London councils head list of parking charge surpluses


Motorists give their views on parking charges in Westminster and elsewhere

Related Stories

Parking charges are providing huge cash surpluses for some English councils, according to the RAC Foundation.

The 359 councils across England had a total current account surplus of £565m from on and off-street parking schemes in 2011-12, according to the figures.

Eight of the biggest 10 surpluses came from London councils with Westminster leading the way with a £41.6m profit.

Westminster City Council disputed many of the figures but said it would work with motorists to reduce fines.

The other two councils outside London making the top 10 were Brighton and Hove in sixth with £14.4m and Cornwall in eighth with £7.9m.

The total profit represented a £54m increase on the surplus from 2010-11 and only 52 of the councils reported a deficit on their 2011-12 parking operations.

The RAC Foundation figures, produced for them by transport consultant David Leibling, are from the annual returns councils are required to provide to the Department for Communities and Local Government.

They are based on three factors - on-street parking charges, off-street parking charges and parking penalties.

Running costs of parking operations are deducted from this total to produce the surplus or deficit figure.

Top 10 parking surpluses

  • Westminster £41.6m
  • Kensington and Chelsea £28.1m
  • Camden £25m
  • Hammersmith and Fulham £19.5m
  • Wandsworth £16.1m
  • Brighton and Hove £14.4m
  • Islington £10.9m
  • Cornwall £7.9m
  • Newham £7.3m
  • Hounslow £7.3m

Source: RAC Foundation. Figures for 2011-12

Tackling congestion

Transport minister Norman Baker said: "The law is quite clear. Councils should not be pricing their parking in order to make a profit.

"Any monies raised from parking in excess of the cost of administration has to go back to transport purposes which can be dealing with potholes, improved road management or can be investing in public transport to encourage people to free up the roads.

Subtracting the money spent by councils on capital projects - such as fixing potholes or traffic schemes - the surplus for 2011-12 stands at the "still very large figure" of £412m, a spokesman for the RAC Foundation said.

Details of what the money is spent on is not provided to the Department for Communities and Local Government, he added.

While disputing some of the figures, Westminster City Council still signalled its intention to work with road users to reduce fines.

Local Government Association's David Sparks: "Local authorities are reviewing their parking charges"

Councillor Daniel Astaire, Westminster City Council cabinet member for business, said: "The system is already changing and councils are already looking to work with motorists to issue fewer fines and crucially increase the amount of people parking correctly.

"Parking is about traffic management, tackling congestion and trying to implement positive benefits for businesses and high streets.

"If we stay in this Jurassic age of pure rhetoric about cash cows and money making, innovation will be stifled and we cannot engage with motorists properly in order to find the best solutions that will benefit everyone."

Kensington and Chelsea Council made the second biggest surplus of £28.1m and a spokesman told BBC London: "There is a greater demand for parking spaces in Kensington and Chelsea than practically anywhere else in the country.

"The council has discretion on how to spend any surplus that may arise, within the allowable purposes provided for by Section 55 of the Road Traffic Regulation Act 1984."

Professor Stephen Glaister, from the RAC Foundation: "Temptation to ramp up charges to pay for general council budget"

Havering Council had the second lowest figures in London, despite its surplus of £703,000 having gone up by £563,000.

A spokeswoman said: "These latest figures show our commitment to giving residents and visitors to the borough value for money, as well as showing our support for local high streets and as a result the wider economy.

"Despite being the third largest London borough, parking charges in Havering are still among the lowest in London and have stayed the same for several years. But in April this year, we cut prices even further."

'Cash cow'

Councillor Peter Box, chairman of the Local Government Association's economy and transport board, said: "Parking revenue is spent on paying for parking services.

"Any money left over goes towards transport services like filling potholes, concessionary travel and road improvement projects.

Is technology the answer to London's parking problems? BBC London's Tom Edwards finds out

"As the report makes clear, many councils have to subsidise parking services as the cost is not covered by charges.

"Parking charges and fines help councils keep traffic flowing and pedestrians and motorists safe."

On Wednesday, government figures showed that money made from parking charges and fines by English councils is set to continue to rise.

The councils expect that net income from parking services is likely to increase from £601m in 2012-13 to £635m in 2013-14.

