Mark Duggan inquest: Jury can consider unlawful killing verdict

Mark Duggan The inquest jury has heard that Mark Duggan was a member of a violent gang

The jury in the inquest into the death of Mark Duggan, who was shot twice by police, has been told it can consider an unlawful killing verdict.

Mr Duggan, 29, was killed in 2011 in Tottenham, north London, after police stopped a taxi he was in.

His death sparked riots in the area which later spread to other parts of England.

Judge Keith Cutler said the jury could decide he was either shot lawfully or unlawfully or return an open verdict.

He said the jury should reach a decision "calmly and coolly on the evidence".

'Beyond reasonable doubt'

The judge said: "This is not a trial, it is not a method of apportioning blame on an individual. It's a public method of establishing facts, and getting to the truth."

He said the jury should consider whether Mr Duggan had a gun, whether a gun was in his hand when he was shot and how a gun came to end up in a grassy area near where he was shot.

Jurors were also told they should consider whether the Metropolitan Police and the Serious Organised Crime Agency did "the best they reasonably could have done" to react to the intelligence that Mr Duggan had a gun.

The judge also asked them to consider whether Mr Duggan was stopped by police in a location in which they could have "minimised recourse to lethal force".

He reminded the jury that in order to reach a conclusion of unlawful killing they must be sure, "beyond all reasonable doubt", that Mr Duggan was unarmed.

He said: "You have to be sure that the act was unlawful, that is that it was not done in lawful self-defence, or the defence of another, or to prevent crime."

He said the "balance of probabilities" standard could be used for the other eventualities.

The inquest has heard police believed Mr Duggan was a leading member of the Tottenham Mandem gang.

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC London



Min. Night 11 °C

BBC Local Live

    Fraud gang to be sentenced 16:48:

    A gang of fraudsters from Harrow face jail for stealing an estimated £16m-worth of bank card details from more than 60,000 people in the UK and abroad. Three men and a woman appeared at the Old Bailey for the first of a two-day sentencing hearing after pleading guilty to fraud offences.

    The prosecution said the gang were involved in three stages of fraud - scamming bank card data from cash machines, downloading it onto a computer and then copying the details onto counterfeit plastic cards.

    Haringey ward by-election 16:35:

    Haringey Council will hold a by-election for the Woodside ward on 2 October.

    The by-election will elect one new member to the council following the death of Cllr Pat Egan in July.

    Walthamstow fire 16:25:

    London Fire Brigade tweets: We rescued a pregnant woman and two others from a fire in Walthamstow this morning.

    Wenger anger over red card 16:15:

    Arsenal boss Arsene Wenger was angry with the decision to send off Aaron Ramsey as his side drew at Besiktas in their Champions League play-off.

    Aaron Ramsey walks off after being shown a red card with 10 minutes to go

    "When you see some of the fouls that were made and we go home with Ramsey sent off, it is a bit unbelievable," said Wenger.

    QEII Bridge lanes closed 16:05:

    On the roads, two lanes are closed on the QEII bridge at the A282/ M25 Dartford Crossing because of a broken down lorry.

    On trains, there is disruption on Southeastern between Cannon Street and Broadstairs, between Victoria and Ramsgate, between St Pancras International and Broadstairs and between Cannon Street and Ramsgate due to earlier electrical supply problems at Margate. Get the latest travel information on BBC London travel News.

    News on the hour 16:00:

    The top stories in the capital on BBC London 94.9:

    • The Health watchdog says poor quality critical care and staff shortages need to be tackled in two hospitals run by the North West London Hospitals NHS Trust
    • A group of 25 small businesses and charities in Islington say they will be made 'homeless' as an unintended result of a relaxation in planning laws.
    Pair charged over teen murder 15:50:

    Two men have been charged with the murder of a teenager four years ago. Charlie Wright, 17, of Eltham, was shot in the face at a house in Park Mews, Calvert Road, Greenwich, in April 2010.

    Charlie Wright

    Hassan Hassan. 32, of Vesta Road, Brockley, and Colin Anderson, 48, of no fixed abode, will appear at Bromley Magistrates' Court charged with murder.

