Russian court rules 'abducted' children to return to UK

Rachael Neustadt's ex-husband took the boys on holiday last December but refused to bring them back

Related Stories

A north London mother has won a landmark ruling to get her children back from Russia after they were abducted by their father.

Rachael Neustadt, from Hendon, says Ilya Neustadt took their two sons on holiday in December but never returned.

Moscow City Court ruled that Daniel and Jonathan had been illegally kept in Russia in breach of a UK High Court order.

Mrs Neustadt said she was delighted by the ruling.

Missing persons

The court said that five-year-old Jonathan and seven-year-old Daniel should be flown back to London.

Mrs Neustadt, a former teacher from the US, claims that Mr Neustadt, who was a lecturer at London Metropolitan University, ignored repeated requests from judges in England to return their sons.

Interpol also issued missing persons notices for the boys.

The case is the first to successfully use the 1996 Hague Convention on child abduction in England and Russia, which Russia ratified in June and the UK signed last year.

In September, the Russian court told Mr Neustadt to return the two children. He appealed against the decision and lost on Wednesday.

Mrs Neustadt said she had campaigned for the last 11 months to bring her sons home.

"I think that day my heart started racing and it hasn't stopped," she said.

Start Quote

Every day I think what can I do to bring them back.”

End Quote Rachael Neustadt

"Every day I think what can I do to bring them back.

"They liked everything and there's nothing that tells me that why just because they've been given a passport that they are Russians that belong in Russia."

The boys' maternal grandmother, Merry Rapp, has been helping care for the youngest son two-year-old Meir, while Mrs Neustadt fights her legal battle.

"It is very confusing for them," she said.

"They have been told so much that is totally wrong. For example, that your mother no longer loves you. How do you say that and not damage a child? It's not right."

'Hidden problem'

The charity Reunite International, which supports parents, said child abduction was a hidden problem. The group said that its helpline received 8,112 calls last year and the numbers were increasing.

Joanne Orton, the advice line co-ordinator, said: "We had 506 new parental abduction cases reported to us which involved 728 children. We also had 412 new prevention cases involving a further 586 children.

"Travel is easier and cheaper than ever leading to more mixed nationality partnerships than ever.

"Where a relationship has formed with one or both parents originating from a different country to the one they have settled in, if that relationship then breaks down, very often one parent will want to return to the comfort of their family in their native country."

She added that 70% of abductions were carried out by the mother.

"The saddest fact is, that when a child is abducted whilst both parents suffer as a result, ultimately the one person that suffers the most is the child," she said.

Mr Neustadt has said he may appeal against the latest ruling.

He said: "We will finally reach some amicable solution based on compromises and not on possible actions that would be completely against the children's best interests."

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC London

Weather

London

Min. Night 12 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    Signing off 18:00:

    That's all from BBC Local Live for today. We'll be back tomorrow from 08:00 with more news, sport, travel and weather updates from across London.

     
  2.  
    Dry later, chilly overnight 17:57:

    This evening and tonight will continue to be dry with with clear spells and light winds. It will feel chilly with some mist likely to form along the River Thames.

    Minimum temperature: 3C (37F)

     
  3.  
    ‘Human’ burgers in Hoxton 17:53:

    'Human burgers' will be served up to for free on Tuesday 30 September to celebrate the premiere of the fifth season of TV zombie drama The Walking Dead, reports London 24.

    Zombies!

    London-based foodies Messhead have designed a burger "based on tales of cannibalism from the 1920s", and will be dishing it up gratis in a pop-up outlet at Hoxton's Terminus Tavern.

     
  4.  
    First FGM clinic opens in London 17:48:

    Britain's first specialist clinic for child victims of female genital mutilation (FGM) opened in London today.

    The clinic, at University College Hospital, will provide medical and psychological treatment for girls, while doctors will also carry out examinations if the police are not sure if mutilation has occurred.

     
  5.  
    Millwall's Edwards 'serious injury' 17:45:

    Millwall defender Carlos Edwards is set for a lengthy spell on the sidelines after suffering a serious knee injury.

    The 35-year-old was stretchered off during Saturday's 0-0 draw against Championship leaders Nottingham Forest.