Local Government Secretary Eric Pickles said: "This municipal parking profit shows why we need to review and rein in unfair town hall parking rules. The law is clear that parking is not a tax or cash cow for town hall officers."

Last week, the High Court ruled against Barnet Council's move to raise the cost of residents' parking permits in a landmark victory for campaigners.

Mrs Justice Lang ruled that the council acted unlawfully when it increased permit costs to generate more money for road maintenance.


More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites


This entry is now closed for comments

Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 685.

    I just can't believe, with the imminent demise of town centres, that councils think charging car drivers is a wise move. No wonder people go to out-of-town 'Malls'. Illegal parking is one thing but charging people silly amounts of money simply to leave their car is going to speed up the death of shopping in towns. Might as well knock them all down and make car parks... oh, the irony!

  • rate this

    Comment number 632.

    While and I like admire Mr Pickles, I think if the councils have to charge what they are to deter inconsiderate parking then making a surplus is a good thing. I agree that council's prime motive in making parking restrictions and setting fines should not be for revenue, but in most cases I don't think it is.

  • rate this

    Comment number 631.

    I have no issue with sensibly enforced parking regulations, especially if the proceeds are reinvested to provide better public transport and repairing the roads. Unfortunately I doubt this is the case and that it just goes towards some councillors 'bun fight'

  • rate this

    Comment number 629.

    Parking fines are a cash-cow - we should do away with private car-parking companies, revert to Traffic Wardens only (who have no financial incentive to issue tickets) and stop this business which is out-of-control.

  • rate this

    Comment number 502.

    I avoid whenever possible going somewhere that I am required to pay to park in order to shop, especially the extortionate rates charged in some places. I am certainly not alone in this and so the high streets continue to die and the politicians wonder why.


Comments 5 of 13


BBC London



29 °C 17 °C

BBC Local Live


    That's all from BBC Local Live for today. Join Debabani Majumdar tomorrow from 08:00 for more news, sport, travel and weather updates from across the capital.

    Prince George illuminations 17:57:

    Two London landmarks are set to be illuminated in blue lights to mark Prince George's first birthday, according to Westminster Council.

    Golden Jubilee Bridge

    The Golden Jubilee Bridge, which crosses the Thames, and fountains at Marble Arch will be illuminated in blue lights between 20:00 and midnight tonight.

    Clear skies 17:55:

    It will be a dry night with clear skies for most. Winds will be light and variable. Lows of 16C (61F).

    On air 17:54: BBC London News TV

    A group of London academies is trying to recover £4m from a former employee after vast sums of money ended up in his personal accounts.

    And a new world record may have been set for the number of people dressed as Sherlock Holmes and gathered in one room. More with Riz Lateef on BBC London News at 18:30 on BBC One.

    Tube delays 17:51:

    Liverpool Street Station has reopened, but there are a number of problems on the Tube. For the latest updates, you can visit Transport for London's website.

    Public holidays for Diwali and Eid? 17:49:

    An MP has spoken in Parliament giving his support to a campaign to make Eid and Diwali public holidays, reports the Harrow Times.

    Bob Blackman (Harrow East) led the debate supporting a national petition which has gathered more than 123,000 signatures.

    Housing matters 17:47: Andy Dangerfield BBC News Online

    Thanks to the more than 300 of you who have commented on my story examining five controversial solutions to London's housing crisis.


    Do you agree with what other readers have said? Comment on the story.

    Station evacuated 17:44:

    Liverpool Station has been evacuated because of a fire alert. For all the latest travel updates visit BBC London's travel website.

    Video: Litvinenko death inquiry 17:38:

    An inquiry is to be held into the death of the Russian dissident Alexander Litvinenko, the government has confirmed.

    Mr Litvinenko, a former KGB officer, died in 2006 in a London hospital after he was allegedly poisoned with radioactive polonium.

    Senior salaries debate 17:28:

    How are the salaries of Greater London Authority (GLA) senior staff set? Why do Transport for London top bosses get performance bonuses, while senior staff at the London Legacy Development Corporation don't?

    These are the kind of questions that will be answered by The London Assembly GLA Oversight Committee tomorrow from 10:30. A video of the meeting will be streamed online.

