Pair guilty of Trafalgar Square homophobic killing

From left: Ruby Thomas, Joel Alexander and Rachael Burke Thomas (left) and Alexander were convicted of manslaughter, Burke was found guilty of affray

Related Stories

Two people who fatally attacked a man in London's Trafalgar Square after he had been subjected to homophobic taunts have been convicted of manslaughter.

Ian Baynham, 62, of Beckenham, south-east London, was assaulted outside South Africa House in September 2009. He died 18 days later.

He was punched by Joel Alexander, 20, and then repeatedly stamped on by Ruby Thomas, 18, as he lay unconscious.

The Old Bailey heard shocked onlookers had seen his head being kicked.

Alexander, of Thornton Heath, south-east London, was 19 at the time of the attack while Thomas, of Anerley, also south-east London, was 17.

Rachael Burke, 18, of Upper Norwood, south-east London, was found guilty of affray at an earlier trial but cleared of manslaughter.

Mr Baynham had just started a new job as a team leader in border control at the Home Office when he was killed during a night out.

The court heard one of the girls was overheard saying "we can do them" as a gay couple walked past them holding hands.

Escalating row

Later Thomas made homophobic comments when the victim and his friend Philip Brown passed them.

The court heard Mr Baynham told Thomas: "No, I don't want to sleep with you", before the row escalated.

She began hitting the victim with her handbag and he grabbed it.

Alexander, a sports science student at the University of East London who was with the group, intervened and punched Mr Baynham, knocking him to the ground.

Ian Baynham Ian Baynham was attacked in Trafalgar Square in September 2009

Mr Brown told the court how he heard a "crunching noise" when his friend "fell like a corpse" and hit the ground.

As Mr Baynham lay on the pavement with blood pouring from his ear, nose and mouth, the girls stamped and kicked him.

Thomas, an ex-public schoolgirl, smiled as she and Burke "put the boot into" Mr Baynham after he was knocked to the ground by Alexander, the court heard.

Brian Altman QC, prosecuting, told the court the girls had been "fuelled by copious amounts of alcohol".

He said: "There is evidence that the female defendants then began putting the boot into Mr Baynham, who was still prone on his back, clearly unconscious and in distress.

Start Quote

I'm just scared 'bout my parents seeing it and scared 'bout us all being caught”

End Quote Rachael Burke Facebook conversation

"Shocked onlookers saw repeated stamping to his chest and forceful kicks to his head."

A witness described the attack as like a scene from the film A Clockwork Orange.

Police later found Mr Baynham's blood on Thomas's handbag and shoes.

The next day Thomas joked about the attack while chatting on Facebook but after Mr Baynham's death she told her then boyfriend "I didn't touch him", the jury heard.

A message from an unnamed friend to Thomas read: "Remember the gay men u beat up?

"Joel knocked him out he had a heart attack he sed [sic]."

Thomas replied: "Omg that is mad."

Burke said in another Facebook conversation: "I'm just scared 'bout my parents seeing it [the CCTV] and recognising it and scared 'bout us all being caught.

CCTV footage of Ian Baynham A paramedic attends to Ian Baynham soon after the attack

"I'm bare (very) scared."

In a victim impact statement Jenny Baynham, 59, said her brother's death had "devastated" their 90-year-old mother.

"I was horrified at what had happened and found it difficult to understand why anyone could have assaulted him in that way.

"It seems so ironic that his life ended so horrifically and senselessly on the streets of London which he loved so much.

"He was very aware some people were prejudiced against him."

She added that her brother, who was openly gay, had "deep-rooted traditional values and would always stand up for his beliefs".

The court heard Thomas was given a referral order after admitting to carrying out a drunken attack on a bus driver at the age of 15.

Evening's 'dark shadow'

All three attackers will be sentenced in 2011.

Following the verdict Det Insp Paul Barran, of the Met, said: "Ian's death was totally unnecessary.

"The dark shadow of that evening's events will remain with those involved for a long time.

"As shown by the court today, there is no place whatsoever in our society for any type of aggressive, abusive, confrontational behaviour or homophobic crime."

More on This Story

Related Stories

From other news sites

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC London



Min. Night 13 °C


  • HoneybeesCreating a buzz

    Can President Obama's taskforce save America's bees?

  • Tracer particles show the flow of water around coral (c) Orr H. Shapiro, Vicente I. Fernandez, Melissa S. Garren, Jeffrey S. Guasto, François P. Debaillon-Vesque, Esti Kramarski-Winter, Assaf Vardi, Roman Stocker, PNAS, 2014Troubled waters

    How corals stir up their world to draw in nutrients

  • Ayodeji Adewunmi, Olalekan Olude and Opeyemi Awoyemi standing outside in business attireJobbermen

    The student entrepreneurs behind Nigeria's online jobs giant

  • Women in front of Windows XP posterUpgrade angst

    Readers share their experiences of replacing their operating system

  • Greylag Goose taken by Lee Acaster in LondonWildlife winners

    Image of greylag goose picks up top photography prize

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.