Duggan inquest: Expert did not consider whether gun was planted

Mark Duggan Mark Duggan was shot dead in Tottenham in August 2011, sparking riots that spread across England

A forensics expert was not asked to consider the possibility that police planted a gun after the shooting of Mark Duggan, an inquest has heard.

Dr Philip Seaman, a ballistics expert, said he had looked at how Mr Duggan might have thrown a gun he was allegedly holding.

The inquest has heard it was "very unlikely" Mr Duggan would have been able to throw the gun 6.1m (20ft).

Firearms officers have said Mr Duggan was shot as they believed he was armed.

He was killed when the taxi in which he was travelling was stopped by armed police in Tottenham, north London, in August 2011, sparking riots across the city.

The disturbances were followed by more disturbances in other English towns and cities.

'Trace evidence'

Michael Mansfield QC, representing the Duggan family, said no witness had said they saw Mr Duggan throwing the gun.

He added that the weapon was found around 6.1m (20ft) from where the 29-year-old was shot, and it was unlikely that Mr Duggan would have been able to throw the gun that far after being shot in the arm and chest by police.

Members of the Duggan family's legal team extended a 4.9m (16ft) tape measure across the courtroom to show how far the gun was found from Mr Duggan.

Leslie Thomas QC, also representing the Duggan family, said it fell short of the distance that Mr Duggan was supposed to have thrown the gun after being shot.

When questioned, Dr Seaman, from Key Forensic Services, said he was unable to comment on the scenario that the police had planted a gun, as the Independent Police Complaints Commission had not asked him to consider this possibility.

He said that if he had been asked to consider the scenario he would have wanted to test the police officers' clothes for "trace evidence".

Dr Seaman agreed with Mr Mansfield that "significant" amounts of police gun residue were found on the front of Mark Duggan's jacket after he was shot, but not on the black sock in which the gun he was allegedly holding was wrapped.

The inquest continues.

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC London



25 °C 16 °C

BBC Local Live

    'Dazzling' war ship 14:11:

    The WWI warship HMS President, one of the last surviving three WWI warships, has had a makeover by artist Tobias Rehberge.


    The artwork, named Dazzle Ship London, has been covered in dazzle camouflage print as part of 14 - 18 Now, a programme of events to mark the centenary of World War I.

    Met's 'Must live in London' job policy 14:00:

    Thanks to Matthew Twyman who emailed london.locallive@bbc.co.uk about the Met Police's new policy to only recruit constables who have lived in London for at least three of the last six years.

    Matthew said: "In view of the high cost of living in London presumably applicants will be required to be living at home with Mum and Dad. The police [will become] another career path subsidised by the bank of Mum and Dad."

    Life sentences over gang feud murder 13:46:

    The Old Bailey heard that Jamie Marsh-Smith, 23, who was known as Freddy after the Nightmare On Elm Street character, was hired to kill Zafer Eren, of the Tottenham Turks gang, by rivals the Hackney Turks.

    Jamie Marsh-Smith

    Marsh-Smith shot dead Zafer Eren as he went into a block of flats in Southgate. He later targeted his getaway driver and co-accused Samuel Zerei who "knew the truth". Zerei the shooting and managed to text his brother to alert him to who had shot him.

    'Sing like a dolphin' 13:31: Mark Savage BBC News entertainment reporter

    London-based Jessie Ware broke through in 2012 with the sumptuous soul of her debut album Devotion.

    Jessie Ware

    As she gears up to release the follow-up, the singer tells the BBC about gaining confidence and her "unique" new vocal style which makes her think she "sings like a dolphin".

    Met's 'Must live in London' job policy 13:22: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    Ken in Haringey told BBC London 94.9: "I've been campaigning for some time to have police in London coming from London.

    "It matters because after 40 years of being a victim of stop and search it's dawned on me that it's because of the culture and difference in our backgrounds.

    "If you're from out of town you may not understand the diversity of the area you're going to police."

    Coming up 13:13: BBC London News TV

    On the lunchtime programme at 13:30 on BBC One: How much disruption will be caused by the closure of Putney Bridge for repairs and the Deputy Mayor for Policing, Stephen Greenhalgh, talks about the Met's new policy to only recruit Londoners.

    Adebayor 'out with Malaria' 13:02:

    Spurs Striker Emmanuel Adebayor will miss Tottenham's tour of North America after being diagnosed with malaria.

    Emmanuel Adebayor of Tottenham

    Adebayor, 30, was admitted to hospital on Saturday with what Spurs describe as a "mild bout" of the disease. He is expected to be released later.