    Penny in Wonderland 17:15:

    BBC London 94.9's very own Penny Smith is attending a gala performance of the opera Alice's Adventures in Wonderland in Holland Park this afternoon.

    Penny Smith
    Arsenal concert battle 17:00:

    Arsenal have launched a High Court battle over a curb on the number of concerts that can be held at the Emirates Stadium.

    The Premier League club have applied to double the number of concerts from three to six at their stadium but opponents have voiced concerns over noise and rowdy music fans.

    Concerts featuring Bruce Springsteen, Coldplay and Muse have generated hundreds of thousands of pounds extra revenue for the club.

    Street party fees slashed 16:49:

    Hosting street parties in Brent have been now been made cheaper after Brent Council approved plans to reduce the fee, writes the Kilburn Times.

    Cabinet members voted in favour of proposals which will see the charge to hold special events slashed to £200. The cost of holding commemorative functions had previously totalled to more than £1,300.

    Beetles kill Harrison tree 16:38:

    A pine tree planted in 2004 in memory of former Beatle George Harrison in a Los Angeles park has died after being infested by beetles.

    George Harrison in 1966

    Last year, a blue plaque was unveiled at 94 Baker Street, for Harrison and fellow Beatle, John Lennon, at the site of the now dissolved Apple Boutique clothing store.

    Photos: Serpentine swimming 16:28:

    The Guardian has captured some great photos of members of the Serpentine Swimming Club gathering for a morning swim in Serpentine lake in Hyde Park.

    Duo smash crowd fund target 16:17:

    Two Camden entrepreneurs, who turned down a never-before-seen offer on BBC show Dragons' Den to instead appeal for funding from the online community, have seen their £20,000 target smashed in less than a day, reports the Ham & High.

    Merton cyclist dies 16:07:

    A cyclist, who died following a collision in Merton, has been named as Laurent Patrick Cullinan (pictured), 25, of New Malden, Surrey.

    Laurent Patrick Cullinan,

    The collision with a silver Honda Accord happened on Kingston Road, at about 00:45 on Saturday, the Met said.

    Your views 15:56:

    We've introduced BBC Local Live to bring you the latest news, sport, travel and weather all in one place. Tell us what you think.

    Richmond cycle death 15:46:

    A 40-year-old cyclist died today following a serious collision in Richmond, Scotland Yard says.

    Police were called just after 08:00 yesterday to reports of a dustcart in collision with a cyclist on the A316, Kew Foot Road, at the junction with St John's Grove, Richmond.

    Housing: your comments 15:36: Andy Dangerfield BBC News Online

    Thanks to Caroline, who has offered her take on the housing crisis in London:


    1. sell social housing (80s on)

    2. deregulate mortgages (mid 80s)

    3. withdraw double tax relief (86)

    4. create shorthold tenancies (88)

    5. create personal pension schemes (88), then

    6. fail to protect invested money, making

    7. property look a safe haven

    8. siphoned pension money inflates the housing market

    9. undertax empty properties

    10. find foreign scapegoats for homegrown problems

    'Dustbowl' 15:26:

    BBC London transport correspondent Tom Edwards tweets: Heat taking its toll at Parliament Square dustbowl

    Parliament square
    WWI Commemoration 15:17:

    At 22:00 on 4 August, a service of Solemn Commemoration at Westminster Abbey will feature the gradual extinguishing of candles, with an oil lamp being extinguished at the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier at 23:00, the exact time Britain joined the First World War.

    WWI commemoration 15:05:

    Details of a national day of commemoration to mark the centenary of Britain's entry into the First World War have been released by the Government.

    On Monday 4 August there will be events at Glasgow Cathedral, St Symphorien cemetery in Mons, Belgium, and at London's Westminster Abbey, says Culture Secretary Sajid Javid.

    Fifty years of broadcasting 14:56:

    A special programme to celebrate Tony Blackburn's 50th year on the radio is to be broadcast on BBC London 94.9.

    Tony Blackburn

    The broadcasting veteran will play his favourite music and talk to the people who have shared his life on air on Friday from 19:00.

