Hillsborough Wikipedia changes inquiry 'challenging'

Hillsborough memorial Ninety-six Liverpool football fans died after a crush at the Hillsborough stadium in 1989

Identifying who made offensive changes to a Wikipedia page about the Hillsborough disaster "may prove challenging", ministers have said.

The government said a full inquiry led by Cabinet Office Permanent Secretary Richard Heaton was under way.

It came after the Liverpool Echo said Whitehall computers on a secure government network were used.

The Cabinet Office said the "sickening" changes were "in complete contravention of the Civil Service Code".

'All relevant material'

A Cabinet Office statement said "important stakeholders" including the Hillsborough Family Support Group, the Hillsborough Justice Campaign and the All Party Parliamentary Group on the Hillsborough Disaster would be kept updated of developments.

How the source was uncovered

Liverpool Echo front page
  • Wikipedia allows any web user to make changes to its pages, but this leaves a trace through the user's internet protocol (IP) address
  • Changes are monitored by Wikipedia, but internet trolls have been known to post insulting material, which is usually swiftly removed
  • Liverpool Echo reporter Oliver Duggan discovered that insults posted on the website's Hillsborough Disaster page had been made using computers within the government's internal intranet
  • He confirmed this after referring to a list of 34 IP addresses used by the government released by former minister Angela Eagle in 2008

A spokesman said Andy Burnham MP, who "has a deserved status as an expert on the disaster", would be given the chance to "view all relevant material from the very outset so that he can assure himself all steps have been taken".

The statement said: "The amendments made to Wikipedia are sickening. The behaviour is in complete contravention of the Civil Service Code. It is entirely unacceptable.

"At this time, we have no reason to suspect that the Hillsborough edits involve any particular department, nor more than one or two individuals in 2009 and 2012.

"As the first incident happened five years ago and there are hundreds of thousands of people on the government's network, it may prove challenging to identify who was involved, but we are exhausting every option."

Mr Burnham said it was "sickening and appalling to think that people in government are aiming this kind of abuse at the Liverpool supporters - particularly the victims and survivors of that tragedy".

He said that "a full and proper inquiry [to] find the name of the individual or individuals responsible" needed to happen, adding that they must then be "held accountable - nothing else will do".

Mr Burnham, during his time as Culture, Media and Sport Secretary, was instrumental in a campaign to have classified documents about the disaster released, which led to the formation of the Hillsborough Independent Panel.

Liverpool anthem

Oliver Duggan, the Liverpool Echo reporter who broke the story, said the paper used a list of 34 internet protocol (IP) addresses for Whitehall computers.

These were released in 2008 by Angela Eagle MP following a parliamentary question to "match up" the addresses with those used to edit the Wikipedia page about the disaster.

The newspaper said the alterations to the page included the Liverpool anthem You'll Never Walk Alone being altered to You'll Never Walk Again and the phrase "Blame Liverpool Fans" being added to a paragraph.

line break
Wikipedia edit for Hillsborough disaster page on 15 April 2009 A Wikipedia edit on the 20th anniversary of the disaster added the words 'Blame Liverpool Fans'
line break

Steve Rotheram, the MP for Liverpool Walton, echoed Mr Burnham's remarks and said he and a group of Merseyside MPs would be writing to the government to ask that any inquiry "be swift".

Sheila Coleman, spokeswoman for the Hillsborough Justice Campaign, said the group would be talking to its legal team about "how to proceed".

Ms Eagle, the MP for Wallasey, said the claims were "pretty shocking" and were "another problem for [the families] having to deal with the grief".

Entries in Wikipedia, an online encyclopaedia, can be edited by anyone with access to the internet.

Jon Davies, chief executive of Wikimedia UK, said it was "appalled by such vandalism".

Ninety-six Liverpool football fans died after a crush at an FA Cup semi-final at the Sheffield ground on 15 April 1989.

New inquests, which are ongoing, were ordered after fresh evidence revealed by the Hillsborough Independent Panel led to the original inquest verdicts being quashed.

More on This Story

Hillsborough Inquests

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Liverpool



22 °C 15 °C

BBC Local Live

    'Don't be alarmed' 12:52:

    Mersey Fire tweets: You may see some helicopters near StrorringtonAvenue,Croxteth,don't be alarmed.It's a large exercise. @MerseyPolice @NWAmbulance @MerseyFire

    More on suspended doctor 12:47:

    A doctor who told a suicidal patient to 'jolly well kill herself' during a row over a sick note has been suspended by the General Medical Council's Medical Practitioners Tribunal Service for three months.

    Arun Kumar Singhal, 65, made the comments at the Huyton practice in 2011.

    The panel found that Dr Singhal's fitness to practise was impaired by his misconduct.

