Hillsborough inquests: 'No changes to safety' after pens introduced

The Hillsborough disaster The Green Guide was for the "only reference" for those looking at stadium safety

No changes were made to Hillsborough Stadium's safety certificate after the Leppings Lane end was altered in the 1980s, the inquests jury has heard.

Structural engineer John Cutlack said no amendments were made to the ground's safety certificate issued in 1979.

Christina Lambert QC, lead counsel for the inquests, said many of the crush barriers were below the height recommended for football grounds.

Ninety-six fans died as a result of the crush at the 1989 FA Cup semi-final.

The Safety at Sports Grounds Act 1975 meant stadia with a capacity of more than 10,000 required a safety certificate.

The inquests in Warrington heard Hillsborough was more like Wembley because of its "quasi-international use".

It was the third largest stadium in the Football League and used for international matches as well as the FA cup semi finals and was required to have safety certificate from 1 January 1979.

Mr Cutlack, the structural engineer brought in by the inquests as their expert in the design of Hillsborough and its safety, told the inquest Sheffield Wednesday spent £120,000 on alterations and the stadium was issued its first safety certificate in December 1979.

Safety certificates were issued by local authorities but the club had an "ongoing duty" to make sure grounds remained safe, Mr Cutlack said.

However, he told the jury no amendments were made to Hillsborough's safety certificate when radial fences on terraces were introduced and changes were made to turnstiles in Leppings Lane in the mid-1980s.

The capacity of Hillsborough's terraces was not amended either, the court heard.

The jury was shown plans to increase the number of turnstiles to 34 in 1985 but they never materialised and when Liverpool fans entered the ground on the day of the disaster they went through 23 turnstiles as opposed to 60 turnstiles for Nottingham Forest fans.

Christina Lambert QC, lead counsel for the inquests, said barriers after the 1989 disaster were found to be under the height recommended in the Green Guide book which Mr Cutlack told the jury was the "only reference" for those looking at stadium safety.

Ms Lambert read a section of the 1976 edition of the Green Guide at the hearing in Warrington, which said one of biggest safety problems at football stadiums was the build-up of pressure within crowd.

It also called for annual safety inspections of grounds, with specific attention paid to the condition of crush barriers, the jury heard.

Mr Cutlack told the jury about the history of Hillsborough and the challenges faced by structural designers particularly at the time of the disaster.

He said there was a "growth in a unruly element" and that "hooliganism crept into football grounds".

Who were the 96 victims?

Eight of the Hillsborough victims, CW from top left: Paul Clark, Stephen Copoc, Tracey Cox, Jon-Paul Gilhooley, Steven Fox, Vincent Fitzsimmons, Christopher Edwards

He told the jury pitch perimeter fences and radial fences which split terraces into pens were introduced to segregate fans after a rise in hooliganism in the game in the 1970s.

He told the hearing in Warrington: "Segregation and safety are two mutually opposing design constraints."

Mr Cutlack told the jury despite previous football disasters such as Bolton Wanderers FC's Burnden Park disaster in 1946 in which 33 people died and the crush on a stairway at Rangers FC's Ibrox stadium in 1971, resulting in 66 deaths, no legislation followed until 1975.

He said it was a "sad fact" that the Green Guide safety book followed a series of disasters rather than preventing one occurring.

The jury visited the Hillsborough stadium on Friday.

Earlier last week, the jury heard "painstaking work" had been carried out by police and families to identify the victims in thousands of videos and photos.

The inquests continue.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Liverpool



4 °C 1 °C

BBC Local Live

    11:30: Queues in Walton BBC Travel

    There is queuing traffic on the A59 Rice Lane inbound in Walton, Liverpool, at the A5098 Hornby Road junction, because of a burst water main and emergency repairs.

    All the latest information is available here.

    11:12: Two's company

    The University of Liverpool Library tweets its own snowy scene - ponies at Leahurst Campus.

    Ponies at Leahurst Campus
    11:00: News on the hour Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    Everton manager Roberto Martinez is hopeful Kevin Mirallas will be fit to face Crystal Palace on Saturday.

    Kevin Mirallas

    The Belgian International was taken off at half-time in their last game against West Bromwich Albion with a tight hamstring, after missing a penalty.

    James McCarthy, Sylvain Distin and Darron Gibson also have a chance of being in the Blues squad, while Muhamed Bešić, who was also substituted with a foot problem, is back fully fit.

    10:47: Snowstorm delays Hillsborough inquests Liverpool Echo

    A snowstorm at Birchwood Park in Warrington has delayed the start of proceedings on day 133 of the Hillsborough inquests.

    10:36: Snow halts flights at Manchester BBC Radio Merseyside

    Snow is affecting flights at Manchester Airport. The runway is closed and there will be no flights before 10:30.

