Met Police 'deleted discrimination findings'

Carol Howard A number of Carol Howard's complaints of "victimisation" were "well-founded", the tribunal said

The Met Police told staff to delete records on sex and race discrimination against one of its employees, an employment tribunal has found.

Firearms officer Carol Howard, 35, was "singled out and targeted" for nearly a year, a panel ruled.

An officer looking at her complaints was asked to delete references in a report into discrimination related to race or sex, it said.

The Met said it was "disappointed" at the findings but would review the case.

Carol Howard Carol Howard was a firearms officer for the Diplomatic Protection Group

Ms Howard, of Purley, south London, brought a claim of discrimination at the Central London Employment Tribunal earlier this year.

A judgement issued by the panel which heard the case said the Met "directly discriminated" against Ms Howard "on the grounds of sex and race" between 31 January and 29 October 2012.

A number of Ms Howard's complaints of "victimisation" were "well-founded", the tribunal added.

The force concluded there was no evidence "without having conducted a proper investigation", it said.

Commitment challenged

It also found that a detective sergeant tasked with looking at Ms Howard's fairness at work (FAW) complaint was asked to delete references to discrimination and harassment relating to sex or race in a report.

Start Quote

Fifteen years after the Met was branded 'institutionally racist' they have failed in addressing discrimination which pervades the system”

End Quote Kiran Daurka Carol Howard's lawyer

The judgement concluded this was done "not because they were not supported by evidence in the report, but because the claimant had brought a complaint of race and sex discrimination in the tribunal".

The tribunal recorded that it was "very concerned the [Metropolitan Police's] policy of not allowing Fairness at Work Advisers to make assessments of discrimination and of instructing to delete them when they do so, might mislead complainants and tribunals into believing that the [investigating officer] has not found any discrimination when in fact he or she has done so".

The 35-year-old worked in the Diplomatic Protection Group (DPG), which provides protection for foreign embassies and missions in London.

Her superior, acting Insp Dave Kelly, subjected her to "a course of conduct which was detrimental to her", the panel said.

'Discriminatory treatment'

Within weeks of becoming her line manager Insp Kelly "formed the view... that the claimant was dishonest and not up to the standard required for DPG", but the panel said he had not provided a "credible basis for forming such a view".


This judgement is a damning one for the force that in 1999 was found to be 'institutionally racist' by the MacPherson Inquiry into its handling of the investigation into the murder of Stephen Lawrence.

In the intervening years the Metropolitan Police has made strenuous efforts to rid itself of institutional racism and to increase diversity among its officers and staff.

The case of Carol Howard raises the spectre once again.

In an especially damaging judgement, the tribunal said there was a policy of deleting findings of sex and race discrimination from internal grievance documents.

Grievance procedures are designed to ensure fairness at work and the equal treatment of all staff.

This case is a particular concern for an organisation that is keen to show that it has moved on from past criticisms and wants to attract more black and ethnic officers, both male and female.

Her commitment was challenged in front of colleagues, her "every absence" was assumed not to be genuine and her application for an armed response vehicle role was not supported, the panel found.

Lawyers for Ms Howard will now seek compensation from the Met Police for injury to feelings and aggravated damages.

Her lawyer Kiran Daurka, from Slater & Gordon, called for a "complete rewrite" of the force's equality procedures.

"The conduct of the Metropolitan Police and some of its senior officers towards Carol Howard was deplorable over the last two years," she said.

"My client was subjected to discriminatory treatment because she is black and because she is a woman.

"Fifteen years after the Met was branded 'institutionally racist' they have failed in addressing discrimination which pervades the system."


And she told BBC Radio 4's Today programme that the deletion of records of sex and race discrimination was a policy within the Met.

"We anticipate that wherever there's findings of discrimination, they're being instructed to delete them. They've admitted that they do this practice... so that there are no findings of discrimination against them."