    Double stabbing in Streatham 12:53:

    Police are appealing for witnesses after two men were stabbed multiple times near Streatham Vale junction on Sunday 7 June.

    The police said the victims aged 22 and 24 were chased from their vehicle and stabbed by the suspects who have been described as an Asian male with facial hair and two black males.

    The vehicle they were driving was grey. Anyone with information is urged to contact the police.

    Hirst refuses sale of painting 12:43:

    Artist Damien Hirst has refused to allow one of his early works, painted directly on to wallpaper in a house in London, to be sold.

    Spot painting

    The 1988 spot painting was created for the then homeowner, Jamie Ritblat, as a birthday present and when the house was sold it remained.

    Now new owner Jess Simpson has removed it and wants to sell it, but Hirst's company Science Ltd has said they are the rightful owners.

    On air 12:32: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    On the Robert Elms show: Author Piers Alexander talks about his new book, The Bitter Trade, which looks at 17th Century London and the coffee trade, and musician Ed Rome is in ahead of his new studio album of Old School Reggae and Ska music being released.

    You can listen live on BBC London 94.9 and contact the team on 020 7224 2000.

    Met's 'Must live in London' job policy 12:19:

    Thanks to Denise Rees who emailed london.locallive@bbc.co.uk about the Met Police's new policy to only recruit constables who have lived in London for at least three of the last six years.

    Denise said: "You must include people from regions of the north. Only inclusion of the whole country will truly represent a whole nation."

    Life sentences over gang feud murder 12:13:

    A man has been sentenced to life imprisonment for the murder of Tottenham Turks boss Zafer Eren and the two attempted murders of the convicted's accomplice and his co-defendant.

    Zafer Eren

    Jamie Marsh-Smith, 22, must serve a minimum of 38 years in prison. Samuel Zerei, Marsh-Smith's targeted accomplice, was also sentenced to 28 years for the murder of Mr Eren. More soon on bbc.co.uk/london.

    Tulisa's co-defendant pleads guilty 12:03:

    Michael Coombs, known as rapper Mike GLC, has pleaded guilty at Southwark Crown Court to supplying cocaine to an undercover reporter from the Sun on Sunday.

    Former X Factor judge Tulisa Contostavlos, who is due to stand trial, denies being concerned in brokering the drug deal.

    Rubbish skyscraper 11:55:

    According to Time Out London, Paris-based architects Chartier-Corbasson want to build a skyscraper made out of people's rubbish, such as plastic bottles and recyclable goods, in Shoreditch.

    Top-eight tennis finals 11:45:

    Rafael Nadal has joined Novak Djokovic in qualifying for the end-of-season Barclays ATP World Tour Finals in London.

    Rafael Nadal

    The tournament, held at the O2 Arena from November 9-16, features the best eight players of the year. The remainder of the line-up is yet to be decided.

    Your views: Met's job policy 11:35:

    The Metropolitan Police will recruit new constables exclusively from London as the force attempts to reflect the capital's cultural diversity.

    From August the Met will only recruit constables who have lived in Greater London for three of the last six years.

    What do you think? You can email london.locallive@bbc.co.uk with your thoughts.

    No pink tutus 11:26: Andy Dangerfield BBC News Online

    Jean-Claude Van Damme, Rio Ferdinand and Christian Bale may not sound like your typical pink tutu-wearing ballerinas. That's because they're not.

    But all three have taken ballet classes in the past and are role models for pupils at the London Boys Ballet School in Islington.

    Your views 11:15:

    We've introduced BBC Local Live to bring you the latest news, sport, travel and weather all in one place. Tell us what you think.

    'Amazing' London skyline 11:04:

    Captain Dude, a London Air Ambulance pilot, tweets: Photo doesn't do it justice but amazing visibility over #London today.

    London skyline
    Met's 'Must live in London' job policy 10:50: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    Maddy in Fulham said: "I think it's absolute tosh. London isn't full of Londoners, London is full of foreigners, I was born and raised in Derby and most of my friends came here via university."

    "London is full of people from everywhere, so why can't they reflect that?"

    Petition over farm plans 10:42:

    A petition has been started by some Harrow residents against the council's plans to transform Pinner Park Farm into a country park with housing, according to the Harrow Times.

    'Dead' parrot unveiled 10:34:

    A giant "dead" parrot measuring 15 metres has been unveiled on London's South Bank to promote the live broadcast of the final Monty Python Live stage show this Sunday.

    Dead parrot sculpture

    A team of three sculptors spent more than two months creating the homage to the famous Norwegian Blue after the dead parrot was voted the nation's favourite Monty Python sketch in a survey by TV channel Gold which will broadcast the show.

