Immigration detainee 'died in handcuffs'

Harmondsworth Immigration Detention Centre HMIP inspectors compiled the report after an unannounced visit to the centre last August

Related Stories

An 84-year-old immigration detainee suffering from dementia and declared unfit for detention died in handcuffs, a report has revealed.

HM Inspectorate of Prisons (HMIP) compiled the report after visiting Harmondsworth immigration removal centre, near Heathrow airport.

Inspectors condemned "shocking cases where a sense of humanity was lost" at the centre in west London.

The Chief Inspector of Prisons said some services were "poorly managed".

The Prison Reform Trust said the centre had "forgotten the basic principles of humanity and decency".

HMIP inspectors compiled the report after an unannounced visit to the centre last August.

Handcuffed detainees

The 84-year-old was taken to hospital in handcuffs and he died while still in restraints, inspectors found.

Start Quote

Have the authorities responsible for Harmondsworth forgotten the basic principles of humanity and decency that must apply to any form of custody?”

End Quote Juliet Lyon Director, Prison Reform Trust

Doctors said the Canadian man was unfit for detention or deportation after diagnosing him with Alzheimer's disease, but he was not released and no referral was made to social services.

Medical notes described him as "frail, 84 years old, has Alzheimer's disease ... demented. Unfit for detention or deportation. Requires social care".

He had been in handcuffs for almost five hours when he died, the report said.

The Prisons and Probation Ombudsman is preparing to investigate his death and inquest proceedings are being conducted by West London Coroner's Court.

Other examples in the report included a stroke victim in a wheelchair, who was handcuffed on a journey to hospital for no obvious reason and a dying man who remained handcuffed while sedated and undergoing an angioplasty procedure in hospital.

Ministers have pledged to scrutinise more closely the performance of the private contractor GEO Group UK Ltd, which runs Harmondsworth.

'Poorly managed'

The group also runs Dungavel House immigration removal centre in South Lanarkshire.

The UK Border Agency's website says "removal centres are used for temporary detention, in situations where people have no legal right to be in the UK but have refused to leave voluntarily."

Isa Muazu Failed asylum seeker Isa Muazu was on hunger strike before his departure from Harmondsworth

"Those detained in any of our centres can leave at any time to return to their home country," it adds.

"Some detainees are foreign national prisoners who have completed prison terms for serious crimes, but who then refuse to comply with the law by leaving the UK."

However inspectors said 11 detainees had been held at the centre for more than a year, including a man who had been held for more than two years despite being willing to return to his own country.

There were also nearly 100 hunger-strikers identified in the six months prior to the inspection and HMIP described some of the rooms at the 600-capacity detention centre as overcrowded, dirty and bleak.

Juliet Lyon, from the Prison Reform Trust, said: "Have the authorities responsible for Harmondsworth forgotten the basic principles of humanity and decency that must apply to any form of custody?"

Chief Inspector of Prisons Nick Hardwick said: "These were truly shocking cases, and they weren't isolated, and they reflected a culture where too often the individual human needs of the people who were being held were simply being forgotten.

"And in the worst case, this frail, elderly Canadian gentleman with dementia died in the most undignified and disgraceful circumstances possible."

He added there was a feeling Harmondsworth was in "a state of drift" with concerns about its future management, as the current contract was under review.

"The centre did not seem to be progressing and some services were being poorly managed," he said.

"Most importantly, there needed to be a refocusing on individual needs of the most vulnerable people in detention, some of whom had been utterly failed by the system."

The report said on at least two occasions, inspectors discovered elderly and vulnerable detainees were "needlessly handcuffed in an excessive and unacceptable manner".

'Completely unjustified'

Immigration minister Mark Harper said the use of restraint in the case of the dementia sufferer seemed "completely unjustified and must not be repeated".

"Clearly, performance by the contractor running Harmondsworth has been below the high standard expected," Mr Harper said.

"This report makes a number of recommendations that we will be taking forward and I expect to see significant improvement."

Shadow Home Secretary Yvette Cooper said: "This shocking report exposes incidents of inhumanity."

"Terminally ill, dying elderly people should not be handcuffed to their hospital bed.

"People will rightly be appalled by this incident and the home secretary should be appalled too."

In a statement Harmondsworth contractor GEO said: "Detainees are not routinely handcuffed when taken out of the centre.

"However, where there is a documented risk of absconding, handcuffs may be used, balanced against a number of factors, including their age.

"Managers have to use discretion to take difficult decisions and we have issued them with additional guidance."

