Hillsborough inquests: Jury chosen to probe fans' deaths

Angus Crawford at the "unique" court being used for the Hillsborough inquests

A jury has been selected to hear fresh inquests into the deaths of 96 football fans who lost their lives in the 1989 Hillsborough disaster.

The inquests, being held in Warrington, were ordered in December 2012 when the High Court quashed the original accidental death verdicts.

Jenni Hicks, vice-chairwoman of the Hillsborough Family Support Group, said: "It's been a long time coming."

The panel of five men and six women are expected be sworn in on Tuesday.

The inquests, set to last a year, were ordered after new evidence was revealed by the Hillsborough Independent Panel about Liverpool FC's FA Cup semi-final where the men, women and children died.

Fresh inquests into the deaths of victims of the Hillsborough disaster

The coroner asked the potential panel to indicate whether they support Sheffield Wednesday, Liverpool or Nottingham Forest football clubs.

Any potential jurors with links to police or ambulance service were excused by the court.

Members of the jury panel have been asked to consider carefully whether they have any connections to any of the issues that may arise or witnesses who may be called before they are sworn in.

They were given a list of witnesses to see if they knew any of them.


The coroner, a serving Lord Justice of Appeal, a very senior judge, is being assisted by five lawyers, five counsel to the inquest, three solicitors and of course there are lawyers representing all the families of those who died who wish to be represented, the authorities, the police, the emergency services and so on.

When the coroner selects individual jurors they will be told they have to set aside up to a year. They will not be sitting continuously for that period, they will have to take a break, but nevertheless it is a considerable period of time.

Obviously, they will be asked about any particular connections to the tragedy at Hillsborough and they will be checked to make sure that they really can serve this considerable period of time.

The coroner could record a verdict of natural causes; accidental death, unlawful killing; an open verdict; or these days, they often give a narrative verdict, where they set out in some detail what they believe to have happened.

Lord Justice Goldring, a Court of Appeal judge who is acting as coroner, said: "It is absolutely fundamental that you must put out of your minds anything you may have heard or read about Hillsborough.

"Do not do any research into Hillsborough, whether on the internet or in any other way."

"Do not discuss the case with anyone. Do not say anything about the case on Facebook or Twitter or any such site," he added.

All of the Hillsborough disaster victims were Liverpool supporters watching their team play Nottingham Forest at Sheffield Wednesday's ground.

The original inquests in March 1991 recorded verdicts of accidental death, which stood for more than 20 years before they were quashed.

Charlotte Hennessy, who lost her father James Robert Hennessy in the disaster when she was six years old, said: "I'm really, really nervous. It's been a long, long fight.

"Hopefully, this is the beginning of the end."

The inquests are being held in a purpose-built courtroom, the biggest in England and Wales, in an office building in Birchwood Park, in Warrington.

Unseen footage

Lord Justice Goldring will open the hearing with a statement to the court.

Families of the victims will be invited to read out "background statements" - or what they are calling "pen portraits" - of their loved ones.

During proceedings the jurors will make a site visit to the Hillsborough stadium but will be directed not to read the "deeply moving" tributes on the memorial to the tragedy.

The hearing will break for several weeks for lawyers to consider new pathological evidence into how each of the 96 died.

Sue Roberts and Margaret Aspinall from the Hillsborough Family Support Group Sue Roberts and Margaret Aspinall, from the Hillsborough Family Support Group, arrive in Warrington for the inquests

Over the course of the inquests, jurors are expected to hear evidence on themes including stadium safety, emergency planning, crowd management and the response of the emergency services.

The court will also be shown hitherto unseen BBC footage recorded on the day.

Kenny Dalglish, Liverpool's manager at the time of the disaster, said: "We were there, we experienced it, but what about the families, the mothers and the fathers who were watching it on television? What a horrible experience that must have been."

'Difficult time'

Margaret Aspinall, who lost her son James in the disaster, said: "A lot of the families will find out an awful lot of things that they did not know about before, and I think that's going to be a very difficult time for them."

