Hillsborough inquests: Disaster 'ripped pages from life'

Clockwise from top left: David Birtle, Nicholas Hewitt, Alan McGlone, Andrew Brookes, Paul Brady, Joseph Clark, Stuart Thompson, Andrew Sefton, Carl Hewitt The court heard from the relatives of nine of the victims of the disaster

The Hillsborough disaster "ripped out the pages" of a 23-year-old man's life, his sister has told his inquest.

Andrew Sefton was one of 96 fans who died after a crush at the ground during Liverpool's FA Cup semi-final match against Nottingham Forest in 1989.

Julie Fallon said her family "no longer have an inkling what life without Hillsborough looks like".

Statements from the relatives of all 96 victims are being heard at their inquests in Warrington.

Ms Fallon said the Skelmersdale security officer's life had been "like a book".

"There's a title, an introduction, a description of the characters - then someone ripped out the rest of the pages.

"Hillsborough made an incompleteness which continues to be, for my family, the central, longest and most overriding topic of the last 25 years and of our lives.

"We no longer have an inkling what life without Hillsborough looks like and ironically neither does my brother."

Police 'turned their backs'

Louise Brookes, from Bromsgrove in Worcestershire, told the court about her brother Andrew, who was "the apple of my mum's eye" and who had never been in trouble with the police.

"My mum said 'the only time Andrew ever brought the police was when they brought his clothes home in a plastic bag [after his death].

Start Quote

As a family we are owed an explanation sooner rather than later of how and why David died that day”

End Quote Jennifer Birtle Mother of Hillsborough victim David Birtle

"Andrew was brought up to respect the police. When he needed them most, they literally turned their backs on him."

She said after his death "the whole dynamics" of the family changed. Her mother later died of cancer, then "Dad just shut himself away", she said.

"I didn't just lose my brother on 15 April 1989, I lost my parents too. The whole Brookes family died that day."

Earlier, Stephen Clark delivered his mother Jacqueline Gilchrist's tribute to his father, Joseph Clark.

He told the hearing she said life had "never been the same since he died that horrible day".

"Our lives changed and I never really got on with my life. I am still the same to this day," she said in her statement.

Who were the 96 victims?

Eight of the Hillsborough victims, CW from top left: Paul Clark, Stephen Copoc, Tracey Cox, Jon-Paul Gilhooley, Steven Fox, Vincent Fitzsimmons, Christopher Edwards

Mr Clark was one of several relatives who was moved to tears while reading what the families have called "pen portraits".

Amy McGlone also cried as she read her mother Irene's words about her father, Alan McGlone, a Liverpool machine repairer she said had "loved being a dad".

In her statement, Mrs McGlone said her husband had played with his daughters on the street before going to Hillsborough and that the family had been due to go to a party when he returned.

Instead, she said she put her daughters to bed and Amy asked "Mummy, will you tell Daddy to come in and wake us up when he gets home?"

"I am still waiting to wake my girls up out of this nightmare and send their daddy into them," she said.

'World at his feet'

Michael Brady spoke about his brother Paul, a 21-year-old refrigeration engineer from Liverpool who had a "very bubbly and outgoing personality".

He said his brother had been "a people person", who excelled at working with his hands and had loved football, fishing and his job.

"He was fun-loving, the joker in our family, always smiling and a joy to be around," he said.

A statement was read from the recently-deceased father of Stuart Thompson, before his sibling Martin spoke of his "brother and friend" who had "the world at his feet at the time of his death" and was "determined to be a success".

He said that when he died, the 17-year-old "wasn't a child but he wasn't yet an adult. He didn't have time to blossom."

The Leppings Lane End at Hillsborough during the 1989 FA Cup semi-final Teenage brothers Carl and Nicholas Hewitt travelled with a supporters' club to Hillsborough

Speaking about her son David, Jennifer Birtle said he liked music and had been to the Glastonbury festival, but that "once David could run, there was always a football attached to his foot".

"David became an ardent fan of Liverpool Football Club. Sadly that decision was to cost him his life," she said.

Mrs Birtle, who was in Oman when she heard about the disaster.

She said she had "had to listen to two ex-pats reading the paper and saying 'oh, the police say it was hooligans' as if that was OK then, that it was their fault".

She added that her family was "owed an explanation sooner rather than later of how and why David died that day".

The final statement of the day came from the mother of Carl and Nicholas Hewitt, brothers from Leicester who had travelled to Hillsborough on a supporters' club bus.