    Expanding London 15:40:

    Business leaders in Surrey have backed a suggestion that areas of the county should become part of London.

    Spelthorne Business Forum was part of a campaign to change the name of Staines to Staines-upon-Thames two years ago.

    Now the forum has backed proposals that parts of Surrey closest to London, including Staines-upon-Thames, become part of the capital.

    Have your say 15:27:

    Tell us what you think of BBC Local Live. We'd like your feedback about this service.

    The art of queuing 15:17:

    London burger restaurant Meatliquor has an hour-long queue most nights of the week and UK drivers spend up to three days a year stuck in traffic jams, BBC News's Lucy Townsend asks are queues sometimes unnecessary?

    Silhouette of people waiting in a queue

    "The queue is still a theatrical thing," says Dr Joe Moran, a social historian. "It's tedious but it's the most visibly fair way of rationing a resource. It also makes something look popular."

    Free market pitches 15:07:

    Hackney Council tweets: We're launching an exciting new scheme for first-time market traders where they can pitch for free - pls read here:

    News on the hour 14:57: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    The top story in the capital on BBC London 94.9:

    The health watchdog has criticised staff shortages and highlighted poor quality critical care at Northwick Park and St Mark's hospitals. The two hospitals, operated by the North West London Hospitals NHS Trust, were graded as requiring improvement by the Care Quality Commission. The Trust says improvements are being made.

    Moulin Rouge screening 14:46:

    As part of a three-week series of films screened in Royal Festival Hall, Baz Luhrmann's Moulin Rouge comes to Southbank Centre's Festival of Love this evening.

    Tickets are still available for the event which starts at 19:30.

    Battersea Power station redevelopment 14:35:

    The demolition of the first chimney at Battersea Power station has begun.

    Battersea Power Station

    The company behind the £8bn redevelopment of the building said the decision to dismantle and rebuild the chimneys was taken in conjunction with English Heritage and Wandsworth Council. The 39-acre site will be turned into 3,500 homes, offices, shops and a park.

    HS2: North-south divide? 14:21:

    HS2 - the proposed high speed rail link from London - is supposed to help bridge the North-South divide.

    But the debate surrounding the controversial project has arguably opened up a divide between councils in the north, who welcome the scheme, and those further south which do not.

    Parks facelift 14:11:

    Sutton Council tweets: North Cheam and Worcester Park benefit from £2.4m facelift partially funded by Mayor of London's Outer London Fund

    News on the hour 13:58: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    The top stories in the capital on BBC London 94.9:

    Bike stolen from fundraiser 13:46:

    A £7,000 bike has been stolen from a triathlete who was raising money for charity.

    Paul Nash and his bike

    Fundraiser Paul Nash, 56, of Worcester, was due to take part in an Iron Man race on Sunday in Menorca, when his bike was stolen from the back of his car on 3 August while it was parked in Highbridge Road, Barking, the Met Police said.

    Screening for E.T. fans 13:33:

    Film fans got into the spirit yesterday evening at a screening of E.T. at Somerset House in central London.

    Somerset House screening

    The event was part of the Film4 Summer Screen at Somerset House.

    Burst water main 13:22:

    Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea tweets: Thames Water have closed Dovehouse St at the junction of Fulham Rd due to a burst water main, traffic is being diverted @rbkc

    BBC London News 13:10: Katharine Carpenter Reporter and presenter

    Join us for BBC London News at 13:30 on BBC One, when we'll have the latest on the health watchdog's criticism of North West London Hospitals Trust.

    We'll also be at a service to remember those who died in the Marchioness disaster on the Thames 25 years ago today.

    News on the hour 12:57: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    The top stories in the capital on BBC London 94.9:

    Man on train station roof 12:45:

    A man has been arrested for unauthorised access after he climbed on top of the roof of Liverpool Street Station and refused to move for an hour.

    man sitting on Liverpool Street station

    British Transport Police were called to a reports of a man on the roof at 11:00 and they were helped by the Met Police air support unit, London Fire Brigade and London Ambulance Service. Network Rail said train services were not disrupted.

