Hillsborough inquests: 'No changes to safety' after pens introduced

The Hillsborough disaster The Green Guide was for the "only reference" for those looking at stadium safety

No changes were made to Hillsborough Stadium's safety certificate after the Leppings Lane end was altered in the 1980s, the inquests jury has heard.

Structural engineer John Cutlack said no amendments were made to the ground's safety certificate issued in 1979.

Christina Lambert QC, lead counsel for the inquests, said many of the crush barriers were below the height recommended for football grounds.

Ninety-six fans died as a result of the crush at the 1989 FA Cup semi-final.

The Safety at Sports Grounds Act 1975 meant stadia with a capacity of more than 10,000 required a safety certificate.

The inquests in Warrington heard Hillsborough was more like Wembley because of its "quasi-international use".

It was the third largest stadium in the Football League and used for international matches as well as the FA cup semi finals and was required to have safety certificate from 1 January 1979.

Mr Cutlack, the structural engineer brought in by the inquests as their expert in the design of Hillsborough and its safety, told the inquest Sheffield Wednesday spent £120,000 on alterations and the stadium was issued its first safety certificate in December 1979.

Safety certificates were issued by local authorities but the club had an "ongoing duty" to make sure grounds remained safe, Mr Cutlack said.

However, he told the jury no amendments were made to Hillsborough's safety certificate when radial fences on terraces were introduced and changes were made to turnstiles in Leppings Lane in the mid-1980s.

The capacity of Hillsborough's terraces was not amended either, the court heard.

The jury was shown plans to increase the number of turnstiles to 34 in 1985 but they never materialised and when Liverpool fans entered the ground on the day of the disaster they went through 23 turnstiles as opposed to 60 turnstiles for Nottingham Forest fans.

Christina Lambert QC, lead counsel for the inquests, said barriers after the 1989 disaster were found to be under the height recommended in the Green Guide book which Mr Cutlack told the jury was the "only reference" for those looking at stadium safety.

Ms Lambert read a section of the 1976 edition of the Green Guide at the hearing in Warrington, which said one of biggest safety problems at football stadiums was the build-up of pressure within crowd.

It also called for annual safety inspections of grounds, with specific attention paid to the condition of crush barriers, the jury heard.

Mr Cutlack told the jury about the history of Hillsborough and the challenges faced by structural designers particularly at the time of the disaster.

He said there was a "growth in a unruly element" and that "hooliganism crept into football grounds".

Who were the 96 victims?

Eight of the Hillsborough victims, CW from top left: Paul Clark, Stephen Copoc, Tracey Cox, Jon-Paul Gilhooley, Steven Fox, Vincent Fitzsimmons, Christopher Edwards

He told the jury pitch perimeter fences and radial fences which split terraces into pens were introduced to segregate fans after a rise in hooliganism in the game in the 1970s.

He told the hearing in Warrington: "Segregation and safety are two mutually opposing design constraints."

Mr Cutlack told the jury despite previous football disasters such as Bolton Wanderers FC's Burnden Park disaster in 1946 in which 33 people died and the crush on a stairway at Rangers FC's Ibrox stadium in 1971, resulting in 66 deaths, no legislation followed until 1975.

He said it was a "sad fact" that the Green Guide safety book followed a series of disasters rather than preventing one occurring.

The jury visited the Hillsborough stadium on Friday.

Earlier last week, the jury heard "painstaking work" had been carried out by police and families to identify the victims in thousands of videos and photos.

The inquests continue.

More on This Story

Hillsborough Inquests

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Liverpool

Weather

Liverpool

17 °C 13 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    Anfield plans approved 14:00: Alex Dibble BBC Radio Merseyside

    The redevelopment of Anfield stadium has been unanimously approved by Liverpool City Council.

    The changes will see capacity at the ground increase to just under 59,000.

    Councillors on the planning committee gave the scheme, part of £260m regeneration plans for the area, the green light after visiting the stadium earlier.

     
  2.  
    news on the hour 13:58: Graham Whyte BBC Radio Merseyside

    Police are hunting two teenagers in connection with an attack on two men in Chester city centre.

    The victims were assaulted following an argument on Upper Northgate Street early on Friday morning.

