Wendy Sewell murder: Pathology report 'contradicts conviction'

Don Hale and Stephen Downing Don Hale successfully campaigned to free Stephen Downing after he was convicted of the murder of Wendy Sewell

Related Stories

A retired police officer has reported Derbyshire police to the Home Office over claims they withheld evidence in a 1973 murder case.

Bakewell man Stephen Downing was convicted in 1974 for killing Wendy Sewell but that was overturned in 2002.

Chris Clark said he has uncovered a crucial pathology report showing she was strangled, which was never told to the jury.

The Home Office said it would send any new criminal evidence to the police.

Evidence of police misconduct would be referred to the Independent Police Complaints Commission, the Home Office added.

Derbyshire police said the case was closed after a reinvestigation in 2002.

Mr Clark, a retired Norfolk police officer, said he has sent his findings to the Home Office after obtaining the original pathology report last month.

He said he believed the report showed Mrs Sewell had clear signs of being strangled.

She was found battered in a Bakewell cemetery in 1973 and died in hospital two days later.

Mr Downing admitted beating her with a pickaxe handle but later retracted that statement, only to be found guilty by a jury.

Peter Sutcliffe Retired policeman Chris Clark said Peter Sutcliffe, the Yorkshire Ripper, could be connected with Wendy Sewell's murder

"I'm reporting the facts as I see them. The pathologist had evidence in his report that could have exonerated Stephen Downing," Mr Clark said.

He said the pathologist's report showed bruising on her neck consistent with a "knotted ligature" used to garrotte her and a rash in her lungs and airways, possibly caused by strangulation.

Mr Clark said none of this was used in Mr Downing's trial. He added the evidence may mean her death was linked to the Yorkshire Ripper, Peter Sutcliffe.

Mr Downing was 17 at the time of Mrs Sewell's murder but was assessed as having a mental age of 11.

His father Ray Downing and Matlock Mercury editor Don Hale campaigned for his release and in 2002 the Court of Appeal found his conviction unsafe because of "procedural reasons".

Mr Hale said the pathology report directly conflicted with the evidence the police presented at the time and called for an independent investigation into the murder.

"This information was available within two or three days of Mr Downing being arrested and it completely contradicts this so-called confession," he said.

But Derbyshire police said the murder was reinvestigated following the quashing of the conviction and it considered the matter closed.

"All possible lines of inquiry were exhausted during the re-investigation. Twenty two people were ruled out of the enquiry but officers were unable to eliminate Stephen Downing as a suspect," a spokeswoman said.

She added there was no evidence to suggest Peter Sutcliffe - the Yorkshire Ripper - was involved.

More on This Story

Related Stories

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

BBC Derby



7 °C 5 °C

BBC Local Live

    18:00: Good evening

    Updates have now finished for today.

    BBC Local Live will be back from 08:00 on Tuesday with the latest news, sport, travel and weather for Derbyshire

    17:52: Cold night Anna Church Weather Presenter, BBC East Midlands Today

    A dry night with clear spells this evening, allowing temperatures to quickly fall close to freezing.


    Cloud increasing through the latter part of the night will help temperatures to recover, but also bring a little drizzle to the Peak District by dawn. Lows of 4C (39F)

    17:44: Guptill returns to Derbyshire BBC Sport

    Derbyshire have re-signed batsman Martin Guptill as their overseas player for the early part of the 2015 season.

    Martin Guptill

    The 28-year-old New Zealander played for the club in the 2011 and 2012 seasons and will return for the opening six Championship matches and first three T20 Blast fixtures of next term.

    17:34: Wild West in Derby Chris Ellis BBC News Online

    BBC news online has been revisiting some of England's lost theme parks. Visitor Matthew Wells said one of the most memorable rides at Derby's old American Adventure theme park was the Nightmare Niagara log flume.

    Wild West Show

    Take a look back at some of England's other lost theme parks here. What do you remember about the American Adventure? Email us.