    It ruled his behaviour "appears to be a single episode" and Dr Singhal was "working under difficult circumstances in a deprived area."

    The suspension will "send the right message" to the doctor and profession that his behaviour was unacceptable.

    Fake train crash in Liverpol 12:39: Roger Phillips BBC Radio Merseyside

    As we've been hearing in the news, a fake train crash has been staged in Liverpool for the biggest emergency services training exercise ever held in the UK.

    It's running as if there's been a real disaster, so the police, fire and ambulance crews can react as if they are under pressure, dealing with the victims.

    Our reporter Nick Hatfield is in Croxteth with the crews.

    Mosquito v horsefly 12:31: Warrington Guardian

    tweets: Warrington's horsefly v mosquito debate answered by tropical medicine expert. Read it here: bit.ly/XndubC

    Allardyce manager on Liverpool 12:26: BBC Sport

    West Ham manager Sam Allardyce on his side's lack of home wins: "What we've clearly got to do is stop our poor home results and we've got to try to do that against Liverpool.

    "We're looking forward to the game as always and hopefully we can play as well as against Tottenham, but this time get a result."

    Wirral line re-opened 12:18:

    Merseyrail says following electrical supply problems at Liverpool Central Wirral, the Wirral line has now re-opened.

    Doctor suspended BREAKING NEWS

    A doctor who told a suicidal patient to 'jolly well kill herself' during a row over a sick note has been suspended by the General Medical Council for three months. Arun Kumar Singhal, 65, made the comments at the Huyton practice where he worked in 2011.

    Waterfront view 12:11:

    Simon Jones tweeted this photograph of Liverpool Waterfront taken from a Mersey Ferry. You can send us your photos on twitter to @bbcmerseyside.

    Picture from @EnjoyinMoss
    News on the hour 12:00: Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    Police officers outside the Hillsborough stadium lost control of the crowd between 2.15 and 2.30pm that day, according to a retired officer on duty.

    Stephen Thomas is the first mounted officer who has given evidence to the Inquests in Warrington.

    He and his horse tried to control the crowd arriving to watch the FA Cup semi-final.

    Mr Thomas also said he thought there weren't enough officers on foot.

    Listen to the live bulletin at 12:00.

    Mersey rose 11:45:

    Here's a beautiful photograph of a rose sent in by David Hudson. We'd love to se your pictures if you'd like to hare them with us, you can email us at merseyside.locallive@bbc.co.uk

    999 video 11:40: Andy Gill BBC North West Tonight

    I'm in north Liverpool where a fake train crash has been staged as a training exercise for the local emergency services.

    Still from Andy Gill's video

    You can watch a video clip on my twitter feed.

    Brandt signing? 11:32:

    The BBC Sport Football Gossip Column reports Chelsea and Liverpool are both keen to sign 18-year-old German midfielder Julian Brandt from Bayer Leverkusen.

    Julian Brandt
    Helicopter flies in 11:27: Nick Hatfield BBC Radio Merseyside

    tweets: #EXERCISE999 RAF helicopter flies in to help

    Emergency mock-up in Liverpool
    What do you think? 11:21:

    We've introduced BBC Local Live from our base in Liverpool to bring you the latest news, sport, travel and weather all in one place. Tell us what you think.

    School seeks new head 11:14: St Helens Star
    Our Zoo cameo 11:04:

    Chester Zoo tweets: Did you spot the real June Mottershead making a cameo?

    Now in her 80s, she's sat next to her son George #OurZoo

    The real June Mottershead
    News on the hour 10:57: Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    A fake train crash has been staged in Liverpool for the biggest emergency services training exercise the UK has ever seen.

    It is playing out as if there has been a real disaster in the city - so the police, fire and ambulance crews can react as if they are under pressure dealing with the victims.

    Listen to the live bulletin at 11:00.

    Thatcher sign 'decorated' 10:47: Liverpool Echo

    A brand-new sign dedicated to the memory of former British Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher has been given a new look in Spain.

    More on exercise 10:41: Nick Hatfield BBC Radio Merseyside

    tweets: #EXERCISE999 police, fire, ambulance meet to come up with incident response

    disaster exercise
    Accident closes Oxton road 10:35:

    BBC Travel says Mill Hill in Oxton is closed in both directions between the Holm Lane junction and the Townfield Lane junction, because of an accident.

    Heritage at risk 10:28: Chester Chronicle
    Emergency training exercise 10:21: Nick Hatfield BBC Radio Merseyside

    tweets: #EXERCISE999 emergency training exercise underway in Croxteth. Flames, smoke, train on its side, multiple casualties.

    emergency exercise
    Whiskers or not? 10:16: Helen Jones BBC Radio Merseyside

    Beards and stubble have become so popular that sales of razors and shaving foam have fallen by more than £70 m across Europe.

