Hillsborough inquests: 'Failures of others' took teenager's dreams

Christopher Barry Devonside Chris Devonside studied A-levels in history, politics and economics

A father whose son's life "ended abruptly" at Hillsborough had his dreams cut short through the "failures of others", an inquest was told.

Chris Devonside died aged 18 after a crush at the FA Cup semi-final in April 1989, which led to the deaths of 96 Liverpool football fans.

He believed the condition of most football grounds was unacceptably poor, the coroner in Warrington heard.

Hillsborough campaigner Barry Devonside said the Heysel disaster was a warning.

Who were the 96 victims?

Eight of the Hillsborough victims, CW from top left: Paul Clark, Stephen Copoc, Tracey Cox, Jon-Paul Gilhooley, Steven Fox, Vincent Fitzsimmons, Christopher Edwards

Mr Devonside Jr, from Wirral, "argued passionately" that "greater transparency and honesty" was needed after the 1985 disaster, where 39 football fans, mostly Italians, died in a European Cup Final between Liverpool and Juventus.

'Life ended unnecessarily'

Mr Devonside Sr said: "He believed that the condition of those football grounds he had visited was unacceptably poor.

"[Chris] argued passionately that the circumstances surrounding the Heysel Stadium disaster warranted greater transparency and honesty on the part of officialdom."

The former Hillsborough Family Support Group secretary added: "His life was ended abruptly, prematurely and unnecessarily because of the failures of others preventing Chris from fulfilling his dreams of travel and university."

Coroner Lord Justice Goldring has described the Hillsborough disaster as "the worst ever at a British sports stadium".

It unfolded on 15 April 1989 during Liverpool's match against Nottingham Forest at Sheffield Wednesday's ground.

Martin Kenneth Wild Martin Wild was a print worker at Dorm Press Birchvale in Cheshire in 1989

The coroner heard about Martin Wild, 29, from Cheshire, who attended the match with a friend who survived.

A statement from Mr Wild's father Kenneth - dated 25 April 1989 - was read out. His family did not respond to the coroner's request for background information.

'Only child'

It said: "Martin was a life-long Liverpool supporter and went to all the home games at Anfield.

"He rarely travelled to away games."

Mr Wild and his younger brother Nigel lived with his paternal grandmother, Anne Wild.

Anthony Peter Kelly Anthony Kelly joined the army aged 18

The mother of Anthony Kelly, 29, from Birkenhead, Wirral said the disaster "should never have happened".

Betty Almond said her son was a "sickly baby" and weighed 2lbs (900g) when he was born but became a "grand lad".

She said: "I miss him so much. Anthony was our only child.

"Hillsborough should never have happened."

Paul Clark Paul Clark was an apprentice electrician

The inquest jury was told about Paul Clark, 18, from Swanwick in Derbyshire who was "happy" and had a "bright future ahead of him".

His father Ken Clark said: "Paul was a popular young man who had many friends.

'My rock'

"To this day they all meet together in the village on the 15 April to remember him and lay flowers on his grave."

Paul William Carlile The street where Paul Carlile lived was renamed Carlile Way

Paul Carlile, 19, from Liverpool, was "not a hooligan" and was "not a drunkard" but was "brought up to be a law-abiding citizen", the inquest heard.

In a statement, his mother Sandra Stringer said: "People say time heals. It doesn't."

The document, read by his sister, Donna Miller, added: "We haven't had time to heal. We just want some answers - that may give us some peace.

"He went to watch the team he loved and came home in a coffin."

Jonathon Owens Jonathon Owens worked at Royal Life Insurance in Liverpool

The mother of Jonathon Owens, 18, from Chester, said she was "glad" of the memories he gave her family.

Pat Owens said: "I'm glad we were able to give him fond memories, just as he gave them to us.

"Our home life was great. It wasn't all a bed of roses but love and laughter was at the forefront.

"The three of us were the best of pals," she added.

Stephen Francis Harrison Stephen Harrison's widow said he was her "rock" and "soulmate"

The inquest jury heard a tribute to father-of-four Stephen Harrison, 31, from Liverpool, died who along with his brother Gary, 27.

His widow Susan Harrison described how: "Stephen was my rock, my soulmate and for our four children he was their world.

"The day Stephen left our lives our world fell apart, not just as a family but as individuals."

A statement from his mother Anne Wright said: "My two boys were good sons, brothers and fathers."