     
  6.  
    Evening news 17:42: Riz Lateef Presenter, BBC London

    On BBC London evening news from 18:30, we take a closer look at the same-sex marriages being exploited by criminal gangs to help people dodge immigration controls.

     
  7.  
    Man, 64, 'may be left blind' 17:37:

    A 64-year-old Muslim man, who was beaten as he drove to morning prayers in Kilburn, could be left blind. He suffered a fractured eye socket and severe bruising.

    He has been to visit loved ones abroad to see them for potentially the last time in case he loses his sight after an operation to treat his injuries, Scotland Yard said.

     
  8.  
    Coldplay to open album art show 17:34:

    Pop group Coldplay will open an east London art exhibition called Ghost Stories by acclaimed artist Mila Fürstová, who created all of the artwork for their recent album.

    Chris Martin from Coldplay

    The exhibition in aid of Kids Company will include original etchings that became the album's cover, and will be staged by Album Artists at 17 Osborn Street, in Shoreditch, from 4-7 December.

     
  9.  
    Residents rescued in fire 17:31:

    London Fire Brigade tweets: Firefighters wearing breathing apparatus have rescued 18 people from the high rise fire in #Battersea.

     
  10.  
    Embassies 'avoid business rates' 17:30:

    Dozens of London's foreign embassies are avoiding paying their share for street lighting and cleaning by refusing to pay business rates bills, reports the Evening Standard.

    Fifty-one embassies and diplomatic missions owe £670,000 with the shortfalls being carried by local businesses, says the paper.

     
  11.  
    RMT's Cash elected 17:28: Tom Edwards Transport correspondent, London

    Mick Cash has been elected new RMT General Secretary, replacing Bob Crow who died in March.

     
  12.  
    Battersea high-rise fire 17:24: Nick Beake BBC News Correspondent

    Met police say 10 people suffering minor injuries - being treated at the scene.

     
  13.  
    Lotto winner 'couldn't believe luck' 17:21:

    A roadsweeper raked in £4.5 million on the Lotto, but then went to work because he didn't believe he had won.

    Joseph Whiting

    Joseph Whiting bought his ticket nine minutes before the deadline and checked his tickets at 04:00 the morning after last week's draw, but still turned up to clean the streets in north London. Watch his interview with BBC London.

     
  14.  
    High-rise fire in Battersea 17:16:

    London Fire Brigade tweets: Currently 12 fire engines and around 80 firefighters are at the scene of the high rise fire in #Battersea.

     
  15.  
    Alice Gross search continues 17:10:

    Specialist police teams continued their painstaking search of shallow waterways and riverbanks throughout the day in the hunt for missing 14-year-old Alice Gross and a convicted murderer who is the prime suspect in her disappearance.

    Frogmen and officers wearing forensic suits were examining the River Brent and its banks near Ealing Hospital in west London today, over three weeks since Alice went missing, as police continue their hunt for suspect Arnis Zalkalns.

     
  16.  
    Wedding miracle 17:04: Eddie Nestor Presenter, BBC London 94.9

    On BBC London 94.9 shortly after 17:00, Eddie talks to Irving Caplan, who was confined to a wheelchair but determined to give his daughter a surprise at her wedding - by walking in to the reception wearing a hi-tech exoskeleton.

     
  17.  
    News on the hour 16:58:

    On BBC London 94.9 at 17:00:

    • London's Transport Commissioner has warned bus and Tube fares can't continue to rise at the rate they have and if they do, there could be "social unrest"
     
  18.  
    High-rise fire in Battersea 16:56:

    Eight fire engines and 58 firefighters are attending a fire in a high-rise tower block on Ingrave Street in Battersea.

    Fire crews are tackling a fire affecting part of a flat on the fourth floor, and police have advised drivers to avoid surrounding roads.

     
  19.  
    Air ambulance figures released 16:48:

    London's Air Ambulance crew treated an average of six cyclists per month in the first eight months of this year.

    London's Air Ambulance

    In figures released to coincide with National Air Ambulance week, London's Air Ambulance said it responded to 133 incidents of pedestrians being hit by vehicles from the start of this year till the end of August.

