Kniveton farmer accuses government of turbine double standards

Craig Barks Craig Barks has accused the government planning inspectorate of inconsistencies on green energy

Related Stories

A farmer has accused the government of double standards on green energy after a battle to build two wind turbines.

Craig Barks from Kniveton, Derbyshire has spent four years changing his designs, only for his appeals to be rejected by the Planning Inspectorate.

He says despite this, the construction of four giant wind turbines in nearby Carsington Pastures has been approved.

The Planning Inspectorate says it takes each appeal on it own merits, plus the legislation and policy at the time.

'Mixed messages'

Mr Barks currently uses a generator to power his farm, which he says is too costly.

He first applied for the 70ft high wind turbines on his land in 2010.

Since then he has brought them closer to the main building and reduced their size.

"I have tried to work with the local council and taken into account the local views and the government objective to come up with something that is acceptable for the farm," he said.

"Throughout that time I have put these applications in and the government has given mixed messages which doesn't help people to know what they are doing."

The giant turbines at Carsington Waters Approval for the construction of the four giant turbines in Carsington Pastures was given in 2008

The Planning Inspectorate approved the building of the four 300ft high turbines in Carsington Pastures five years ago, with some conditions.

A spokesman said: "Inspectors are appointed to hear wind farm appeals for their experience, skill and judgement and will always remain impartial when deciding an appeal."

Derbyshire Dales District Council says it makes decisions "on a case-by-case basis" and has previously rejected applications for wind turbines in the area.

Rob Norris, from RenewableUK, a non-profit trade association said 70% of farmers were relying on renewable energy to support their income.

"It does go to show that the planning process is a really hit and miss affair and perfectly good applications are being turned down," he added.

"We need to streamline the process so people know more or less what the outcome will be if they put in an application."

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Derby



19 °C 13 °C

BBC Local Live

    'Impressed by players reaction' 09:26: Owen Bradley BBC Radio Derby Sport

    Burton Albion caretaker manager Mike Whitlow says he's been impressed by the reaction of his players to the departure of Gary Rowett earlier this week.

    Rowett left Burton to take over at Birmingham on Monday, with Whitlow taking charge for tomorrow's home match with Plymouth.

    Burton could go back to the top of League Two with a win.

    Posters can be downloaded 09:14:

    If you don't like the idea of trick or treaters visting this evening you can print off posters.

    'Sorry no trick or treaters' poster

    Derbyshire Police has free posters online that you can print and put up in your window or door.

    News on the hour 08:59: Sally Swinfen Reporter, BBC Radio Derby

    The charity Childline says it held more than 34,000 counselling sessions in the year to April with children under 18 who have spoken about killing themselves.

    Hear more on our top story in the news at 09:00 on BBC Radio Derby.

    Bid to tackle Halloween egg throwing 08:45:

    Shopkeepers are being told they can refuse to sell flour or eggs to under 16s over the Halloween and bonfire night period.

    Derbyshire Police posters

    Police in Derbyshire say anti-social behaviour such as egg throwing is a problem and they are trying to reduce incidents.

    'Harder than ever' to pick team 08:35: Owen Bradley BBC Radio Derby Sport

    After Tuesday's League Cup success, Derby County head coach Steve McClaren claims picking a team for tomorrow's Championship trip to Brentford will be harder than ever.

    Jake Buxton, Omar Mascarell and Simon Dawkins

    The likes of Jake Buxton, Omar Mascarell and Simon Dawkins (pictured left to right) all impressed in the 5-2 win at Fulham.

    McClaren takes his team to Griffin Park knowing a victory should keep his team top of the Championship.

    'Wear a helmet' 08:25:

    The mother of a cyclist who was killed in a crash this week has urged riders to wear a helmet.

    Maxx Church and his mother

    Maxx Church, 18, from Wolfa Street in Derby, was in a collision with a car on Tuesday evening. He later died in hospital.

    His mother Nikki Blount has released a message through police saying: "Please don't do this to your own mums, wear a helmet. I'd rather you looked like an idiot than look like Maxx did when he died in my arms."

    No travel problems 08:13: Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    There are no travel problems to report at the moment, according to BBC Travel.

    If you spot something, get in touch if it's legal and safe to do so.

    Warm day ahead 08:07: Mel Coles BBC Weather

    Any mist will lift and the cloud will break up to leave a warm day with lengthy spells of hazy sunshine.

    Breezy but mild, with highs of 19C (66F).

    Good morning 08:00: Stephanie Barnard BBC Local Live

    Happy Halloween! We'll have the latest spells, witches brew and pumpkin carving ideas for Derbyshire today.

    Oh hang on.... I'm in the BBC Derby newsroom this morning bringing you the latest news, sport, travel and weather.



BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.