Met Police 'deleted discrimination findings'

Carol Howard A number of Carol Howard's complaints of "victimisation" were "well-founded", the tribunal said

The Met Police told staff to delete records on sex and race discrimination against one of its employees, an employment tribunal has found.

Firearms officer Carol Howard, 35, was "singled out and targeted" for nearly a year, a panel ruled.

An officer looking at her complaints was asked to delete references in a report into discrimination related to race or sex, it said.

The Met said it was "disappointed" at the findings but would review the case.

Carol Howard Carol Howard was a firearms officer for the Diplomatic Protection Group

Ms Howard, of Purley, south London, brought a claim of discrimination at the Central London Employment Tribunal earlier this year.

A judgement issued by the panel which heard the case said the Met "directly discriminated" against Ms Howard "on the grounds of sex and race" between 31 January and 29 October 2012.

A number of Ms Howard's complaints of "victimisation" were "well-founded", the tribunal added.

The force concluded there was no evidence "without having conducted a proper investigation", it said.

Commitment challenged

It also found that a detective sergeant tasked with looking at Ms Howard's fairness at work (FAW) complaint was asked to delete references to discrimination and harassment relating to sex or race in a report.

Start Quote

Fifteen years after the Met was branded 'institutionally racist' they have failed in addressing discrimination which pervades the system”

End Quote Kiran Daurka Carol Howard's lawyer

The judgement concluded this was done "not because they were not supported by evidence in the report, but because the claimant had brought a complaint of race and sex discrimination in the tribunal".

The tribunal recorded that it was "very concerned the [Metropolitan Police's] policy of not allowing Fairness at Work Advisers to make assessments of discrimination and of instructing to delete them when they do so, might mislead complainants and tribunals into believing that the [investigating officer] has not found any discrimination when in fact he or she has done so".

The 35-year-old worked in the Diplomatic Protection Group (DPG), which provides protection for foreign embassies and missions in London.

Her superior, acting Insp Dave Kelly, subjected her to "a course of conduct which was detrimental to her", the panel said.

'Discriminatory treatment'

Within weeks of becoming her line manager Insp Kelly "formed the view... that the claimant was dishonest and not up to the standard required for DPG", but the panel said he had not provided a "credible basis for forming such a view".

Analysis

This judgement is a damning one for the force that in 1999 was found to be 'institutionally racist' by the MacPherson Inquiry into its handling of the investigation into the murder of Stephen Lawrence.

In the intervening years the Metropolitan Police has made strenuous efforts to rid itself of institutional racism and to increase diversity among its officers and staff.

The case of Carol Howard raises the spectre once again.

In an especially damaging judgement, the tribunal said there was a policy of deleting findings of sex and race discrimination from internal grievance documents.

Grievance procedures are designed to ensure fairness at work and the equal treatment of all staff.

This case is a particular concern for an organisation that is keen to show that it has moved on from past criticisms and wants to attract more black and ethnic officers, both male and female.

Her commitment was challenged in front of colleagues, her "every absence" was assumed not to be genuine and her application for an armed response vehicle role was not supported, the panel found.

Lawyers for Ms Howard will now seek compensation from the Met Police for injury to feelings and aggravated damages.

Her lawyer Kiran Daurka, from Slater & Gordon, called for a "complete rewrite" of the force's equality procedures.

"The conduct of the Metropolitan Police and some of its senior officers towards Carol Howard was deplorable over the last two years," she said.

"My client was subjected to discriminatory treatment because she is black and because she is a woman.

"Fifteen years after the Met was branded 'institutionally racist' they have failed in addressing discrimination which pervades the system."

'Deliberate'

And she told BBC Radio 4's Today programme that the deletion of records of sex and race discrimination was a policy within the Met.

"We anticipate that wherever there's findings of discrimination, they're being instructed to delete them. They've admitted that they do this practice... so that there are no findings of discrimination against them."

Daphne Romney QC added: "What is particularly shocking is the deliberate attempt to cover up internal findings of discrimination.

"The outcome of the internal grievance investigation led PC Howard to believe that the investigating officer did not accept that there had been either race or sex discrimination, when clearly this was not the case."

Duwayne Brooks, Stephen Lawrence's friend who was with him when he was murdered, tweeted his reaction to the judgement and said: "Is this what @metpoliceuk is all about to protect it's integrity?"

