London woman challenges stop-and-search powers in court

A woman who was subjected to a search after failing to pay a bus fare in north London is seeking a judicial review of stop-and-search powers.

Ann Juliette Roberts, 39, was arrested and handcuffed when she resisted the search in Haringey in September 2010.

Her barrister told the Court of Appeal the powers were used disproportionately against black people.

The bus route was "a hotspot" for knife crime and the search had nothing to do with race, the QC for the police said.

Mrs Roberts, who is of African-Caribbean heritage and lives in Upper Edmonton, was on the 149 bus route when she was searched for not paying the fare and behaving suspiciously, the court heard.

Race 'completely irrelevant'

Hugh Southey QC, representing the appellant, told the judges that official statistics showed the searches were "without adequate justification" and were violating Article 14 of the European Convention on Human Rights - which prohibits racial discrimination.

Lord Justice Maurice Kay, Lady Justice Rafferty and Lady Justice Macur were being asked to overturn a previous application for a judicial review which was rejected by the High Court .

Jeremy Johnson QC, representing the police commissioner, said the bus route was known to be used by gang members in the area and hence was "a hotspot" for knife crime, which meant police carried out stop-and-search operations to prevent further violence.

No weapons were found on Mrs Roberts after she was arrested for obstructing the search and a caution for the incident was later quashed, the court heard.

Mr Johnson said: "The fact that she was black was completely irrelevant to the decision to search her.

"She was searched because she had failed to pay her fare, she had been caught, she had lied, she was acting in a suspicious manner, she was in a place which was a hotspot for the the carriage of weapons, and the officer thought she might be concealing a weapon."

Mr Southey said: "She comes from a community scarred by knife crime. However, she also knows communities need to have faith in the way the police operate.

"That is why it is important for her to ensure proper safeguards are in place and to ensure proper justification when these powers are used."

The three judges have reserved their judgment on Mrs Roberts's application for a declaration that random searches under section 60 of the 1994 Criminal Justice and Public Order Act violated the human rights of black people.

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC London

Weather

London

26 °C 16 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    Robert Elms show 12:14: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    On the show today, author Alex Daley talks about his new book 'Fighting Men of London' which explores the lives of seven former professional boxers who fought in London between the 1930s and 1960s. The author is a grandson of 1920s boxing legend Nipper Pat Daly.

    And Adam Cohen will play live with his band from his new album 'We Go Home'.

     
  2.  
    Secret Cinema screenings to begin 12:09:

    Secret Cinema's screenings of Back to the Future are to begin in London tomorrow, one week late.

    Secret Cinema's clock tower Twitter user @AntipodeanMs posted an image appearing to show an unfinished clock tower

    Organisers were forced to cancel the opening week of screenings because they could not meet technical requirements to satisfy local authorities. For the event, elaborate sets were built featuring replicas of buildings from the 1985 film and there are plans for live performances using around 80 actors.

     
  3.  
    News on the hour 11:59:

    The top headlines on BBC London 94.9 at midday

    • Rolf Harris's sentence for sexual offences will not be referred to the Appeal Court to decide if it was unduly lenient
    • Two senior journalists at the News of the World are to be charged with phone hacking
    • The High Court has thrown out Arsenal's bid to double the number of concerts allowed to be staged at the Emirates Stadium
     
  4.  
    Transport plans for 2050 11:54:

    The London Infrastructure Plan 2050 tackles the issue of growing demand for transport with a projected 70% increase in rail capacity, plus:

    • A new four-runway hub airport to the east of London
    • Up to 36 trains per hour on some Tube lines
    • Crossrail 2 by 2030
    • Extending the Bakerloo line
    • New East-London river crossings
    • A South London Metro
    • An inner orbital road tunnel
    • 200km of new cycle highways
     
  5.  
    London Bridge delays warning 11:45:

    Croydon commuters travelling to or through London Bridge are being warned to expect severe delays and disruption at the end of August, reports the Croydon Advertiser.

     
  6.  
    The story of London Jack 11:40: Justin Parkinson BBC

    London Jack, a black retriever, has spent almost a century collecting money for charities - eight of those while he was living and a further 83 years as a stuffed corpse.

