Is Crossrail 2 a bridge too far for regions?

Related Stories

The chancellor George Osborne has said he is not yet prepared to support a second Crossrail for London, apparently dashing Boris Johnson's hopes of getting the project off the ground during his mayoralty.

It comes as Tory MPs outside London are voicing concerns about further investment in major transport infrastructure in the capital at the expense of other parts of the country.

'Patch and mend job'

Mr Osborne believes work on the existing £16bn Crossrail should be completed first - in 2018 - before he considers further major transport schemes for London.

It indicates there will be no support for Crossrail 2 when the government publishes its spending review next month - outlining departmental budget limits for the next three years - and will add to speculation that the capital's transport budget may face significant cuts.

George Osborne George Osborne believes the first Crossrail should be completed before another is considered

The former Transport Secretary Lord Andrew Adonis, who is heading the campaign for Crossrail 2, described the approach as "short-termist".

Last week, Mr Osborne visited the Crossrail construction site near the Olympic park in east London.

One of the project's engineers told him he hoped to go on and work on a second Crossrail after the first was completed.

Mr Osborne told him, "They want me to build Crossrail 2. Let's finish Crossrail 1 first and then we will look at other projects."

Supporters of Crossrail 2 - which would run north-south through London from Hertfordshire to Surrey - say preparatory work needs to start soon if it is to be completed by 2030.

Lord Adonis told the BBC it was necessary to convince the chancellor that it made sense to ensure a seamless transition from Crossrail 1 to Crossrail 2 to capitalise on the ready workforce and the available tunnelling and engineering expertise.

He argues there is a particular need for investment in north-south routes, and by 2030 the Victoria, Northern and Piccadilly Lines - already overcrowded at times - would be under massive pressure from growing passenger numbers.

"Doing nothing is not an option," he said.

The regional option There are two Crossrail 2 routes being consulted upon

"The alternative is a patch-and-mend job. But even if you do that now, you will only have to build Crossrail 2 eventually anyway," he said.

Mayor Boris Johnson said Crossrail 2 was being "seriously considered" by the Treasury and that it was the timing of it at issue.

But he said despite being a "passionate optimist" he thought Crossrail 2 would most likely be a separate project starting "as early as 2019".

Growing resentment

A report, commissioned by business organisation London First, says Crossrail 2 is essential to reduce journey times, tackle over-crowding, relieve pressure on the tube and south-west overground rail routes and promote economic growth - especially in the Lea Valley in north-east London.

But there are signs of growing resentment among Tory backbenchers at Westminster at what they perceive to have been favourable treatment of the capital over recent years.

Last week in Parliament, David Mowat, Conservative MP for Warrington South, attacked the London mayor's pursuit of a second Crossrail project, saying London gets too much taxpayers' money for public transport.

Prompted by claims by Boris Johnson that "momentum" was growing for Crossrail 2, he demanded a parliamentary debate before any money was approved even for preparatory work on a new rail line.

Earlier Mr Mowat said: "I think there is a view, which may or may not be fair, that the Department for Transport finds it easier to allocate money to London.

"London is our capital city and we're all proud of London and want it to continue to prosper. But there other parts of the country that need transport spending as well including my constituency.

"I'm keen to make sure CR2 comes under scrutiny like HS2 and also keen to put it on policy maker's agendas that there are other parts of the country that need infrastructure and parts that are not as strong as London.

Two potential routes for Crossrail 2 have been put out for consultation Conservative MP for Warrington South wants CR2 to be scrutinised as much as HS2

"It is true to say London has higher capital spend per head than other parts of the country and it also has higher current spending per head than other parts of the country."

'London has done well'

Eric Ollerenshaw, former leader of the Conservatives on the London Assembly and now MP for Lancaster and Fleetwood, said one of the government's priorities was to rebalance the economy between the north and south, and funding for Crossrail 2 could leave their regions short of investment.

