Mark Duggan inquest: Why killing was deemed lawful

Mark Duggan Mark Duggan was shot by police in north London in 2011

The jury at the inquest into the death of Mark Duggan has concluded by a majority of eight to two that he was lawfully killed by police. The inquest raised important questions about the way the police carry out firearms operations on the streets of Britain.

Mark Duggan may have been a gangster in possession of a gun, but that alone would not have made his killing by police lawful.

The law and police guidelines say that an officer can only shoot someone if absolutely necessary, and they honestly believe that person was an imminent threat.

Police witnesses say Mr Duggan was such a threat when they killed him. The officer who shot him, V53, and another officer, W70, standing alongside the first, said that when Mr Duggan got out of the cab he reached toward the waistband of his trousers and pulled out a gun.

A third officer standing behind Mr Duggan said he shouted "he's reaching, he's reaching". After V53 fired a first time, he said he "reassessed", Mr Duggan still had the gun, and he shot him again.

However, the inquest had other evidence to consider. The account above was given by police officers. The inquest heard from only one civilian witness to the shooting itself and he gave a very different account.

"Witness B" said he was watching through the open window of a ninth floor flat on the other side of the road. He described what he saw as "an execution".

Gun disappeared

Mr Duggan was not holding a gun, he said, but a mobile phone. He said Mr Duggan tried at first to run away, but was "trapped", appeared "baffled" and was holding his arms up as if to surrender when he was shot by an officer within five to seven steps of him. But Witness B's evidence was not enough to convince the jury.

Pamela and Mark Duggan Mark was described by his mother as shy when he was younger

The inquest was shown police briefings which said Mr Duggan was a senior member of a gang called Tottenham Man Dem, he had previously been arrested on suspicion of attempted murder and possession of guns, and on the day that he was shot he was being followed by police.

They believed he had collected a gun from another man, Kevin Hutchinson-Foster, and the inquest was told that the aim of the operation was to take that gun off the streets.

As soon as Mr Duggan was shot by police the gun apparently disappeared. One officer at the scene said that even as he fell to the ground, and the officer grabbed his arms, the gun was nowhere to be seen.

Nobody said they saw him throw it, either before or after. Officers said they later found the gun, wrapped in a black sock, some 20ft (6m) away on the other side of some railings.

An independent pathologist said that because of Mr Duggan's injuries it was "very unlikely" - but not impossible - that he would have been able to throw the gun such a distance after he had been shot.

During his summing up, the coroner told the jury the conviction of Hutchinson-Foster for supplying the gun was "not determinative" of Mr Duggan having a gun in the minicab, but it was "very strong evidence".

Lawyers for the Duggan family suggested police had "planted" the gun on the grass after the shooting. That was vehemently denied by the police.

In their findings, the inquest jury decided that the police were right to choose the location they used for the "hard stop" - and they decided by a majority of nine to one that Mark Duggan had thrown the gun way from his minicab before he faced police. They concluded by a majority of eight to two that Duggan was lawfully killed.

Crime scene

The Independent Police Complaints Commission (IPCC) was also scrutinised during the inquest. Because of a lack of resources, the IPCC lead investigator - a former police officer of 30 years' experience - explained that the organisation was reliant on police officers to secure the crime scene.

Jurors visit the scene of the shooting Jurors have visited the scene of the shooting

He admitted he had not known "for some days" that the gun was found 20ft from the shooting and had not been present when the police officers sat in a room together to compose their witness statements.

In the hours that followed the shooting the IPCC was also responsible for making public the most incendiary claim of all - an entirely incorrect suggestion that Mr Duggan had himself fired at police officers.

The IPCC has yet to publish its long-awaited report into the Duggan shooting, but has apologised to his family.

By the time relatives and friends of Mr Duggan arrived to protest at Tottenham police station 48 hours after the shooting, they were angry and suspicious.

They had not been properly notified of Mr Duggan's killing, and had heard conflicting accounts of what had happened. The riots began that night.

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC London

Weather

London

12 °C 6 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    11:43: 'Tore apart' family

    The judge said Muddar deliberately "tore apart" Chowdhury's family by constructing an "extraordinary web of deceit and lies" through alter egos.

    Judge Moss paid tribute to the "courage and personal restraint" of Ayesha's father Afsar Ali who as a witness had to learn the disturbing details of how his daughter died as the case unfolded in court.

    He also highlighted the painstaking police investigation which discovered a situation which could only "astonish and horrify" anyone listening to the trial.