    London Jack - 1894-1900 Waterloo Station The original London Jack collected at Waterloo Station between 1894 and 1900

    The dog patrolled London's Waterloo Station and was one of a number of celebrity dogs (including Brighton Bob, Bruce of Swindon and Chelmsford Brenda), who raised thousands of pounds from the mid-Victorian era until the 1950s. London Jack now resides in a glass display case at the Bluebell Railway museum in East Sussex.

     
  7.  
    London in 2050 11:31:

    The London Infrastructure Plan 2050 considers the challenges the capital will face by the middle of this century.

    • Demand for public transport to increase by 50%, with demand for Tube and rail services up by 60% and 80% respectively
    • Demand on energy supplies set to rise by 20% and demand on electricity supplies to more than double
    • Need for water will exceed supply by 10% by 2025, rising to 21% by 2040
    • More than 600 new schools and colleges needed
    • Around 50,000 new homes a year must be provided
    • With Heathrow already operating at 98.5% of its capacity, a new four runway hub airport in the Thames estuary will be needed
     
  8.  
    London's needs in 2050 11:21:

    London's mayor has unveiled the London Infrastructure Plan 2050, which looks at what the capital needs to have in place over the next few decades as the population is expected to reach 11 million, a 37% rise since 2011.

    Boris Johnson, said: "This plan is a real wake up call to the stark needs that face London over the next half century. Without a long term plan for investment and the political will to implement it this city will falter."

     
  9.  
    VIDEO: Charge on diesel cars 11:07:

    As we reported yesterday, plans to charge drivers of diesel cars about £10 to drive into central London to tackle high levels of air pollution, are being considered.

    Drivers in London could be charged up to £10 on top of the congestion charge.

    If you missed it, watch BBC London transport correspondent Tom Edwards' report.

     
  10.  
    News on the hour 10:58:

    The top headlines on BBC London 94.9 at 11:00

    • Hospital demo: Campaigners rallying against plans to sell part of Charing Cross Hospital
    • Bank bonuses: Bankers found guilty of recklessness could be asked to pay back rewards
    • Ebola warning: Government chairing COBRA meeting over threat to the UK
     
  11.  
    Undercover officers sex claims 10:47:

    The Met has agreed to reveal whether two men had relationships with women while working as undercover police officers.

    It has so far refused to say whether the men worked for police because of a general policy of keeping identities of undercover officers secret. The officers were known by the aliases "Jim Sutton" and "Bob Robinson".

     
  12.  
    Video: Teetotaller's hospital 10:37:

    For hundreds of years alcohol was widely used in medicine, both as a therapy in its own right and as well as a carrier for other substances.

    The former National Temperance Hospital

    But in 1873, a group committed to removing alcohol from medicinal practice set up the London National Temperance Hospital. Despite it closing in 1990 the BBC's Neil Bowdler looks at its work, its legacy and the future of the building.

     
  13.  
    Bethnal Green fire 10:28:

    London Fire Brigade tweets: The fire on Pott St in #BethnalGreen is now under control. Thankfully there are no reports of any injuries.

     
  14.  
    Clawback plan for bank bonuses 10:22: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    Thanks for your comments on Vanessa Feltz's Facebook page on the Bank of England's plan penalise rule-breaking bankers who could be asked to return bonuses from up to seven years ago.

    Hilary Keren said: "I'd put money on the fact that it will never happen. Ironic really..."

    While Lance Pearce asks: "Is this a trick question?"

     
  15.  
    Bethnal Green flat fire 10:13:

    London Fire Brigade tweets: We're tackling a flat fire on Pott Street in #BethnalGreen. Part of a ground floor flat is alight. Around 50 people have left the block.

     
  16.  
    War Memorial damaged 10:09:

    Lewisham MPS tweets: The War Memorial on Lewisham Way jw Upper Brockley Road was criminally damaged last night. If you have any info pls call 101. #SgtBiddle

    Cleaning up the memorial Cleaning up the damage to the War Memorial
     
  17.  
    News on the hour 09:58:

    The top local headlines on BBC London 94.9 at 10:00

    • HSBC bank: Muslims' bank accounts closed
    • Ebola warning: Government warns of outbreak
    • Driverless cars: Vince Cable to announce first trials
     
  18.  
    On this day 09:45:

    A little known fact - on this day in 1966, England won the World Cup at Wembley Stadium by beating West Germany 4-2 in extra time.