There are two separate inquiries running alongside the inquests.

Operation Resolve, led by former Chief Constable of Durham Jon Stoddart, is a criminal investigation into events leading up to the disaster, as well as the disaster itself.

The Independent Police Complaints Commission is looking into allegations of police misconduct arising from the aftermath of the tragedy.

Hillsborough memorial Accidental death verdicts on the 96 men, women and children who died were quashed in December 2012

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Liverpool



15 °C 12 °C

BBC Local Live

    John, Paul, George or Ringo? 10:52:

    Museum of Liverpool tweets: It's International Beatle Week! Which #Beatle are you? - find out here: ow.ly/Arupk

    Chips delight 10:44: Helen Jones BBC Radio Merseyside

    Damian Davis has been in touch with his favourite "simple pleasure".


    He posted on Facebook: "Bag of chips open at the top walking along the sea front. Wife in hand."

    Pensioners attacked by robber 10:37:

    An elderly couple have been knocked to the ground by a robber who then fled with one of the bags they were carrying.

    Stour Avenue, St Helens

    Police said the pair were walking back from a dance at St Helens village hall, in Stour Avenue, when the attacker pounced and snatched a small brown leather bag.

    Both were knocked to the ground and the man suffered a fractured arm. His wife was uninjured following the robbery, which happened at about 22:30 on Sunday.

    Zico's praise for Phil 10:30:

    News of Reds ace Philippe Coutinho's call-up to the Brazil national team has been greeted with delight by Liverpool fans - and Brazil legend Zico.

    Philippe Coutinho

    Zico told Liverpool's official website: "Coutinho is a very skilled and tactical player.

    "He has already played in a number of countries, which must have been a good learning experience for him as he has achieved a higher level of confidence now at Liverpool."

    Ship's final voyage 10:23: Liverpool Echo

    Historic warship HMS Plymouth on which Argentinian forces surrendered during the Falklands War looked set to be lost to Merseyside forever when it set sail for Turkey this morning.

    Rubbish takeaway 10:15:

    MerPol Allerton tweets: Local Bellevale PCSO visited Mcdonalds employees this morning in the area taking part in a neighbourhood clean up.

    Community clean-up in Bellevale
    Fran-tastic relay win 10:07:

    Southport's Fran Halsall helped her team-mates take the first European 4x100m mixed medley title at the European Swimming Championships in Berlin last night.

    Jemma Lowe, Chris Walker-Hebborn, Fran Halsall and Adam Peaty

    The swimmer joined Chris Walker-Hebborn, Adam Peaty and Jemma Lowe on the podium after they won in record time.

    She also took bronze in her women's 50m butterfly race.

    News on the hour 10:00: Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    The best town criers on the planet are showing off their vocal talents in Chester over the next three days.

    Listen to our live bulletin.

    Simple pleasures 09:54: Helen Jones BBC Radio Merseyside

    A list of the country's top 25 simple pleasures has been released today - and number one was fish and chips by the sea. Lovely.

    Fish and chips

    Let me know your own simple pleasures this morning!

    Visit our Facebook page.

    Criers on the radio 09:47:

    Visit Chester tweets: Annnnddd.. we're back! The Town Criers are live on @bbcmerseyside

    Town criers
    Trains delayed 09:39:

    Merseyrail emails: "Due to signalling problems at Bank Hall the Southport and Hunts Cross line is disrupted."

    Icy what you did there 09:32: Tony Snell BBC Radio Merseyside

    So who should follow Stephen Twigg in the ice bucket challenge? You've been having your say.

    Christopher Cottam posted on Facebook: "You do it to Snelly, see what noise he makes!!"

    Hmmm. I'm not too sure!

    Blues boss snubs Ross rumour 09:25:

    The BBC Sport Gossip Column says Everton manager Roberto Martinez has played down his earlier claim that midfielder Ross Barkley could be out until early 2015 with a knee injury.

    Ross Barkley

    The Blues boss said: "I don't know where this figure of five months came from."