'Zest for life'
Joseph Daniel McCarthy Joseph Daniel McCarthy was studying business at Sheffield University

Sheffield University student Joseph Daniel McCarthy, 21, from London, was "one of life's good guys", the coroner was told.

His cousin Anthony Goggins said he excelled both academically and at sports.

Mr Goggins said: "Joe was one of life's good guys. He was genuinely a lovely human being, full of joy with a zest for life."

Jurors have been listening to brief background statements about how the Hillsborough disaster affected individual families.

The inquests, set to last a year, were ordered after new evidence revealed by the Hillsborough Independent Panel led to the original inquest verdicts being quashed.

The hearing was adjourned until Friday.

More on This Story

Hillsborough Inquests

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Liverpool



19 °C 15 °C

BBC Local Live

    Gunman in shop robbery 13:22:

    A man burst into an Ellesmere Port shop with a gun and threatened staff before fleeing with cash.

    Loxdale Local store

    Merseyside Police are appealing for information after the robbery, which happened at the Loxdale Local store in Loxdale Drive, at about 07:25.

    Det Insp Debbie Dodd said: "It has not been established whether the gun was real or imitation. The weapon was not discharged and no injuries were reported but staff, who were in the shop at the time, were understandably left very shaken by their ordeal."

    News on the hour 13:00: Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    A former police sergeant on duty at Hillsborough would not have mentioned 'drunk or ticketless fans' in his statement, had he not been briefed by a top South Yorkshire Police officer after the disaster.

    Philip Lomas is giving evidence for a second day at the Hillsborough inquests in Warrington.

    Listen to our live bulletin.

    Eto'o 'perfect fit' for Everton 12:53:

    Roberto Martinez has described new signing Samuel Eto'o as a "perfect fit" for Everton.

    Roberto Martinez and Samuel Eto'o

    Speaking at a press conference where the former Chelsea striker was unveiled after joining on a free transfer, the Everton boss said: "He's hungrier than ever.

    "We welcome his know-how, his experience, his attacking threat. He has a winning mentality, knows what it takes to win trophies and he's a goal scorer".

    "In a squad full of young talent, Samuel Eto'o with his experience and desire is the perfect fit for Everton".

    Find your family history 12:45:

    Museum of Liverpool tweets: "Discover how to find out more about your #familyhistory today with Curator Karen O'Rourke from 2-4pm #HomeFront"

    PC 'welded' to Hillsborough account 12:28: Ben Schofield BBC Radio Merseyside

    A former police sergeant has been accused of being "welded" to his account of seeing large numbers of football fans drinking and carrying alcohol before the Hillsborough disaster.

    Turnstiles at the Hillsborough stadium

    The jury at the Hillsborough Inquests has heard Philip Colin Lomas say he had never seen so much drinking ahead of a match.

    A barrister for a group of families showed him nine photographs and video footage taken of fans before kick off. Mr Lomas couldn't point out any drunk fans or anyone carrying cans or bottles of alcohol. But he said the pictures were taken away from where he was on patrol.

    Your views 12:21:

    We've introduced BBC Local Live from our base in Liverpool to bring you the latest news, sport, travel and weather all in one place. Tell us what you think.

    A Giant gesture 12:15: Tony Snell BBC Radio Merseyside

    You've been having your say about so-called "victimless crimes" after a study suggested people are becoming less honest - and Nick Steven has told us an inspiring tale of an experience he had during the Giants spectacular in Liverpool.

    The Little Girl Giant

    Nick posted on Facebook: "When we visited Liverpool recently for the Giants, I managed to lose my wallet (long story). The next day we got a call that it had been handed in at the police station.

    "I got there to find the whole thing intact, not even cash gone. We never found out who handed it in - but it was refreshing to know there are still honest people in the world."

    Fans demand cheaper tickets 12:10: Liverpool Echo

    Merseyside football fans' groups joined forces to urge the city's Premier League clubs to slash the cost of tickets for away supporters at this season's Anfield and Goodison derbies.

    News on the hour 12:00: Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    A former police sergeant has been accused of being "welded" to his account of seeing large numbers of football fans drinking and carrying alcohol before the Hillsborough disaster.

    The jury at the Hillsborough Inquests in Warrington has heard Philip Lomas claim he had never seen so much drinking ahead of a match.

    Listen to our live bulletin.

