Derby fire deaths: Philpott killings 'not predictable'

Duwayne Philpott, 13, Jade Philpott, 10, and brothers John, nine, Jack, seven, Jesse, six, and Jayden, five Duwayne, Jade, John, Jack, Jesse and Jayden Philpott died in the fire in 2012

Related Stories

The deaths of six children in a Derby house fire "could not have been predicted or prevented", a serious case review has concluded.

Social services, police and health workers were given no reason for concern beforehand, the report said.

The children, aged between five and 13, died as a result of the fire at their home in Victory Road in May 2012.

Parents Mick and Mairead Philpott, and their friend Paul Mosley, were jailed for manslaughter last April.

The Derby Safeguarding Children Board (DSCB) said the review was to "examine closely" agency work and practices.

'Sad truth'

The report said it had been well known for years there were overcrowding issues in the home and that living arrangements were "unorthodox".

It also stated no members of the family, community, teachers or agencies had raised concerns about the children.

Glenys Johnston, the report's author, said: "Despite the horrific deaths of these children there are few areas for learning for professionals.

"The sad truth is that no-one could have predicted or prevented the events that took place on 11 May 2012."

The report added: "Given the notoriety of the father, the incidents of domestic abuse and visibility of the children, there were some opportunities to get to know the family better.

"However this would not have led to professionals becoming aware that there were plans to deliberately set fire to the house when the children were sleeping."

The report also said an earlier assessment in 2006 concerning domestic violence against Mairead Philpott was "explained away as insignificant by the family" and treated as minor.

"Several agencies did not know of his violent past; had they, they may have considered their assessment of him differently at the time of their involvement," the report said.

'Unusual family'

The report made 10 recommendations for improving practice and procedures among the police, local authority and health services, many of which the DSCB said were already in place.

Mick Philpott, Mairead Philpott and Paul Mosley Mick and Mairead Philpott and Paul Mosley were found guilty in April

It outlined that a system had been put in place to ensure children in large families were linked when referrals were received and clearer guidelines had been introduced for police officers investigating domestic violence to ensure children's details were recorded.

DSCB chairwoman Christine Cassell said: "This was an unusual family and the adult relationships were unusual, but they were never illegal.

"The evidence found that the children were happy, well-nourished, attended school and they had good social relationships between themselves and with other children."

Mairead Philpott's sister Jennifer Lobban said: "I do think in some cases they could have been more involved with the family.

"I think they were just kind of left to carry on with their own devices."

She added: "As bad as [Mick Philpott] was, no-one would ever have known that he was going to do something like that."

A spokesperson for Derby City Council said the authority "acknowledges the findings".

Jade Philpott, 10, John, nine, Jack, eight, Jesse, six, and Jayden, five, died in the fire. Duwayne Philpott, aged 13, died later in hospital.

Derbyshire Fire and Rescue said the sound of smoke alarms in the house at the time, failed to wake the children.

Watch manager Dave Coss carried out research into children and alarms and concluded many do sleep through the noise.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Derby



Min. Night 10 °C

BBC Local Live

    Share your views 16:31: Sandish Shoker

    We've introduced BBC Local Live to bring you the latest news, sport, travel and weather all in one place. Tell us what you think.

    Ancient woodland to be restored 16:21: Belper News

    An area of ancient woodland in Derbyshire is to be restored after the project received funding worth £15,085.

    'Huge honour' to play Cloughie 16:09:

    Michael Sheen has been talking to BBC Radio Derby's Andy Potter about his role as Brian Clough in The Damned United.

    Michael Sheen

    "It was a huge honour to be a part the legacy of Cloughie," he said.

    "There's not many characters like him and they don't come around very often."

    News on the hour 15:57: BBC Radio Derby

    Police are appealing for witnesses after a man was assaulted in one of the car parks at Alton Towers on Saturday evening.

    The victim, in his 40s, is a manager at one of the hotels and was taken to hospital for treatment. He is now recovering at home. Listen live.

    Disruption on the trains 15:52:

    East Midlands Trains are reporting problems on services running between Derby and Crewe because of an incident in Kidsgrove, Staffordshire, BBC Travel reports.

    Alternative services have been made available for passengers.

    Train delays in Derby 15:45:

    East Midlands Trains tweets: #EMTUpdate Customers travelling from Crewe and Derby can use alternative routes via Tamworth and Birmingham #Kidsgrove

    Keogh signs new contract 15:37:

    Derby County captain Richard Keogh has signed a new deal with the club which will keep him there until 2017, BBC Sport reports.

    Richard Keogh

    First-team coach Paul Simpson said it had taken longer than the club would have hoped to confirm the three-year deal.

    Lancasters wow Peak District crowds 15:27:

    Here is another great shot from Mick Ryan, who was one of the hundreds of spectators who stood on hills in the Peak District to get a glimpse of the two airworthy Lancasters flying over Ladybower yesterday.

    Lancaster Bombers

    Hear more from the historic event on BBC Radio Derby after 16:00.

    Warm weather still to come 15:08: Charlie Slater Weather Presenter, BBC East Midlands Today

    There'll be cold mornings and lots of dry weather around this week. We may even a get a slightly warmer air mass later this week too.

