London councils head list of parking charge surpluses

 

Motorists give their views on parking charges in Westminster and elsewhere

Related Stories

Parking charges are providing huge cash surpluses for some English councils, according to the RAC Foundation.

The 359 councils across England had a total current account surplus of £565m from on and off-street parking schemes in 2011-12, according to the figures.

Eight of the biggest 10 surpluses came from London councils with Westminster leading the way with a £41.6m profit.

Westminster City Council disputed many of the figures but said it would work with motorists to reduce fines.

The other two councils outside London making the top 10 were Brighton and Hove in sixth with £14.4m and Cornwall in eighth with £7.9m.

The total profit represented a £54m increase on the surplus from 2010-11 and only 52 of the councils reported a deficit on their 2011-12 parking operations.

The RAC Foundation figures, produced for them by transport consultant David Leibling, are from the annual returns councils are required to provide to the Department for Communities and Local Government.

They are based on three factors - on-street parking charges, off-street parking charges and parking penalties.

Running costs of parking operations are deducted from this total to produce the surplus or deficit figure.

Top 10 parking surpluses

  • Westminster £41.6m
  • Kensington and Chelsea £28.1m
  • Camden £25m
  • Hammersmith and Fulham £19.5m
  • Wandsworth £16.1m
  • Brighton and Hove £14.4m
  • Islington £10.9m
  • Cornwall £7.9m
  • Newham £7.3m
  • Hounslow £7.3m

Source: RAC Foundation. Figures for 2011-12

Tackling congestion

Transport minister Norman Baker said: "The law is quite clear. Councils should not be pricing their parking in order to make a profit.

"Any monies raised from parking in excess of the cost of administration has to go back to transport purposes which can be dealing with potholes, improved road management or can be investing in public transport to encourage people to free up the roads.

Subtracting the money spent by councils on capital projects - such as fixing potholes or traffic schemes - the surplus for 2011-12 stands at the "still very large figure" of £412m, a spokesman for the RAC Foundation said.

Details of what the money is spent on is not provided to the Department for Communities and Local Government, he added.

While disputing some of the figures, Westminster City Council still signalled its intention to work with road users to reduce fines.

Local Government Association's David Sparks: "Local authorities are reviewing their parking charges"

Councillor Daniel Astaire, Westminster City Council cabinet member for business, said: "The system is already changing and councils are already looking to work with motorists to issue fewer fines and crucially increase the amount of people parking correctly.

"Parking is about traffic management, tackling congestion and trying to implement positive benefits for businesses and high streets.

"If we stay in this Jurassic age of pure rhetoric about cash cows and money making, innovation will be stifled and we cannot engage with motorists properly in order to find the best solutions that will benefit everyone."

Kensington and Chelsea Council made the second biggest surplus of £28.1m and a spokesman told BBC London: "There is a greater demand for parking spaces in Kensington and Chelsea than practically anywhere else in the country.

"The council has discretion on how to spend any surplus that may arise, within the allowable purposes provided for by Section 55 of the Road Traffic Regulation Act 1984."

Professor Stephen Glaister, from the RAC Foundation: "Temptation to ramp up charges to pay for general council budget"

Havering Council had the second lowest figures in London, despite its surplus of £703,000 having gone up by £563,000.

A spokeswoman said: "These latest figures show our commitment to giving residents and visitors to the borough value for money, as well as showing our support for local high streets and as a result the wider economy.

"Despite being the third largest London borough, parking charges in Havering are still among the lowest in London and have stayed the same for several years. But in April this year, we cut prices even further."

'Cash cow'

Councillor Peter Box, chairman of the Local Government Association's economy and transport board, said: "Parking revenue is spent on paying for parking services.

"Any money left over goes towards transport services like filling potholes, concessionary travel and road improvement projects.

Is technology the answer to London's parking problems? BBC London's Tom Edwards finds out

"As the report makes clear, many councils have to subsidise parking services as the cost is not covered by charges.

"Parking charges and fines help councils keep traffic flowing and pedestrians and motorists safe."

On Wednesday, government figures showed that money made from parking charges and fines by English councils is set to continue to rise.

The councils expect that net income from parking services is likely to increase from £601m in 2012-13 to £635m in 2013-14.

Local Government Secretary Eric Pickles said: "This municipal parking profit shows why we need to review and rein in unfair town hall parking rules. The law is clear that parking is not a tax or cash cow for town hall officers."

Last week, the High Court ruled against Barnet Council's move to raise the cost of residents' parking permits in a landmark victory for campaigners.