Daphne Romney QC added: "What is particularly shocking is the deliberate attempt to cover up internal findings of discrimination.

"The outcome of the internal grievance investigation led PC Howard to believe that the investigating officer did not accept that there had been either race or sex discrimination, when clearly this was not the case."

Duwayne Brooks, Stephen Lawrence's friend who was with him when he was murdered, tweeted his reaction to the judgement and said: "Is this what @metpoliceuk is all about to protect it's integrity?"

London mayor Boris Johnson said he was "dismayed" by the tribunal findings.

Questioned by members of the Greater London Authority, he said there were "without doubt lessons to be learned" and would be ensuring that the Met Police addressed all the tribunal findings through the mayor's office of policing and crime.

In a statement, the Met Police said: "We are disappointed at the tribunal's finding in favour of PC Howard.

"We will review the findings, take legal advice and take forward any learning or actions as appropriate."

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC London



24 °C 15 °C

BBC Local Live

    Station closed 09:23:

    South Ruislip station is closed due flooding.

    The Central Line and Chiltern trains are not stopping at Chiltern and are calling at West Ruislip instead.

    BBC Travel has the latest.

    Where do parking charges go? 09:16:
    Man stabbed 09:08:

    Two people have been arrested after a man in his 40s was stabbed in Southall.

    Detectives are keeping an open mind about the motive after the man suffered multiple stab wounds in West Avenue in the early hours of this morning.

    His injuries aren't believed to be life threatening.

    Latest news 08:58: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    Our top headlines this hour:

    • Flash flooding's causing major disruption in parts of west London this morning.
    • The AA's Special Operations Response Team, which rescues vehicles from floodwater, says six cars are stuck in Uxbridge.

    Check out the rest of the headlines with BBC London 94.9 at 09:00.

    On air 08:52: Vanessa Feltz Presenter, BBC London 94.9

    One door if you're rich. One door if you're poor. The trend for segregated entrances to London's apartment blocks grows - but at what cost?

    I'm on air from 09:00 and want to know your views.

    Get in touch with your views: call 020 7224 2000 or text 81333, starting your message with the word London.

    Tulisa talks 08:46:

    Tulisa has told Newsbeat about how she thought about taking her own life during the last 12 months.


    Speaking for the first time since being found guilty of assault and the collapse of a drug trial against her the former N-Dubz singer said: "There was a really low point.

    Southall Broadway closed 08:38:

    In Southall Broadway is closed between Lady Margaret Road and Abbotts Road, following a police incident, with diversions in place to the west of Southall Park.

    For the latest information go to BBC London's travel page.

    Top Headlines
    First Capital Connect delays 08:30:

    On the trains, there are delays of up to 10 minutes on First Capital Connect services via Stevenage following an earlier road accident at a local rail bridge

    For the latest travel news follow @BBCTravelAlert on Twitter.

    A4 Chiswick problems 08:18:

    In Chiswick, the traffic lights are faulty on the A4 Great West Road at Sutton Court Road, with eastbound delays at times to the M4 at the Chiswick Roundabout.

    Sunny intervals and showers 08:08:

    Sunny intervals and showers are expected, which will be locally very heavy and thundery. Generally it will feel warm or very warm in the light winds. Showers will become more isolated as the day progresses.

    Maximum temperature: 26C (79F).

    08:00: Rebecca Cafe BBC News

    Morning. I'll be guiding you through BBC Local Live today, bringing you the latest news, travel, weather and sport from across London.

    Get in touch with your comments and photos by emailing



  • SyedTanks not toys

    Lyse Doucet on the plight of children in Syria and Gaza

  • Boy with head stuck in railingsSmall Data

    Heads stuck in banisters - the official statistics

  • The two sisters in their bakeryBaking hot

    Why two Spanish sisters started a bakery in the desert

  • A farmer walks in front of a construction site of new residential buildings in Hangzhou, ChinaPrice drop

    Sharp falls in China's property market

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.