    Weather map
    News on the hour 14:55: Kelly Smith Reporter, BBC Radio Derby

    Lea Wood Nature Reserve, in Cromford, has been handed a £15,000 grant from Derbyshire Wildlife Trust to restore an area of ancient woodland. Listen live to the bulletin.

    Derby's derelict buildings 14:48:

    Photographer David Sillitoe explores the urban decay of some of the buildings in the East Midlands on tonight's BBC Inside Out.

    Derelict buildings

    In Derby he meets members of the Hippodrome Restoration Trust. The hippodrome has suffered a fire and partial unlawful demolition.

    The photographer also peers through the railings of the crumbling and vandalised old Derbyshire Royal Infirmary. Watch more from 19:30 on BBC One.

    Derbyshire Day time-lapse video 14:29:

    Head over to the BBC Radio Derby Facebook page to see two time-lapse videos of the Derbyshire Day event at Calke Abbey on Sunday.

    Derbyshire Day
    Little Eaton is blooming marvellous 14:08:

    Sue Stone and Moira Hutchinson, from Little Eaton in Bloom, say they are "absolutely flabbergasted" after the village won silver in the large village category at its first attempt in the East Midlands in Bloom competition.

    Little Eaton
    News on the hour 13:58: BBC Radio Derby

    Coming up in the news bulletin at 14:00: Police have released CCTV footage of two women they'd like to trace in connection with the theft of a large amount of money in Derby.

    Council gets travel award nomination 13:51:

    Derbyshire County Council has been nominated in a national travel awards for two projects to encourage pupils and parents to walk or cycle to school.

    The council has received two nominations in the Modeshift National Travel Awards for its project with Newbold Community School and the Wheely Fun Wheels activity week.

    Masked gang attack man 13:40: Matlock Mercury

    Masked raiders forced their way into a man's Brimington home before assaulting him in a late night attack.

    Lancaster bomber photo 13:27:

    Mick Ryan has sent us this stunning photo of the Lancaster bombers flypast over Derwent Dam this weekend.

    Lancaster Bombers

    If you missed it, BBC News Online has footage of the moment the Lancasters came together in a tribute to the men who practised the Dambusters raid there.

    London Road bridge works 13:15:

    Derby City Council tweets: Don't forget business open as usual along London Road, including Midland Road and City Gate as works on London Road Bridge continue #Derbyuk

    Thousands watch historic flight 13:04: Geeta Pendse Reporter, BBC East Midlands Today

    On BBC East Midlands Today we look back at the thousands of people who came to Derbyshire to see a recreation of the famous Damnbusters flight.

    Tune in from 13:30 on BBC One.

    News on the hour 12:57: BBC Radio Derby

    A former chemical factory in Derby, which dates back to 1916 and once employed 20,000 people, is due to be demolished.

    Production at the plant ceased in 2012 but members of the public were invited to see the site of the acetate production plant for one last time this weekend. Listen live

    Health centre plans collapse 12:41: Derby Telegraph

    Eagerly-awaited plans for a multi-million pound health centre at eyesore Duckworth Square have fallen through.

    New managers for clubs 12:28:

    Two Derby football teams are looking for new managers after Peter Duffield quit as Belper boss following their 5-1 defeat at Buxton on Saturday and Gresley manager Martin Rowe resigned on before their 4-2 loss at Goole.

    What is Derbyshire Day? 12:16:

    Derbyshire Day was started by BBC Radio Derby in 2007 to celebrate the very best of the county.

    It is marked on 22 September to coincide with the anniversary of the unveiling of the Derbyshire Flag and includes music, arts, crafts and food and drink.

    Listen again to BBC Radio Derby's coverage of this year's event which attracted 11,000 people.

    Brian Clough remembered 12:05: Sandish Shoker BBC News Online

    Saturday marked the 10th anniversary of the death of former Derby County manager Brian Clough.

    Brian Clough

    I spoke to some of the people who worked with him at football clubs over the years to get their stories of Old Big 'Ead.

    In the news at 12:00 11:57: Sally Swinfen Reporter, BBC Radio Derby

    CCTV has been released by Derbyshire Police of two women they would like to speak to after a large amount of money was taken from a 71-year-old woman while she was shopping with her husband in the Intu Derby shopping centre.

    The victim noticed her bag was open and the cash had gone as she got onto a bus in Albert Street at about 12:25 on Wednesday.

    E-cigarette fire warning 11:55:

    Derbyshire Fire and Rescue tweets: E-cigarette user? Be aware of the fire hazards they pose; See @Derbyshirecc advice & ours too

    Record numbers at Derbyshire Day 11:40: Derby Telegraph

    Bumper crowds came through the gates at Calke Abbey on Sunday for Derbyshire Day.

    Visitors met their favourite BBC Radio Derby presenters while a World War One roadshow brought re-enactments and workshops.

    Investigation into Al-Madinah finances 11:26: Simon Hare Reporter, BBC East Midlands Today

    The National Union of Teachers is calling for an investigation into finances at the Al-Madinah free school in Derby and regional representatives have called it "an appalling use of public money".