The contractor added that GEO Group UK Ltd had an "excellent track record" of providing services as evidenced in other recent reports by the HMIP.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC London

Weather

London

18 °C 9 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    Weather 13:15:

    There will be sunny spells and one or two showers this afternoon. The winds will remain light and it should feel warm with highs of Maximum Temperature: 17C (63F)

     
  2.  
    Coming up 13:03: Katharine Carpenter Reporter and presenter

    Coming up on BBC London News at 13:30, we will have the latest on the FBI's attempts to trace victims of a paedophile who taught at a London school. William Vahey took his own life but police in the USA say he admitted abusing boys at international schools around the world.

    Also on the programme, a sneak preview of the mini prima ballerinas from London Children's Ballet during their final rehearsals for tonight's premiere performance.

     
  3.  
    Coming up 12:50: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    On BBC London 94.9, Dotun Adebayo will be joined by historian and author Chris Laoutaris to discuss his new book Shakespeare and the Countess, which is the first ever biography of Lady Elizabeth Russell, the woman who waged battle against Shakespeare.

     
  4.  
    Rugby Union salary cap 'warning' 12:41:

    The chairman of Saracens rugby club, Nigel Wray, has told BBC Extra Time that the £5m salary cap in the English Premiership Rugby Union is helpful at keeping down costs, but could cause talented players to go elsewhere.

    Chairman of Saracens rugby club in London, Nigel Wray

    "It is a short-lived profession and actually it is quite wrong that you stop people getting what they are worth," he said.

     
  5.  
    Ilford murder trial 12:29:

    The jury in the trial of two men accused of murdering a businessman is due to start considering verdicts later.

    Harjinder Singh Bhurji, 32, was stabbed in Ilford, east London, for allegedly refusing to hand over his car keys.

    Rory Gordon, 22, of Bow, and Jae-don Fearon, 20 of Manor Park Drive, Harlesden, deny murder. Andre Campbell, 22 of Aldriche Way, Waltham Forest, denies handling stolen goods.

     
  6.  
    Man rescued from water 12:21:

    Tower RNLI tweets: Last night the crew had a call at 20:48 and rescued a man from the water with @MPSonthewater #teamwork .

    RNLI board
     
  7.  
    PuppetSoup event 12:10:

    Imperial NHS tweets: Mums & dads in #NWLondon come to special @puppetsoup theatre events for advice on #childhealth tinyurl.com/mnh6qfl

     
  8.  
    Ivor Novello awards 12:00:

    Group London Grammar are up for the best song musically and lyrically award at this year's Ivor Novello awards, for their track Strong.

    London Grammar

    The annual ceremony will take place at London's Grosvenor House Hotel, in Park Lane, on 22 May.

     
  9.  
    Contactless payment pilot 11:50:

    The first customer volunteers have begun Transport for London's pilot of contactless payment on the Tube and rail network.

    Around 5,000 customers are trialling the new way of touching in and out on the network ahead of the launch of the scheme later in the year. Contactless payment is already used on London's buses.

     
  10.  
    Severed finger found in Sutton park 11:40:

    The grim discovery of a severed finger led to a North Cheam park being sealed off by police, reports the Wandsworth Guardian.

     
  11.  
    Have your say 11:30:

    Tell us what you think of BBC Local Live. We'd like your feedback about this service.

     
  12.  
    Waterloo delays 11:16:

    South West Trains ‏tweets: #Waterloo. Delays to and from London Waterloo expected until 12:30.

     
  13.  
    Russell Square collision 11:08:

    Simon Lamrock sent us this photo of a car in collision with a van at the junction of of Woburn Place and Bernard Street, near Russell Square.

    Vehicles at Woburn Place and Bernard Street

    The Met Police said there were no serious injuries following the incident which happened at 05:20. TfL tweeted that the road has now reopened.

     
  14.  
    New Malden Deaths 10:58:

    Post mortems are due to take place later on three children who were found dead in New Malden on Tuesday, the Met Police has said.

    The examinations will take place at Great Ormond Street Hospital this afternoon. A 42-year-old woman is being questioned by officers on suspicion of murdering her children.

     
  15.  
    Central Line suspension 10:45:

    Service has been suspended on the Central Line Westbound between North Acton and West Ruislip. There are also minor delays on the rest of the line due to a signal failure at North Acton.

    For more travel news visit the BBC Travel website.

     
  16.  
    Thames Tunnel tours tickets 10:36:

    The public are being given the opportunity to take a public tour of the historic Thames Tunnel, which runs under the Thames between Rotherhithe and Wapping Stations.

    The tours will run from 24-26 May and tickets go on sale on from 10:00 on the London Transport Museum website and will cost £18 per person.

     
  17.  
    Banksy art to be auctioned 10:25:

    A collection of street art works by Banksy, removed from walls, is to go on display at a London hotel before being sold at auction.

    Banksy's 2 Rats mural

    Banksy has not commented, however auction house Bonhams said buyers should be wary of buying artwork which had not been authenticated.