Northampton South MP Brian Binley, who was a member of the Crossrail parliamentary committee, said, "Enough money's been spent on London already.

"I support Crossrail and want it to get moving as quickly as possible but I don't think there needs to be any money spent on Crossrail 2."

Lord Adonis accepted that investment in London transport was becoming increasingly "politically contentious" ahead of the Chancellor's spending review next month which will outline departmental budgets for the next three years.

He said it was important for a strong case to be put together, backed by a partnership between the mayor, local authorities and London businesses.

"There is a strong view in the DfT that London has done very well recently," he said.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC London

Weather

London

Min. Night 5 °C

BBC Local Live

  1.  
    Soho pictures exhibition 16:50:

    Robin Muir spoke to Robert Elms earlier about the exhibit of John Deakin's Soho pictures. Here's one entitled Girl in Cafe taken in the late 1950s.

    Girl in Cafe
     
  2.  
    Burst water main 16:38:

    TfL Traffic News tweets: A41 Hendon Way is slow moving N/B due to a burst water main at The Vale, towards Brent Cross. Down to 1 lane. Queues from Cricklewood Lane.

     
  3.  
    More things to do 16:25:

    Londonist's rundown of things to do today includes seeing Van Gogh's Sunflowers at the National Gallery and London Friday Night Skate open to roller skaters and bladers. Both are free.

     
  4.  
    Snail-chucking survey 16:13:

    A survey by the Royal Horticultural Society has found gardeners in London are the most likely to get rid of snails by throwing them into their neighbours' gardens. Scottish gardeners were least likely to.

    A snail on an allotment
     
  5.  
    Jo Good 15:57: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    Still to come before 17:00, Killian Donnelly, who plays the part of Deco in the musical version of The Commitments in the West End.

     
  6.  
    West Ham player dies 15:45:

    On Saturday there will be a minute's applause in memory of Dylan Tombides who has died of cancer aged 20.

    A statement from West Ham said: "Dylan's amazing resilience and positivity saw him through months of surgery and chemotherapy, while his outstanding talent saw him make his first-team debut in a League Cup tie with Wigan Athletic at the Boleyn Ground in September 2012."

     
  7.  
    Mosque demonstration 15:35:

    Met Police officers are outside Central London Mosque next to Regent's Park. A spokesman said there are "small numbers" demonstrating.

    A spokesman for the mosque said radical Islamist preacher Anjem Choudary and a group of his followers were barred from prayer and then clashed with a right wing group outside.

     
  8.  
    Good Friday celebration 15:20:

    Services today include the Solemn Liturgy at Westminster Abbey which started at 15:00 and the Stations of the Cross at Westminster Cathedral at 18:30.

     
  9.  
    Good Friday performance 15:05:

    Reporter Tarah Welsh captures the Wintershall Players' recreation of Christ's crucifixion in Trafalgar Square:

    Trafalgar Square

    The performance is repeated at 15:15.

     
  10.  
    Live music 14:49: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    Ian Prowse and Eimear McGeown perform on Robert Elms' show:

    Ian Prowse and Eimear McGeown
     
  11.  
    West Ham player dies 14:35:

    West Ham United have announced that forward Dylan Tombides has died at the age of 20.

    "Dylan passed away on Friday morning with his family by his side having courageously fought the disease for three years after initially being diagnosed with testicular cancer in summer 2011," says a statement on the club's website.

     
  12.  
    Things to do 14:25:

    Time Out highlights The Passion of Jesus in Trafalgar Square and the Family Weekend at Sadler's Wells.

     
  13.  
    Chanel shop robbery 14:10:

    A smash-and-grab raid took place at the Chanel shop in Brompton Road, Chelsea, shortly before 02:40, police say.

    A stolen Audi was reversed into the shop window and a number of handbags were stolen.