Brenda Hewitt said her "boys" were "always together [and] together always", who "loved football and were season ticket holders".

The inquests, set to last a year, were ordered after new evidence revealed by the Hillsborough Independent Panel led to the original inquest verdicts being quashed.

The background statements are the first time the court has heard how the disaster affected individual families.

The inquest has been adjourned until Thursday.

More on This Story

Hillsborough Inquests

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Liverpool



17 °C 12 °C

BBC Local Live

    Red Squirrels make comeback 15:47:

    It's Red Squirrel week and the animals - which live on the Sefton coast - are being celebrated by the Wildlife Trust.

    Red Squirrel

    The squirrels were nearly wiped out by a pox in 2008, but the trust said they are now back up to 80% of the levels they were before the virus hit.

    The gorgeous animals can be seen in the National Trust pine forests in Formby.

    Guide dog owners' shark dive 15:42: Julia Bryson BBC Local Live

    Two guide dog owners are set to dive with sharks at a Cheshire aquarium next week.

    Lynette Proctor

    Kerry Singleton from Warrington and Lynette Proctor (pictured) from Wirral are visually impaired and are taking on the shark challenge to raise awareness and funds for Guide Dogs.

    Police investigate van incident 15:22: BBC Radio Merseyside

    tweets: Investigation launched by @MerseyPolice in #Wallasey after two young girls approached by man driving a white van in separate incidents.

    Hodgson plays down rift 15:11: BBC Sport

    England manager Roy Hodgson has played down talk of a rift with Liverpool over injured striker Daniel Sturridge.

    Roy Hodgson

    Sturridge, 25, is not in Hodgson's latest squad after suffering a thigh strain on England duty last month.

    News on the hour 14:58: Alex Dibble BBC Radio Merseyside

    The new Hillsborough inquests have heard the suggestion that Liverpool fans forced their way into the stadium before the disaster was a "wicked lie".

    Supt Roger Marshall has been giving evidence for a third day.

    Listen to the live bulletin at 15:00.

    Witches on air 14:54: Claire Minter BBC Radio Merseyside

    BOS Musical Theatre Company (formerly Birkdale Orpheus Society) perform The Witches of Eastwick from this Saturday - join Billy this afternoon to hear more!

    Peaky Blinders returns 14:45: Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    The BBC Two drama Peaky Blinders, part filmed in Liverpool, is back on our screens tonight.

    Peaky Blinders

    Based on real life gangsters operating in Birmingham in the late 19th and early 20th centuries the award winning series has been partly shot at the Black Country Museum.

    The series picks up in 1922 as gang leader Tommy Shelby, played by Cillian Murphy, is expanding his illegal betting empire. Watch a teaser trail online now.


    Cheshire Police tweets: Yesterday Cheshire and Merseyside officers worked together in #OpCrossbow, for more info watch the video how.ly/CcfcD

    Operation Crossbow
    Everton protest 14:23: Lynette Horsburgh BBC News

    Around 100 people held a protest last night against plans for Everton to use part of Walton Hall Park for a new stadium.

    Residents got the chance to see the proposals which include up to 1,000 new homes alongside shops and leisure centres.

    Ace university! 14:07: BBC North West Tonight

    Jayne McCubbin tweets: "@livuninews: Up 12 places in the @timeshighered World University Rankings /news.liv.ac.uk/2014/10/02/liv … " ace uni!

    Liverpool University
    news on the hour 13:58: Alex Dibble BBC Radio Merseyside

    A senior officer on duty at Hillsborough has told the new inquests the suggestion that Liverpool fans forced open a gate - was a "wicked lie".

    Supt Roger Marshall's giving evidence for a third day.

    Listen live at 14:00.

    Slow in Kirkdale 13:43:

    BBC Travel reports slow traffic on Kirkdale Road inbound in Kirkdale at the Great Homer Street junction.

    Man 'tried to grab' girls 13:37:

    Merseyside Police is appealing for information following two separate incidents involving young girls and a man in a white van who tried to grab them.

    On Tuesday, a 12-year-old girl was walking along Breck Road in Wallasey at 15:40 when a white van pulled up by her. A man got out, approached her, and spoke in a foreign language.

    The man then tried to grab the girl's jacket but she ran away and told her parents, who later called police.

    The following day, a 10-year-old girl was walking along Poulton Road at 16:00 when a white van stopped. A man got out, walked towards her, and tried to grab her jacket, but she ran away.

