Hillsborough disaster: Bells rung to mark anniversary

The crowd at Anfield fell silent to mark the moment the match was halted

Bells have been rung 96 times across Merseyside to mark the 25th anniversary of the Hillsborough disaster.

The bells of Liverpool's Anglican Cathedral, Liverpool Town Hall and churches in Merseyside rang at 15:06 BST during a one-minute silence.

It marked the moment Liverpool's FA Cup semi-final at the Sheffield ground was halted on 15 April 1989 after a crush that led to the deaths of 96 fans.

An annual memorial service was held at Anfield stadium.

Seats left empty

Campaigner Margaret Aspinall, chair of the Hillsborough Family Support Group, and other families of victims were clapped as they arrived for the service.

96 seats with scarves draped over them A seat was left empty and draped with a football scarf for each Liverpool fan who died

Fans, players and club officials also gathered in the ground. Ninety-six seats, which were draped in scarves, were left empty.

The service began with the singing of the hymn, Abide With Me, which is synonymous with the FA Cup and has been sung at every final since 1927. It was also recorded as part of a charity single in memory of the victims in 1989.

A ring of lights called the Band of Life, with each light inscribed with the name of a victim, was lit as the names of those who died were read out by the Reverend Kelvin Bolton, the Reverend David Smith and Father Stephen Maloney.

The Band of Life As each name was read out, a light was lit on the Band of Life sculpture

A minute's silence followed, which Rev Bolton ended with the words "a time never to forget".

Taking the first reading, Everton manager Roberto Martinez said he was was only 15 when the disaster happened and that "as a family, we couldn't believe the pain and horror".

He said he was there representing his club, adding that "Everton remembers - we always will".

The service was also screened at Everton's ground, Goodison Park, for fans to pay their respects.

Roberto Martinez, Steven Gerrard, Daniel Agger, Luis Suarez, Daniel Sturridge, Kenny Dalglish, Ian Rush and others Everton manager Roberto Martinez (top left) sat among Liverpool players past and present

Martinez was followed by Liverpool manager Brendan Rodgers, who said that while "you don't struggle for inspiration [at] this great football club, the single biggest source for me is when I arrive each match day and see the Hillsborough memorial".

Speaking to the families of the victims, Rodgers said they had "all stood for 25 years together [and] the love for the people you lost inspires me every day as manager".

"I really do feel inadequate in your company. You will never walk alone."

Standing ovations

Many aspects of today's service felt the same as the service did five years ago for the 20th anniversary.

The 96 names were recited then, as now. The Kop was full then, as it was today.

But in every other sense, today's service was different.

When Andy Burnham spoke in 2009, he was heckled by a lone cry of "Justice for the 96", which spread throughout the Kop.

This year when he spoke, it was to a very different reception - applause filled the stadium.

With new inquests under way, the justice process is ongoing.

This year's commemorations were tinged with a feeling of hope and optimism for the future.

Leigh MP Andy Burnham, who had been booed at a Hillsborough memorial service in 2009 while delivering a speech as Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport, thanked the families of the victims.

In a speech which saw several standing ovations for the people he mentioned, including campaigner Anne Williams who died shortly after the memorial service last April, he said he had asked his mother what he should speak about.

He said she "told me to wish you all the best for the league and to say how fitting it would be if you won it in this of all years".

He also praised former Liverpool manager Kenny Dalglish for his work with the families over the last 25 years, adding, "what leadership, what loyalty he has shown on your behalf".

Trevor Hicks, the president of the Hillsborough Family Support Group, said the 25 years since the disaster had been "a very long road".

'Spirit of 96'

Mr Hicks, who lost two daughters at Hillsborough, thanked Liverpool Football Club for their support and the Hillsborough Independent Panel.

Trevor Hicks, father: "The families of the 96 - we did it... we made it all happen"

"The spirit of the 96 burns in our hearts and drives us on," he said.

He also paid tribute to the families of the victims, who he said had "made it all happen".

"We stood together. We pulled, we pushed, we refused to lie down, we refused to go away, which is something that annoyed an awful lot of people."

His words were echoed by Mrs Aspinall, whose son died at the Sheffield stadium.

She said the families had been "fighting for 25 years".

"No matter how much dirt they tried to throw at us, Liverpudlians, Scousers, we don't lie down and take it."

Their speeches were followed by a rendition of You'll Never Walk Alone, led by the singer Gerry Marsden, during which 96 balloons were released.