London mayor Boris Johnson said he was "dismayed" by the tribunal findings.

Questioned by members of the Greater London Authority, he said there were "without doubt lessons to be learned" and would be ensuring that the Met Police addressed all the tribunal findings through the mayor's office of policing and crime.

In a statement, the Met Police said: "We are disappointed at the tribunal's finding in favour of PC Howard.

"We will review the findings, take legal advice and take forward any learning or actions as appropriate."

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC London

Weather

London

5 °C -1 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    14:04: House price woe for first-timers

    The Times tweets: Soaring house prices force first-timers out of London http://thetim.es/1y0H9Il (PA)

     
  2.  
    13:47: Crooning cabbie

    If you are lucky enough to hail Aiden Kent's taxi, you can expect a journey with a difference because he is London's crooning cabby.

    Singing cabby Aiden Kent
     
  3.  
    13:30: Man charged over flat murder

    A man has been charged with the murder of a woman found dead in a flat in east London.

    The 34-year-old, named by police as Somali national Abdulqadir Abdullah, is due to appear before magistrates later.

    Officers found the body of a 40-year-old woman inside a flat at Denning Point on Commercial Street, near Aldgate East, after being called to a disturbance there on Saturday night.

     
  4.  
    13:17: On air Sonja Jessup Presenter, BBC London News

    We'll have the latest from the BBC London newsroom at 13:30. We're live at King's Cross station following a weekend of rail disruption.

    Plus, are London's rugby coaches ready for next year's World Cup? It's thought there'll be a big boost in the number of people taking up the sport.

     
  5.  
    13:01: Showbiz quiz

    Do you think you know what happened this year in the world of entertainment?

    Ant and Dec

    Have a go at the BBC News Entertainment 2014 quiz and see how much you remember about the past 12 months.

    You can also try the music and arts brain-teasers. A film-themed quiz will also be published tomorrow.

     
  6.  
    12:42: Cold and sunny afternoon Sara Thornton Weather Presenter, BBC London

    This afternoon will be dry but cold with good sunny spells. Highs of 5C (41F).

     
  7.  
    12:28: Download Robert Elms Robert Elms Presenter, BBC London 94.9

    If you missed any of my shows last week you can now get the weekly download.

    Artist Gordon Robert McHarg III was my Listed Londoner, author Sean Kelly talked about his new book and musician Clifford Slapper chatted about his biography written about David Bowie's pianist, Mike Garson.

     
  8.  
    12:16: Unwanted presents

    Westminster Council tweets: Don't want that Christmas present but don't know your rights? Westminster Trading Standards suggest reading this: http://tinyurl.com/oqp4th9

     
  9.  
    12:05: Feedback Claire Timms BBC News Online

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? We'd like your feedback about this service.

     
  10.  
    11:50: Mourinho: There is a campaign against us BBC Sport
  11.  
    11:35: New Year's Eve

    With just two days until Londoners welcome in the New Year at a ticketed event at the London Eye, those without tickets are urged to stay away from the Embankment and Southbank areas.

    Fireworks explode over London on 1 January 2014

    From 14:00 on Wednesday road closures will start , with most in place by 20:00, stretching from Oxford Street to Elephant & Castle and Vauxhall Bridge to Southwark Bridge.

    Some Tube stations will become exit only or be closed completely for crowd management purposes.

     
  12.  
    11:19: Big changes for O's Newham Recorder Newspaper

    Leyton Orient boss Fabio Liverani admits he will make changes to the starting line-up for tonight's 'massive' League One game at Yeovil Town.

    The O's beat Crawley Town 4-1 on Boxing Day, but with the short space of time in between fixtures the Italian will rotate his squad for the trip to the side bottom of League One.

     
  13.  
    11:03: Signalling problems

    BBC London Travel tweets: No @SouthernRailUK between Clapham Junction and Milton Keynes Central - signalling problem at Wembley Central. [ro]

     
  14.  
    10:44: Is Pardew Palace-bound? BBC Sport

    Newcastle boss Alan Pardew has avoided commenting on reports that he could become the new Crystal Palace manager.

    Alan Pardew

    Former Eagles player Pardew, 53, failed to fulfil media duties after Sunday's 3-2 win over Everton.

    Newcastle assistant John Carver, who did the post-match conference, said: "Alan didn't say why I was doing the press, he just told me to do it."