     
  20.  
    Kingston brews up awards 16:41:

    Kingston's best pubs, bars and clubs are jockeying for position in the town's latest Best Bar None awards, which recognise the best staff member, best atmosphere and best on the door, reports Surrey Comet.

    O'Neill's won the best atmosphere prize in last year's awards, while Woody's has snagged best behind the bar for two years running.

     
  21.  
    Air Ambulance call-outs 16:29:

    London's Air Ambulance was called to 282 shootings and stabbings in the first eight months of 2014.

    The E14 postcode area of Tower Hamlets was the busiest area with 27 incidents, while the Muswell Hill area was second, said London's Air Ambulance in figures released to mark National Air Ambulance week.

     
  22.  
    Runner dies after race 16:19:

    A man from Battersea has died in hospital after collapsing while taking part in the Reigate half-marathon in Surrey.

    Reigate Half Marathon

    The man in his 20s was taken ill during yesterday's race, and attempts were made to resuscitate him but he died at East Surrey Hospital.

     
  23.  
    'Breaking Bad inspired murder plot' 16:10:

    A graphic designer attempted to kill her mother by putting poison in a drink in a plot inspired by US TV series Breaking Bad, a court has heard.

    Kuntal Patel, 37, denies trying to murder her "controlling and selfish" magistrate mother Meena by putting abrin in her Diet Coke drink.

    Prosecutors said she was angry that her mother had "forbade" her from marrying her boyfriend.

     
  24.  
    On air 15:59:

    On BBC London 94.9 at 16:00:

    • Police investigating the disappearance of Alice Gross, who's 14, are to ask their Latvian counterparts for more information about their main suspect
     
  25.  
    Industrial action on Tube 15:50:

    The RMT union has instructed its members not to work any overtime on the London Underground from 00:01 on Wednesday morning as it campaigns against staff cuts, leading to the possibility of stations closing if they become unstaffed due to the industrial action.

    Transport for London said it was unable to gauge the affect this would have on its services, although a spokesman said TfL would ensure stations "operate to the best service we can provide".

     
  26.  
    Roman temple reconstructed 15:40:

    Sixty years ago, a Roman God was uncovered at a London building site, and about 400,000 people ended up visiting the excavations for the site uncovered by archaeologists.

    Temple of Mithras

    A huge new office block was being built on the site of the Temple of Mithras, described as the Roman discovery of the century, and the ruins were moved from place but to place for decades - but will now be reconstructed on the spot they were found.

     
  27.  
    Tube staff to strike 15:30:

    The RMT union has confirmed plans to strike on Wednesday, in its "ongoing fight to halt the cuts to jobs and services across the network" being brought in by the London mayor and Transport for London (TfL).

    The strike will start at 00:01 on Wednesday over plans to close ticket offices across the network.

     
  28.  
    'Fowl play' in Bethnal Green flat 15:21:

    Twelve chickens were discovered living in a flat in Bethnal Green and had to be rescued by the RSCPA, reports London 24.

    A member of Tower Hamlets Homes staff spotted the birds while visiting the Collingwood estate - they were found living in the lounge and on the balcony, in contravention of the tenant's housing agreement.

     
  29.  
    Up in the air 15:05:

    Our reporter Andy Dangerfield has been flying with London Air Ambulance this morning, he managed to grab this shot of St Paul's cathedral as the mist cleared.

    St Paul's Cathedral
     
  30.  
    News on the hour 14:55:

    Our latest top local story on BBC London 94.9 is:

    The investigation into the disappearance of London teenager Alice Gross has stretched to Latvia - where it's believed the main suspect could be hiding.

    It's thought Arnis Zalkalns could be in his home country, where he has a conviction for murder.

     
  31.  
    Sunny and dry this afternoon 14:46:

    This afternoon will be fine and dry with some good sunny spells, feeling quite pleasant in the sunshine with light winds.

    Maximum temperature: 19C (66F)

     
  32.  
    Alice Gross: Unfair Met criticism 14:36: Tom Symonds Home Affairs correspondent

    There has been some newspaper coverage suggesting Scotland Yard only contacted Latvian authorities regarding Alice Gross suspect Arnis Zalkalns this weekend, some days after he became a suspect, but this appears not to be correct.