The service ended with the crowd singing You'll Never Walk Alone

In Sheffield, the city's cathedral held a two-minute silence at 15:07 BST.

At the Hillsborough ground, a short service and a wreath-laying ceremony also took place at the memorial garden and the stadium was opened to allow people to lay flowers and remember those who died at the match against Nottingham Forest.

A minute's silence was observed at Old Market Square in Nottingham for the victims.

Hillsborough memorial service A memorial service was held at the monument at Hillsborough

Scarves from every club in the top four divisions were laid on the pitch to create a number 96 at Anfield as a "sign of unity" for the service, a spokesman for Liverpool said.

Liverpool mayor Joe Anderson said the city "will never forget those who died at Hillsborough, and this is a day for us to unite and remember each and every supporter and the friends and families left behind".

Who were the 96 victims?

Eight of the Hillsborough victims, CW from top left: Paul Clark, Stephen Copoc, Tracey Cox, Jon-Paul Gilhooley, Steven Fox, Vincent Fitzsimmons, Christopher Edwards

Tuesday's events follow a weekend of tributes to the 96 fans, which saw wreaths left at Anfield's and Hillsborough's memorials to those who died and football matches in leagues across England kick-off seven minutes late.

The commemorations come as fresh inquests into the deaths of the fans are held in Warrington. The inquests have been adjourned until 22 April.

They were ordered after the original accidental death inquest verdicts were quashed in 2012 following an independent report.

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Liverpool



18 °C 15 °C

BBC Local Live

    Coming up on North West Today 13:19: BBC North West Today

    The headlines this Friday lunchtime include concerns for the welfare of severely disabled adults in Salford as spending cuts hit specialist transport services.

    And protesters are planning to picket the site of a news lap dancing club in Liverpool's gay quarter ahead of the Liverpool Pride festival this weekend.

    The council's given it the go-ahead but opponents fear it could increase anti-social behaviour and hate crime in the area.

    Watch more on BBC One at 13:30.

    Whistleblower treatment 'often shocking' 13:08:

    The treatment of employees in public services who have raised concerns about wrongdoing has often been "shocking", a group of MPs has said.

    The Hillsborough disaster

    The Commons Public Accounts Committee said whistleblowers had often been subjected to bullying and harassment.

    Its report called for whistleblowers to be offered legal and counselling help and for "swift sanctions" to be imposed on staff who victimised them.

    The "important" role whistleblowers had played in uncovering details about the Hillsborough disaster (pictured) and the Mid Staffordshire NHS trust scandal was highlighted.

    News on the hour 12:58: Alex Dibble BBC Radio Merseyside

    Our main headline at 13:00 is a new crackdown on hate crime's been unveiled by Merseyside's Police and Crime Commissioner Jane Kennedy.

    The launch of the Hate Crime Strategy's kick-starting two weeks of action aimed at raising awareness of the problem, ways of tackling it and promoting the support available to victims.

    Jane Kennedy says attacks are often completely unprovoked.

    Local stories from WW1 12:51:

    BBC North West Tonight tweets: Discover more local stories from a global conflict - #WW1AtHome

    BBC promo
    Appeal for mourners after man's death 12:44: BBC Radio Merseyside

    A St. Helens man - who died last week - could have no friends or family at his funeral.

    The council are desperately trying to get in touch with Darryl Rumbold's relatives, or people who knew him, before next Thursday.

    The 34-year-old died at Parr Nursing home, but has no-one close to him in the town. It's thought he may have relatives in Surrey.

    Merseyside boxers' bouts 12:33: James Mountford BBC Radio Merseyside Sport

    In the Commonwealth Games in Glasgow this afternoon 25-year-old Sam Maxwell (pictured) meets Scotland's Josh Taylor in the light welterweights at 14:08. Maxwell defeated Olympic champion Manoj Kumar in the quarter-finals.

    Sam Maxwell

    Also in action is Anthony Fowler. He fights Benny Muziyo of Zambia at 21:20. Fowler got a call off Carl Froch following his quarter-final win, a bout Fowler compared to a "sparring session".

    Fight against dog-free beach 12:28: Wirral Globe
    Your selfie mates 12:22: via Facebook

    Sean Styles asked you to send pictures with your best friends and you didn't let him down.

    Mike Boardman says: Wedding selfie.