    Man sold illegal fireworks 13:31: Liverpool Echo
    Coming up 13:24: Annabel Tiffin Presenter, North West Tonight

    On North West Today, we have the latest from the Hillsborough inquests.

    We have the story of he protest against Everton Football Club's plans to build a new stadium on part of Walton Hall Park.

    Also, a disappointing defeat for the Reds in Switzerland against Basel in the Champions League.

    Watch more on BBC One at 13:30.

    Hillsborough latest 13:17: Ben Schofield BBC Radio Merseyside

    Former Supt Roger Marshall, giving evidence for a third day at the Hillsborough inquests, was accused of refusing to criticise officers in the police control box for fear of being disloyal.

    He said: "I really don't wish to criticise my colleagues. My colleagues - we were under enormous pressure at that time."

    "I can't speak for what was going on in their minds. I can't speak for whatever discussions took place in the control room."

    Collymore driving ban 13:08: Warrington Guardian

    Former Liverpool striker and football pundit Stan Collymore has escaped a driving ban despite clocking up 12 points for speeding - after successfully pleading a case of exceptional hardship.

    news on the hour 12:59: Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    Liverpool council's taking on cold callers who target vulnerable people in their own homes across the city.

    After some reported being ripped by by as much as £400 by people turning up at their door, the authority's acted by setting up a No Cold Calling Zone to cover about 55 homes in Stanley Gardens at Orrell Park.

    Listen live at 13:00.

    Cold calls no go zone 12:47: Jessica Robbins BBC Radio Merseyside

    Cold callers are the target of an exclusion zone in Stanley Gardens at Orrell Park after residents complained they felt intimidated in their own homes and been conned out of up to £400.

    Orrell Park residents with councillor Ann O'Byrne

    Edna Mansfield was a target and she told me it was hard to make a so-called painter who kept knocking on her door go away.

    She said: "I'm 83 and they must have thought I was a soft touch but I'm a game old bird and I just said 'No it doesn't need painting'. "

    Freedom of city for actor 12:39:

    Ricky Tomlinson will receive the Freedom of Liverpool on Monday in recognition for his varied work over the years fighting for justice, entertaining millions on TV and raising money and awareness for charity.

    Ricky Tomlinson
    No cold call campaign 12:34: Jessica Robbins BBC Radio Merseyside

    I'm at the launch of the No Cold Call zone with Ann O'Byrne, who is instrumental in the campaign.

    Cold call launch
    At the traffic centre 12:26: Roger Phillips BBC Radio Merseyside

    After an email from a taxi driver about chaos caused by changes to Liverpool's traffic lights for special events, I've been to the Liverpool Urban Traffic Control Centre.

    Liverpool Urban Traffic Control Centre

    Martin said alterations to traffic light sequences in the city causes delays and can take up to three weeks later before they back to normal.

    Well, to address some of those concerns, I went to Tithebarn Street and met senior engineer Michael Kehoe. He explained how the city's traffic lights are programmed.

    What do you think? 12:13: Lynette Horsburgh BBC News

    What you think of BBC Local Live? We'd like your feedback about this service, which we produce from our base in Liverpool.

    Hillsborough latest 12:07: Ben Schofield BBC Radio Merseyside

    The suggestion Liverpool fans forced open gates ahead of the Hillsborough disaster was a "wicked lie", the inquests have heard.

    Former Supt Roger Marshall agreed that the lie, told by his commander David Duckenfield, was wicked. He said the first time he heard about it was at the public inquiry overseen by Lord Justice Taylor - and that he was "surprised and not a little shocked" by it.

    Mr Marshall, who's giving evidence for a third day, has said the idea he and Mr Duckenfield colluded to cover up what happened was "utter rubbish".

    news on the hour 11:59: Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    Cold callers are the target of an exclusion zone in Liverpool after residents complaints they were feeling intimidated in their own homes.

    The no go area covers about 55 homes in Stanley Gardens at Orrell Park. Some people have been reporting frauds of up to £400.

    Listen live to the 12:00 bulletin.

    Tribute to Lynsey de Paul 11:48: Sean Styles BBC Radio Merseyside

    It is such sad news about the death of singer and songwriter Lynsey de Paul who has died at the age of 64 of a suspected brain haemorrhage.

    Lynsey De Paul

    I remember her as a judge on New Faces and she was a lovely lady.

    Pay your tributes to her by emailing, or sending your thoughts on Facebook or Twitter.

    sturridge 'five-year deal' 11:43: Liverpool Echo

    Liverpool FC are in advanced talks with the representatives of Daniel Sturridge over a new five-year contract.

