Mistake in poet Manley Hopkins' name angers lecturer

Dr Mack and the inscription outside Exeter Cathedral: Pic Matt Austin Dr Mack said it was a "disgraceful and embarrassing" mistake

A "disgraceful" mistake over the name of a famous English poet has upset a university lecturer in Devon.

Dr Robert Mack, an English lecturer at the University of Exeter, noticed the error on a paved inscription outside Exeter Cathedral.

A quotation is wrongly attributed to Gerald Manley Hopkins - when the 19th Century Victorian poet's name was actually Gerard.

The cathedral authorities said the mistake would be corrected.

The poetry-engraved paving around Cathedral Green is part of the cathedral's Third Millennium Campaign.

'Provincial fools'

The cathedral said the aim of the quotations was to stimulate "thought and reflection".

Start Quote

Why didn't someone see it before the chisel hit the stone?”

End Quote Dr Robert Mack English lecturer

Dr Mack, however, said for him it stimulated "disbelief and anger".

"It was busy on the High Street and I wanted some peace and quiet," he told BBC News.

"I made my way to the cathedral because I usually find looking at its towers gives me a sense of calm.

"First of all I noticed the benches were gone, then I noticed the inscription... I couldn't believe what I saw."

The English lecturer, who is originally from the US, said such a mistake was "disgraceful and embarrassing for Exeter".

Inscription outside Exeter Cathedral: Pic Matt Austin The cathedral said it would not be necessary to have the whole stone done again

"So let's fix it, because we don't want to look like provincial fools," Dr Mack said.

"We can all make mistakes, but how many eyes must have seen this?

"There must have been many, many pairs, so why didn't someone see it before the chisel hit the stone?"

The inscription "The world is charged with the grandeur of God" is the opening line of "God's Grandeur", written by the Roman Catholic poet in 1877.

While he accepts that many people might not know who Manley Hopkins was, Dr Mack is "puzzled" that no-one from the cathedral noticed.

"Not only was he a major English poet, he was a Jesuit priest," he said.

A cathedral spokesperson said the error would be rectified as soon as possible, but it would not be necessary to have the entire stone redone.

More on This Story

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Devon



25 °C 17 °C


BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.