    Robert Elms 12:31: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    On BBC London 94.9, Robert Elms will be joined by chef Rick Stein who will be talking about his new book Rick Stein's Fish and Shellfish.

    Grammy-nominated singer songwriter MNEK will also be performing live on the show after 14:30.

    £1m fraud charges 12:19:

    Two men from east London have been charged as part of an investigation into a £1m fraud in south-west England.

    Rahim Choudhrey and Abdul Shafee, both 18, of Tower Hamlets, have been charged with 10 counts of conspiracy to defraud victims out of £168,000.

    Paddington delays 12:08:

    London Paddington tweets: Apologies for the continued delays and cancellations to services to/from Paddington due to the earlier freight train failure nr #Reading.

    On air right now 11:59: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    The top local story on BBC London 94.9: A new offence of "domestic abuse" could be created under plans being considered by the government.

    Beyonce in the park 11:49:

    Madame Tussauds has unveiled a new wax figure of the singer Beyonce Knowles in Regent's Park.

    Person takes a picture of new Beyonce waxwork
    Hospital trust criticised 11:40:

    Health watchdog Care Quality Commission (CQC) has criticised staff shortages and highlighted poor quality critical care at hospitals run by a North West London Hospitals Trust.

    Northwick Park and St Mark's hospitals were graded "requires improvement" while the trust's third hospital, Central Middlesex, was rated "good".

    Ticket sales consultation 11:31:

    An independent body representing passengers has launched a consultation into how commuters buy tickets.

    The London Travel Watch questionnaire will form the group's response to London Underground's plans to change the way in which tickets are sold at stations.

    Bromley crime prevention 11:21:

    Bromley MPS tweets: Crime prevention stand at Hoblingwell Wood Lessons Way Orpington. 2pm - 5pm @BromleyYouth #bromleysafertransport

    Marchioness disaster 25 years on 11:09: Andy Dangerfield BBC News Online

    Simon Senior, 20, lived the epitome of cool '80s lifestyle: he modelled for ID magazine, lived with his girlfriend on west London's King's Road and played bass guitar in a band.

    Simon Senior

    He was onboard the Marchioness 25 years ago. 'Fate was against him,' his mother told me. Here's his story.

    On air 10:58: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    The top local story on BBC London 94.9: The Prime Minister is cutting short his holiday and returning to Downing Street where he will discuss an online video purporting to the beheading of an American journalist by a jihadist.

    Secret Cinema new dates 10:50:

    Two new dates have been added for Secret Cinema presents Back to Future after the shows sold out.

    Tickets for the event on 25 and 27 August go on sale at 13:00.

    Marchioness disaster remembered 10:43:

    RNLI tweets: The Marchioness disaster is one of the reasons we now offer our search & rescue service on the Thames.

    Rescue boats
    Pet thefts soar 10:32:

    The Barking and Dagenham Post reports the number of animals reported stolen from Barking and Dagenham more than doubled in the first three months of this year, new figures show,

    Feedback 10:22:

    We've introduced BBC Local Live to bring you the latest news, sport, travel and weather all in one place. Tell us what you think.

    Who started Notting Hill? 10:10:

    Who started the Notting Hill Carnival? Wyn Baptiste investigates the origins of Europe's biggest street party, meeting the key players and pioneers. Watch his exclusive video on the BBC iPlayer.

    iPlayer page for Notting Hill: 1. Who started it
    10:00: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    The top stories in the capital on BBC London 94.9:

    • The Home Secretary, Theresa May, has launched a consultation to look at strengthening the law on domestic violence by creating a specific new offence of 'domestic abuse'.
    • Two men have been charged with the murder of a 17-year-old who was shot dead in south-east London more than four years ago.
    Bank holiday travel 09:54:

    Chiltern Railways tweets: Travelling this bank holiday? Engineering wk is taking place on the Aylesbury via Amersham line. No trains between G Missenden & Marylebone

    M25 delays 09:45:

    On the M25 anticlockwise, one lane is blocked and there is heavy traffic between J11, A317 at Chertsey and J10, A3 at Wisley Interchange, because of an accident.