    So I want to know are you a fan of the face fuzz? Beards yes or no? And if you have beard why not share your beard selfies with us?

    Call 0151 709 9333 or contact us via Facebook.

    Everton set for Europa League 10:09: Phil Kinsella BBC Merseyside Sport

    It's been five seasons without European football for Everton, but the Blues make their return to the Europa League tonight.

    Everton forward Samuel Eto'o

    Samuel Eto'o is available for his team's first appearance on the European stage for four years.

    Wolfsburg are their opponents at Goodison this evening in their first group game.

    999 mock-up 10:03: Andy Gill BBC North West Tonight

    tweets: "Bodies" #Derailed train" "crashed cars" - part of #Excercise999 in #Liverpool today @BBCNWT

    Emergency mock up incident in Liverpool
    News on the hour 09:57: Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    A fake train crash has been staged in Liverpool for the biggest emergency services training exercise the UK has ever seen.

    We can't give too many details for security reasons - but it will play out as if there has been a real disaster in the city.

    Listen to the live bulletin at 10:00.

    Giant fish display 09:45:

    A new display at Blue Planet Aquarium is highlighting the problem of fish keepers who buy giant fish species without realising they will be unable to accommodate them when fully grown.

    Redtail catfish

    The exhibit includes several different 'problem' catfish species including red tailed catfish, tiger shovel nose catfish and giraffe catfish - all of which have been donated by members of the public after outgrowing their original tanks.

    Early start for cycling 09:32:

    Cycling Projects tweets: Early morning start for our Wirral cycling programme interviews with radio Merseyside @bbcmerseyside @Merseytravel

    Marc and cyclist
    Attack at music festival 09:25: St Helens Star
    Mosquitoes on rise 09:14: Marc Gaier BBC Radio Merseyside

    I'm in Little Neston where people are complaining about an increase in mosquito bites because of the warm weather.

    Aedes aegypti

    The insects are thought to be coming from the nearby Dee Estuary salt marshes.

    You can listen to BBC Radio Merseyside live where we will be talking to Louise Gittins, Labour Councillor for Little Neston and Burton.

    Blue lights 09:09: Andy Gill BBC North West Tonight

    tweets: Lorra lorra blue lights in #Liverpool today. Massive emergency exercise - not real. More @BBCNWT #Excercise999

    Mock emergency in Liverpool
    News on the hour 09:00: Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    A major training exercise, designed to test the joint response of Merseyside's police, fire and ambulance services, will take place in north Liverpool this morning.

    It will involve nearly 1,000 people - including a survivor of the Hillsborough disaster.

    Listen to the live bulletin at 09:00.

    Mock emergency test 08:49:

    A large training exercise designed to test the initial joint response of the police, fire and ambulance services will take place later in Liverpool.

    The mock test aims to ensure the blue light emergency services work effectively together when responding to a major incident.

    top headlines
    Yellow or lellow? 08:36: Tony Snell BBC Radio Merseyside

    We're talking about words this morning. When you were little, do you remember struggling to say certain things? What about lellow for yellow or chimley for chimney? I used to say taski instead of taxi.

    We've got a list of the top 10 words that children struggle to say and we'll be reading them out on the show.

    What words did you or your kids struggle with?

    You can send us your photos or comments on email, Facebook or Twitter.

    Balotelli 'donates to dogs' 08:22: Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    It's being claimed Liverpool's Mario Balotelli has donated a five-figure sum to the dogs' home in Manchester gutted by a fire last week.

    Liverpool's Mario Balotelli celebrates his first goal for the club

    The Reds striker has volunteered for them in the past, walking the dogs for them while his own pet was in quarantine before moving from Italy.

    An anonymous donation was spotted on the Just Giving page - and the kennels believe it is the Anfield star so want to say thank you.

    Sunny and warm 08:11: Mel Coles BBC Weather

    It will be another largely dry day with some sunny spells developing once any early patchy mist or hill fog clears through the morning.

    Mel Coles with the weather

    Feeling warm in the sunny spells with generally light winds.

    News on the Hour 08:02: Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    There will be a huge disaster in Liverpool later - but it won't be real. It will be the biggest training exercise for our emergency services the UK has ever seen.

    Listen to the live bulletin at 08:00.

    Good morning 08:00: Julia Bryson BBC Local Live

    Hello from Liverpool city centre, I'm here with you today with all the local news, sport, travel and weather from across Merseyside. Remember you can get in touch and share your comments and pictures by emailing merseyside.locallive@bbc.co.uk, tweeting @bbcmerseyside or posting a message on Facebook.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.