Hillsborough inquests: Father was 'powerless to help'

James Aspinall James Aspinall travelled to the match by coach with a friend, who also died in the disaster

A father was "powerless to help his son when he was most needed" as he saw the Hillsborough disaster unfold, an inquest has heard.

Jimmy Aspinall "could only watch from the side pen" near the crush, a family statement said.

The inquest jury in Warrington heard James Aspinall, 18, was one of 96 people to die in the tragedy.

The statement, written by his mother Margaret Aspinall, said a "darkness fell" on the family in 1989.

Mrs Aspinall, chair of the Hillsborough Family Support Group, had her statement read out by her son David.

'Reclaim my brother'
Michael Kelly Michael Kelly was described to the court by his brother

He told the coroner: "A darkness fell over our family on April 15, 1989. It's only being here now, being allowed to describe what a decent human being James was, that it's finally given our family a shard of light in to that darkness."

James, who worked as a clerk at a shipping firm on Merseyside, travelled to the game by coach with a friend, Graham John Wright, who also died. His father travelled separately.

Jurors have been listening to background statements about how the Hillsborough disaster affected individual families.

A statement about Michael Kelly, 39, was read by his brother Steve.

He said: "In death he became body number 72, also the last to be claimed by his family, yet another statistic. His name was Michael David Kelly.

"I want to remove that sequence of numbers from him. I'm here today to reclaim my brother."

Tribute to Hillsborough victim James Aspinall, written by mother Margaret and read by brother David

He told the jury his brother was "a real man, a father, son, brother and friend".

'Reunited with son'

Sue Roberts, sister of Graham, 24, paid tribute to the "family, friends and survivors" of Hillsborough who have died since 1989.

She said Graham was planning to marry his fiancée in 1990, they had chosen a house to buy and were due to sign a contract.

Ms Roberts, secretary of the Hillsborough Family Support Group, said: "Both my parents are now reunited with their son which, sadly since his death, was all they ever wanted."

Peter Harrison, a 15-year-old schoolboy from Liverpool, was described by his mother Patricia Harrison.

Peter Harrison A statement about 15-year-old Peter Harrison was read out in Warrington

In a statement read by a lawyer, she said her son received a Liverpool season ticket for Christmas, which was buried with him.

She said: "What happened was terrible. But we all try to remember the good times we had with Peter. I often go to this room which still has his bed and bedside table."

'Grief etched'

Karen Staniford read a statement about her brother Gary Church, 19. He was a joiner who lived with his family in Seaforth.

Gary Church Gary Church was described as a "hard worker" and often did long shifts

She described him as "typical little boy" who enjoyed football and a "hard worker" who often did 14-hour days.

Who were the 96 victims?

Eight of the Hillsborough victims, CW from top left: Paul Clark, Stephen Copoc, Tracey Cox, Jon-Paul Gilhooley, Steven Fox, Vincent Fitzsimmons, Christopher Edwards

Ms Staniford said: "To this day I live just a few doors from the home my family and I shared with Gary as we were growing up and each day I look out of my window expecting Gary to come home".

In a further statement, Tracey Phelan spoke about the effect of losing her brother Paul Hewitson, 26, from Liverpool.

She said: "Each year as April 15 drew near we would see our mum and dad's sadness increase and the grief that was so clearly etched on to our mum's face became more apparent.

"Her heart was broken and remained broken for the rest of her life. Paul was the apple of his mother's eye. He was the light of her life."

Paul Hewitson Paul Hewitson's statement was written by his sister

Paul Murray got tickets for the game for his 14th birthday - just three days before the disaster.

Paul Murray Paul Murray's former schools have named football competitions after him

When they came in the post he leapt into the air shouting "This is the best day of my life", his mother Edna told the inquest.

The church choirboy from Stoke-on-Trent supported the Reds because his grandfather was a Liverpudlian. His old schools have named their football competitions after him.

'Belonged to me'

Kevin Tyrrell, 15, from Runcorn was a "football mad" teenager, his father Frank Tyrrell said in a statement read by the boy's uncle.

Kevin Tyrrell Kevin Tyrrell played for the Tranmere Rovers youth team

He was having trials for Tranmere Rovers and played in their youth team.

His father added: "In the early hours of 16th April 1989, after identifying Kevin, as I went to touch my son I was told that I couldn't as he now belonged to the coroner.

"He didn't. He belonged to me and my wife and he was Gary and Donna's brother and to his aunties, uncles, cousins and friends he was Tizzer."

The daughter of Henry Burke, 47, told the jury how she wished she could have held his hand when he was lying on the pitch, "like he had held my hand through my life".

Henry Burke Henry Burke's daughter Christine paid tribute to her father at the inquest

Christine Burke said the father of three, a builder from Liverpool, was "old school" and they were brought up to have manners and respect for others.