    One was punched to the ground and then kicked in the head, suffering a fractured jaw.

    Listen live to the 14:00 bulletin.

     
  3.  
    James Bulger documentary 13:47:

    A documentary about the murder of James Bulger is broadcast on Channel 5 tonight.

    James Bulger

    Two-year-old James was killed in Bootle in February 1993 by Jon Venables and Robert Thompson, both aged 10.

    The candid film includes testimonies from James's mother, as well as police and reporters close to the case.

     
  4.  
    Arts venue closes 13:37: BBC Radio Merseyside

    One of Liverpool`s most popular arts venues has closed its doors for the final time with 20 people losing their jobs.

    Mello Mello on Slater Street staged all sorts of music and dance as well as being a bar and restaurant.

    The closure's being blamed on a big increase in business rates and a number of break-ins.

     
  5.  
    Queues at party conference 13:30: Marc Gaier BBC Radio Merseyside

    I'm at the Labour party conference in Manchester where Ed Miliband delivers a keynote speech in an hour. Delegates are forming a long queue for seats.

    Labour conference in Manchester
     
  6.  
    red squirrels in Formby 13:23:

    Thanks to Hugh Parry who sent some great pictures of red squirrels at Formby Point.

    squirrel formby

    Do you have pictures you'd like to share? Email merseyside.locallive@bbc.co.uk and we'll use the best on Local Live.

     
  7.  
    coming up on North West Today 13:18: Roger Johnson Presenter, North West Tonight

    Coming up on North West Today, the latest on the council meeting to discuss the plans for the expansion of Liverpool Football Club's Anfield stadium.

    The family of a couple found stabbed to death in Toxteth pay tribute to them.

    Watch more on BBC One at 13:30.

     
  8.  
    Tribute to murdered man 13:13:

    The family of Stephen Bennett, who was killed on Sunday, have paid tribute to a "beautiful, beautiful, beautiful boy."

    Stephen Bennett

    The 28-year-old (pictured) died in hospital. A man's been charged with murder

    Mr Bennett's family said: "His heart was made of gold. he was one of the nicest lads you'll ever meet and anyone who had the pleasure of meeting Ste, all loved him."

    "He was one of the few true Blues. He still had his whole life ahead of him."

     
  9.  
    Making Chester safer 13:05: BBC Radio Merseyside

    Cheshire's chief constable has told BBC Radio Merseyside he is working closely with officers to make the streets of Chester safer.

    In recent years businesses have complained about drunk behaviour in the city centre and violence escalated outside the bars.

    Simon Byrne is reassuring the community he will take action.

     
  10.  
    news on the hour 12:59: Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    Liverpool's planning committee group has been given a tour of Anfield and the surrounding streets ahead of a meeting later where they are expected to approve the stadium extension.

    Roughly 14,000 extra seats will be added according to the designs in order to increase the capacity at the Reds home to just under 59,000.

    Listen live to the 13:00 bulletin.

     
  11.  
    Objectors to expansion 12:52: Alex Dibble BBC Radio Merseyside

    Objectors to Anfield expansion say Liverpool Football Club has "selfishly blighted" the area.

    Demolition of a house in Anfield

    Businesses and hoteliers say closing Anfield Road to redevelop the stadium will: "take money away from local traders" and clog Walton Breck Road.

    I saw demolition work in the area earlier (pictured).

     
  12.  
    lots of laughs ahead 12:47:

    The 13th Liverpool Comedy Festival begins later.

    Michael Palin

    Established comedians Michael Palin and Robin Ince will be on stage, but the event is also supporting new talent.

    Festival manager Sam Avery is encouraging people to watch unknown acts. "You might see the star of tomorrow," he said.

     
  13.  
    Discussing Anfield expansion 12:42: Alex Dibble BBC Radio Merseyside

    tweets: #Anfield stadium expansion being discussed @lpoolcouncil planning meeting in #Liverpool Town Hall. @LFC

    council chamber
     
  14.  
    Chief constable in hot seat 12:37: Roger Phillips BBC Radio Merseyside

    Another caller John, from Ellesmere Port, says: "We have problems with off-road bikes. When I ring up the police they ask a load of questions. Every time they come in a marked car and the perpetrators disappear. Why can't they come in unmarked cars?