    Coming up 11:54: Roger Phillips BBC Radio Merseyside

    On today's show we'll be discussing the scandal in Rotherham, where South Yorkshire's Police and Crime Commissioner Shaun Wright is being urged to resign following a damning report on the sexual abuse of children by criminal gangs in the town.

    Each one of those children were horribly abused. How were their lives affected? We'll hear from one of them - who's 24 now and uses the name Emma - who was targeted at the age of 12.

    Later, Merseytravel chairman Liam Robinson will be talking about plans for a new train station in Liverpool. Listen to the show from 12:00.

    Cup draw tonight 11:48: BBC Sport

    The draw for the 3rd round of the Capital One Cup takes place tonight after Bradford vs Leeds. Everton are 10, Liverpool 13.

    Tunnel closed 11:37: BBC Radio Merseyside

    Motorists heading from Liverpool to Wirral should beware the Birkenhead tunnel is closed due to an accident. Police are assessing damage caused by a truck. Stay updated with BBC Travel.

    Table tennis club fears 11:24: Leanne Harper Reporter, BBC Radio Merseyside

    I've been meeting members of a Wirral over-50s table tennis club, who are worried about their future due to the redevelopment of West Kirby Concourse leisure centre.

    Tennis club members in West Kirby

    The 75-strong group has been meeting at the Concourse for 30 years, but fear the multi-million pound project could mean they have to find a new home.

    However, Wirral Council has said they will not be forced to move.

    New city rail station planned 11:12: Tom Airey BBC News

    A new Liverpool city centre railway station is to be considered by the area's transport authority.

    Mersey train

    Merseytravel has revealed its plans for the rail network over the next 30 years, which includes "investigating the potential" for a new central stop.

    Other moves include new rolling stock, electrifying lines and improving travel times and connections.

    News on the hour 11:00: Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    Merseyside Police are making enquiries after a video of a group of youths pouring a bucket of ice water on a homeless man in Everton was posted online.

    The footage has now been removed and officers are looking into the incident, despite no official complaint being made

    Listen to our live bulletin.

    Eto'o unveiled 10:57: James Mountford BBC Radio Merseyside

    I've been at Finch Farm this morning as new Everton signing Samuel Eto'o is officially unveiled.

    Speaking to journalists during his first press conference, the striker said he is looking forward to joining his new teammates for training.

    He also thanked former boss Jose Mourinho for giving him an "fantastic opportunity" in the Premier League.

    Robrto Martinez and Samuel Eto'o

    The 33-year-old striker could make his debut at Goodison Park on Saturday - against former club Chelsea.

    Recycling banks axed 10:35: Southport Visiter

    Sefton Council will reduce the number of recycling banks across the borough but will not be reducing the amount it pays the contractors.

    On air 10:28: Sean Styles BBC Radio Merseyside

    The Florence Institute for Boys in Liverpool - or the Florrie as it's known - is 125 years old today.

    The Florence Institute for Boys

    The Florrie is thought to be the oldest surviving purpose-built boys club in the UK. And to find out more, I'll be speaking to heritage consultant Steph Blundell.

    We'll also be hearing about the young entrepreneurs entering Wirral Youth Enterprise competition. Listen to BBC Radio Merseyside.

    Watch Eto'o press conference 10:12:

    New Everton signing Samuel Eto'o will be answering questions during a press conference, scheduled to begin at 10:00.

    Samuel Eto'o

    You can watch the session live on the club's official website.

    News on the hour 10:00: Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    A second teenager has now been charged over an alleged attack on a young man and woman in Liverpool city centre over Bank Holiday weekend.

    The pair were threatened with a glass bottle on Dale Street early on Saturday, and forced to get money out of a cash machine before the woman was indecently assaulted.

    Listen to our live bulletin.

    Mario to make debut 09:53:

    Liverpool manager Brendan Rodgers expects to be able to play new signing Mario Balotelli in Sunday's clash with Tottenham Hotspur.

    Mario Balotelli

    The Italian striker missed the match with former club Manchester City, but could make his debut at White Hart Lane this weekend.

    Rodgers told Liverpool's official website: "We've done some analysis on him. The medical and sports science team have worked with him already and he's in very, very good condition. He's in to work and he'll be available for the squad for the weekend."

    Youths film ice bucket 'assault' 09:41: Liverpool Echo

    A gang of youths posted a video of themselves chasing a homeless wheelchair user and pouring a bucket of ice water over his head.