She added: "He was always there for us to protect us, guide us and advise us".

'Upsetting and uplifting'

Philip Steele, 15, from Southport, had gone to the match with his father Les.

Philip Steele The inquest heard Philip Steele's love of Liverpool stemmed from his father

His mother Dolores said her husband, who has since died, never came to terms with the fact that he was at Hillsborough but was not able to save his son.

She added: "My first thought each morning is of Philip as well as the last thought at night. When I think of our lovely son his laughter rings in my ears."

Peter Burkett, 24, from Birkenhead, was a kind and gentle young man, his sister Lesley Roberts said.

Peter Burkett Peter Burkett's statement was written by his sister Lesley

Her brother, who worked as an insurance clerk in Liverpool, had walked her down the aisle on her wedding day five months before he died.

She added: "When he smiled it warmed your body through to your soul."

A statement from David Benson's mother was read out to the jury. The 22-year-old from Warrington was working as a rep for a timber company when he died.

Mr Benson was a young father at the time of his death and if he had lived "would now be a grandfather".

David Benson David Benson drove to the game with his friend but separated at the ground because they had tickets for different sections

Gloria Benson added: "To this day David is sorely missed."

At the end of today's hearing the coroner, Lord Justice Goldring, addressing the jury said: "It's been both very upsetting and yet an uplifting day, has it not?"

The inquests, set to last a year, were ordered after new evidence revealed by the Hillsborough Independent Panel led to the original inquest verdicts being quashed.

The hearing was adjourned until Monday.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Liverpool



6 °C 3 °C

BBC Local Live

    13:25: Milk leaked onto M6

    More than 150bottles of milk leaked after a lorry overturned on the M6 southbound between J21 and J20, according to a tweet from Cheshire Fire.

    13:14: Tranmere frontman loaned out Nathan Middleton BBC Sport

    Conference side Southport have signed Tranmere striker George Donnelly on loan until the end of the season.

    George Donnelly George Donnelly was a trainee at Liverpool but was released in 2007

    The 26-year-old had been made available for transfer by Rovers boss Micky Adams at the start of the month.

    12:57: News on the hour Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    At 13:00 we hear from Merseyrail operations director Andy Heath, as he explains why frozen snow affected the Wirral and Northern lines this morning.

    Listen live to BBC Radio Merseyside.

    12:47: M6 southbound closure BBC Travel

    The M6 is closed and there is queuing traffic southbound between J21 for Woolston and J20 for the Lymm Interchange because of an overturned lorry.

    Congestion is back to J21a at the Croft Interchange, drivers are warned.

    12:42: Liverpool v West Ham Simon Brotherton Match of the Day commentator

    Mamadou Sakho is a doubt for Liverpool with a back problem sustained during the midweek League Cup defeat against Chelsea.

    The Reds will be boosted by the return of Daniel Sturridge from his thigh injury.

    12:31: Blaze victim not yet named Tom Mullen BBC News

    An elderly woman was found dead after firefighters tackled a house fire in St Helens.

    Birchfield Street

    Merseyside Fire and Rescue Service were called to Birchfield Street, Thatto Heath at about 23.20 last night.

    The body of the woman, who has not yet been identified, was discovered in the lounge.

    12:16: Ex-Blues keeper: probation 'in safe hands' Chester Chronicle

    He may be best known for his legendary moves on the pitch but Grenville Millington is determined to show the people of Chester that community payback is in a safe pair of hands.

    The new chairman of the Blues started working in the probation service two years before he hung up his goalkeeping gloves in 1984 - and he has never looked back.

    11:57: News on the hour Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    Latest figures from NHS England show an improvement in A&E waiting times - for the third week in a row. 93% of patients are being seen within four hours - 2% short of the target.

    We hear from the BBC's Health Correspondent Adam Brimelow at 12:00.

    11:42: Sturridge 'anxious and excited' about return Emlyn Begley BBC Sport

    Liverpool striker Daniel Sturridge is "anxious and excited" as he prepares to return from five months out injured.

    Daniel Sturridge

    The 25-year-old also told BBC Radio 5 live the mental side of his game has improved during his layoff.

    The former Chelsea striker has not played since suffering a thigh injury while on England duty in September. Since then he has injured his calf and thigh again.

    11:28: Your views Alex Homer BBC Local Live

    BBC Local Live brings you the latest news, sport, travel and weather all in one place.

    Tell us what you think

    11:18: Warehouse restaurant to close Southport Visiter

    A Southport restaurant owned by businessman Paul Adams and Liverpool FC captain Steven Gerrard is to close.

    11:08: Locate gritters near you BBC Travel North West BBC Travel

    Wondering where all the gritters are? This link shows a real-time map with the locations of all gritters across the Cheshire East council area.

