Essex Police criticised over domestic violence deaths

(l-r) Jeanette Goodwin, Christine Chambers, Shania Chambers and Maria Stubbings The report follows the murder of Jeanette Goodwin, Christine Chambers, Shania Chambers and Maria Stubbings

Related Stories

Inspectors say they have "significant concerns" about how domestic violence victims are supported by Essex Police.

HM Inspector of Constabulary (HMIC) has released its report following a number of domestic violence-related killings.

Maria Stubbings, Jeanette Goodwin and Christine Chambers were all murdered by their ex-partners, while Christine's daughter Shania was also killed.

HMIC said more work was needed to manage properly the risk to victims. Essex Police said it had improved.

The Independent Police Complaints Commission found failings in all three murder cases.

Start Quote

Stephen Kavanagh

We receive 80 calls on domestic abuse a day and we are very conscious that we must get our response right every single time”

End Quote Stephen Kavanagh Chief Constable, Essex
'Poor' communication

In their report, HMIC inspectors said the way officers dealt with domestic violence was "fragmented" and of "significant concern".

HMIC said better support should be given to victims of crime and added those involved in domestic violence investigations were "poor" at communicating with each other and outside bodies.

The report said: "Most staff were not able to demonstrate a broad understanding of the wider response to domestic abuse, and of how dealing with it effectively can enhance the confidence of victims and ultimately prevent homicides."

Zoe Billingham, from HM Inspector of Constabulary, said: "It's absolutely vital the police get the handling of these cases right for victims.

"The force has taken a number of important steps to address how domestic abuse cases are handled.

"However, there is still more work to do to ensure that victims get the best possible service from their force."

'Tragedy'

Women let down by police

  • Maria Stubbings, 50, was strangled with a dog lead by her ex-boyfriend Marc Chivers, who had also killed a previous girlfriend
  • The IPCC said Ms Stubbings was not given adequate protection
  • Christine Chambers, 38, complained about violence from David Oakes for two years before he murdered her
  • The IPCC found the force's response was "inadequate"
  • Jeanette Goodwin, 47, was stabbed 30 times by her ex-partner Martin Bunch in front of her husband
  • The IPCC said Mrs Goodwin had called police before the attack but they did not recognise "urgent action" was needed

Chief Constable Stephen Kavanagh said the report recognised "the substantial steps" taken to arrest suspects as soon as possible and deal with calls quickly.

He added: "But I also recognise that it highlights several areas where we need to streamline our processes, improve communication and provide a better service to victims.

"This includes improving information sharing between other agencies by tackling the issue with a genuine partnership response and commitment."

He added: "I'm interested in listening to charities, local authorities, social services, prosecutors, academic experts, victim advocates and my own officers - who deal with this problem on the front-line.

"We receive 80 calls on domestic abuse a day and we are very conscious that we must get our response right every single time."

John Hayward-Cripps, from Victim Support, said: "The tragedy is that it has taken the deaths of four people to drive forward this change in approach.

"As the HMIC report recommends, Victim Support firmly believes that identifying those at the most risk of harm is critical to protecting victims, as is early identification to stop domestic abuse before it escalates.

"It is also only through joined-up working between police and other agencies that come into contact with those affected by abuse that victims do not fall through the cracks."

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Essex

Weather

Chelmsford

Min. Night 7 °C

Features

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.