Hillsborough inquest: Police lawyers to probe fans' 'drunkenness'

Hillsborough disaster Ninety-six fans died as a result of the crush at the 1989 FA Cup semi-final

The disputed suggestion drunkenness among fans played a part in the Hillsborough disaster will be explored again in new inquests, lawyers for senior police officers have said.

The disclosure drew angry cries from victims' families at a hearing ahead of next month's fresh inquests.

Ninety-six Liverpool fans died as a result of a crush in 1989 .

The Hillsborough Independent Panel found no evidence alcohol "played any part in the genesis of the disaster".

Fresh inquests into the deaths at the FA semi-final match are set to begin on 31 March in Warrington, Cheshire.

'Present neutral opinion'

At the fifth pre-inquest hearing in central London, John Beggs QC acting for match commander Ch Supt David Duckenfield and other senior officers announced they intend to explore if drunkenness among fans contributed to the deaths.

In submissions to the coroner, Lord Justice Goldring, a QC representing 22 of the bereaved families, said his team have commissioned an expert report on alcohol to present a neutral opinion.

Lord Goldring will consider whether this can be given as evidence.

Newspaper reports that "drunk and ticketless" fans were to blame for the Hillsborough stadium disaster on 15 April 1989 were dismissed by the 1989 Taylor Inquiry which concluded the main cause was the police failure of crowd control.

The Hillsborough Independent Panel (HIP), published in September 2012, also cleared Liverpool supporters of any wrongdoing.

It said: "The Panel found no evidence among the vast number of disclosed documents and many hours of video material to verify the serious allegations of exceptional levels of drunkenness."

It added that an emphasis on alcohol consumption had "fuelled persistent and unsustainable assertions about drunken fan behaviour".

Earlier, the hearing was told jurors will also make a visit to the stadium but will not be allowed to read on-site tributes to the victims.

'Objective approach'

Christina Lambert QC, counsel to the inquests, said: "The reason that we make this final observation is because the jury must remain objective and must be seen to be objective in their approach to the issues.

"Having visited the memorial myself, there is no doubt that the tributes that are made there are deeply moving."

She added there was "broad agreement" on the parts of the stadium and locations nearby, which should be viewed by the jurors.

"Our view is that it is reasonable for the jury to view the current police box even though its location is not precisely as it was in 1989," Ms Lambert said.

She told coroner Lord Justice Goldring the fresh inquest should aim to conclude around Christmas time.

The High Court quashed the original inquest verdicts in December 2012 following publication of the Hillsborough panel report.

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Liverpool



9 °C 1 °C

BBC Local Live

    13:35: Bootle road closed

    BBC Travel reports the A566 Knowsley Road in Bootle is closed both ways due to accident involving a pedestrian and a vehicle at Gray Street.

    13:28: Lennon home to be auctioned Tom Mullen BBC News

    A Liverpool house once home to John Lennon's mother is going up for auction.

    Blomfield Road, Garston, Liverpool

    Although he lived with his aunt Mimi at a home in Menlove Avenue, a teenage Lennon would regularly visit his mother, Julia, at 1, Blomfield Road, in Garston.

    Plans have been made for an auction to be held at Liverpool Town Hall on 31 March.

    13:16: Tesco confirms local store closures

    Supermarket giant Tesco has named the 43 stores it is closing across the country, a move that will see 2,000 staff lose their jobs.


    The Express store in Liverpool Kensington, Metro shops in Bootle, Ormskirk and Runcorn and the Homeplus in Chester will all close.

    The Express and Home Plus stores will close on 15 March with the Tesco Metros and Superstores on the list closing on 4 April.

    13:00: News on the hour Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    Tesco's confirmed five stores across the region will be closed down because of financial pressures - two are on Merseyside, two in Cheshire and one in Lancashire.

    The Express store in Liverpool Kensington, Metro shops in Bootle, Ormskirk and Runcorn and the Homeplus in Chester will all close.

    Tesco has already confirmed it's scrapping plans to build a new unit in Kirkby.

    Listen live to the 13:00 bulletin

    12:50: Wet and windy weather

    This afternoon will be cold with sunny spells and scattered rain or snow showers feeding in on the strong to gale force northwesterly winds.

    wet and windy weather

    These winds will be strongest around exposed coasts areas such as Hoylake.