    We've spoken several times to the Latvian police liaison who says the Met contacted police there around a week ago, and Scotland Yard sources say an International Letter of Request to Latvia for formal access to the files in the case was sent on Friday.

     
  33.  
    Alice Gross investigation 14:27:

    BBC News special correspondent Lucy Manning tweets: Police searching river looking for Alice Gross find and remove a knife. Not clear if any way connected to the investigation.

     
  34.  
    Have your say 14:14:

    We've introduced BBC Local Live to bring you the latest news, sport, travel and weather all in one place. Tell us what you think.

     
  35.  
    Alice Gross search continues 13:55:

    Police continued their search in Ealing this morning for missing schoolgirl Alice Gross, who was last seen on 28 August by the Grand Union Canal in west London.

    Alice Gross search

    Officers have formally asked Latvian police for details of the murder conviction of the prime suspect, Arnis Zalkalns, who was jailed for seven years after being convicted of stabbing his wife to death in Latvia.

     
  36.  
    News on the hour 13:50:

    BBC London 94.9's top local story this hour is:

    Darren Johnson from the Green Party at City Hall has told BBC London that as well as new public transport, the capital needs to invest more in cycling and in tackling congestion

     
  37.  
    Armed robbers 'scared off by victims' 13:40:

    Two armed burglars who tried to rob a family of their valuables were chased off empty-handed by their intended victims, reports the Sutton Guardian.

    The hooded men with covered faces were carrying silver hand guns, and broke into the house on Benfleet Close, in Sutton, close to midnight on Saturday, but their intended victims fought back and forced them out of the house.

     
  38.  
    Chinatown sculpture unveiled 13:29:

    A 20ft sculpture has been unveiled in Chinatown's Gerrard Place, commissioned by Chinatown Arts Space and Shaftesbury plc, to help recreate the area as "a creative hub for Chinese & East Asian arts".

    Gerrard Place sculpture

    Entitled Flowing, the sculpture was created by Singaporean artist Chua Boon Kee and is heavily influenced by nature and Eastern philosophy.

     
  39.  
    Enfield's £50m housing project 13:17:

    Enfield Council has announced a new £50m retail and housing development in Ponders End that would provide 88 affordable homes.

    The Electric Quarter Scheme, in Enfield's town centre, will provide an additional 160 homes for open market sale, with work due to start on the scheme in 2015.

     
  40.  
    News on the hour 13:00:

    On BBC London 94.9 at 13:00:

    • Police investigating the disappearance of 14-year-old Alice Gross are to ask their Latvian counterparts for more information about their main suspect, Arnis Zalkalns, who it is suspected could be in his home country
     
  41.  
    Ozil: 'Nothing to prove' 12:37:

    Arsenal playmaker Mesut Ozil says he has nothing to prove to anyone after his Arsenal display this weekend, but accepts he will always be an easy target for the critics.

    Mezut Ozil

    The German World Cup winner gave a commanding display in the 3-0 demolition of Aston Villa on Saturday, scoring the first goal and creating the second for Danny Welbeck, but has been under constant scrutiny since signing for the Gunners in September 2013.

     
  42.  
    Alice Gross: River searched 12:28:

    Two van loads of police are continuing the search for missing teenager Alice Gross at the River Brent in Hanwell.

    Forensic officers are bagging rubbish next to the river as four more policemen search the river bed, more than three weeks after Alice went missing by the Grand Union Canal in west London.

     
  43.  
    Old Oak consultation begins 12:19:

    Transport for London (TfL) has launched its consultation into the Old Oak station planned for west London, which is needed to link the London Overground, Crossrail and HS2 rail services.

    The new connections are needed to support the London Mayor's vision for 24,000 new homes and 55,000 new jobs in west London, with local regeneration expected to open up jobs in the area to 250,000 more people, according to TfL.

     
  44.  
    Walkie Talkie from above 12:07:

    It's National Air Ambulance week, and our reporter Andy Dangerfield has been taken to the skies over the capital by London's Air Ambulance crew.