    Second teen charged over attack 09:28:

    A second teenager has now been charged after a couple were attacked in Liverpool over the weekend., say Merseyside Police.

    A man, 23, and woman, 20, were attacked on Saturday night as they left Mersey Kebab shop on Dale Street. The female victim was sexually assaulted.

    A 17-year-old, from Litherland, is charged with two counts of robbery, one count of attempted rape and one assault. He will appear before Liverpool and Knowsley Youth Court this morning.

    A 16-year-old boy has been charged with attempted rape, wounding and robbery.

    Allen 'a target' for Man United 09:18:

    Stung after last night's shock 4-0 defeat to cup minnows MK Dons, Manchester United boss Louis van Gaal is weighing up a £20m move for Liverpool midfielder Joe Allen, 24, the BBC Sport gossip column reports.

    Joe Allen
    Sheep in road 09:12: Via Twitter

    Cheshire Police tweet: Reports of sheep in the road on A533, Runcorn Road, Little Leigh. Patrols en route. Approach area with caution. #traffic #sheep

    Top headlines
    News on the hour 09:00: Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    A new train station in Liverpool city centre is one of a number of proposals set out by Merseytravel in a major 30-year plan.

    New stations are being considered near the Baltic Triangle area of Liverpool, and in Maghull.

    Listen to our live bulletin.

    PC 'instructed' on Hillsborough statement 08:56:

    A police sergeant working on the day of the Hillsborough disaster was told what to put in and leave out of his statement by a senior officer, an inquest into the deaths heard.

    The Hillsborough disaster

    Philip Colin Lomas said the instructions were given because of "blame" towards South Yorkshire Police.

    Assistant Chief Constable Stuart Anderson was said to have told officers not to blame themselves for the disaster because it was the fault of 'drunk, ticketless fans'.

    Are we less honest? 08:47: Tony Snell BBC Radio Merseyside

    Good morning. I've been hearing how, according to new research, more of us are comfortable with smaller perceived "victimless" crimes - like downloading music, TV programmes and films, stealing from supermarkets or hitting parked cars and driving off.


    Have we lost our way when it comes to being honest, even if it does seem like the small things?

    Let us know your thoughts on Facebook.

    Teens held over attack 08:40:

    A second teenager has been arrested following an attack on a couple in Liverpool.

    Mersey Kebab on Dale Street

    A man, 23, and woman, 20, were attacked on Saturday night as they left Mersey Kebab shop on Dale Street. The female victim was sexually assaulted.

    On Tuesday, a 16-year-old boy was charged with attempted rape, wounding and robbery.

    A 17-year-old boy was later arrested and remains in police custody.

    Rail expansion plan unveiled 08:32: Liverpool Echo
    Sam's a Blue 08:24:

    New Everton signing Samuel Eto'o is set to be formally unveiled as a Toffees player later today.

    Samuel Eto'o

    The Cameroon international, 33, has joined on a free transfer and links up with fellow former Chelsea team-mate Romelu Lukaku, who signed for £28m this summer.

    He'll be answering questions during a press conference scheduled for this morning.

    Rush hour delays 08:15:

    BBC Travel is reporting delays due to roadworks between Crown Street, Liverpool, and West Derby Street.

    Roadworks in Sefton are also causing congestion along Dunnings Bridge Road, northbound from the Copy Lane junction to Switch Island.

    Warm, sunny spells 08:06:

    After a rather chilly start, it will be a mostly dry and bright day with warm, sunny spells. Towards the evening however, cloud will start to thicken in the south with winds strengthening.

    BBC weather

    There should be a dry end to the day, with top temperatures this afternoon of 19C (66F).

    News on the hour 08:02: Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    A second teenager is being questioned about an alleged attack on a young man and woman in Liverpool city centre over the Bank Holiday weekend.

    The pair were threatened with a glass bottle on Dale Street early on Saturday, and forced to get money out of a cash machine before the woman was indecently assaulted. A 16-year-old from Huyton has already been charged.

    Listen to our live bulletin.

    Good morning 08:00: Tom Mullen BBC News Online

    Greetings on this fresh August morning in Liverpool. I'm here with today's news, sport, weather and travel updates. Feel free to send in your comments, pictures or snippets of news by tweeting us, emailing us, or posting on our Facebook page.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.