    12:40: Shed load of trouble on M6

    NW Motorway Police say you can expect long delays on the M6 southbound between Holmes Chapel and Knutsford... and here is why...

    lorry shed its load
    12:32: Hillsborough memorial quilt created Chester Chronicle

    A woman from Ellesmere Port has created a quilt as a memorial to the 96 people killed in the Hillsborough disaster.

    Linda Whitfield sent out a request on social media for donations of Liverpool football shirts.

    She soon had enough shirts to make a quilt in memory of those who lost their lives in the 1989 disaster.

    12:19: Health Trust explores future

    A Merseyside NHS Trust could be one of the first in the region to join forces with GPs to provide out-of-hospital care and reduce more of the pressures on A&E and other acute services.

    Nurse on the ward

    It is one of the options Liverpool Community Health NHS Trust said it would explore after receiving support from the NHS.

    12:04: Coming up Roger Phillips BBC Radio Merseyside

    From 12:00, I'll be discussing the cost of social care for the over 65s and a new scheme in Scotland where pregnant women are given shopping vouchers as an incentive to give up smoking.

    11:59: News on the hour Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    From next year, the government will cap the amount you can spend on care in your old age to £72,000 - to stop people wiping out their life savings.

    It is something that happened to Viv Galley from Stockport, who said she spent everything she had on caring for her husband Bill who had Alzheimer's.

    Listen live to the 12:00 bulletin

    11:54: Gritters on standby

    Cheshire East Council says the gritters are on standby as another spell of cold weather heads for the region.

    Snow gritting vehicle

    The council also says it would be nice to take a moment to check on vulnerable neighbours.

    11:39: Merseyrail up and running

    Merseyrail tweets: Services are disrupted on the Northern line - http://www.merseyrail.org/disruption *** CLEARED NOW ***

    11:28: Costa stamps 'accidental' - Mourinho

    Diego Costa's alleged stamps during Chelsea's Capital One Cup semi-final win over Liverpool were "absolutely accidental", says boss Jose Mourinho.

    Chelsea's Diego Costa and Liverpool's Martin Skrtel

    Costa trod on Emre Can and Martin Skrtel in a second-leg tie that saw the Londoners progress after extra time.

    Mourinho insisted the Blues striker was blameless. But Liverpool boss Brendan Rodgers said: "He has this edge to him. With Emre Can, that was poor, I felt."

    11:15: Animal feed firm prosecuted Emma Stanley BBC News

    An animal feed company is to be prosecuted following the death of a lorry driver who was buried under a mound of feed.

    Malcolm Harrison was working at the Cargill terminal at Seaforth Dock in Liverpool on 6 September 2012 when a stockpile of soya meal collapsed on him. The 64-year-old from Keighley died of his injuries in hospital.

    The Health and Safety Executive is bringing criminal proceedings against Cargill plc on Health and Safety charges following an investigation into Mr Harrison's death.

    11:06: Care cost calculator

    The BBC has launched an online guide to the care system for the over-65s.

    Older person's hand

    The "care calculator" covers both residential care and the support provided in people's own homes, for tasks such as washing and dressing.

    Users can submit their postcode and find out how much each service costs wherever they live in the UK.

    10:28: Bungling intruders get wrong house Liverpool Echo

    Armed gunmen burst into a Wallasey home and attacked a man - after raiding the wrong house.

    Five masked men forced their way into the family home on Sunday night and fled with a small amount of cash.

    The intruders, who were armed with a handgun and a knife, punched a 30-year-old man, who was at home alone.

    Police believe the men behind the terrifying ordeal targeted the wrong house.

    10:14: Coming up Sean Styles BBC Radio Merseyside

    After 10, I'll be talking about the price of your food shop and how to eat well for less.


    And if you're finding January a bit miserable, listen to the programme to find out about a new comedy club venue in Liverpool.

    09:59: News on the hour Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    From next year the government will cap the amount you can spend on care in your old age - to stop people wiping out their life savings.

    The limit will be £72,000.

    Listen live to the 10:00 bulletin

    09:54: Johnny Vegas to be a dad again St Helens The Reporter

    St Helens comic Johnny Vegas and his wife are expecting their first child.

    Johnny Vegas

    The funnyman, who has a son from his first marriage, announced the news via Twitter, posting a picture of the scan and photoshopping a pint of Guinness into the picture.

