Hillsborough decision 'a victory for democracy'


During the debate, Wirral MP Alison McGovern called for the truth to be acknowledged

Related Stories

The decision to release all government documents relating to the Hillsborough disaster has been called a "victory for democracy and people power".

The comments were made by Labour MP Steve Rotheram after the Home Secretary agreed to the disclosure during a Commons debate on Monday.

He said it remained to be seen whether it was a victory for the families, who had been let down so many times before.

Ninety-six Liverpool fans died in the tragedy in April 1989.

'Significant change'

Ninety-five supporters were killed in a crush of fans at Sheffield Wednesday's ground, where the club was playing an FA Cup semi-final against Nottingham Forest.

Start Quote

Lost lives cannot be regained but bereaved families have just waited too long to find out just what happened”

End Quote Louise Ellman MP

The 96th victim was in a coma for three years and died in 1992.

Trevor Hicks, the president of the Hillsborough Family Support Group, who lost two daughters at the match, said on Tuesday he welcomed the vote.

"I think for the first time I am very positive, I think that the house today has done itself proud," he said.

"For many years I have watched the house and some of the silly antics of party politics, but I do think for once I have seen a very positive will across the house in trying to bottom this once and for all.

"We saw some very emotional scenes which show that MPs have a heart as well as a mouth."

He admitted it could be some time before the findings were released.

"The report from the independent panel will be published probably in May or June of next year but again, our position on that is we want them to do a full and proper job, and we would rather them take a few more months and do the job properly than rush it and meet an artificial timeline."

The debate was triggered by 140,000 people signing an e-petition, set up by Liverpool fan Brian Irvine.

He said: "I hope in the end the family get the answers that they are looking for from this.

Trevor Hicks Trevor Hicks, who lost two daughters in the tragedy, has welcomed the vote

"They are the most important people at the end of the day. I hope Theresa May will be good to her word and all the relevant documents will be released to the relevant panel and they can get closure on this after 22 years."

Liverpool Riverside MP Louise Ellman, who took part in the Commons debate, said it was a significant step forward.

"Lost lives cannot be regained but bereaved families have just waited too long to find out just what happened," she said.

"This means that all the papers the government holds will be released so I think that is a very significant change."

Mr Rotheram, whose Walton constituency includes Anfield, opened the debate on Monday.

He said there had been a campaign to blame Liverpool fans for the tragedy and has called on the prime minister to issue a formal apology.

The MP is also making a fresh demand for an apology from The Sun newspaper over its infamous "The Truth" headline and story which alleged drunken and criminal behaviour by Liverpool fans.

'Fundamental rights'

Labour frontbencher Andy Burnham has also welcomed the disclosure, saying it was one of the "biggest injustices of the 20th Century".

"The home secretary has made an unequivocal commitment to full disclosure, echoing the words of the Prime Minister in his letter to me," he said.

"We thank her for it. And the fact that there is now agreement across this house between all parties shows the watching world that this is not about party politics but the fundamental rights of victims and their families."

He has joined Mr Rotheram in calling for an apology from the government.

Speaking to Radio Merseyside on Tuesday, he said: "Some people are confused as to why a prime minister who obviously wasn't there 22 years ago would be forced to make an apology but he apologised after the Saville Report for the atrocities on Bloody Sunday.

"I think it is appropriate that if, as we all believe, the government was complicit in any of this cover up, then the prime minister now should apologise for the government's mishandling of what happened at Hillsborough."

West Lancashire MP Rosie Cooper added to calls for a government apology.

She said: "I also support Steve Rotheram in his calls for the prime minister to make a public apology to the families of the 96 and everyone associated with Liverpool Football Club.

"The record needs to be set straight and the lies told about events on that day recognised as the lies they were. Lies the government of the day were part of pedalling.

"After 22 years perhaps now we can finally begin to get justice for the 96."


More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 209.

    Our fans were amongst the best behaved anywhere in the world in the 1980's

    No they weren't. They were as bad as many other clubs and with regards to Heysel worse. The 1980s was a horrible decade in terms of violence & most clubs were equally bad.

    H'boro however was a combination of too many people in too small a space caused by a varirty of factors which will hopefully never be repeated.

  • rate this

    Comment number 208.

    The whole event was extremely tragic and I feel for the families of all those involved and welcome the making of ALL documents public but would ask what are people hoping to get from it ? I thought it had been proven that a combination of poor crowd control and a poorly designed ground led to the tragedy.

  • rate this

    Comment number 207.

    So The Taylor Report which dismissed Fans behaviour as a significant cause of events can be dismissed ? utter nonsense. And despite LFC's pleas for UEFA not to go ahead with a major final on a decrepit stadium it was OK for them to do so? Ignorance in the extreme.As for Athens, the Greek authorities have admitted organisation there was a farce. You're just another who believes the bigoted myths.

  • rate this

    Comment number 206.

    I'm glad someone has finally mentioned the issue of the pens. I'm a Bradford fan, and when our dreadful fire happened in 1985 many managed to escape by running onto the pitch. It shocks me that, after Bradford, such pens were allowed to exist, and, ultimately, lead to so many deaths here. But if there had been a fire at Hillsborough that day the deathtoll would have been unimaginable. RIP the 96.

  • rate this

    Comment number 205.

    Has no-one thought that without the penning and pitch fences, this disaster would never have happened? Which is why they were removed from all grounds post-disaster? With good policing, the disaster still could have happened.

    That's "the truth".

    Why all this fuss? I guess Boris knows why.......


Comments 5 of 209


BBC Liverpool



8 °C 7 °C


BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.