    MP braves ice bucket challenge 09:16:

    Liverpool MP Stephen Twigg has taken on the "ice bucket challenge" which raises awareness for charity.

    MP Stephen Twigg

    The craze sees people douse themselves in ice water before sending out their nominations for who they think should do it next.

    Watch Mr Twigg squirm on our Facebook page.

    Jordan tipped for Trotters loan 09:09:

    Liverpool winger Jordon Ibe, 18, will join Championship side Bolton on loan after being squeezed out at Anfield following the summer arrivals of Lazar Markovic, 20, and Adam Lallana, 26, according to the Daily Mirror.

    Jordan Ibe
    News on the hour 09:00: Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    A Liverpool MP has joined in the latest internet craze known as the ice bucket challenge, where you pour ice cold water over your head to raise money for charity.

    Steven Gerrard and David Beckham have got involved - and so has West Derby MP Stephen Twigg.

    Listen to our live bulletin.

    Oh yay, oh yay... I'll be back 08:54: via Facebook

    Kevin Fischer has been in touch with his suggestions for the best - and worst - town criers.

    Arnold Schwarzenegger

    He posted on Facebook: "Worst: Joe Pasquale! Best: Arnold Schwarzenegger!"

    And Philip Sagar posted: "John Savident (Fred Elliott the butcher from Coronation Street) would make an excellent town crier. 'I say Chester, Ashley'."

    Boy charged with cemetery theft 08:48:

    A 10-year-old boy has been charged with theft after more than 100 headstones and memorials were damaged at a cemetery in Birkenhead.

    Flaybrick Hill Cemetery, Birkenhead

    A report of "extensive damage" at Flaybrick Hill Cemetery, in Tollemache Road, was made on 23 May, but police believe it happened the evening before.

    The boy has been bailed to appear before Wirral Youth Court on 2 September.

    999 worker 'fell asleep on job' 08:41: Liverpool Echo

    An inquiry has been launched after a worker in Merseyside's ambulance control room was pictured appearing to fall asleep on the job.

    Children's hospital 'must improve' 08:33: Nafeesa Shan BBC News

    Alder Hey Children's Hospital "requires improvement" in the areas of critical care and outpatient services, health inspectors have said.

    Alder Hey Children's Hospital

    The Care Quality Commission (CQC) found a shortage of nurses, a lack of senior doctors on the high dependency unit and outpatients had long waiting times.

    Inspectors rated areas such as end-of-life care, surgery and accident and emergency as Outstanding or Good.

    M62 congestion 08:24:

    BBC Travel News is reporting slow traffic on the M62 eastbound between junction 10, near the M6, and junction 11 at the A574 (Birchwood).

    There is also congestion on the A562 Penketh Road in Great Sankey, Warrington, where traffic is busy but moving at the Murco traffic lights.

    Vying for town crying crown 08:16: Tony Snell BBC Radio Merseyside

    Oh yay, oh yay, oh yay! Chester will host the World Town Crier Championships for the next few days.

    Town criers

    It's not the sort of job that Marcel Marceau would be any good at, but Brian Blessed would be great! So who do you think would make the best and worst town criers?

    Let us know by emailing us or posting on our Facebook page.

    Dry with showers 08:09:

    It's been a rainy start and while there may be a few showers around, many places will have a dry day with some decent periods of sunshine.

    BBC weather

    It looks like another cool day, with top temperatures of 17C (62F).

    News on the hour 08:01: Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    Liverpool's Alder Hey Children's Hospital has recruited about 40 nurses in the last week after a critical report revealed their wards weren't staffed properly.

    The Care Quality Commission found wards were not staffed properly and outpatient care needed to be improved.

    Listen to our live bulletin.

    Good morning 08:00: Tom Mullen BBC News Online

    Greetings from Liverpool on this rather rainy Wednesday morning. I'm here all day with news, sport, weather and travel updates.

    Feel free to get involved by tweeting us, emailing us, or posting on our Facebook page.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.