    Cheshire's chief constable Simon Byrne said: "Sometimes we have a small team who pursue people on off-road bikes. Our worst nightmare is if someone is being chased by police on off-road bikes and they crash into a group of children."

    John added: "I've been here for six-and-a-half years. Every time it's the same rigmarole."

     
  15.  
    Balcony fall boy 'stable' 12:32:

    A two-year-old who fell from a mezzanine balcony at the Hilton hotel in Liverpool city centre on Saturday is in a stable condition in hospital, say Merseyside Police.

    Hilton Hotel, Liverpool

    Police said his condition is no longer "serious."

    A Liverpool City Council spokesman said: "We are starting an investigation to see if health and safety regulations have been complied with. We're at the start of that process."

     
  16.  
    Chief constable in hot seat 12:27: Roger Phillips BBC Radio Merseyside

    Ronald, from Penketh, asks Cheshire Police's chief constable Simon Byrne about new recruits on a two-year course doing frontline duties. "Yet there's no guarantee of a job at the end of it," he says.

    "We want to set a standard and occasionally we don't achieve that standard," Mr Byrne said. "These days how you get in the police has changed. There's one way into the police these days."

     
  17.  
    Lane blocked on M6 12:23:

    There are reports one lane is blocked due to broken down car on the M6 northbound at Junction 23 (Haydock).

     
  18.  
    Cenotaph to stay 12:18: Warrington Guardian
  19.  
    Hillsborough inquests 12:13: Phil Cooper BBC Radio Merseyside

    A Liverpool fan who was on the Leppings Lane terrace on the day of the Hillsborough disaster has described how police pushed supporters back onto the terrace.

    Leppings lane

    Ian Devine has been giving evidence at the inquests into the deaths of 96 Liverpool fans.

    He described the "eerie" sound of supporters screaming, something he'd never heard before or since.

     
  20.  
    on air 12:02: Roger Phillips BBC Radio Merseyside

    The chief constable of Cheshire Police, Simon Byrne, is in the hot seat today.

    Chief Constable Simon Byrne

    Eight months ago when he was sworn in, he pledged to recruit 50 more offices, respond to car crimes within an hour of a 999 call and to reduce bureaucracy within the force.

    Is he managing to fulfil these pledges and promises?

    You can ask him yourself between 12 and 13:00, by calling 0151 709 9333, emailing or texting 81333 with Mersey in the subject line.

     
  21.  
    news on the hour 11:58: Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    Liverpool's planning committee group has been given a tour of Anfield and he surrounding streets ahead of a meeting later where they are expected to approve the stadium extension.

    Roughly 14,000 extra seats will be added according to the designs in order to increase the capacity at the Reds home to just under 59,000.

    Listen live at 12:00.

     
  22.  
    Church Street traffic 11:49: Tony Snell BBC Radio Merseyside

    tweets: Traffic in Church St came up on the show @bbcmerseyside today. Found this great pic. Looks 50s maybe? #woolys pic.twitter.com/MVAd2otJx

    church st in 50s
     
  23.  
    Zoo founder's daughter speaks 11:44: Chester Chronicle
  24.  
    Beefeater on the show 11:38: Helen Jones BBC Radio Merseyside

    I've been talking to Jason Woodcock (pictured). He's moving from Liverpool to London to work as a Beefeater at the Tower of London.

    Jason Woodcock

    He told me he's going to be flying the flag for the city down south.

     
  25.  
    Councillors at Anfield 11:32: Alex Dibble BBC Radio Merseyside

    The planning committee from Liverpool city council is at Anfield to assess Liverpool Football Club's expansion plans.

    Planning committee at Anfield

    The club hopes to increase capacity at the stadium to almost 59,000.

     
  26.  
    Changing colours of autumn 11:26:

    One of our team sent this picture of the leaves changing colour on a south Liverpool street.

    leaves

    Do you have a photograph you'd like to share? Email merseyside.locallive@bbc.co.uk and we'll use the best on Local Live.

     
  27.  
    What do you think? 11:21:

    We've introduced BBC Local Live from our base in Liverpool to bring you the latest news, sport, travel and weather all in one place. Tell us what you think.