     
  14.  
    Easter getaway 13:55:

    London Paddington tweets: Please allow plenty of time for tickets and boarding trains as we are very busy today. Please check trains with @nationalrailenq thanks

     
  15.  
    Pulis ready to meet league 13:40:

    Crystal Palace manager Tony Pulis is willing to meet the Premier League over claims his club were given Cardiff's team-sheet before they beat their rivals in early April.

    Crystal Palace manager Tony Pulis

    He said: "I log every session that I do and I'll be taking those sessions up to the Premier League to show that I picked my team on the Monday before. That team was worked with for a week and there were no changes whatsoever."

     
  16.  
    Bullied children 13:25: BBC Radio 5 live

    Professor Louise Arsenault of King's College London discusses research which has found being bullied as a child can have consequences into people's fifties.

     
  17.  
    Ramsey nets young player nomination 13:10:

    Arsenal star Aaron Ramsey joins Chelsea player Eden Hazard, Liverpool's Daniel Sturridge and Raheem Sterling, Everton's Ross Barkley and Southampton's Luke Shaw in the PFA young player of the year nominations.

    Arsenal midfielder Aaron Ramsey
     
  18.  
    Hazard up for player of the year 12:55:

    Chelsea midfielder Eden Hazard has been nominated for the Professional Footballers' Association's player of the year title.

    Eden Hazard

    He will need to beat Liverpool trio Steven Gerrard, Luis Suarez and Daniel Sturridge, Man City's Yaya Toure and Southampton's Adam Lallana if he is to pick up the award.

     
  19.  
    Council newspapers warning 12:40: BBC Radio 4

    Communities Secretary Eric Pickles is threatening to stop councils printing their own newspapers and giving them away free.

    One is Newham Borough Council. Its elected mayor Sir Robin Wales told the Today programme: "We've got the most diverse community in the world. We have a turn-round of 40% in four years - huge churn - and we have to get our messages out."

     
  20.  
    Good Samaritans sought 12:25:

    London24 reports that a teenager who was stabbed in the chest in Finsbury Park is trying to find the two men he says saved him. He said: "I would like to meet and thank them in person. I'm sure that I would not be here today if it wasn't for their help."

     
  21.  
    Roads warning 12:14:

    BBC London Travel tweets: #Westminster Good Friday parade leaving Storey's Gate at 12:15 for Westminster Cathedral via Broad Sanctuary and Victoria St ps #roads

     
  22.  
    Eurostar services normal again 12:06:

    Channel Tunnel rail services have returned to normal following disruption, Eurostar says.

    Annabel Troost is among those who have tweeted complaints: She wrote: @Eurostar I had to cancel my journey from London to Amsterdam last evening. Not great at all. Full refund and reaction appreciated.

    The firm told her it was sorry she had to cancel her trip and urged her to contact them.

     
  23.  
    Blues women beat Bristol 11:50:

    In the Women's Superleague, Chelsea beat Bristol Academy 2-0 thanks to two goals from Japan striker Yuki Ogimi.

    Yuki Ogimi
     
  24.  
    Robert Elms 11:35: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    From 12:00 on the programme, it's Funky Friday. Robert hears from the curator of John Deakin and the Lure of Soho at The Photographer's Gallery, and the Widow's Son pub in Bow where the annual hot cross bun ceremony is taking place later. Ian Prowse, who is playing The Borderline tonight, performs.

     
  25.  
    Channel Tunnel 11:19:

    Eurostar says it expects a normal service today after yesterday's delays, but trains will be busy. If you are booked to travel today you should check in as normal, but may wish to get there a bit earlier. This is the Twitter feed for information.

     
  26.  
    Bees buzzing for promotion bid 10:59: Ankur Desai Sport journalist, BBC London

    In League One, second placed Brentford play Preston and Leyton Orient travel to Crawley Town. If the Bees win and Orient and Rotherham both lose, Mark Warburton's side will be promoted into the Championship.