     
  15.  
    10:29: Icy night

    Last night was the coldest of 2014.

    Trafalgar Square

    Press Association photographer Louisa Collins-Marsh captured ice forming in the Trafalgar Square fountains.

     
  16.  
    10:16: Out and about Ham & High Newspaper

    If you're stuck for things to do in Hampstead and Highgate this week, look no further than this High & High list of the five best things to do.

     
  17.  
    09:51: Bus strike update Claire Timms BBC News Online

    Route W14 isn't running. All other routes (25, 26, 30, 58, 236, 308, 339, 425, RV1 and W15) are running a reduced service. Around 60% of the buses from the Lea Interchange Garage are running.

     
  18.  
    09:41: Tube engineering works BBC London Travel

    Due to planned engineering works there are the following disruptions:

    • No Circle line between Edgware Road and Aldgate via Victoria
    • No District line between Embankment, Edgware Road and Wimbledon, Richmond, Ealing Common and Kensington Olympia
    • No Jubilee line between Finchley Road and Waterloo

    For the latest information go to our travel page or follow us on Twitter @BBCTravelAlert

     
  19.  
    09:31: Quiet at King's Cross

    BBC London 94.9 tweets: Quiet start at Kings Cross following the weekend's train chaos. So far no reported delays to departures

    King's Cross
     
  20.  
    09:21: Bus strike problems BBC London Travel

    The bus strike is affecting 11 day routes - 25, 26, 30, 58, 236, 308, 339, 425, RV1, W14 and W15.

    They are all running but some with half normal number of buses.

    For the latest information go to our travel page or follow us on Twitter @BBCTravelAlert.

     
  21.  
    09:10: Millen wants Palace job BBC Sport

    Crystal Palace caretaker boss Keith Millen has said he is ready to become the club's full-time manager.

    Crystal Palace caretaker manager  Keith Millen

    Millen, in temporary charge after Neil Warnock was sacked by the Eagles on Saturday, oversaw Palace's goalless draw against Queens Park Rangers.

     
  22.  
    08:57: On air Vanessa Feltz Presenter, BBC London 94.9

    Join me after 09:00 on BBC London 94.9 for a financial review of 2014.

    How's it been for you? Get involved by calling 020 7224 2000 or 81333 and start your message with "London". You will be charged at your standard message rate.

     
  23.  
    08:47: Rail problems BBC London Travel

    South West Trains has some disruption from Waterloo to Guildford, Dorking and Hampton Court because of emergency repairs to a broken rail at Clapham Junction.

    Southern says signalling problem in the Selhurst/Norwood/West Croydon area is creating delays of around 45 minutes. It is also causing minor delays for London Overground between Sydenham and West Croydon.

    For the latest information go to our travel page or follow us on Twitter @BBCTravelAlert.

     
  24.  
    08:35: Bus drivers go on strike

    A 24-hour strike by bus drivers in London over pay and conditions has begun.

    Unite protestors

    Unite union members working for the bus company Tower Transit are taking action on 13 bus routes in east and central London, claiming members were left with little choice but to strike.

     
  25.  
    08:21: QPR boss 'devastated' over missing jet

    AirAsia boss and QPR owner Tony Fernandes says he is "devastated" that a plane carrying 162 people from Indonesia to Singapore has gone missing.

    AirAsia CEO Tony Fernandes in Surabaya, 28 Dec

    Flight QZ8501, an Airbus A320-200, disappeared over the Java Sea an hour into its flight at 06:24 local time (23:24 GMT Saturday).

    Mr Fernandes, flew to Surabaya and told a press briefing: "Our concern right now is for the relatives and for the next of kin - there is nothing more important to us, for our crew's family, and for the passengers' families."

     
  26.  
    08:09: Dry, sunny and cold
  27.  
    08:03: Man dies in street stabbing

    A man in his late 50s has died after being stabbed in a street in Ilford in east London.

    He was found in Richmond Road after officers were called to reports of an assault at about 03:30 on Sunday

    A 30-year-old man was arrested on suspicion of causing grievous bodily harm, and later re-arrested on suspicion of murder.

     
  28.  
    08:00: Good Morning Claire Timms BBC News Online

    Welcome to today's Local Live page. I'll be bringing you all the latest news, sport, travel and weather until 18:00.

    You can email your comments or photos of yourself enjoying London at Christmas or tweet @BBCLondonNews.

     

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.