    17:23: Questions unanswered BBC Radio Derby

    Just over 24 hours before Sandra Bainbridge was killed by squatter Andrea Cutler in Belper, Derek Joyner had been with Sandra for what he called an "idyllic holiday" in Turkey, where this picture was taken with them both.

    Sandra Bainbridge and Derek Joyner

    He said: "The people responsible for Andrea and her medication did everything in their power to make sure she [was] administered drugs, and it was her refusal to take the drugs which would have stopped her from being a violent person. "

    17:08: Thorne to make comeback for Rams U21s BBC Sport

    Derby County midfielder George Thorne is set to play his first game in six months when he features for the Rams' Under-21 side against Stoke tomorrow.

    George Thorne

    The 22-year-old joined the club in the summer following a loan spell last season but damaged knee ligaments during pre-season in July.

    16:57: News on the hour Lucy Vladev Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    More on the trial of Derbyshire's chief fire officer - accused of raping a woman seven years ago. Sean Frayne denies the charge.

    Hear more details in the news at 17:00

    16:50: Feedback

    BBC Local Live brings you the latest news, sport, travel and weather all in one place. Tell us what you think.

    16:41: Extended regional TV news

    From tonight the BBC is doubling the amount of time for the regional news in its late evening bulletin.


    The East Midlands Today bulletin which follows the BBC News at Ten will be extended to 15 minutes, Monday to Thursday, and will run until after the general election in May.

    16:27: BBC Young voter panel

    If you are aged between 18 and 24, and eligible to vote in May's General Election, the BBC wants to hear from you.

    BBC generation 2015 project

    BBC Politics is building Generation 2015, a UK-wide group of young voters who will take part in local and national BBC programmes in the run up to the General Election in May.

    You could find yourself on the One Show, Radio 1 Newsbeat, or Newsnight - in fact, anywhere across BBC output where the Election is being discussed. Read more online now.

    16:17: Facing his partner's killer Caroline Lowbridge BBC News

    A squatter who stabbed a grandmother to death when she returned home from holiday has been detained under the Mental Health Act.

    Mentally ill Andrea Cutler (pictured) claimed to be a neighbour of her victim Sandra Bainbridge but her partner Derek Joyner said he knew something was "really, drastically wrong".

    Andrea Cutler

    She was charged with murder but pleaded guilty to manslaughter on the grounds of diminished responsibility.

    15:58: News on the hour Lucy Vladev Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    The trial is underway of Derbyshire's chief fire officer - accused of raping a woman 7 years ago. Sean Frayne denies the charge.

    Hear more details in the news at 16:00

    15:49: Alleged rape victim's account Rachael Gilchrist Reporting from Derby Crown Court

    A woman's told a court how Derbyshire's chief fire officer raped her in a pub seven years ago. Sean Frayne, aged 48, denies the allegation.

    Sean Frayne

    A recorded interview with the alleged victim was played to the jury where she described how she tried to stop Frayne as he raped her in an Etwall pub.

    The trial continues.

    15:35: Your Story Alex Homer BBC Local Live

    Who was number one in the charts when you were born?

    BBC Your Story

    BBC Taster is giving you the opportunity to try the new tool Your Story that intertwines your back story with BBC News archive.

    15:18: PM supports town’s £2.5m care facility Matlock Mercury

    Prime Minister David Cameron has come out in support of replacing Heanor memorial Hospital with a new £2.5m care unit.

    The asbestos-riddled hospital is set to be demolished this year and a new facility will take its place - with many of the same services on offer.

    14:59: News on the hour Lucy Vladev Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    A woman has told a court how Derbyshire's chief fire officer raped her in a pub as his wife sat nearby.

    We will have more on the case from 15:00. Sean Frayne denies the allegation.

    14:47: Red Nose Day 2015

    This year's Comic Relief campaign has been launched.

    Red Nose Appeal 2015

    This year's campaign is "make your face funny for money".

    This year nine noses have been launched, question is, which one is your favourite?

    Put it in your diary - Friday 13 March.

    14:28: Council backs smoking drive Derbyshire Times

    Derbyshire County Council leaders have signed up to the Local Government Declaration on Tobacco Control as part of work to protect residents from the harm caused by smoking.