Mrs Justice Lang ruled that the council acted unlawfully when it increased permit costs to generate more money for road maintenance.

 

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

Comments

This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    +22

    Comment number 685.

    I just can't believe, with the imminent demise of town centres, that councils think charging car drivers is a wise move. No wonder people go to out-of-town 'Malls'. Illegal parking is one thing but charging people silly amounts of money simply to leave their car is going to speed up the death of shopping in towns. Might as well knock them all down and make car parks... oh, the irony!

  • rate this
    -34

    Comment number 632.

    While and I like admire Mr Pickles, I think if the councils have to charge what they are to deter inconsiderate parking then making a surplus is a good thing. I agree that council's prime motive in making parking restrictions and setting fines should not be for revenue, but in most cases I don't think it is.

  • rate this
    +15

    Comment number 631.

    I have no issue with sensibly enforced parking regulations, especially if the proceeds are reinvested to provide better public transport and repairing the roads. Unfortunately I doubt this is the case and that it just goes towards some councillors 'bun fight'

  • rate this
    +19

    Comment number 629.

    Parking fines are a cash-cow - we should do away with private car-parking companies, revert to Traffic Wardens only (who have no financial incentive to issue tickets) and stop this business which is out-of-control.

  • rate this
    +51

    Comment number 502.

    I avoid whenever possible going somewhere that I am required to pay to park in order to shop, especially the extortionate rates charged in some places. I am certainly not alone in this and so the high streets continue to die and the politicians wonder why.

 

Comments 5 of 13

 

BBC London

Weather

London

Min. Night 16 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    Baby shaking acquittal 16:22:

    Allan Young, the 36-year-old who was today acquitted of manslaughter, was unemployed and living with his partner Erica Francis in Belsize Road, north-west London, when he shook his five-week-old baby Michael Winn early on 16 April 1998, the Old Bailey heard.

    Allan Young

    Upon waking later that day, Miss Francis, then 17, noticed Michael had become "all floppy" and had "staring eyes that did not focus", prosecutor Zoe Johnson QC said.

     
  2.  
    Hounslow holds rowing taster sessions 16:17:

    The University of London Boathouse in Hounslow is running rowing taster courses throughout August.

    Hounslow offering rowing taster sessions throughout August

    Taster sessions are free for local residents and £25 for people from outside the area.

     
  3.  
    Train disruption 16:10:

    There's disruption on First Great Western trains between London Paddington and Reading due to person being hit by a train at Ealing Broadway.

    It is affecting all services to and from London Paddington towards Oxfordshire. There's no estimate for when normal service will resume.

     
  4.  
    Yarde embraces Quins move 16:06:

    England winger Marland Yarde says he expects his move to Harlequins will help him develop as a player, as he plays alongside team-mates who he says are "building the spine of the England team at the moment".

    New Harlequins signing Marland Yarde

    The 22-year-old started all three Tests against New Zealand last month and has joined Quins from London Irish on a two-year deal.

     
  5.  
    News on the hour 15:59:

    On BBC London 94.9 at 16:00:

     
  6.  
    Londoner faces Games pass theft trial 15:45:

    A man from London is to stand trial on suspicion of stealing a Commonwealth Games accreditation pass.

    Eric Noubayo, 36, allegedly took the pass belonging to Romeo Djoumessi, from the Scottish Exhibition and Conference Centre (SECC) on 29 July and then tried to access the athlete's village by pretending to be the Cameroonian wrestler.

     
  7.  
    Arsenal captain 'may leave' 15:35:

    Arsenal boss Arsene Wenger has suggested club captain Thomas Vermaelen may leave the Gunners.

    Arsenal's Thomas Vermaelen and Arsene Wenger

    The Belgian defender, 28, has been linked with a move to Manchester United, and speaking at a news conference today Wenger said: "Vermaelen is injured. It is a possibility that he goes."

     
  8.  
    Shaken baby accused is acquitted Breaking News

    Allan Young, 36, has been acquitted of manslaughter at the Old Bailey, 16 years after shaking his newborn son and causing catastrophic brain injuries.

     
  9.  
    Banksy pays tribute to rival Robbo 15:21:

    Graffiti artist Banksy has paid tribute to his rival King Robbo, who died yesterday aged 45.

    Graffiti along Regent's Canal

    King Robbo rose to prominence in London in the 1980s and notoriously feuded with fellow artist Banksy, but had been in a vegetative state since 2011 when he was found at the bottom of a flight of stairs with a head injury.

