Q&A: Why A&E units in London are set to close

Health services across London are under going a vast overhaul, with NHS trusts across the city deciding what services each hospital should offer.

On Tuesday, health bosses in north-west London are set to approve plans to close A&E units across the area and instead have trauma centres at major hospitals.

What has been proposed?

Protest against changes to Charing Cross Hospital Protests have taken place against the planned changes

The recommendations are for four A&E departments in hospitals in north-west London to be closed.

The departments at Ealing, Central Middlesex, Charing Cross and Hammersmith hospitals would be downgraded to 24/7 urgent care centres and would no longer take "blue light patients".

Five "major hospitals" - Chelsea and Westminster, Hillingdon, Northwick Park, St Mary's in Paddington and West Middlesex - would have more specialist and experienced doctors available more of the time.

Five specialist hospitals in the area, Harefield, Mount Vernon, Royal Brompton, Royal Marsden and Royal National Orthopaedic Hospital, are not affected by the proposals.

What services will the hospitals offer?

Some hospitals already have urgent care centres which is where treatment is GP-led. They treat cases which are not quite as serious.

The hospitals would still offer things such as outpatient and diagnostic care like X-rays and physiotherapy, however they would not be able to treat life-threatening conditions such as strokes, internal bleeding and heart attacks.

"Major hospitals" will have 24/7 A&E units and would be able to undertake both emergency and elective operations; have intensive care units, psychiatric liaison, inpatient paediatrics and a maternity unit.

Why are these changes being made?

The NHS trusts say 70% of patients that go to A&E units do not need to go there, for example, if someone has a sprained ankle.

Hospital ward Think Tank Health 2020 said hospitals as they are have become "unsustainable" financially

Julia Manning, chief executive of Health 2020, a non-profit Think Tank, said there were many cases where people did not need to go to an A&E unit.

"The reality is we have a hospital system that has grown up unplanned, unstructured, and we have too many hospitals.

"A hospital should be a place of last resort that you go to, it shouldn't be where most people go for routine checks."

She said the hospitals as they currently are, were financially unsustainable and not safe as they could not offer "the quality of specialised care in every hospital at the bottom of people's roads".

What has the reaction been?

Local campaigners say the changes mean that they are no longer hospitals but "super GP clinics" and that it would pit "hospitals against hospital".

Ealing Council leader Julian Bell said he was "bitterly disappointed" and that the council would fight the proposals "all the way". He said the scrutiny committee was going to take it up with Health Secretary Jeremy Hunt and it would also consider a judicial review.

Save Our Hospitals campaign has raised concerns that the A&E departments that remain would not be able to cope with the increase in admissions.

And a King's Fund review into A&E waiting times said that across England, 232,000 people had waited for more than four hours to be seen, adding waiting times were the highest level for a decade.

What about the rest of London?

On Thursday, health bosses in south-west London are going to outline their recommendations for the area. Of the five hospitals, it is expected that the A&E departments in Epsom and St Helier are to close.

In south-east London, proposals to downgrade Lewisham Hospital's A&E department and to turn the maternity unit to one which is midwife-led have been met with fierce opposition with up to 15,000 people protesting against the plan.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC London



9 °C 5 °C

BBC Local Live


    The CPS says it would have charged Mr Zalkalns if he had been alive although there was no forensic or eyewitness evidence, only circumstantial.


    The Met Police have sent a report to the Crown Prosecution Service saying Arnis Zalkalns was responsible for the murder of 14-year-old school girl Alice Gross.

    09:00: News on the hour Jason Rosam Journalist, BBC London

    In the London News at 09:00, the mayor's cycling commissioner says the consultation into plans to segregate cyclists from traffic along the Embankment.

    And the wife of a Russian spy who was murdered in London in 2006 says what she hopes an inquiry into his death will achieve.

    08:51: On air BBC London 94.9 Radio

    London Mayor Boris Johnson is to go ahead with his flagship cycle superhighway on Victoria Embankment.

    You can tell Vanessa what you think of the plans on BBC London 94.9 from 09:00.

    08:39: Travel BBC Travel

    There are no Virgin or London Midland trains in or out of Euston at the moment due to electrical supply problems in the Wembley area.

    Keep up to date with BBC Travel or on Twitter @BBCLondonTravel

    08:27: TV headlines BBC London News TV

    The headlines in this morning's bulletins include:

    • Public Health England has found that young people in London are the least likely to smoke in the country
    • A care home for the elderly in Rotherhithe is holding cocktail parties to help people with dementia relive their younger years
    Asad Ahmad
    08:17: Thameslink service returns Louise Pepper Journalist, BBC London

    Thameslink trains are back to normal after the disruption yesterday and on Friday following flooding in one of the tunnels.

    08:10: Milder than lately

    It's a bright, chilly start with some patchy ground frost.

    Weather today

    Cloudy conditions will gradually spread from the west, but it should remain dry with a maximum temperature of 9C (48F).

    08:01: Radio headlines Jason Rosam Journalist, BBC London

    The top stories this morning:

    08:00: Rebecca Cafe BBC News

    Good morning. I'll be bringing you all the latest news, sport, travel and weather until 18:00.

    You can email me your comments about the stories of the day or send photos or tweet @BBCLondonNews.



Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.