    Council gritter
    10:58: News on the hour Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    Merseyside police have told us the death of a 13-year-old boy in Whiston is not being treated as suspicious.

    He was discovered by a member of the public in Stadt Moer Park on Thursday afternoon.

    Officers are working with the coroner to establish the circumstances surrounding his death. Join us for the 11:00 headlines.

    10:48: Reds bid for striker Ings Ben Smith BBC Sport

    Liverpool will attempt to sign Burnley striker Danny Ings before Monday's transfer deadline.

    Danny Ings

    Manager Brendan Rodgers is willing to loan the 22-year-old back to Sean Dyche's side for the rest of the season in order to complete a deal.

    10:38: 'Major disruption' from frozen snow Wirral Globe

    Merseyrail is warning frozen snow caused major disruptions at Southport, Kirby, Hunts Cross, Ellesmere Port and Chester.

    10:28: Health and safety Tony Snell BBC Radio Merseyside

    It was our last day looking at the work of Health and Safety Executive in Bootle on BBC Radio Merseyside today. Here's the king!

    Painter doing window ledges over a great height, balancing on wooden boards between open windows
    10:17: Baines back on spotkicks BBC Sport

    Left-back Leighton Baines, 30, will be restored to Everton penalty duties this weekend after forward Kevin Mirallas' controversial miss against West Bromwich Albion, reports the Daily Telegraph.

    More football gossip is here.

    10:04: Buy a tile scheme Runcorn & Widnes Weekly News

    Each Victorian tile on the floor of the medieval undercroft at Norton Priory is being painstakingly removed by archaeologists under a £3.7m conservation project.

    Victorian tiles at Norton Priory in Runcorn

    A buy-a-tile scheme has been launched to ensure the project to restore the 12th century landmark can be completed.

    09:54: News on the hour Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    A woman's body was discovered by firefighters called to a blaze in St Helens.

    Smoke alarms were fitted and they did activate at the house on Birchfield Street in Thatto Heath late last night.

    More on this story and others in our 10:00 bulletin.

    09:37: Teenager's body found in park St Helens Star

    The body of a 13-year-old boy has been found at a Whiston park.

    Emergency crews were called by a member of the public to the scene in Stadt Moers Park at about 13:00 yesterday, according to reports.

    09:21: Probe into inmate's death Andy Gill BBC North West Tonight

    The Prisons Ombudsman will investigate the death of Lee Rushton, a 34-year-old inmate found in his cell at Walton prison in Liverpool on Wednesday.

    09:12: Police attending crash scene

    Here's another photograph from the accident on the M62, which is causing major rush hour delays this morning.

    M62 accident

    Thanks to Mark Warren for tweeting us.

    08:59: News on the hour Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    Have we hit what some experts are calling "peak fat"?

    One in three British children are now overweight - but new research suggests childhood obesity rates in England may be levelling off.

    We hear from Simon Capewell, a professor at the University of Liverpool, who founded the campaign group Action on Sugar in our 09:00 bulletin.

    08:48: Live pictures from M62 accident Tom Mullen BBC News

    Mark Warren has run into trouble at the accident on the M62. He has tweeted these pictures from the scene.

    08:40: Wave of mourners expected at traveller funeral Liverpool Echo

    Motorists heading from Merseyside towards Ellesmere Port and Chester are being warned of potential delays as mourners from across the country attend a traveller funeral in Cheshire later.

    08:30: Blueprint for the future approved

    A document outlining how Cheshire West and Chester will develop over the next 15 years has been approved.


    Only two councillors voted against the borough's Local Plan at a meeting last night - it details the level and location of development in the borough up to 2030.

    Twenty-two thousand homes will be built and 365 hectares of land have been earmarked for development.

    08:20: Frozen snow blocks lines BBC Travel

    Frozen snow is blocking Merseyrail train lines at Ellesmere Port and Kirkby, so commuters are warned to expect some disruption.

    The latest information is here.

    08:17: Motorway crashes warning BBC Travel

    Two lanes are closed on the M62 eastbound at J5 for Huyton because of a crash.

    There is also slow traffic and one lane closed on the M57 southbound between J3 for Stockbridge Village and J2 for the A57 at Prescot, because of another crash.

    Drivers are warned to take care in icy conditions.

    08:08: Icy start BBC Weather Latest

    An icy start this morning, and another cold feeling day, especially in the brisk north-westerly wind. A scattering of wintry showers, especially this afternoon, but generally fewer than Thursday.

    Snow mainly confined to hills, with sleet at lower levels. Highs of 5C (41F). More about the weekend's outlook is here.

    08:00: Good morning Alex Homer BBC Local Live

    I'm back with today's news, sport, travel and weather updates for Merseyside.

    Get in touch with us during the day over email, Facebook and Twitter.



Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.