     
  27.  
    Canoe race delayed 10:46:

    The Devizes to Westminster International Canoe Race has been delayed because of a "police incident".

    Wiltshire Police say it's an ongoing incident and don't know when the 125-mile marathon will be able to start. They have said they're considering starting it from another location but it won't be cancelled.

     
  28.  
    Overheard in the newsroom 10:29:

    "I think you could interview Jesus."

    Producer Jeremy Rawlins briefs reporter Tarah Welsh who is now heading to Trafalgar Square to report on the re-enactment of the Passion of Jesus by the Wintershall Players.

     
  29.  
    Channel Tunnel disruption 10:15:

    Technical problems and a fatality near Lille caused severe disruption in the Channel Tunnel yesterday.

    Disruption

    You can find details of Eurostar's disruption compensation here.

     
  30.  
    Engineering works on trains 09:59: Paul Murphy-Kasp Journalist, BBC London

    Engineering works will affect trains in and around London across the Easter weekend with no trains at Charing Cross and a very limited service from London Bridge.

    At Paddington, some lines will be closed which means changes on trains to Heathrow and the west of England, and on the East Coast main line some lines will be closed between Finsbury Park and Kings Cross meaning there is a very limited service.

    Services affected: Southeastern; First Capital Connect, Southern and Thameslink; First Great Western, Heathrow Connect and Heathrow Express; East Coast, First Hill trains and Grand Central trains.

     
  31.  
    Good Friday celebration 09:45:

    The Passion of Jesus is to be performed in Trafalgar Square by Wintershall Players at 12:00 and 15:15 today, recreating Christ's crucifixion and resurrection with a huge cast in historic dress.

    Cardinal Vincent Nichols will give the closing prayers at 13:15.

     
  32.  
    LATEST UPDATES
     
  33.  
    Today's sport 09:30: Ankur Desai Sport journalist, BBC London

    A busy weekend of bank holiday football kicks off later this afternoon on BBC London 94.9. Charlton will continue their battle against Championship relegation at 15:00 when they take on Bolton at The Valley.

     
  34.  
    Weekend weather 09:16:

    Watch Elizabeth Rizzini's Easter weather report here.

    Elizabeth Rizzini
     
  35.  
    Long weekends 09:00:

    Every weekend could be four days long with today's technology, writes David Spencer, Professor of Economics and Political Economy at the University of Leeds in The Conversation.

     
  36.  
    Nikki Bedi in for Vanessa Feltz 08:44: BBC London 94.9 Radio

    Coming up from 09:00: The effects of childhood bullying in adult life - Elizabeth Kesses, author of The Ugly Girl Trilogy and Bea Appleby editor of Girl Talk magazine discuss the issue. And how would you feel about your child singing the national anthem every day at school?

     
  37.  
    Tube and Overground disruption 08:21:

    Disruption over the Easter period:

    • District Line: No trains between Ealing Broadway and Turnham Green from 20:45 tonight
    • Jubilee Line: No trains between Waterloo and Finchley Road
    • Piccadilly Line: No trains between Acton Town and Uxbridge from 20:50 tonight
    • Bakerloo Line: No trains between Harrow & Wealdstone and Willesden Junction on Easter Sunday
    • London Overground: No trains between Surrey Quays and Clapham Junction all weekend, and no trains between Watford Junction and Queens Park on Sunday.
    • DLR: No service between Stratford and Bow Church for a week from Good Friday
     
  38.  
    Looking good weather-wise today 08:06:

    It will be dry with long sunny spells, feeling quite pleasant by the afternoon with only light winds.

    Maximum temperature: 14C (57F).

     
  39.  
    08:00: Josephine McDermott BBC News Online

    Good morning from an empty central London. I'll be here throughout the day bringing you the latest news, sport, travel and weather for London.

    Regent Street

    You can tell me your news by emailing london.locallive@bbc.co.uk or tweeting @BBCLondonNews.

     

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.