     
  10.  
    Met officer claims £47,000 damages 15:04:

    A black female police officer who was discriminated against because of her race and sex is hoping to claim £47,000 in damages, a compensation hearing has heard.

    Met firearms officer Carol Howard

    The Metropolitan Police is facing a compensation claim from firearms officer Carol Howard, 35, after a judgment last month found that she was "singled out and targeted" for almost a year while serving in the Diplomatic Protection Group.

     
  11.  
    News on the hour 14:54:

    In the headlines on BBC London 94.9 at 15:00:

     
  12.  
    Jail over ecstasy death 14:46:

    Daniel's mother made a victim impact statement which left some people in court in tears.

    She said: "It is like having a limb ripped off without any anaesthetic. It it like having an enormous wound but it is much worse.

    "I would choose either of those things than losing my son."

     
  13.  
    Jail over ecstasy death 14:35:

    Nicqueel Pitrora, 18, of Croydon, admitted to being concerned in the supply of a class A drugs on the day.

    Nicqueel Pitrora

    The court heard he regularly sold drugs to schoolboys under the street name Shampz to supplement his benefits.

     
  14.  
    Jail over ecstasy death 14:30:

    A man has been jailed for five years for supplying drugs after a 16-year-old boy died at a rave in west London.

    Daniel Spargo-Mabbs,

    Daniel Spargo-Mabbs, from Croydon, south London, died from multiple organ failure three days after taking ecstasy at a rave in Hayes on 17 January this year.

     
  15.  
    West Ham signs Arsenal defender 14:16:

    West Ham has signed Arsenal defender Carl Jenkinson on a season-long loan.

    West Ham's new signing Carl Jenkinson

    The 22-year-old right-back had been linked with several Premier League clubs, but opted for the Hammers.

     
  16.  
    14:01: Tom Edwards Transport correspondent, London

    New software is being trialled to try to reduce deaths on London's roads, Transport for London (TfL) has confirmed.

    A man walks in front of a bus as part of a controlled demonstration of the Cycle Safety Shield device

    Two systems will be tested out by bus drivers, including the 'Cycle Safety Shield' which is designed to detect pedestrians, cyclists and motorcyclists nearby.

     
  17.  
    Hoxton student wins design award 13:51:

    A student from Hoxton, Vivian Lambert, has beaten thousands of entrants to a prestigious design award for his redesign of packaging for Purdey's drinks, the Hackney Gazette reports.

     
  18.  
    School rapped over abuse 13:41:

    An independent review has found that a convicted paedophile drugged and abused dozens of boys left in his care after a series of failings by his employer, Southbank International School in London.

    William Vahey pictured in 2013 (left) and 2004

    Hugh Davies QC found that the school failed to properly handle concerns raised about 64-year old American national William Vahey, who killed himself earlier this year.

     
  19.  
    Miliband criticised for London claims 13:30:

    Labour Party leader Ed Miliband has been criticised by the UK statistics watchdog over his claim that "four out of five" new jobs were being created in London.

    Ed Miliband

    Sir Andrew Dilnot said official statistics suggested the reverse was true and only 21.7% private sector jobs had been created in London.

     
  20.  
    London Zoo 'cruelty' probe 13:20: Matthew Bell BBC News, London

    Some pretty strong views coming in on the investigation into claimed cruelty at London Zoo's late night events.

    Kat Andreakou said on our Facebook page: "After-hour parties at the zoo? They shouldn't be held in the first place, of course they are distressful to the animals."

    Michael Melbourne added: "This zoo is an awful place to keep many types of animals - whilst they will claim it has been improved over the years, it is really just a tourist attraction."

     
  21.  
    Lunchtime news 13:10: Sonja Jessup Presenter, BBC London News

    On BBC London News at 13:30, we'll talk to the family of a teenage actor about the hunt for his suspected killer after his death in Vauxhall five years ago.

    And after days of cancellations, Secret Cinema's screening of Back To The Future has finally gone ahead - we were there!

     
  22.  
    Hundreds of blood samples stolen 13:00:

    A van carrying up to 300 blood samples has been stolen from outside a GP's surgery in Morden, near St Helier hospital, Sutton Guardian reports.

    The van was also carrying urine samples, microbiology swabs and smears and the theft is thought to affect 10 surgeries, said the paper.

     
  23.  
    Highgate 'needs more police' 12:49:

    Residents in Highgate have called for more police patrols to battle a perceived recent rise in crime, Ham & High reports.

    People in one area of Highgate already rely on a private firm, CPS, to provide security patrols, but residents also want an increased police presence, the paper said.