     
  18.  
    Waterloo delays 10:14:

    South West Trains tweets: #Waterloo #ClaphamJunction NEW - power supply issues between Waterloo & Clapham Junction, trains subject to delay, cancellation & alteration

     
  19.  
    Police make Syria plea 10:03:

    British counter-terrorism police chiefs are making an appeal to Muslim women to urge their relatives not to travel to Syria to fight. Shiraz Maher, from Kings College London, said the strategy was ill conceived.

    "The inference that the average parent, in particular, will draw and this is who the campaign is directed at, is that if they take any information about their child to the police they will risk having their child locked up or imprisoned under very draconian legislation," he said.

     
  20.  
    London private schools 'boom' 09:52:

    Pupil numbers at private schools in London have soared since the start of the recession, while institutions in the North have been left struggling, the TES reports.

     
  21.  
    Green park access 09:40:

    TfL Travel Alerts ‏tweets: Step free access has been restored at Green Park to the @piccadillyline platform @TfLAccess

     
  22.  
    Dounreay to be put on display 09:31:

    Parts of a fast reactor control room at Dounreay in Caithness, in the Scottish Highlands, look set to be dismantled and rebuilt at the Science Museum in London.

    Control panels at DFR control room

    The panels and the control desk from the former experimental nuclear power plant near Thurso would be displayed temporarily at the museum.

     
  23.  
    Tower Bridge opening times 09:22:

    Tower Bridge will open at the following times:

    • 11:30
    • 12:!5
    • 14:45
    • 15:30
    • 18:30
    • 19:30
    • 22:30
    • 23:30

    Traffic will be halted while the bridge is open.

     
  24.  
    Mortlake murder charge 09:07:

    A man has been charged with murder following the death of a 49-year-old man in Mortlake, the Met Police have said.

    The victim was found at the Tapestry public house, on Lower Richmond Road on 22 April and died in hospital on 23 April. Nicholas Hunter, 36, from Clapham, is due to appear at Wimbledon Magistrates' Court later.

     
  25.  
    Vanessa Feltz 08:56: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    As counter-terrorism police urge Muslim women to step in if they think their male relatives are planning to join the civil war in Syria, Vanessa Feltz will be asking what do you think of the appeal?

    The call from Scotland Yard comes after the deaths of at least 10 men from Britain in the conflict. Join Vanessa on BBC London 94.9 from 09:00.

     
  26.  
    New Malden deaths 08:47:

    Police are continuing to question a 42-year-old woman suspected of murdering three of her children in south-west London.

    House where the children were found

    Tania Clarence was arrested after the bodies of a girl, aged four, and twin boys, aged three, were found at home in Thetford Road, New Malden, on Tuesday.

     
  27.  
    Central Line 08:37:

    Trains are not stopping on the Central Line at Bond Street because of station improvement works.

     
  28.  
    Latest updates
     
  29.  
    Video: Police quiz mother 'murders' 08:27:

    Flowers and toys have been left outside a home in Thetford Road, New Malden, after three children were found dead at the property on Tuesday.

    Police are continuing to question a 42-year-old woman on suspicion of murder following the deaths of a girl, aged four, and twin boys, aged three.

     
  30.  
    Travel 08:17:

    On the roads, the M1 is blocked northbound from junction 10 at the Luton Airport Spur towards junction 11 at Dunstable following an accident.

    There is queuing traffic on the M25 clockwise between junction 25 A10 at Enfield and junction 26 A121 at Waltham Abbey due to an earlier breakdown in the Holmesdale Tunnel.

    For the latest travel updates follow BBC London Travel on Twitter pr go to our travel page.

     
  31.  
    Police make Syria plea 08:08:

    Events in London will see police reach out to Muslim women to urge men against travelling to possibly fight in Syria in an unprecedented appeal.

    Abdul Waheed Majeed
     
  32.  
    Weather 08:03:

    It will be mainly dry through this morning with any mist quickly clearing. This afternoon will bring sunny spells and scattered, slow moving showers, with the odd heavy one possible. Winds will remain light and it will feel warm. Highs of 18C (64F).

     
  33.  
    08:00: Elaine Okyere BBC London News

    Good morning. I'll be bringing you the latest news, sport, travel and weather for London today.

    You can tell me your news by emailing london.locallive@bbc.co.uk or tweeting @BBCLondonNews.

     

Features

  • Spanner CrabEdible images

    Are these the best food photographs of the past year?


  • Beckford's TowerFolly or fact?

    The unlikely debt capital of Britain


  • European starlingBird-brained

    How 60 starlings multiplied into a nightmare flock of 200 million


  • Observatory in Chile with sun in the backgroundStar struck

    Why tourists are flocking to Chile's observatories


BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.