    Daniel Sturridge
    Conker champions 11:31: Sean Styles BBC Radio Merseyside

    The Reader Organisation is hosting the north west conker championship this weekend. They popped in for a chat and I had a go myself.

    Sean Styles
    Walmsley back for Saints 11:24:

    St. Helens have prop Alex Walmsley back from suspension and he returns in place of Matty Dawson in the squad.

    Alex Walmsley
    Thousands caught drink-driving 11:13:

    Thousands of under-18s have been caught drink-driving, police records show.


    Records released by 43 UK police forces in response to a Freedom of Information request show 6,558 people aged under 18 were caught driving under the influence of alcohol between 2008 and 2013.

    The total number of under-age drink-driver incidents has fallen slightly year-on-year - Merseyside and Devon and Cornwall saw the greatest fall between 2012 and 2013.

    Kate Moss helps Liverpool unit 11:07:

    Supermodel Kate Moss has modelled a new range of lingerie designed by Stella McCartney to raise funds for a new mammography unit in Liverpool.

    Kate Moss

    Proceeds from the underwear range will go towards a new breast screening suite in the Linda McCartney Centre at the Royal Liverpool University Hospital.

    news on the hour 10:59: Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    Liverpool council's taking on cold callers who target vulnerable people in their own homes across the city.

    After some reported being ripped by by as much as £400 by people turning up at their door, the authority's acted by setting up a No Cold Calling Zone to cover 55 homes in Stanley Gardens at Orrell Park.

    Listen live at 11:00.

    Christmas lights switch-on 10:53: Lynette Horsburgh BBC News

    Sorry to bring up Christmas at the start of October, but St. Helens has secured three major acts for the switch on of its Christmas lights.

    Ian Broudie of the Lightning Seeds

    Liverpool band The Lightning Seeds, Scouting for Girls and The Hummingbirds are among the line-up for the free switch-on event being held on 15 November in Victoria Square, St. Helens.

    Only 12 weeks til Christmas!

    Sturridge 'NOT IN ENGLAND SQUAD' 10:38: BBC Sport

    Liverpool manager Brendan Rodgers does not expect striker Daniel Sturridge to be named in Thursday's England squad to face San Marino and Estonia.

    Daniel Sturridge and Brendan Rodgers
    What a skyline 10:33:

    Life in Liverpool tweets: GOOD MORNING LIVERPOOL #TheBestCityInTheWorld #WhatASkyline

    RT if you ❤️ Liverpool

    skyline Liverpool
    Cheap alcohol 'epidemic' 10:28: Dan Whitworth Newsbeat reporter

    There is an "epidemic" among young people who are drinking cheap alcohol at home before going out, then carrying on and ending up in hospital, according to the UK's top A&E doctor.

    There has been a 58% rise over the last decade in the number of 15 to 29-year-olds being admitted to hospital because of alcohol problems.

    University moves up table 10:22:

    Liverpool University has moved 12 places up in the Times Higher Education (THE) World Rankings for 2014-15.

    University of Liverpool

    Liverpool is now 157th in the top 200 of the global higher education league table.

    Rail disruption 10:13:

    Merseyrail reports there are disruptions to the Chester and Ellesmere Port line due to signalling problems at Bromborough.

    It says train services may be cancelled or delayed by up to 10 minutes until 12:00.

    ON AIR 10:07: Sean Styles BBC Radio Merseyside

    This morning we're talking about emigrating.

    Sunny Liverpool

    A new poll has shown that the thing expats from the UK miss the most is our lovely, changeable, weather. So I want to know you would miss about home?

    Tell me by calling 0151 709 9333 or text 81333 with Mersey before your text or get in touch via email, Facebook or Twitter.

    news on the hour 09:59: Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    Cold callers are the target of an exclusion zone in Liverpool after residents complaints they were feeling intimidated in their own homes.

    The no-go area covers about 55 homes in Stanley Gardens at Orrell Park. Some people have been reporting frauds of up to £400.

    Listen live to the 10:00 bulletin.

    Drunken minority criticised 09:54:

    A senior police officer has told an inquest a "substantial minority" of fans "had too much to drink" ahead of the 1989 Hillsborough disaster.

    CCTV of fans at Hillsborough

    Ninety-six Liverpool fans died as a result of the crush at the FA Cup semi-final in Sheffield.

    The inquests in Warrington heard how an initial crush of fans developed outside the stadium before kick-off.