     
  24.  
    Banksy rival King Robbo dies 12:39:

    Graffiti artist King Robbo, a rival to street artist Banksy, has died, according to his official website.

    A graffiti artwork by Banksy

    King Robbo and Banksy had been painting over each other's work for years in a tit-for-tat graffiti battle that ran for several years.

     
  25.  
    Heathrow owner could sell airports 12:29:

    The owner of Heathrow Airport, Heathrow Airport Holdings (HAH), could sell off its three other airports by the end of the year to just focus on Heathrow.

    Planes at Heathrow Airport

    HAH, formerly known as BAA, at one time ran seven airports but said it was "entering a sales process" that could lead to the sell-off of Southampton, Glasgow and Aberdeen airports, possibly to HAH's biggest shareholder, Spanish infrastructure firm Ferrovial.

     
  26.  
    Theatre Royal receives grant 12:20:

    Stratford East's Theatre Royal is among five of the UK's theatres to receive small capital grants from the Theatres Trust.

    A performance at the Theatre Royal in Stratford East

    The grade II listed theatre will receive £5,000 towards a project to repair the fabric of its trompe l'oeil curtain, which uses art techniques to create an optical illusion of objects appearing in three dimensions.

     
  27.  
    Robert Elms 12:08: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    On the show today, the curator of the Museum of London's Olympic Cauldron exhibition, Georgina Young, talks about the complex and clever design of this centrepiece of the Games two years ago.

    The cauldron at the London 2012 Olympic Games

    And Shaun Escoffery will be performing live, with his new single Nature's Call.

     
  28.  
    News on the hour 11:58: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    In the latest headlines at 12:00:

     
  29.  
    West End launches Kids' Week 11:54:

    The annual London theatre projects Kids' Week starts today, with a day of free family activities at Regent's Park Open Air Theatre, which is expected to attract hundreds of children and their families.

    The event features 39 shows including Stomp, The Commitments, Wicked, Phantom of the Opera and Shakespeare in Love, and more than 40,000 tickets are still available.

     
  30.  
    Tottenham sign Sporting's Dier 11:41:

    Tottenham have agreed to sign Sporting Lisbon defender Eric Dier for £4m, subject to a medical.

    Eric Dier

    The England Under-21 international, who was born in Cheltenham but moved to Portugal as a child, has made 30 appearances for the Lisbon club.

     
  31.  
    Rolf Harris starts appeal 11:30:

    Rolf Harris has applied for permission to appeal against his convictions for indecent assaults.

    Entertainer Rolf Harris

    Lawyers for the 84-year-old have lodged papers at the Court of Appeal this week, a spokesman for the Judicial Office said.

     
  32.  
    Haringey criticised for pay-offs 11:20:

    Haringey's housing arm has been criticised for spending £1.7m to make 50 people redundant last year at an average pay-off cost of £35,000 each, Ham & High reports.

     
  33.  
    London Zoo: 'Well-being our priority' 11:10:

    A spokesman for London Zoo said the well-being of its animals is its "first priority", after Westminster Council began an investigation into claims that after-hours parties at the zoo caused animals "fear and distress".

    Penguins pictured at London Zoo

    The spokesman said the zoo was "taking every measure to ensure our Zoo Lates evenings are positive experiences for both our animals and visitors", adding it would continue working with Westminster Council "to make sure they are satisfied we are meeting and exceeding all licence requirements".

     
  34.  
    News on the hour 11:03:

    The top news at 10:00 on BBC London 94.9:

     
  35.  
    Have your say 10:50:

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? We'd like your feedback about this service.

     
  36.  
    London Zoo starts 'cruelty' probe 10:40:

    Westminster Council has begun an investigation into after-hours parties at London Zoo following claims they caused animals "fear and distress".

    A tiger at London Zoo

    More than 21,000 people have signed a petition to stop the Zoo Lates events, where it is claimed guests poured beer over animals and crushed butterflies.

     
  37.  
    Syria terrorism inquiry 10:30:

    A 23-year-old man has been bailed after being arrested on suspicion of raising money for terrorism in Syria.

    The man was arrested in west London by officers from Scotland Yard's counter-terrorism unit. An address in south London was also searched, police said.

     
  38.  
    Bus detection system trialled 10:21: Tom Edwards Transport correspondent, London

    Transport for London is to trial a pedestrian and cyclist detection system on four buses on routes 25 and 73.

    TfL warning and sensor system on trial

    The warning system, pictured here, detects cyclists and pedestrians that are close to the bus and alerts its driver.