    FB Radio Merseyside

    Niecey Pendlebury says My sisters are my best friends. We are so alike in our ways yet all very different. Love them with all my heart. (But Zoë has never forgiven me for ripping her Phillip Schooled poster!!) x

    FB Radio Merseyside
    Disabled hate crime plea 12:17:

    Merseyside Police and Crime Commissioner Jane Kennedy tweets: 90% of people with a disability experience #hate in their lives yet only 4% of reported #hatecrime relate to disability @stophateuk

    Traffic chaos after accident 12:12: Southport Visiter
    Mayor's Gaza vigil pleas 12:07:

    The Mayor of Liverpool Joe Anderson (pictured) is calling on people to attend a peace vigil at St George's Plateau at 11:00 on Sunday.

    Joe Anderson

    It will be addressed by faith and community leaders and will urge an end to the bloodshed.

    "However small an act this might be, it is a big message from Liverpool in calling for an end to this war," he said.

    Anti-social behaviour campaign 12:00:

    Special constables in Knowsley have been working to prevent anti-social behaviour.

    Knowsley specials

    Operation Cherub has 45 special constables embedded with local neighbourhood policing teams in districts that had problems with anti-social behaviour.

    "We have found this operation has made a real difference to the level of anti-social behaviour in the area," said Insp Tami Garvey-Jones.

    News on the hour 11:55: Alex Dibble BBC Radio Merseyside

    Our main headline at 12:00 is the unveiling of a new hate crime strategy on Merseyside which includes round-the-clock support for victims.

    It will kick start a fortnight of events raising awareness, which include the anniversaries of the deaths of Anthony Walker and Michael Causer, both victims of hate crime

    Lukaku's German debut 11:45: James Mountford BBC Radio Merseyside Sport

    Everton's record signing Romelu Lukaku (pictured) will make his debut in the friendly against SC Paderborn in Germany.

    Chelsea forward Romelu Lukaku

    The striker be presented to the fans at Leon Osman's testimonial against Porto on Sunday.

    Seventy-eight attacks on prison staff 11:38: Liverpool Echo
    Coming up 11:34: Roger Phillips BBC Radio Merseyside

    We're talking the single room supplement today as at least two of our local councils have had to find hundreds of thousands of pounds of extra cash to help people affected by changes to housing benefit.

    Local authorities were given a pot of government money from which to make "discretionary housing payments".

    Knowsley and Liverpool have had to top this up from other funds because of high demand.

    Also we will hear why Norman Baker, the minister in charge of regulating animal experiments in the UK says wants to see an end to all testing.

    Listen from 12:00.

    Liverpool bid for games 11:28:

    Liverpool would be a "superb location" for the 2026 Commonwealth Games Ukip North West MEP Paul Nuttall has said.

    Commonealth Games 2014 opening ceremony

    He added: "No city in the country has such fantastic sporting credentials and it is also in an easy to reach location not just from within the UK but all over the world."

    Mr Nuttall said he is writing to Liverpool Mayor Joe Anderson to enlist his support.

    He said this year's Glasgow games (pictured) had brought in £52m for the Scottish economy.

    Arrest in Norris Green 11:22:

    A man has been arrested after reports that a man had a gun in Norris Green on Thursday.

    Merseyside Police said the 25-year-old was searched and found to have an imitation gun hidden in his trousers.

    He has been arrested on suspicion of possessing an imitation firearm.

    Peace campaigner praise for McGuinness 11:15: Warrington Guardian
    Best friends? 11:11: Sean Styles BBC Radio Merseyside

    Here's mine and Hattie's selfie for Friendship Day this weekend. Tell us about your best mates and share any photos of your mates on Facebook.

    Sean and Hattie
    Policing with pride 11:06:

    Merseyside Police officers will be taking part in this year's Liverpool Pride parade on Saturday under the banner "Police with Pride".

    Uniformed officers will march alongside members of civilian staff with Police and Crime Commissioner Jane Kennedy and her Deputy Ann O'Byrne.

    It's the fourth year the force has participated and they will be joined by colleagues from from Cheshire, Lancashire and Greater Manchester forces.

    Hate crime crackdown 11:02: Marc Gaier BBC Radio Merseyside

    I'm at the launch of the new 24/7 support service for victims of hate crime which has been started by Merseyside Police and Crime Commissioner Jane Kennedy (pictured).

