Chase Farm Hospital closures bid gets legal challenge

Chase Farm Hospital protesters The Save Chase Farm Campaign Group has been opposing merger proposals

Related Stories

Enfield Council in north London has said it will seek a judicial review against the decision to close maternity and A&E units at Chase Farm Hospital.

The local NHS Clinical Commissioning Group (CCG) announced the labour ward will close in mid-November and the A&E will close on 9 December.

The services will move to Barnet and North Middlesex hospitals, where new midwife-led units are being developed.

The council said it was a "grave breach" of residents' expectations.

The changes are part of a plan which was given approval by former health secretary Andrew Lansley to reorganise hospital services.

The plans, which have been under discussion for several years and will see the hospital now focussing on non-emergency care, have faced strong opposition from health campaigners, GPs and the council.

'More senior doctors'

Enfield Council leader Doug Taylor said: "For many years the people of Enfield have been assured that improvements to primary care would be in place before the closure of the A&E and maternity services at Chase Farm Hospital.


So, after nearly a decade, it seems the future of Chase Farm has been settled.

Local GPs have said the long-planned closure of its A&E and maternity units can go ahead.

It could put to bed a story that started back in 2004 with a document called "Healthy Hospitals".

When the A&E closes for the last time on 9 December it will mark the end of a process that has seen mass demonstrations, legal challenges, political campaigns and referrals to a number of NHS bodies.

If ever you wanted an example of how hard change can be in the health service, Chase Farm is it.

It will be an argument played out again and again across London in the months ahead.

And like many of those arguments it may yet face a court challenge.

So, after a decade, the final chapter may not yet have been written.

"The CCG's decision to go ahead without these promises being fulfilled is a grave breach of our residents' legitimate expectations."

He said the CCG had ignored several preconditions set down by the government as far back as 2008, and the decision to close the services without meeting those conditions was unlawful.

"These conditions required that a number of new sites were to be developed to provide improved primary care services to the people of Enfield before the A&E and maternity departments could be closed.

"There are also a number of other conditions relating to the provision of services by GPs which should have been fulfilled before closure."

Mr Taylor said he had written to Health Secretary Jeremy Hunt "urging him to halt proceedings until our concerns are addressed".

But the CCG said the decision on the timing of the closures was founded on robust, clinically-led decision making.

Liz Wise, chief officer for Enfield CCG and senior responsible officer for the Barnet, Enfield and Haringey clinical strategy, said: "Changes under the strategy mean more senior emergency doctors in A&E, better maternity care in modern labour wards and improved children's inpatient services.

"We have always said changes will only be implemented when we have assurances that safe, high quality services can be provided for the local population. These assurances have been met, and I am pleased the decision has been made to press ahead."

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC London



Min. Night -2 °C


Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.