    It is after a government inspection found conflicts of interest between some governors and companies supplying the school with things like cleaners and midday supervisors.

    Village in bloom 11:16: BBC Radio Derby

    A gardening group in Derbyshire says it was astonished to win silver at its first attempt in the East Midlands in Bloom competition.

    Little Eaton in bloom

    Little Eaton was entered in the large village category.

    Bridge work road closure 11:06:

    There are severe delays today following the closure of the A5194 London Road, Derby, BBC Travel reports.

    The road is closed in both directions between Bateman Street and the Railway Technical Centre because of bridge maintenance work. Diversions are in place.

    News on the Hour 11:00: BBC Radio Derby

    In the news at 11:00 with Sally Swinfin, the National Union of Teachers is calling for an investigation into finances at the Al-Madinah free school in Derby.

    Derbyshire Day today 10:48: Aleena Naylor BBC Radio Derby presenter

    Today, 22 September, is actually Derbyshire Day - it's just BBC Radio Derby celebrates it on the nearest Sunday.

    Lancaster bombers over Derwent 10:35:

    Crowds gathered at the Derwent Dam in Derbyshire yesterday to see the last two airworthy Lancaster bombers fly over the site where the famous Dambusters raid was practised.

    Derwent Dam

    BBC News Online has a video of the "once in a lifetime" sight.

    Car park to close 10.18: Ilkeston Advertiser

    A car park in Ilkeston will no longer be run by Erewash Borough Council following the sale of the former Woolworths building.

    Keogh to secure deal at Derby 10:03:

    Derby County captain Richard Keogh is expected to sign on a new three-year contract this week after manager Steve McClaren called him a vital part of the team.

    Richard Keogh

    The 28 year-old will become the latest senior player to commit his future to the club over recent months, following the likes of Craig Bryson, Will Hughes and Chris Martin.

    News on the hour 09:56: Sally Swinfen Reporter, BBC Radio Derby

    Our lead story in the news at 10:00 on BBC Radio Derby is that there are calls for improved care for the elderly at Burton's Queen's Hospital after the death of pensioner Ethel Sanders in 2011.

    The hospital admitted the quality of care provided was inadequate.

    Slow traffic on A38 09:50:

    BBC Travel says there's slow traffic on the A38 northbound in Derby between Mickleover and Markeaston Islands in the roadworks area.

    Share your views 09:36: Sandish Shoker

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? We'd like your feedback about this service.

    Al-Madinah finances 09:23:

    A BBC Inside Out investigation has found an irregularity in the financial accounts of Al-Madinah school in Derby after one former employee received an unauthorised overtime payment of £12,000.

    Al-Madinah School

    The latest published records at the free school showed the employee has still not repaid the money.

    There will be more on BBC Inside Out at 19:30 on BBC One.

    Belper boss quits 09:04: Derby Telegraph

    Peter Duffield quit as Belper Town manager following Saturday's 5-1 defeat at Buxton.

    News on the hour 08:56: BBC Radio Derby

    Hear more in the 09:00 news about calls for improved care for the elderly at Burton's Queen's Hospital after the death of a pensioner.

    Top headlines
    • Al-Madinah: Calls for fresh inquiry
    • Derbyshire Day: Record turnout
    • Listen: BBC Radio Derby
    Record turnout for Derbyshire Day 08:49: BBC Radio Derby

    There was a record turnout for Derbyshire Day yesterday with 11,000 people visiting the event we organised at Calke Abbey.

    The annual event showcases some of the great people and produce of Derbyshire.

    Calls for fresh inquiry at Al-Madinah 08:39: East Midlands Today

    Calls are being made for a fresh investigation into the financial accounts of the Al-Madinah free school in Derby.

    There'll be more on BBC Inside Out at 19:30 tonight on BBC One.

    Slow traffic on M1 08:22: Derbyshire Times

    Motorists using the M1 southbound between the A617 Heath and the A616 Sheffield are experiencing congestion this morning due to ongoing roadworks.

    Mainly dry week ahead 08:11: Charlie Slater Weather Presenter, BBC East Midlands Today

    Cold to start in the East Midlands, but there's lots of blue sky and sunshine to be enjoyed. It looks like it is going to be a mainly dry week too.

    Weather map for East Midlands
    Accident on A38 08:03:

    BBC Travel News says the A38 in Ripley is partially blocked northbound between the A610 junction and Watchorn Island because of an accident involving a car.

    Good morning 08:00:

    BBC Local Live will be bringing you the latest news, sport, travel and weather for Derbyshire until 18:00 today.

    If you want to get in touch email, tweet or Facebook us.



  • Two sphinxes guarding the entrance to the tombTomb mystery

    Secrets of ancient burial site keep Greeks guessing

  • The chequeBig gamble

    How does it feel to bet £900,000 on the Scottish referendum?

  • Tattooed person using tabletRogue ink

    People who lost their jobs because of their tattoos

  • Deepika PadukoneBeauty and a tweet

    Bollywood cleavage row shows India's 'crass' side

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.