    Hornchurch grass fire 14:46:

    London Fire Brigade tweets: Hornchurch fire update: Around six hectares of grassland is alight - the equivalent of around six football pitches.

    The Romford Recorder has a photo of the blaze.

    Hornchurch grass fire 14:43:

    London Fire brigade tweets: Around 20 firefighters are currently dealing with a grass fire on Wingletye Lane, Hornchurch. Four fire engines are at the scene.

    Housing: your comments 14:33: Andy Dangerfield BBC News Online

    As pressure to tackle London's housing crisis grows, a number of controversial views are being offered including, building on green belt and moving the elderly out of large houses if they live alone.

    Jes comments: "Hmmm, attacking the green belt, the aged and removing the option to buy - sound very much like the wishes of the rich, property owners who wish to balance the situation more heavily in their favour.

    "The way to do it is, as others have said, is to stop non-citizen purchase of properties and to insist that empty properties are returned to market via compulsory purchase."

    Met rated as 'good' 14:23:

    The HMIC report said the 22% reduction in the overall MPS budget was greater than most other forces in England and Wales and it faced "a particular challenge because of the scale of the financial savings that must be made".

    Met officer

    Deputy Commissioner, Craig Mackey, said: "We are delighted the HMIC has recognised the scale of the savings already made by the Met as well as the success we have had improving the quality and efficiency of the service we deliver.

    "We are cutting crime, keeping officer numbers high and making sure they are increasing visible to the public.

    Met rated as 'good' 14:13:

    The Met has been rated as "good" in all categories in Her Majesty's Inspectorate of Constabulary's (HMIC) report "Responding to austerity".

    It examines how the MPS has responded to the reductions in its budget and accompanying demands for improvement in service quality.

    Snakes in a park 14:03:

    A pair of 8ft (2.4m) boa constrictors were found near a children's play area in a park in East Ham, it has been revealed today.

    Snake in Plashet Park

    A crowd of 40 people gathered around the snakes after they were spotted in Plashet Park on 13 July.

    Video: Wooing BME vote 13:51:

    In the 2015 general election, political parties need to do more to woo ethnic minority voters says Trevor Phillips, a former chair of the Equality and Human Rights Commission.

    In a Daily Politics film from south London, Eleanor Garnier spoke to Croydon BME (black and minority ethnic persons) forum chief Nero Ughwujabo and Prof Richard Webber from King's College London.

    Eco schools lead the way 13:40:

    Sutton's schools are leading the way in their plans to be more green, reports the Sutton Guardian.

    The borough has the highest sign-up rate to the Eco-Schools scheme in London and the seventh highest rate in the country.

    Merged tennis and cricket? 13:30:

    As the 20th Century began, London-based commercial traveller John George Grant felt the division between the summer ball sports of tennis and cricket was pointless and perhaps a wasted opportunity for money-making.


    So he invented a quick-moving hybrid version - "Vigoro".

    Brent ban for baby killer 13:18:

    A teenage mother who starved her four-month-old baby to death has been banned from entering Brent as part of her sentence, reports the Kilburn Times.

    The 19-year-old, who has not been named for legal reasons, admitted the manslaughter of the child who died from severe acute malnutrition and dehydration last October.

    Through the roof 13:03: Andy Dangerfield BBC News Online

    Should we face the fact the golden age of home ownership might be over? This is one of five controversial solutions offered to London's housing crisis.

    BBC website reader Brian Dorken commented: "The Berliners and the Parisians do it. Get rid of this constant indoctrination from an early age that one of the ways you show how successful you are is the size of house you own and how much it will be worth in 25 years time."

    Do you have any alternative suggestions? Comment on the story.

    Anatomy of FGM 12:51:

    The world could put a stop to female genital mutilation (FGM) within a generation, international leaders and campaigners are saying at an international conference held in London.

    While it is hard to get a handle on the true scale, figures suggest at least 4,000 women and girls have been treated for FGM in London's hospitals since 2009.

    Cole wedding celebration 12:39:

    Singer Cheryl Cole has celebrated her surprise wedding with a party for her Girls Aloud band mates, friends and family in central London.

    Cheryl Cole and Jean-Bernard Fernandez-Versini

    The X Factor judge married French restaurateur Jean-Bernard Fernandez-Versini two weeks ago on the Caribbean island of Mustique.