    Thankfully he remembered his camera...

    Walkie Talkie
     
  45.  
    News on the hour 11:58:

    On BBC London 94.9 at 12:00:

    • Politicians on all sides at City Hall have welcomed a call by London's Transport Commissioner for urgent investment in new buses and train lines and an end to inflation-busting fare rises
     
  46.  
    Travel 'riot' talk 'unhelpful' 11:50:

    Val Shawcross, transport spokesperson for the London Assembly Labour Group, has criticised comments from London's Transport Commissioner suggesting "social unrest" could be caused by low-paid workers being unable to travel to work.

    She called his comment "as incendiary as it is unhelpful", adding: "We get enough bluster from Boris Johnson, what Londoners need is to see action to prevent the transport system becoming overloaded and unaffordable."

     
  47.  
    Friendships 'harder in London' 11:36:

    A survey of Londoners and New Yorkers found meeting people is harder in the British capital than the Big Apple.

    London skyline

    A survey of over 1,000 'young urbanites' in both cities found that three quarters of New Yorkers thought it was difficult to meet people in their city, compared to 80% in London, according to friend-finding network citysocializer.

     
  48.  
    'Illegal immigrants' arrested on M25 11:25:

    Police have arrested 13 suspected illegal immigrants on the M25 after they were seen running from the back of a lorry.

    The suspects were detained between junctions 12 and 13 during rush-hour traffic, said Surrey police.

     
  49.  
    'Fighting dogs' cause playground damage 11:14:

    Enfield Council plans to install CCTV cameras to catch those responsible for "wrecking" a new children's playground installed last month.

    The council said it believes "extensive vandalism" is being caused by "the owners of fighting dogs who are training their animal by making them hang off the equipment by their jaws", and plans to increase guard and police patrols in the area to catch the culprits.

     
  50.  
    Video: London hospital's 'eye bank' 11:07:
  51.  
    News on the hour 10:58:

    On BBC London 94.9 at 11:00:

    • London's Transport Commissioner warns bus and Tube fares can't continue to rise at the rate they have been, and if they do there could be "social unrest"
     
  52.  
    War memorial restored 10:48:

    Locals in Waltham Forest have restored a 'forgotten' war memorial 70 years after residential buildings were destroyed by World War Two bombing, reports the Waltham Forest Guardian.

    In December 1944, six buildings in Walthamstow's Callonfield Estate were destroyed in an attack from the air, but the memorial to residents killed in the attack became neglected for decades on disused land.

     
  53.  
    'More strikes' due for Underground 10:39:

    London Underground workers are due to launch a fresh wave of industrial action in a long-running row over ticket office closures.

    King's Cross

    The RMT union said that despite months of talks with London Underground, the company remained "hell-bent" on carrying out a programme of ticket office closures and job cuts.

     
  54.  
    Lampard love story over - Mourinho 10:29:

    Chelsea boss Jose Mourinho said there was nothing emotional about Frank Lampard's goal against the Blues, and insisted the "love story" finished when the midfielder joined Manchester City.

    The 36-year-old former England international, who left Chelsea in the summer, came off the bench to equalise in the 1-1 draw at Etihad Stadium.

     
  55.  
    Soho 'most expensive for travellers' 10:19:

    Soho is the most expensive London district for travellers to stay in, according to a new survey.

    The average hotel price a visitor needs to pay is higher in Soho than in 19 other London districts, said CheapRooms.co.uk.

     
  56.  
    British Museum recreated for Minecraft 10:09:

    The British Museum in London - complete with all of its exhibits - is to be recreated in the video game Minecraft.

    Artefacts In The British Museum's Winning At The Ancient Games Exhibition The British Museum has a collection of eight million objects

    The project is part of the Museum of the Future scheme, which aims to expand the institution's appeal.

     
  57.  
    News on the hour 09:58:

    On BBC London 94.9 at 10:00:

    • Criminal gangs have started organising gay weddings to help illegal immigrants get a UK passport, according to a BBC investigation
     
  58.  
    Have your say 09:52:

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? We'd like your feedback about this service.