    Jane Kennedy hate crime
    News on the hour 10:55: Alex Dibble BBC Radio Merseyside

    Our main headline in the 11:00 bulletin is a new crackdown on hate crime's been unveiled by Merseyside's Police and Crime Commissioner.

    The launch of the strategy is kick-starting two weeks of action aimed at raising awareness of the problem, ways of tackling it and promoting support available to victims.

    Merseyside Police and Crime Commissioner Jane Kennedy says attacks are often completely unprovoked.

    Courage of bone cancer boy 10:46: St Helens Star
    Hate crime crackdown 10:42:

    Merseyside's Police and Crime Commissioner Jane Kennedy has started a round-the-clock support service for victims of hate crime.

    Anthony Walker and Michael Causer

    The launch of the Hate Crime Strategy is part of a fortnight of action aimed at raising awareness and finding solutions.

    It marks the anniversaries of the deaths of Anthony Walker (pictured left) and Michael Causer (right).

    Mr Walker was murdered in a racist attack in 2005 while Mr Causer's family say his murder in 2008 was homophobic.

    Give us your views 10:33:

    We've introduced BBC Local Live to bring you the latest news, sport, travel and weather all in one place. Tell us what you think.

    Fara's caps record 10:25:

    England midfielder Fara Williams (pictured) says it will be a "great honour" to win a record-breaking 130th cap in Sunday's friendly against Sweden.

    Fara Williams

    The Liverpool midfielder would become England's most capped player, passing Rachel Yankey's total, if selected at Hartlepool United's Victoria Park.

    Day on the tiles? 10:20:

    The splendid Minton-tiled floor at Liverpool's St George's Hall will be revealed for public viewing on Saturday.

    Minton-tiled floor

    When the priceless mosaic floor, consisting of 30,000 tiles, was uncovered to mark the hall's centenary in 1954, more than 100,000 people queued to see it.

    Lord Mayor Coun Erica Kemp (pictured) is doing her bit to keep it clean.

    Talking friends 10:16: Sean Styles BBC Radio Merseyside

    I'm taking about friends.

    Well, this Sunday is apparently Friendship Day, so this morning I simply want to hear about yours.

    Tell me about your best mates. You can call me on 0151 709 9333 and listen live here.

    Avian botulism kills birds 10:11: Marc Gaier BBC Radio Merseyside

    An outbreak of avian botulism has led to the death of more than 50 birds at Birkenhead Park, the RSPCA has confirmed.

    I'm looking into the story.

    Drug suspect arrested 'walking dog' 10:06: Liverpool Echo
    Murder appeal 20 years on 10:02:

    Merseyside Police tweets: 20th Anniversary Of Death Of Leslie Woodward, the family is urging anyone who has info to come forward. bit.ly/1qP3qG2

    News on the hour 10:00: Alex Dibble BBC Radio Merseyside

    Our main headline in the 10:00 bulletin is BBC Radio Merseyside's been told the £260m regeneration of Anfield is ahead of schedule.

    News of the progress comes as the last house on Lothair Road has been knocked down.

    Anfield regeneration 09:51: Marc Gaier BBC Radio Merseyside

    I've been to Anfield, where people who were a bit cynical about regeneration a few years ago - can see the diggers and building equipment (pictured).

    Anfield demolition

    BBC Radio Merseyside has been told the £260m regeneration is ahead of schedule. The last home in Lothair Road has been knocked down.

    Garden centre uprooted 09:47:

    One of Merseyside's oldest garden centres is to close after more than 80 years.

    Sally Cornellison

    Sally Cornellison (pictured), granddaughter of the founder of Gateacre Garden Centre in south Liverpool said it was "the hardest decision" to make.

    She said it could not compete with big out-of-town centres, which have become destinations in their own right.

    Special Giants programme 09:43: Helen Carter BBC Local Live

    It's hard to believe on this drizzly grey August day that it's just five days since the Giants sailed off from a sunny Liverpool.

    Giant Grandmother

    But you can re-live all the excitement by watching Liverpool's Giant War, a special programme on BBC One next Tuesday at 19:00, presented by Sue Johnston..

    It tells the story of the Liverpool Pals who died in World War One.

    Wolves face Catalan Dragons 09:38: Warrington Guardian
    Braving the rain 09:35:

    Councillor Ann O'Byrne shares the pain of BBC Radio Merseyside's Marc Gaier in Anfield with her tweet: A bit of a technical hitch with the brolly!

