Devon health boss Dr Paula Vasco-Knight suspended after 'nepotism' tribunal

Dr Paula Vasco-Knight Dr Paula Vasco-Knight was appointed a CBE in the New Year Honours List for services to the NHS

Related Stories

A hospital boss has been suspended from her job after being criticised by a tribunal over whistle-blowers who accused her of nepotism.

South Devon Healthcare NHS Foundation Trust said chief executive Dr Paula Vasco-Knight would be suspended during an investigation into her actions.

Last week, non-executive trust board directors launched a "formal process to investigate concerns" about her.

The board said the suspension would have no bearing on the investigation.

An employment tribunal vindicated two women who had accused Dr Vasco-Knight of nepotism and favouritism by recruiting her daughter's boyfriend to a job at the hospital.

It found Claire Sardari and Penny Gates had been victimised as a result of whistle-blowing about their concerns.

Penny Gates and Clare Sardari Penny Gates and Clare Sardari suffered from their whistle-blowing allegations, the tribunal ruled

The tribunal chairman Nick Roper said the trust had acted in an "astonishing way" and made "dishonest" attempts to suppress the findings of an investigation into the affair.

Immediately after the judgement, the chairman of South Devon Healthcare, Peter Hildrew, resigned.

'Victimises staff'


With the resignation of the chairman, Peter Hildrew, followed by the departure last week of acting chairman, Topsy Murray, for health reasons, the suspension of the chief executive leaves South Devon Healthcare with a leadership vacuum. However, the board had been left with no choice.

In the wake of the Mid Staffordshire scandal, when those who flagged up their worries about poor care were not listened to, hospitals have to make it clear that whistle blowers will be given a fair hearing.

On the anniversary of his report into Mid Staffs, Robert Francis said what had happened at Torbay Hospital was an example of "oppressive managerial behaviour" which "victimises staff who raise honestly held concerns".

His view was shared by local NHS commissioners, who said it was "fundamental to good patient care" that whistle-blowers felt able to speak out without fear. In a spirit of "candour, transparency and openness" the CCG said Paula Vasco-Knight could not remain in her job while the trust investigated her actions. The board now appears to agree.

On Friday, the local NHS body, the South Devon and Torbay Clinical Commissioning Group, said the chief executive, who became a CBE in the New Year Honours List, should be suspended.

Robert Francis, who wrote the report into the care failings at Stafford Hospital, said the case was an example of "oppressive managerial behaviour... which victimises staff who raise honestly-held concerns".

He added it was "hugely damaging to the confidence of staff contemplating raising concerns".

Chairman Dr Sam Barrell said: "It's fundamental to good patient care that whistle-blowers feel able to raise their concerns without fear of retribution."

David Allen, speaking on behalf of the non-executive directors of the trust, said their decision to suspend Dr Vasco-Knight was a "neutral act" which was "in the best interest of all parties".

He said he wanted to remind patients that "serious as the recent employment tribunal case is, it stems from allegations of favouritism in a recruitment process for a single administrative role. It has absolutely nothing to do with our core business of patient care".

More on This Story

Related Stories

From other news sites

* May require registration or subscription

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Devon



19 °C 13 °C


BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.