    Gerrard says Basel wanted it more 09:49: BBC Sport

    Liverpool captain Steven Gerrard questioned his team-mates' desire and determination after their 1-0 Champions League defeat at Basel.

    "They wanted it more, which is very disappointing," he told Sky Sports.

    "We didn't deserve anything. We were too soft all over the pitch and conceding again from a set piece isn't good enough."

    A56 LANE CLOSURE 09:43:

    BBC Travel reports one lane is closed on Hoole Road in Chester at the Doubletree roundabout because of an accident involving a car and a van.

    GP 'at risk' of closure 09:38: Nick Triggle Health correspondent

    Hundreds of GP practices are at risk of closure because of the ageing workforce, doctors' leaders say.

    Doctor writing script

    An analysis by the Royal College of GPs has identified 543 GP practices out of the 8,000 in England it believes could be forced to shut in the next year as they all have more than 90% of their doctors aged over 60 and the average retirement age is 59.

    The issue will be debated at the College's annual conference in Liverpool today.

    Dossier looked at police 09:26: Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    A dossier of online abuse directed at the parents of Madeleine McCann is being looked at by police.

    More than 80 pages of Tweets, Facebook posts and forum messages aimed at Kate and Gerry McCann have been handed in by members of the public.

    It is now seven years since she vanished in Portugal.

    top headlines
    • Cold callers: Ban in Stanley Gardens
    • Everton plans: Protest at meeting
    • Listen: BBC Radio Merseyside
    House prices treble 09:21: Liverpool Echo
    Great to talk to Snelly 09:02:

    Ann O'Bryne tweets: Great to talk to @snellyradio @bbcmerseyside this morning about the launch of our 'No Cold Calling Zone' in Stanley Gardens, Orrell Park

    news on the hour 08:57: Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    Liverpool council's taking on cold callers who target vulnerable people in their own homes across the city.

    After some reported being ripped by by as much as £400 by people turning up at their door, the authority's acted by setting up a No Cold Calling Zone to cover 55 homes in Stanley Gardens at Orrell Park.

    Listen live to the 09:00 bulletin.

    Missing man 'safe' 08:47:

    Cheshire Police emails to say Runcorn man Michael Johnson, reported missing from his home on 1 October has been found safe in South Cheshire,

    Woman attacked with ice skate 08:42: Chester Chronicle
    No cold callers 08:35: Tony Snell BBC Radio Merseyside

    Door-to-door salespeople have been banned from an area of North Liverpool.

    A No Cold Calling Zone has been set up to cover about 55 homes in Orrell Park, after a number of residents ended up paying over the odds for poor and shoddy work.

    So tell us your funny or inventive ways of getting rid of cold callers?


    Liverpool's hopes of making the Champions League knockout stages were dented as they succumbed to a 1-0 Group B defeat at Basel.

    Steven Gerrard
    Military medicine exhibition 08:25: Jessica Robbins BBC Radio Merseyside

    A new exhibition, charting the advances in how injured soldiers are treated, opens in Liverpool today.

    The trenches at the exhibition

    Then and Now displays the changes in military medicine from 1914, through to life on the front line in Afghanistan in 2014.

    Visitors to the city's Medical Institution will be able to walk through a recreation of a World War One trench and see how wounded personnel are now treated in a modern military vehicle.

    Haydock crash 08:20:

    BBC Travel says there's been an accident involving two vehicles on Piele Road in Haydock at the Birch Road junction which is causing congestion.

    Protest about Everton plans 08:16: Lindsey Prosser BBC North West Tonight

    Around 100 people protested against Everton's plans to build a new stadium on part of Walton Hall Park at public meeting last night.

    Everton protest
    Cold and dry 08:10: Sara Blizzard Weather Presenter, BBC

    It will be a cold and mostly sunny start to the day and any mist or fog patches will clear during the morning.

    Weather forecast

    It will become a little cloudier into the afternoon, but it will remain dry throughout. Maximum Temperature: 17C (63F)

    news on the hour 08:00: Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    A senior Liverpool councillor's warning people could get hurt, if something isn't done about the number of bars and clubs on Allerton Road.

    The area south of the city centre has seen more open up in recent years.

    A man was stabbed over the weekend outside one of the late-night venues.

    Listen to the 08:00 bulletin.

    Good morning 08:00: Lynette Horsburgh BBC News

    I'm here to bring you the news, sport, weather and travel from around Merseyside.

    If you'd like to share your pictures and comments, you can email, Facebook or Twitter.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.