Companies bidding to take over some of our rail franchises are being asked to outline how they'd introduce services without guards on some routes.

    Councillors in Liverpool want a re-think by the Department for Transport amid concerns over passenger safety. What do you think? Let us know via Facebook or tweet @bbcmerseyside.

     
  20.  
    Dry with sunny spells 08:06:

    BBC Weather predicts it will be a dry day, with variable cloud and sunny spells developing once any early patchy mist or hill fog in the east clears.

    Weather forecast

    Feeling warm in the sunshine with light winds.

     
  21.  
    News on the hour 08:02: Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    Councillors in Liverpool will today discuss controversial government plans to get rid of conductors on some train services on Merseyside.

    Driver-only operations could be run on Northern Rail and Trans-Pennine Express routes.

    Listen live to the bulletin at 08:00.

     
  22.  
    Good morning 08:00: Nafeesa Shan BBC News

    Hi everyone, I'm here with the news, sport, travel and weather updates throughout the day.

    Remember you can get in touch and share your comments and pictures by emailing merseyside.locallive@bbc.co.uk, tweeting @bbcmerseyside or posting a message on Facebook.

     

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.