    Johnny's wife, Irish journalist and TV presenter Maia Dunphy, captioned the snap: "Well Johnny, at least we know he's definitely yours."

    Johnny added: "No need for a DNA test then, or for Maia to splash out on expensive maternity gear, just borrow my jeans."

    09:46: Liverpool 'fantastic' despite cup exit Pat Nevin BBC Radio 5 live

    "It was captivating. First and foremost, I thought Liverpool were fantastic. Jordan Henderson was brilliant. The way they've got themselves back after a sticky start to the season shows Brendan Rodgers has got a huge amount out of this team."

    09:38: Quad bike crash

    An investigation is underway after a quad bike crashed with a car in Birkenhead yesterday evening.

    the junction of Worcester Road and Hoylake Road

    Two young men were found lying injured in the road, and were taken to Aintree Hospital with head injuries.

    Merseyside Police want to speak to anyone who saw the collision at the junction of Worcester Road and Hoylake Road.

    09:25: Shop thieves post stolen DVDs home

    Thieves used an Asda supermarket's own in-store post box in Ellesmere Port to mail stolen CDs and DVDs to themselves.

    Asda logo

    Bosses discovered that people were pinching padded envelopes to post discs stolen from the store.

    The envelopes have been moved behind a counter on the other side of the supermarket from its post office.

    09:12: Blues beat Lincoln BBC Sport

    In last night's Conference action Chester recorded their biggest victory since returning to the Conference top flight in 2013.

    The blues beat Lincoln City 4-0 at the Swansway stadium.

    08:59: News on the hour Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    It's hoped a cap on the amount you can spend on care will stop people in the North West losing their life savings.

    From next April an individual will only be able to spend £72,000 before the government picks up the bill - in an effort to stop people spending all their money.

    Listen live to the 9:00 bulletin

    08:53: Listed status for former bank

    The former Midland Bank at 4 Dale Street in Liverpool has been given a Grade II listing.

    former Midland Bank at 4 Dale Street

    The building - and 13 other post-war office buildings in England - were chosen in an English Heritage project to research and assess commercial buildings of 1964 to 1984.

    Constructed in the early 1970s to the designs Bradshaw, Rowse and Harker, English Heritage said the building employs "a high-quality Modernist design" and "a form of late 1960s pop architecture" that has "brought fun and diversity to the streetscape".

    08:45: Coming up Tony Snell BBC Radio Merseyside

    This morning we'll hear about the authentic artefacts arriving at Chester Zoo today as part of a £30m project.

    Island attraction at Chester Zoo

    And we'll try to bust some of the health and safety myths out there as we continue our look at the Health and Safety Executive.

    08:35: Road closed in Birkenhead

    BBC Travel reports the A552 Woodchurch Road is closed in Birkenhead between J3 of the M53 and Arrowe Park Road because of a fallen tree. It is causing traffic queues.

    08:29: Mum's lucky escape Liverpool Echo

    A Merseyside mum spoke of how she had a lucky escape after her car was smashed off the road by a rogue driver - sending her vehicle crashing through a wall and into her neighbour's front garden.

    Mum-of-five Sophie Moss told the newspaper she believes she was deliberately rammed off the road.

    08:19: Reds miss out on League Cup final Phil Kinsella BBC Merseyside Sport

    A great effort by Liverpool but in the end it was to no avail as a goal four minutes into extra time saw Chelsea reach the final of the Capital One Cup.

    Chelsea v Liverpool

    Branislav Ivanovic scored the winner for Chelsea to win the tie 2-1 on aggregate.

    08:08: It might snow today, wrap up

    The Met office has issued a yellow "be prepared" warning for snow.

    weather map

    Across northern England 3-8 cm could accumulate by tomorrow morning, especially over high ground and strong, gusty winds will add to the mix.

    There's also a warning travel may be disrupted.

    08:00: News on the hour Giulia Bould BBC Radio Merseyside

    It's hoped a cap on the amount you can spend on care will stop people in the North West losing their life savings.

    From next April an individual will only be able to spend £72,000 before the government picks up the bill - in an effort to stop people spending all their money.

    Listen live to the 8:00 bulletin.

    08:00: Good morning Emma Stanley BBC News

    I'm here with all your news, sport, travel and weather updates from across Merseyside today. If you've got a story you'd like me to hear about or a photograph you'd like to share, you can contact me on email, Facebook or Twitter



Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.