    10:32: Cocaine courier caught Liverpool Echo

    A Huyton drugs crook was caught at the wheel with cocaine potentially worth almost £1m and £80,000 in cash.

    10:16: Snow clearing at Manchester Airport BBC Radio Merseyside

    Manchester Airport said a "handful" of planes were forced to circle before landing earlier while one of their two landing runways was cleared of snow.

    The operation to de-ice and clear the snow began around 07:00. The airport's snow team will then switch to clear the other runway so that the "flow rate" of landings will be reduced.

    It is not expected to cause any major disruption, said a spokesman.

    10:02: News on the hour Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    Men across Merseyside are being encouraged to talk to their friends as part of efforts to tackle Prostate Cancer.

    Thousands of men are diagnosed with the disease every year - but many ignore the symptoms.

    Join us at 10:00 to hear from Owen Sharp, from Prostate Cancer UK.

    09:44: Bookmakers robbery bid appeal

    This is the man Merseyside Police wish to speak to, after an attempted robbery of the William Hill bookmakers at 206 Vauxhall Road, Vauxhall.

    A raider, with his face covered and hood up, demanded a female member of staff hand over cash at just before 18:15 on Wednesday 13 January.

    the man police wish to speak to

    Officers said the worker "kept their cool" and called 999 immediately. The bookies was fitted with toughened security screens and the robber left empty-handed.

    09:37: 'Assault' at Blues' training ground Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    A 17-year-old suffered a neck injury in an alleged assault at Everton's training ground, police have revealed.

    Investigations are ongoing, after the teenager was taken to hospital following the alleged assault at Finch Farm in Halewood.

    09:29: Legal threat over name St Helens Star

    A Hollywood comedy club has failed to see the joke after threatening a St Helens event with legal action over using the same name.

    09:21: Snow in Liverpool Tom Mullen BBC News

    The snow's started falling in Liverpool now. I can see it out of the window from my desk here at our Liverpool offices. I've tried to get a photo but there's not much to see just yet. Let's see how it develops.

    Email us: merseyside.locallive@bbc.co.uk 09:16: Your pictures

    Thanks to Gaynor Atherton for sending in this picture of snow in Aughton.

    Snow in Aughton

    Keep emailing us your pictures.

    09:07: Disaster ambulance boss criticised Paul Burnell BBC News

    An ex-chief ambulance officer said in the wake of the Hillsborough tragedy he would "take credit" for a successful response, the inquests heard.

    Hillsborough disaster

    But Albert Page also warned two other senior officers their heads would be "on the block" if things did not go well, the hearing was told yesterday.

    Mr Page denied both allegations by one of his deputies, former assistant chief ambulance officer David Jones.

    09:00: News on the hour Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    The weather warning for icy conditions has been upgraded to amber as snow starts to fall in some areas of Merseyside and Cheshire.

    We are in for a very cold, windy day with sleet and rain.

    We will hear from Charlie Spencer, from the BBC Weather Centre, at 09:00 who tells us the greater risk of snow is on higher ground.

    08:53: Snowy St Helens Tom Mullen BBC News

    It seems there's been a dusting of snow in St Helens this morning. Mark Warren has tweeted us this picture. Keep them coming!

    Snow in St Helens
    08:41: M57 lane closure BBC Travel

    One lane is closed on the M57 southbound between J6, A506 for Kirkby and J5, for the A580 East Lancs Road, because of an overturned vehicle, drivers are being warned.

    08:32: Zoo recreates Indonesian habitat Paul Burnell BBC News

    A container load of old and battered objects from half way around the world has arrived at Chester Zoo.

    Indonesian boat arrives at Chester Zoo

    They included a boat, some roof tiles and several cages - artefacts from Indonesia being used in a new development at the zoo.

    The Islands project aims to recreate natural environments for tigers, orang-utans and crocodiles.

    08:14: Gun and machetes seized BBC Radio Merseyside

    Four people have been arrested as armed police seized a gun and machetes at a house on the Wirral - after a woman was threatened.

    She was told the group would come back for her later on Beryl Road in Noctorum around 19:20 last night.

    Later officers sealed off a house on Whetstone Lane in Birkenhead and arrested three men aged between 18 and 21 as well as a girl who is 17.

    08:04: Today's forecast BBC Weather Latest

    Another cold and windy day with sunny spells and further snow showers.

    However, these showers will likely fall as sleet near the coasts and the snow will become increasingly confined to the hills later in the day. Highs of 4C (39F).

    08:00: Good morning Alex Homer BBC Local Live

    I'm bringing you today's news, sport, travel and weather updates for Merseyside.

    Get in touch with us during the day over email, Facebook and Twitter.



Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.