     
  39.  
    'Where's Boris?' game launched 10:10:

    A new search-and-find picture book featuring London Mayor Boris Johnson has been released by publisher Orion Books.

    Cover of the Where's Boris book from Orion

    Evocative of the Where's Wally book, in Where's Boris? an illustrated Mr Johnson is seen dangling from a zip wire in Victoria Park, peeking round the corner at No. 10 Downing Street and "baffling the locals in China's Forbidden City", said Orion.

     
  40.  
    Police cameras 'to track performance' 10:01:

    Croydon's top police officer, Chief Superintendent Andy Tarrant, has said the borough's new body-worn cameras will help track the performance of his officers, the Croydon Advertiser reports.

     
  41.  
    News on the hour 09:53:

    On BBC London 94.9 at 10:00:

    • 'Zoo cruelty': Westminster Council investigates claims of animal cruelty during after-hours parties at London Zoo
     
  42.  
    Anti-Semitic attacks rise 09:40:

    Anti-Semitic crimes in the capital hit a five-year high in July following an upsurge in violence in the Gaza conflict, the Evening Standard reports.

    New figures from the Community Security trust reported 130 incidents linked to the Gaza conflict and suggested a 36% rise in anti-Semitic incidents including violent crime and vandalism, said the paper.

     
  43.  
    Secret Cinema finally goes ahead 09:31:

    The Secret Cinema screening of the film Back To The Future has finally gone ahead, after the first four nights were cancelled, disappointing hundreds of fans.

    Back to the Future

    The event includes replicas of buildings featured in the film and live performances by actors, but was called off during the opening week because the local authority was unsatisfied with technical issues.

     
  44.  
    Latest travel 09:20:

    A lane is shut on the Brixton Road in Kennington, near South Island because of a gas leak and repair works.

    For more travel updates, visit BBC London's travel website.

     
  45.  
    News on the hour 09:00:

    The top headlines on BBC London 94.9 at 09:00

    • DJ murder: Police investigating a five-year-old murder say the main suspect is in Nigeria
    • 'Zoo cruelty': Westminster council looks into claims of animal cruelty at London Zoo late events
     
  46.  
    Tottenham's Rose renews contract 08:53:

    Tottenham defender Danny Rose has signed a new five-year contract, putting him in competition with Ben Davies - a new signing from Swansea - for the left-back spot at White Hart Lane.

    Tottenham defender Danny Rose

    Rose, 24, has made 38 Premier League appearances for Spurs since joining from Leeds in 2007 and was part of the GB squad at the London 2012 Olympics.

     
  47.  
    Mass migration 08:40: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    On Vanessa Feltz's show after 09:00, large-scale migration would put huge pressure on services and and living standards, according to a new report - are you worried?

    Call 020 7224 2000 or text 81333, starting your message with 'London', to share your views.

     
  48.  
    A survivor's story 08:32:

    With numerous inquiries into alleged child abuse either up and running or poised to begin, is there a risk the individual voices of victims might get lost? One survivor believes so.

    "I was trafficked to Wrexham, Cornwall, Plymouth and London and forced to perform sex acts on men there," he says.

     
  49.  
    Top headlines
     
  50.  
    CBBC actor's killing appeal 08:22:

    Police hunting a man over the stabbing of a children's TV actor have offered a £10,000 reward for information leading to his arrest and prosecution.

    Carl Beatson Asiedu

    Carl Beatson Asiedu, 19, who had appeared in CBBC's MI High, was stabbed in the heart near Club Life nightclub in Vauxhall, south London, in 2009.

     
  51.  
    Traffic jam 08:15: Paul Murphy-Kasp Journalist, BBC London

    There are queues going into London on the A13 through Barking and Dagenham.

    For further travel updates, visit BBC London's travel website.

     
  52.  
    North Circular travel woes 08:08: Paul Murphy-Kasp Journalist, BBC London

    A lane is shut on the North Circular eastbound, by Ikea in Neasden, causing tailbacks.

    For more travel updates on twitter follow @BBCTravelAlert

     
  53.  
    Dry with sunny spells 08:03:

    This morning should be dry with sunny spells. There should still be some fine weather this afternoon, however showers are likely to spread in from the west. Maximum temperature: 24C (75F).

     
  54.  
    08:00: Matthew Bell BBC News, London

    Good morning. I'll be bringing you the latest news, sport, travel and weather for London throughout the day.

    Get in touch with your comments and photos by emailing london.locallive@bbc.co.uk.

     

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.