    For up to date travel news visit BBC London travel News or on Twitter @BBCTravelAlert.

    Watchdog calls for religion evidence 09:40:

    A human rights watchdog has called for evidence about religion in the workplace after a Christian registrar was disciplined by Islington Council for refusing to conduct gay civil partnerships, reports the Islington Gazette.

    Marchioness disaster 25 years on 09:31: Andy Dangerfield BBC News Online

    "The lights went out and we knew water had got into the hull," said Iain Philpott, who was a 26-year-old fashion photographer, from Highbury, north London. "There were lots of screams and next thing, we were all in the water."


    On 20 August 1989, 131 people were on board the Marchioness when it was hit by the dredger Bowbelle, killing 51 people. A memorial service will be held at Southwark Cathedral later to mark the 25th anniversary of the disaster.

    Welwyn North delays 09:20:

    National Rail tweets: UPDATE: Residual delays of up to 15 minutes between Stevenage and London Kings Cross following signalling problems near #WelwynNorth

    Marchioness disaster 25 years on 09:15: Andy Dangerfield BBC News Online

    On August 20, 1989, the Marchioness pleasure boat collided with the dredger Bowbelle and sank in the River Thames, killing 51 people.

    Marchioness The Marchioness collided with the dredger Bowbelle

    Twenty-five years on, survivors and the victims' families recall what happened and the legacy that remains.

    Vanessa Feltz 09:06: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    On BBC London 94.9, Vanessa Feltz discusses Theresa May's plans to create a new domestic abuse crime.

    On air 09:00: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    The top story in the capital on BBC London 94.9: The Home Secretary, Theresa May, launches a consultation to look at strengthening the law on domestic violence by creating a specific new offence of 'domestic abuse'.

    Carnival travel guide 08:54:

    Planning on going to the Notting Hill Carnival this weekend? Here are some road closures you need to be aware of:

    • Sunday from 07:00 until around 23:59
    • Monday from 07:00 until around 03:00 on the morning of Tuesday 26 August

    Road closures will be from:

    • Harrow Hill in the north
    • Notting Hill Gate in the south
    • Clarendon Road in the west
    • Queensway in the east

    For full details visit the Transport for London website.

    Ask the Met boss 08:44:

    Metropolitan Police tweets: Commissioner Sir Bernard Hogan-Howe will be taking your q's from 11:30 today in his Twitter Q&A. What do you want to ask him? #askMetBoss

    Top headlines
    New temple opens 08:34:

    A £20m Hindu temple has opened in north west London, funded entirely by the local community.

    The exterior of the Shree Swaminarayan Siddhant Sajivan Mandal Temple in Kingsbury The Shree Swaminarayan Siddhant Sajivan Mandal Temple in Kingsbury opened on 19 August

    The ornate Shree Swaminarayan Mandir in Kingsbury combines traditional Indian architecture and carvings with "green" technology.

    Queuing traffic 08:25:

    On the M25, one lane is blocked clockwise after J5 Sevenoaks and there are queues from J4 Orpington. In the City, roadworks continue on Lower Thames Street leading to delays westbound along The Highway.

    And a broken down vehicle on the A312 southbound at A4 Jolly Waggoners has led to queues all the way from the Uxbridge Road.

    Train delays 08:14:

    There is some disruption on the Southeastern service due to a line-side fire at Margate.

    And there are delays of about 15 minutes on East Coast and First Capital Connect trains between King's Cross and Stevenage because of signalling problems.

    Get the latest travel information on BBC London travel News or on Twitter @BBCTravelAlert.

    Sunny spells 08:07:

    It will be a mainly dry start, with some good sunny spells during the morning.

    However, some cloud will develop during the afternoon. It will feel rather cool. Highs of 18C (64F).

    08:00: Elaine Okyere BBC London News

    Good morning, I'll be bringing you all the latest news, sport, travel and weather from London today for BBC Local Live.

    You can also send your news, pictures and comments to



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.