    14:11: Stolen drugs warning Alex Homer BBC Local Live

    Prescription drugs have been stolen from a Chesterfield pharmacy, prompting a police warning about the dangers of taking them.

    Among the medications stolen was Clonazepam - used to stop the effects of epileptic fits which Derbyshire Constabulary warned could be "particularly dangerous if used incorrectly".

    The theft happened from Lloyds Pharmacy, Wardgate Way, at about 03:30 on 23 January.

    14:00: News on the hour Lucy Vladev Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    A pedestrian has been hit by a van outside the Blue Peter pub in Alvaston.

    More on this in our 14:00 bulletin.

    13:37: Coming up this afternoon Andy Potter Presenter, BBC Radio Derby

    Comedian and actor Rob Brydon will be telling me about the launch of this year's Comic Relief appeal.

    And I'll be chatting to a Derby actor whose voice has been used for one of the characters in the new Shaun the Sheep movie. Join me for today's programme.

    13:23: Coming up on TV Angelina Socci BBC East Midlands Today

    Politicians in the East Midlands are coming together today for a joint campaign for what they call "fair funding."

    Councillors in Derbyshire are among those claiming they're losing out to more affluent areas. The government says its delivered a fair settlement throughout the country.

    Join us for more on this in the East Midlands Today on BBC One at 13:30.

    13:09: Rolls-Royce engines

    Rolls-Royce's MTU business, which makes large diesel engines, has won a £75m order for freight locomotive engines for South African trains.


    The 20-cylinder engines (pictured) kick out 3,300 kilowatts of power.

    13:00: News on the hour Lucy Vladev Newsreader, BBC Radio Derby

    The jury has been sworn in for the trial of Derbyshire's chief fire officer - accused of raping a woman 7 years ago. Sean Frayne denies the charge.

    Hear more details in the news at 13:00

    12:40: 'Like a horror movie' BBC Radio Derby

    Derek Joyner was trying to separate himself from mentally ill squatter Andrea Cutler, who was on the other side of the door with an eight-inch blade, having stabbed Sandra Bainbridge 73 times at her Belper home.

    He described the experience was "like a horror movie".

    12:28: Fire chief denies rape Rachael Gilchrist News Editor, BBC Radio Derby

    I'm at Derby Crown Court today where Derbyshire's chief fire officer is standing trial accused of raping a woman seven years ago.

    Sean Frayne denies raping the woman in Etwall, Derby, between 30 November 2006 and 1 January 2007.

    Sean Frayne

    The 48 year old has been suspended from his role. A jury has been sworn in and are listening to the prosecution's opening statement.

    12:15: Repeat roadworks fears Ashbourne News Telegraph

    Ashbourne commuters are likely to face long delays again when two major traffic islands, which caused misery for many last year because of roadworks, are likely to be dug up again.

    11:57: News on the hour Sally Swinfen Reporter, BBC Radio Derby

    Police are appealing for witnesses after a man was assaulted in Alfreton on Saturday night. He was walking from High Street onto Rogers Lane between midnight and 01:00.

    He received a fractured cheekbone, cuts and bruises and his teeth were also damaged. More on this story in our 12:00 headlines.

    11:46: Late equaliser helped Burton BBC Sport

    Substitute Adam McGurk scored a late equaliser for promotion-chasing Burton to deny York a first win in four games.

    11:32: Snow warning

    The Met Office tweets that it has a yellow warning for snow in Derbyshire for later this week, valid from 09:00 on Wednesday until 23:55 on Thursday.

    Higher ground could see 3-6cm in Northern England, according to current forecasts.

    11:16: 'Jilted John': Raffle winner was 'overjoyed' Ian Skye Presenter, BBC Radio Derby

    "She was overjoyed, screaming. It was nice to think that finally all the hard work has got somewhere"

    That was "Jilted John" speaking to me earlier, after he raffled off his ex-fiancée's honeymoon place and called the winner to let her know.