     
  59.  
    Pellegrini criticises 'small team' Chelsea 09:41:

    Manchester City manager Manuel Pellegrini said Chelsea played like a "small team" during yesterday's 1-1 draw and criticised their defensive style.

     
  60.  
    More powers for City Hall? 09:33:

    In the wake of the Scottish "No" vote, devolving more power to Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland has been pushed up the political agenda - so could City Hall and the London Assembly get extra powers?

     
  61.  
    Alice Gross: Police probe suspect's conviction 09:22:

    Police investigating the disappearance of 14-year old schoolgirl Alice Gross will ask their Latvian counterparts for more information about the murder conviction of suspect Arnis Zalkalns.

    Alice Gross

    Officers want to know about the murder of Mr Zalkalns' wife, for which he was found guilty and spent time in prison before coming to the UK.

     
  62.  
    Overcrowding 'could spark riots' 09:08:

    London could see riots again unless more trains and buses are provided at affordable fares for the poorest communities as the population soars, the city's transport commissioner Sir Peter Hendy has told The Guardian newspaper.

    He said the city will face "overwhelming" overcrowding on its congested transport networks by 2030 without urgent progress on new rail lines.

     
  63.  
    News on the hour 08:57:

    On BBC London 94.9 at 09:00:

    • London's Transport Commissioner has warned of Mumbai-style overcrowding if there isn't urgent investment in more buses and trains - and of "social unrest" if people can't afford to use them
     
  64.  
    Alice suspect 'could be in Latvia' 08:47:

    Latvian police have said a convicted murderer wanted over the disappearance of London schoolgirl Alice Gross could be in the eastern European country - but has not entered by plane.

    Arnis Zalkalns

    Arnis Zalkalns has been named as prime suspect in the hunt for Alice, 14.

     
  65.  
    On air 08:38: Vanessa Feltz Presenter, BBC London 94.9

    On BBC London 94.9 from 09:00, Vanessa unpicks claims from the Transport Commissioner that London could see "social unrest" unless more buses and trains are provided at affordable fares. Tell us about your journey to work. Call 020 7224 2000.

     
  66.  
    Gay weddings targeted for UK citizenship 08:27: Zack Adesina BBC Inside Out, London

    Same-sex marriages were made legal in March this year but within weeks of the legislation coming into effect, criminal gangs were touting sham gay weddings to those wanting to dodge immigration controls.

    Gay marriage ceremony

    Inside Out London went undercover to expose the fraud and discovered one gang that organises sham gay marriages for £10,000. Watch the full story tonight at 19:30 on BBC One.

     
  67.  
    as it happened
    • News, sport, travel, weather for Mon 22 Sept
    • More updates from 08:00 on Tuesday
    • Listen to BBC London 94.9
     
  68.  
    Travel 08:18: Louise Pepper Journalist, BBC London

    South West trains are disrupted through Vauxhall after a person was hit by a train.

    On the M1, there are reports of a six-vehicle collision southbound between London Gateway services and Fiveways Corner.

    And there are queues on the A40 eastbound from the M40 at Denham to Gypsy Corner, not helped by a broken down vehicle at Hanger Lane.

    For more travel news, visit BBC London's travel website. or follow us on Twitter @BBCLondonTravel

     
  69.  
    Chilly start, warm later 08:08:

    It will be a fine and dry day with some good sunny spells. After a chilly start it will feel quite pleasant in the sunshine and the winds will turn light by the afternoon. Maximum temperature: 19C (66F).

    Weather chart
     
  70.  
    08:00: Matthew Bell BBC News, London

    Good morning. I'll be bringing you all the latest news, sport, travel and weather from London today for BBC Local Live.

    You can send your news, pictures and comments to london.locallive@bbc.co.uk or on Twitter @BBCLondonNews

     

Features

  • Peaky Blinders publicity shotBrum do

    Why is the Birmingham accent so difficult to mimic?


  • Oliver CromwellA brief history

    The 900 year story behind the creation of a UK parliament


  • Image of Ankor Wat using lidarJungle Atlantis

    How lasers have revealed an ancient city beneath the forest


  • TheatreBard taste? Watch

    Are trailer videos on social media spoiling theatre?


BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.