    Met's 'Must live in London' job policy 10:24:

    The Met's new policy requiring job applicants to have lived in the city for at least three years comes into effect on 1 August and will be the first time the force has hired exclusively from London.

    Mayor Boris Johnson says it will mean the goal of taking 5,000 new officers in the next two years can be achieved more quickly.

    Man dies after suspected fight 10:15:

    A man has died after police were called to a fight on Coniston Road in Bromley at about 20:54 last night.

    It is believed the man died from stab injuries although a post-mortem examination is due to take place later, Scotland Yard said.

    Women bishops? 10:05:

    The Church of England will decide later whether to allow women into its top ranks as bishops after a crucial vote on the issue was blocked in 2012.

    Justin Welby and the Reverend Canon Philippa Boardman, at a service at St Paul's Cathedral in May to celebrate the 20th anniversary of ordination of women as priests

    Rev Jody Stowell, from Harrow, said lots of work had been done since 2012 to "improve relationships" between those with differing opinions and there would be "utter outrage" if the General Synod rejects the legislation.

    Garden search for human remains 09:57:

    Police have started a search for human remains in an Islington garden after receiving a tip-off in July.

    The allegations that human remains may be buried in Searle Place go back 30 years and do not relate to the current occupiers of the property, Scotland Yard said.

    Trains suspended 09:49:

    BBC London Travel tweets: First Great Western - A signalling problem between Twyford and Reading means trains are now suspended between Reading and Paddington.

    M25 delays 09:37:

    On the M25, there is slow traffic anticlockwise at J4, A21 (Orpington), because of an accident involving van and two cars and recovery work.

    For travel updates on twitter, follow @BBCTravelAlert.

    Met's 'Must live in London' job policy 09:27: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    Scotland Yard has announced a new recruitment policy which stipulates any job candidates must have lived in London for at least three of the last six year.

    'Northern' Mike who has worked in both North Yorkshire and London said: "In principle I actually agree with this, I think the police in London should represent the people that it's actually policing."

    London Broncos relegated 09:18:

    The London Broncos have been relegated from the Super League.

    London Broncos

    The teams' relegation was confirmed by Sunday's 72-12 loss to Warrington.

    'Missing' dementia diagnoses 09:10:

    Two thirds of dementia sufferers in Havering have not been diagnosed, according to a new report by regulators Healthwatch.

    According to the Romford Reporter, the reports states that there should be about 3,000 people with a formal diagnosis but only 1,000 have been so diagnosed.

    The "missing" 2,000 should be identified quickly", it stated.

    Swan upping starts 08:59:

    Today marks the start of swan upping - the annual census of the Thames' swan population.

    Swan upping

    The tradition, which sees all swans and cygnets caught, measured and tagged, dates back to the 12th Century.

    Bike rack closure 08:48:

    London Victoria station tweets: The old bike racks on platforms will close today. Please relocate your bike to the new racks at the front of the stn & in the car park above

    On air from 09:00 08:41:

    Vanessa Feltz will be talking about the Met's new recruitment policy which means candidates will have to have lived in the city for at least three of the last six years to work for the force.

    Scotland Yard said the criteria would help ensure the force is more reflective of the diverse city.

    You can listen live on BBC London 94.9 and contact the team on 020 7224 2000.

    Met's 'Must live in London' job policy 08:30:

    Anyone wanting to apply to the Metropolitan Police for a job will have to have lived in London for at least three of the last six years, under Scotland Yard's new policy.

    Sir Bernard Hogan Howe

    Commissioner Sir Bernard Hogan-Howe said the plan is to make Scotland Yard "more reflective of the city that it serves".

    Traffic jams 08:21: Louise Pepper Journalist, BBC London

    There are traffic jams on the A3 Northbound to Wandsworth Bridge and on Castelnau in Barnes heading towards the Hammersmith Bridge because of Putney Bridge being closed for repairs.

    For further travel updates visit the BBC London travel website.

    Putney Bridge closes 08:13:

    A bridge over the Thames in south-west London has closed to all traffic for three months as it undergoes repairs.

    Putney Bridge

    Putney Bridge closed to motor vehicles earlier on Monday and is expected to reopen in October.

    Dry and sunny morning 08:02:

    After a dry and sunny morning across the area, cloud will increase from the west during the afternoon but it should remain dry into the early evening. Maximum temperature: 25C (77F).

    Good morning 08:00: Beth Rose BBC News

    I'll be guiding you through BBC Local Live today, bringing you the latest news, travel, weather and sport from across London.

    Get in touch with your comments and photos by emailing london.locallive@bbc.co.uk.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.