    The England team raise the Jules Rimet trophy The England team raise the Jules Rimet trophy
     
  19.  
    Mental health services cut 09:38:

    There are plans to close mental health services at Queen Mary's Hospital in Roehampton, which treats 500 patients a year, Wandsworth Guardian reports.

    The cuts are part of a proposal to centralise mental health services at Springfield University Hospital, Tooting, and Tolworth Hospital, Kingston.

     
  20.  
    Injuries in subway crash 09:29:

    Two people were taken to hospital after a car crashed into railings and ended up in the entrance of a subway at the Elephant and Castle roundabout, south-east London.

    Elephant and Castle crash

    A London Ambulance Service spokesperson said: "Our staff treated two patients for minor injuries - a man aged about 30 for an arm injury and a woman believed to be in her 20s for a facial injury - and both were taken to St Thomas' Hospital."

     
  21.  
    Charing Cross Hospital sale protest 09:20:

    Protesters will demonstrate in Hammersmith this morning against plans which could lead to more than half of Charing Cross Hospital being sold off.

    Under the plans, the current Charing Cross building would be replaced with a new development along with new facilities at St Mary's in Paddington.

     
  22.  
    Muslim bank accounts closed 09:12:

    HSBC has written to Finsbury Park Mosque and other Muslim organisations and individuals to tell them their accounts will be closed.

    HSBC sign

    The bank has denied discriminating on the grounds of race or religion saying that would be immoral, unacceptable and illegal, but said it was because the accounts fell outside its "risk appetite".

     
  23.  
    News on the hour 09:00:

    The top headlines on BBC London 94.9 at 09:00

     
  24.  
    Sexism at work 08:55: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    On Vanessa Feltz's show after 09:00, the Ebola outbreak in Africa is a 'potential major threat' to us in the UK, says Foreign Secretary. Are you worried?

    And, have you been mistaken for the tea lady? We are talking about sexism at work.

    Call 020 7224 2000 or text 81333, starting your message with 'London', to share your views.

     
  25.  
    Blackout London 08:45:

    Boris Johnson claims London could face future power blackouts as the population continues to rise.

    Later, he will launch a consultation into how to meet London's demand for electricity over the next 50 years and is calling for more than £200m investment in the capital's sub-stations, which he says are already at full capacity.

     
  26.  
    Top headlines
     
  27.  
    Elephant & Castle subway crash 08:32:

    A driver walked away with minor injuries after his car crashed and fell in to the entrance of a south-east London subway.

    Elephant and Castle crash

    The car left the road at about 20:00 last night and went into the subway at the Elephant and Castle roundabout, Scotland Yard said. These great photos come courtesy of Chris Hawkswell.

     
  28.  
    Lorry fire delays 08:24:

    Traffic on the M25 anticlockwise is down to two lanes, just past the Clacket Lane Services, following a lorry fire earlier. There are also clockwise delays from J4 Orpington towards the services as drivers slow down to look.

    There are northbound delays at Kew Bridge for the South Circular and northbound queues at Battersea Bridge, which is partly due to the ongoing closures at Putney Bridge and the Hogarth Flyover.

    For the latest information go to BBC London's travel page or on Twitter @BBCTravelAlert.

     
  29.  
    Signal problems 08:15:

    On the Tube, there are severe delays on the Circle and Hammersmith and City lines following an earlier a signal failure at Baker Street.

    Greater Anglia services in and out of Liverpool Street via Ipswich are also disrupted following signal problems.

    And signal problems are also leading to delays on South West trains heading out of London via Southampton.

     
  30.  
    Weather 08:08: Kate Kinsella BBC Weather, London

    Dry and fine with plenty of sunny spells. Feeling just a little fresher but still warm with a max of 26C (79F).

     
  31.  
    08:00: Debabani Majumdar BBC London News

    Good morning. I'll be guiding you through BBC Local Live today, bringing you the latest news, travel, weather and sport from across London.

    Get in touch with your comments and photos by emailing london.locallive@bbc.co.uk.

     

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.