     
  2.  
    11:35: Not delusional

    During the trial, a psychiatrist found Muddar had not been delusional in her actions and understood what she was doing.

    Prosecutor Richard Whittam QC said: "However immoral, abhorrent and illegal her judgment, it was rational... there is no question of either defendant having been mad."

     
  3.  
    11:25: 'Dying inside'

    In this emotional interview, Ayesha's father Afsar Ali said he was "dying inside" over her death.

    Afsar Ali

    The young girl was found dead in her bedroom with more than 50 injuries in east London, in August 2013.

     
  4.  
    11:17: 'Manipulative, wicked woman'

    Jailing Mudder for 18 years, Judge Christopher Moss QC said she bore the lion's share of responsibility for Ayesha's death, describing her as a "manipulative, wicked woman".

    He told Ayesha's mother she had "disgracefully failed" in her fundamental position of trust to keep her daughter from harm.

     
  5.  
    11:16: Child killers jailed

    Muddar also sent Chowdhury more than 40,000 messages which included texts that Ayesha was "evil" and had "bad blood", and repeatedly encouraged her to discipline the child.

    Find out more about their complex relationship and how Ayesha was tortured by the pair.

     
  6.  
    11:11: Child killers jailed

    Ayesha was abused, tortured and killed by her mother who was brainwashed by her sadistic lesbian lover.

    Ayesha Ali

    Their Old Bailey trial had heard how Muddar created a fantasy world of alter egos on Facebook and text message through which she seduced Chowdhury and turned her against her daughter because she saw her as a threat.

     
  7.  
    Child killers jailed BREAKING NEWS

    A mother and her former female lover have been jailed for killing her daughter Ayesha Ali.

    Polly Chowdhury received 13 years and Kiki Muddar was jailed for 18 years after they were both found guilty of manslaughter.

     
  8.  
    11:00: News on the hour BBC London 94.9 Radio

    In the 11:00 bulletin: Fire crews say they're making "good progress" in tackling a large house fire in Bounds Green.

    Firefights at a home in Bounds Green

    More than 30 firefighters are at the scene in Crescent Rise and one person's been treated for the effects of breathing in smoke.

     
  9.  
    10:45: Special delivery Jason Caffrey BBC World Service

    In the mid-1960s, Australian athlete Reg Spiers found himself stranded in London with no money to buy a plane ticket home.

    Box replica

    Desperate to get back to Australia in time for his daughter's birthday, he decided to post himself in a wooden crate.

     
  10.  
    10:29: Gabriel ruled out BBC Sport

    Arsenal defender Gabriel has been ruled out for two to three weeks with a hamstring problem.

    Gabriel was making his second Arsenal start at Loftus Road

    The Brazilian, a £16m signing from Villareal, was injured in Wednesday's 2-1 Premier League win at QPR.

     
  11.  
    10:20: Arrests over cybercrime raids

    The UK's National Crime Agency (NCA) has mounted a "strike week" against suspected hackers resulting in 56 arrests.

    The biggest operation in the week of action involved the arrest of 25 people in London and Essex suspected of using the net to steal money, launder cash and carry out other frauds.

     
  12.  
    10:10: Second bailed in Alan Cartwright murder

    A second person arrested on suspicion of the stab murder of 15-year-old Alan Cartwright in Islington a week ago while he was cycling with friends, has been released on bail.

    Alan Cartwright

    The 21-year-old man arrested on Wednesday has been bailed until April. A 17-year-old was previously released on bail.

    Two 18-year-old men, one of whom was arrested after attending a police station, remain in custody.

     
  13.  
    10:00: News on the hour BBC London 94.9 Radio

    Coming up at 10:00: The charity that runs London's air ambulance says it's raised more than half the £4.4m it needs to buy a second helicopter.

    Find out who has donated in the bulletin.

     
  14.  
    09:51: Oxford St overcrowding London Evening Standard Newspaper

    Scuffles broke out as more than a 1,000 people crammed on pavements at the four entrances to Oxford Circus when gates were closed after a Victoria Line train broke down, causing overcrowding on the platforms below.

    Despite hundreds of angry commuters taking to Twitter to complain about the "insane" crush, TfL bosses insisted the situation was: "nothing out of the ordinary".