    Marc Gaier
    Snap, crackle and heritage 09:32:

    We reported that a historic Liverpool warehouse threatened with demolition has been saved after it was granted Grade II listed status.

    heap mill

    But we did not know about Heap's Rice Mill (pictured), on Beckwith Street, was the warehouse that fed countless breakfasts for the nation's children.

    Peter Brown, chairman of Merseyside Civic Society told the BBC that it was also the warehouse which stored the rice for the popular cereal Rice Krispies. He said it has "great heritage potential."

    Saints' injury woes 09:23:

    St. Helens will be without two players for tonight's away match at Hull FC in the rugby league Super League.

    Jon Wilkin

    The league leaders are without scrum-half Luke Walsh for the rest of the season after he broke his fibula in last week's win over Widnes.

    Second-rower Jon Wilkin (pictured) is out with a shoulder injury and there is no date set for his return.

    More mind bending lyrics 09:06: via Facebook

    Paul Salt has been asking for your baffling song lyrics.

    Fran Stellman says: And if you want some fun, say OBLA-DI BLA DA!!!!

    Debbie Thompson says: Happy Mondays step on, 'your twisting my melon man' eh? Marvellous song though even if it does have daft lyrics.

    Paul Roberts says: dean friedman's 1978 hit, Lucky Star has a really naf lyric in it, which goes "listen hun, I know you're dumb, but that's OK, you don't have to look so glum". also Change of Heart by change "I Have Opened Up My Eyes, Now I can see clearly".

    top headlines
    news on the hour 08:55: Alex Dibble BBC Radio Merseyside

    Our main headline in the 09:00 bulletin is BBC Radio Merseyside's been told the £260m regeneration of Anfield is ahead of schedule.

    News of the progress comes as the last house on Lothair Road has been knocked down.

    Lorry queue cleared 08:51:

    BBC Travel News says the disruption has cleared which was caused by a broken down lorry on Edge Lane Drive inbound in Old Swan at the Mill Lane junction.

    Liverpool lap dance club protest 08:41:

    Campaigners against a new lap dancing club in the middle of Liverpool's gay quarter are staging a protest later.

    Stanley Street

    Paradise has already been told it can open on Stanley Street, but there are fears the among the lesbian and gay community it could lead to hate crime in the area.

    Coun Steve Radford said the council's hands are tied because of licensing regulations, but it will take action if there's trouble.

    Baffling song lyrics 08:30: Paul Salt BBC Radio Merseyside

    "I am the egg man they are the egg men... I am the walrus" - yes we're talking odd lyrics as the Beatles have been pipped to the number one slot in a poll by The Killers (pictured) with: "Are we human or are we dancer?"

    The Killers

    So what lyrics have left you scratching your head over the years? Get in touch via Facebook and listen live to BBC Radio Merseyside.

    Lukaku: I'm a better player 08:24:

    Everton's new £28m signing Romelu Lukaku (pictured) believes signing for the club will make him a world-class player.

    Romelu Lukaku

    The club's record-breaking signing from Chelsea said his loan spell at Goodison Park last season has already improved his game. Belgium's World Cup striker said he's a better player with his "back to goal".

    Anfield revamp on course 08:17:

    Liverpool City Council says the regeneration of Anfield (pictured) is running ahead of schedule.

    Anfield generic

    The news comes as as the last house on Lothair Street has been knocked down.

    A £260m plan was approved in April to end nearly a decade of stalled regeneration.

    Broken down lorry queues 08:12:

    BBC Travel News says there's queuing traffic on Edge Lane Drive inbound in Old Swan at the Mill Lane junction, because of a broken down lorry and recovery work.

    News on the hour 08:09: Alex Dibble BBC Radio Merseyside

    Our main headline at 08:00 included at least two of our local councils have had to find hundreds of thousands of pounds of extra cash to help people affected by changes to housing benefit.

    Morning showers 08:07:

    BBC Weather reports showers or rain will soon spread from the west this morning, heavy at times.

    Weather forecast

    The rain should start to ease and clear later this afternoon, with a fine evening for most parts.

    Good morning 08:00: Paul Burnell BBC News

    Hello everyone, I'm here with all your news, weather, travel and sports updates throughout the day.

    If you have any pictures or comments you'd like to share post a message on Facebook, tweet @bbcmerseyside or email merseyside.locallive@bbc.co.uk.

    I look forward to hearing from you.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.