    Very warm afternoon 12:26:

    A fine and very warm afternoon is expected, with light winds. Maximum temperature 25C (77F).

    Rezone east London? 12:16:

    Calls have been made to rezone West Ham, Canning Town and four DLR station to increase the rate of regeneration in east London, reports

    Newham Mayor Sir Robin Wales said it would be unfair not to make the changes after Stratford was given the go-ahead to move from Zone 2 to 2/3 by 2016.

    Stolen bike appeal 12:06:

    A triathlete has appealed for help on Twitter after the bike she rode to victory in an Ironman World Championship was stolen.

    Chrissie Wellington on stolen bike

    Chrissie Wellington, who won her fourth title in 2011, said it had "great sentimental value" and had been taken from an office in London.

    Robert Elms show 11:55: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    St James' Church in West Hampstead has opened its doors as a Post Office.

    It's believed to be the first full-time Post Office to open inside a church. Father Andrew Caine will be talking to Robert Elms about the unique service. Have you used it yet? Let us know.

    Build on the green belt? 11:43:

    Could building on some of London's green belt land solve the capital's housing shortage?

    Ken Herbert, from Radlett, in Hertfordshire, emailed to say: "We cannot go on building, particularly in the south east, to meet the demands of an ever increasing population without destroying much that is special about this country."

    Do you agree? Email

    Home truths 11:33: Andy Dangerfield BBC News Online

    Thanks for your comments on our story which examines five controversial solutions to London's housing crisis.

    London houses

    BBC website reader Ranfurly commented: "Control rents and test the consequences for 5 years. We actually don't now know to what extent this would hurt landlords. We need to know this to shape future policy."

    Do you agree? Comment on the story.

    Daley flight engine fire 11:22:

    A flight with England divers including Tom Daley on board almost had to make an emergency landing in a river after developing an engine fire.

    Tom Daley dives in the World Series final in Shanghai

    Daley and team-mates including Sarah Barrow and Tonia Couch were returning to London from Shanghai yesterday after diving at the World Series.

    Video: Clegg on FGM 11:05:

    New measures aimed at ending female genital mutilation within a generation will be announced at a global summit in London.

    Speaking ahead of the conference, Deputy Prime Minister Nick Clegg said: "This is illegal. It is wrong. There is no cultural issue about not intervening to protect these girls."

    Have your say 10:54:

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? We'd like your feedback about this service.

    Tube disruption 10:42:

    The Tube service has been suspended on the Waterloo and City Line because of a signal failure at Bank.

    For more travel updates, visit BBC London's travel website.

    Julian Dicks on highs and lows 10:34: Anna Thompson BBC Sport

    He was a no-nonsense, tough-tackling hard man of football in the 1990s, who earned the nickname the Terminator, and played more than 250 times for West Ham.

    Julian Dicks

    Now Julian Dicks is back at the east London club, this time managing the women's football team.

    FGM summit 10:24:

    Parents will face prosecution if they fail to stop their daughters undergoing female genital mutilation under new measures being announced.

    Prime Minister David Cameron is unveiling a £1.4m prevention programme aimed at ending the practice at a global summit in London.

    Home Truths 10:13: via Facebook

    This week BBC London is looking at the capital's housing problems in our series Home Truths. We've asked some of London's housing experts what they think would help.

    Today Patricia Brown, who is chair of the London Festival of Architecture, tells us her idea.

    What do you think? Would longer rentals help?

    Litvinenko death inquiry 10:02:

    An inquiry will be held into the death of the Russian dissident Alexander Litvinenko, Home Secretary Theresa May is expected to announce.

    Alexander Litvinenko

    Mr Litvinenko, a former KGB officer, died in 2006 in a London hospital after he was allegedly poisoned with radio active polonium.

    Water cannons 09:53: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    On water cannons, Mr Johnson says: "I don't want them to ever be used.

    "They're not there to be part of the furniture of the streets."

    'MP' Boris Johnson? 09:49: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    When asked by Vanessa Feltz whether he intends to be an MP at the same time as being mayor, Boris Johnson said: "I've got to deliver the mandate I've been elected on."