     
  28.  
    Imagine a perfect world 11:16: Helen Jones BBC Radio Merseyside

    is asking you to finish the sentence In A Perfect World...

    John Lennon

    Fran Stellman emails: "In A Perfect World John Lennon would still be here!"

    Call 0151 709 9333 or text 81333 with Mersey before your text email, Facebook or Twitter your idea of a perfect world.

     
  29.  
    Club cash could be withheld 11:08:

    Liverpool could have almost £7m of Champions League prize money withheld pending a Uefa inquiry into a possible breach of Financial Fair Play regulations, reports the Times.

     
  30.  
    news on the hour 10:58: Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    Liverpool's planning committee group are being given a tour of Anfield ahead of a meeting later where they are expected to approve the stadium extension.

    It will also kick start the long awaited £260m regeneration of the area.

    Around 14,000 extra seats will be added to increase the capacity to just under 59,000.

    Listen live to the 11:00 bulletin.

     
  31.  
    Nurse struck off 10:52: Warrington Guardian
  32.  
    Site visit at Anfield 10:41: Alex Dibble BBC Radio Merseyside

    I'm at Anfield where a site visit is taking place by councillors looking at plans to expand the stadium and increase capacity to almost 59,000.

    Anfield

    If approved, the plans would see the Hillsborough memorial (pictured) moved from Anfield Road to a special location under the main stand.

     
  33.  
    POLICE MAKE 173 ARRESTS 10:31:

    Cheshire Police says it has made 173 arrests spread over the north, east, west and Ellesmere Port areas as part of Operation Hatay Two.

    The arrests were for road traffic and drugs related offences and burglary, including the 18th century icon stolen from Chester Cathedral last month.

     
  34.  
    On air 10:16: Helen Jones BBC Radio Merseyside

    An economic think tank is proposing people work four days a week rather than five.

    Will it happen? Maybe in a perfect world. But what else would you have in a perfect world?

    I want you to finish the sentence In a Perfect World, what would you say.

    Please call 0151 709 9333 or text 81333 with Mersey before your text or send it via email, Facebook or Twitter.

     
  35.  
    Man freed after crash 10:11:

    Merseyside Fire tweets: Firefighters Use Hydraulic Spreaders To Force Car Door Open To Free Man Following Collision, Southport

     
  36.  
    news on the hour 09:58: Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    Councillors are expected to approve Liverpool's plans for a bigger Anfield today.

    The football club's proposals for the main and Anfield Road stands would increase capacity to almost 59,000.

    The expansion of the stadium forms part of £260m plans to regenerate the area.

    Listen live to the 10:00 bulletin.

     
  37.  
    Write a Ceefax match report 09:51:
  38.  
    Tributes to murder victim 09:33: Liverpool Echo
  39.  
    top headlines
     
  40.  
    Car park anger 09:23: Simon Moffatt Reporter, BBC Radio Merseyside

    I am in a car park in Mount Avenue in Heswall where Wirral Council's parking charges have caused a stir.

    Car park ticket

    Coun Lesley Rennie told me since the charges were put up from 40 pence to between £1.05 and £1.10 for an hour, the car parks have been empty.

    She said they were "totally unfair" and are stopping people coming into town.

    Wirral Council is yet to comment. What do you think? Tell us via email, Facebook or Twitter.

     
  41.  
    man charged with murder 09:14:

    A man has been charged with murder after a stabbing at a house in Liverpool.

    Snowdon Lane, Vauxhall

    He is accused of killing Stephen Bennett, who was found with knife wounds in Snowdon Lane, Vauxhall, on Sunday.

    The 28-year-old suffered injuries to his back and face and was taken to hospital, but later died.

     
  42.  
    Missing man appeal 09:04: BBC Radio Merseyside

    tweets: MISSING: Have you seen Terence Sullivan? The 47 year old was last seen leaving his home in Toxteth on Wed 17th Sept.

    Terence Sullivan
     
  43.  
    news on the hour 08:59: Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    Councillors are expected to approval Liverpool's plans for a bigger Anfield today.

    The football club's proposals for the main and Anfield Road stands would increase capacity to almost 59,000.

    The expansion of the stadium forms part of £260m plans to regenerate the area.