     
  15.  
    09:41: Bounds Green fire

    London Fire Brigade tweets: Six fire engines now fighting fire on Crescent Rise in #Bounds Green. One person being treated for smoke inhalation

     
  16.  
    09:30: Restaurants wage crackdown Hackney Gazette Newspaper

    Restaurants have been targeted as part of an ongoing campaign to tackle national minimum wage breaches, with employers found to potentially owe staff more than £300 in unpaid wages.

     
  17.  
    09:19: Population rise through immigration Dominic Casciani Home affairs correspondent

    The population of England has risen by 565,000 since 2011 because of immigration, a study by the University of Oxford has estimated, with two-thirds of those attributed to people from the European Union.

    Migration estimates from Oxford University

    The analysis suggests the greatest change has been in London, with almost 3.2 million people in the capital are now born abroad - 200,000 more than at the time of the last census.

     
  18.  
    09:10: Child killers to be sentenced In court Old Bailey

    A mother from east London who abused, tortured and killed her eight-year-old daughter while under the spell of her lover is due to be sentenced at the Old Bailey later.

    Polly Chowdhury and Kiki Muddar

    Polly Chowdhury and Kiki Muddar were both convicted of the manslaughter of Chowdhury's daughter Ayesha Ali at their home in Chadwell Heath in 2013.

    Ayesha's body had more than 50 injuries including bite marks and carpet burns.

     
  19.  
    09:00: News on the hour BBC London 94.9 Radio

    In the news at 09:00:

    • New research suggests London's migrant population has risen by almost 200,000 since 2011
    • BBC London's discovered a hidden camp underneath flyovers on the North Circular whose only entrance is a ladder in the middle of the road.
    • The government's confirmed drivers will get 10 minutes' grace before being fined if they stay too long in council-owned car parks.
     
  20.  
    08:55: Full forecast via Facebook

    Elizabeth Rizzini has a full forecast ahead of the weekend which you can see on BBC London's Facebook page.

    Elizabeth Rizzini
     
  21.  
    08:45: On air BBC London 94.9 Radio

    BBC London's discovered a hidden camp underneath flyovers on the North Circular that's home to around 20 casual workers from Romania.

    More on what's been nicknamed "The Fortress" with Vanessa Feltz from 09:00.

     
  22.  
    08:37: Wanted man arrested by extradition unit

    The Met Police's extradition unit has arrested a man after appealing for help in finding criminals wanted by authorities across Europe.

    Janusz Kedziora, 28, was held at an address on Staffa Road, Lea Bridge in Waltham Forest on a European Arrest Warrant on Wednesday. He is wanted by Polish authorities for actual bodily harm, criminal damage, robbery, attempted robbery and burglary.

     
  23.  
    08:30: Freemasons pledge £2m

    The London Freemasons have pledged £2m to London Air Ambulance - half the money needed to buy the capital a second emergency helicopter.

    Landing at the British Museum

    London Air Ambulance now has £2.35m left to raise for the Your London Your Helicopter scheme which is hoping to buy the helicopter by the end of the summer.

     
  24.  
    08:19: 'Stunning sunrise'

    Tower RNLI tweets: As the night shift start to hand over to the day shift here it the view we have this morning #Stunning #sunrise

    Sunrise
     
  25.  
    08:12: Queuing traffic BBC London Travel

    On the M11 Southbound traffic is slow between J7 for Harlow and J6 for the M25 following an accident and there's queuing traffic on the A200 Creek Road westbound in Greenwich between the A2211 Greenwich Church Street junction and the Deptford High Street junction due to roadworks.

    For the latest information go to our travel page or follow us on Twitter @BBCTravelAlert.

     
  26.  
    08:07: Dry with some cloud BBC Weather Latest

    It will stay dry for most of today with some cloud at times, but also some sunny intervals. However it will also become windy through the day.

    Maximum Temperature: 12C (54F)

    BBC Weather website graphic
     
  27.  
    08:00: Rebecca Cafe BBC News

    Morning! I'm here until 18:00 bringing you all the latest news, sport, weather and travel for London.

    If you want to contact me with a story, comment or photo email or tweet @BBCLondonNews.

     

Features

  • Replica of a cargo boxSpecial delivery

    The man who posted himself to the other side of the world


  • Cartoon of women chatting on the metroChat wagon

    The interesting things you hear in a women-only carriage


  • Target practice for Lithuanian troopsBaltic shiver

    Europe editor Katya Adler on the alarm at Russian muscle-flexing


  • Ruben ReuterRuben returns Watch

    Child TV star with Down's syndrome on life away from home


Try our new site and tell us what you think. Learn more
Take me there

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.