    Hybrid buses 09:46: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    London's mayor tells BBC London 94.9: "The future is zero carbon buses. "

    "Electric double-decker buses are very expensive. We're working towards that," he adds.

    'Cool' Tube 09:36: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    Mr Johnson tells BBC London 94.9 a "New Tube for London" will be introduced on the Central, Waterloo & City, Bakerloo and Central lines.

    He says it will be a "cool train with heat relief".

    "As chairman of TfL I apologise to Londoners who are suffering from excessive heat," he added.

    Empty homes 09:30: BBC London 94.9

    London's mayor Boris Johnson says "homes not in use" are at the "lowest level" since the 1970s.

    Call 020 722 42000 or email with your questions.

    Video: Forced marriage 09:27:

    As a global summit begins, aimed at tackling the issue of forced marriage, BBC News has heard from a teenager whose parents made her marry a stranger.

    teenager washes pots

    The Girl Summit, which is being held in London today, also aims to end female genital mutilation within a generation.

    Affordable homes 09:20: BBC London 94.9

    Boris Johnson tells BBC London 94.9: "We are going to deliver a record number of affordable homes in London."

    He says 400,000 homes will be built in London in 10 years.

    Get in touch with your questions by calling 020 722 42000 or emailing

    Oxford Street pollution 09:15: BBC London 94.9

    London Mayor Boris Johnson tells Vanessa Feltz: "I've just cycled along Oxford Street. It's not the most polluted place but we've got to make it better."

    Get in touch by calling 020 722 42000 or emailing

    'Perfect storm' for mosquitoes 09:08:

    The muggy weather has created ideal conditions for mosquitoes to feast on Londoners as they sleep or enjoy spending evenings outside, reports the Evening Standard.


    Experts said the warm weather and high water table has caused a "perfect storm" for biting insects, which also includes horseflies and midges.

    Boris Johnson takes your calls 08:59: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    This morning from 09:00, Vanessa is joined by the Mayor of London Boris Johnson taking your calls.

    Get in touch by calling 020 722 42000 or emailing

    On this day 08:50:

    In 1844 the Rev William Spooner was born in London. He was an albino and suffered defective eyesight and it is thought that this caused some of his verbal confusions which were later dubbed "spoonerisms". These included "it is kisstomary to cuss the bride" and "you hissed my mystery lecture".

    Met gave 30,000 cautions 08:41:

    Police in London gave cautions for 29,560 offences last year, including for rape and violence, figures show.

    Cautions were given in two cases of rape, for 284 other sexual offences and 1,356 for wounding. And 236 people were given cautions on more than five occasions.

    Five housing crisis 'solutions' 08:33: Andy Dangerfield BBC News Online

    Should we move old people to smaller flats? Or build over the green belt?


    These are some of the more controversial solutions that have been suggested as BBC London looks at ways to tackle the capital's growing housing crisis. What do you think? Email us.

    as it happened
    • News, sport, travel and weather for Tues 22 July
    • More updates from 08:00 on Wednesday
    • Listen to BBC London 94.9
    Train problems 08:18: Paul Murphy-Kasp Journalist, BBC London

    First Capital Connect and Southern has 30 minute delays after a vehicle hit a railway bridge at Tulse Hill in south London.

    For the latest travel information visit BBC London's travel page.

    M25 delays 08:09: Paul Murphy-Kasp Journalist, BBC London

    On the M25 anti-clockwise there are long queues from before J28 for the A12 to J26 for Waltham Abbey following a collision after J26.

    The problems are also causing lots of extra traffic on the M11 southbound from J6 to J4 and the Westbound North Circular from the M11 to Arnos Grove.

    For the latest travel news follow @BBCTravelAlert on Twitter.

    Cloudy start, sunny later 08:04:

    Generally it will be a rather dull and misty start to today, with low cloud and perhaps some fog.

    Weather chart

    Sunny spells will gradually develop as the mist and low cloud lift through the morning, this will lead to a fine and very warm afternoon with highs of 25C (77F).

    08:00: Andy Dangerfield BBC News Online

    I'll be guiding you through BBC Local Live today, bringing you the latest news, travel, weather and sport from across London.

    Get in touch with your comments and photos by emailing



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.