    Listen live to the 09:00 bulletin.

     
  44.  
    City's bid for Everton player 08:54: BBC Sport

    Tuesday's gossip column says Manchester City are ready to make a fresh bid for Everton and England midfielder Ross Barkley, 20, next summer after the Toffees' £50m valuation drove them away during the last transfer window. (Guardian)

     
  45.  
    Actor's bid to clear name 08:48: Ian Youngs Entertainment reporter, BBC News

    Before becoming one of Britain's best-loved actors through roles in Brookside and The Royle Family, Ricky Tomlinson was controversially jailed for his part in a strike in 1972. He is trying to clear his name, and hopes a new play about the case will help.

    Ricky Tomlinson (centre)

    He is trying to clear his name, and hopes a new play about the case will help.

    In 1972, Ricky Tomlinson was a plasterer in his mid-30s, living in a council house in north Wales, known by his real name Eric, with his familiar gift of the gab and a fiery streak.

     
  46.  
    More on Hillsborough inquests 08:43:

    The altering of a sergeant's statement after the Hillsborough disaster was "possibly" an attempt to mislead an inquiry, the inquests jury has heard.

    Fans entering through Gate C

    William Crawford said he only found out in January that comments criticising the low number of officers at the Leppings Lane end had been "expunged".

    They were removed before his statement was sent to Lord Justice Taylor's 1989 public inquiry into the disaster.

     
  47.  
    Anfield expansion plans 08:35:

    Plans for the expansion of Liverpool FC's stadium are being considered by the city council later.

    Artist's impression of the new Anfield stadium

    The move, which will raise Anfield's capacity to almost 59,000 is part of a £260m scheme to regenerate the local area.

    The proposals also include conference and banqueting facilities, a new club shop and extra car parking.

     
  48.  
    Couple 'sorely missed' 08:23:

    The family of Paul and Dorothy Brown who were found dead at a property in Toxteth on Friday said the couple would "be sorely missed".

    Dorothy and Paul Brown

    In a statement the family said: "Dorothy and Paul both came from large families and they always lived life to the full and were very well travelled.

    "Dot, as she was known to friends and family, was glamorous and very creative and really enjoyed painting. Paul was a retired electrician and was very witty."

     
  49.  
    Slow on the M62 08:18:

    BBC Travel says there's slow traffic on the M62 eastbound between Junction 9, (Winwick) and Junction 11, (Birchwood).

     
  50.  
    No concerns over Gerrard - Rodgers 08:13: BBC Sport

    Liverpool manager Brendan Rodgers insists he has "no concerns whatsoever" about Steven Gerrard.

    Liverpool's Steven Gerrard

    The Reds captain struggled to make an impact in his side's 3-1 Premier League defeat at West Ham on Saturday.

    Rodgers said: "He is a brilliant player for us. It was the team performance that wasn't up to scratch."

     
  51.  
    Patchy rain 08:08: Charlie Slater Weather Presenter, BBC

    Cloud and patchy rain in the far north will steadily spread southwards through the day and will become more persistent and heavy in places during the afternoon.

    Weather forecast Liverpool

    The best of the brightness will be across southern parts in the morning.

    Maximum temperature: 17C (63F).

     
  52.  
    news on the hour 08:00: Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    Councillors are expected to approve Liverpool's plans for a bigger Anfield today.

    The football club's proposals for the main and Anfield Road stands would increase capacity to almost 59,000.

    The expansion of the stadium forms part of a £260m scheme to regenerate the local area.

    Listen live to the 08:00 bulletin.

     
  53.  
    Good morning 08:00: Lynette Horsburgh BBC News

    I'm here to bring you the news, sport, weather and travel from around Merseyside.

    If you'd like to share your pictures and comments, you can email, send via Facebook or Twitter.

     

Features

  • Peaky Blinders publicity shotBrum do

    Why is the Birmingham accent so difficult to mimic?


  • Oliver CromwellA brief history

    The 900-year-story behind the creation of a UK parliament


  • Image of Ankor Wat using lidarJungle Atlantis

    How lasers have revealed an ancient city beneath the forest


  • Tesco signBest before?

    Has Tesco passed its sell-by date, asks Richard Anderson


BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.