    John Whitbread

    Two bidders previously failed to pay the winning sum following eBay auctions for the £1,800 trip to the Dominican Republic.

    10:55: News on the hour Sally Swinfen Reporter, BBC Radio Derby

    At 11:00 a Derbyshire man tells us how different things might have been if the mentally ill woman who stabbed his partner to death, had taken her medication.

    Listen live here.

    Email: derby.locallive@bbc.co.uk 10:49: Your memories Chris Ellis BBC News Online

    Did you ever visit Derby's Britannia Park, or you might have known it by its second moniker The American Adventure?

    American Adventure Theme Park

    Opened in 1985 and known for its signature rollercoaster The Missile, the attraction also boasted other white-knuckle rides including the Runaway Train and Skycoaster.

    BBC News is looking back at England's lost theme parks. Email us with your memories.

    10:32: Have your say Alex Homer BBC Local Live

    What do you think of BBC Local Live? We'd like your feedback about this service.

    10:15: Derby County hero Roger Davies 'may never be same again' after crash Derby Telegraph

    Former Derby County star Roger Davies says he does not know if he will ever return to full fitness after a car crash nearly cost him his life.

    The 64-year-old was involved in a collision in November which closed the A516 in Burnaston for four-and-a-half hours.

    09:59: News on the hour Sally Swinfen Reporter, BBC Radio Derby

    Local people are being encouraged to give their views to the Highways Agency on plans which would see flyovers or underpasses built at three roundabouts on the A38 in Derby.

    The plans for Markeaton, Little Eaton and Kingsway Islands will be on show over the next few weeks.

    More on this in our 10:00 news.

    09:44: Police outposts to close Dave Wade BBC News Online

    Derbyshire Police is to close 58 police buildings, including stations and offices, in its latest round of cuts.

    Derbyshire Police headquarters

    The number of officers will be reduced by 64 over the next year with more reductions in 2016 and 2017.

    Police and crime commissioner Alan Charles warned that some types of crime will "in all likelihood" increase.

    09:29: Authority bid branded 'shambles' Buxton Advertiser

    High Peak Conservatives have branded Labour's organisational skills as "completely shambolic" after set-backs in talks over Derbyshire's home-rule bid.

    09:12: Ex-Ram robbed Derby Telegraph

    A former Derby County player has been robbed of his mobile phone in Derby.

    Nigel Callaghan led out the sides for a benefit match in 2010 as part of his fight against bowel cancer

    Ex-winger Nigel Callaghan took to social media to report how three youths with their faces covered by scarves grabbed the phone off him on Saturday night.

    08:57: News on the hour Sally Swinfen Reporter, BBC Radio Derby

    A Derbyshire man has been talking about the moment he confronted a mentally ill woman who had stabbed his partner to death.

    We will hear how he found a stranger upstairs in her Belper home in our 09:00 bulletin.

    08:42: 'Jilted John' finds companion Dave Wade BBC News Online

    After being jilted three times, a man who tried to auction his ex-fiancée's honeymoon place has finally found a holiday partner.

    John Whitbread

    John Whitbread, who grew up in Derbyshire, put the £1,800 trip to the Dominican Republic on eBay in the hope of finding a female companion.

    But when the two highest bidders failed to pay the winning sum, he instead sold £10 raffle tickets and the lucky winner was drawn out of a hat.

    08:30: Rams on the road to Wembley BBC Sport

    On-loan Darren Bent's first goal for Derby helped see the Rams past a spirited Chesterfield side into the last 16 of the FA Cup.

    Darren Bent

    Bent, on loan from Aston Villa, opened the scoring for Steve McClaren's Championship promotion chasers with a close-range first-half header.

    08:16: East Midlands trains affected BBC Travel

    There is a reduced service on East Midlands trains heading to London because of flooding.

    Services between St Pancras International and Corby, Nottingham and Sheffield are among those affected.

    Train users cab find more information here.

    08:05: Today's forecast Sara Blizzard Weather Presenter, BBC East Midlands Today

    Starting off cloudy with some patchy rain, but it will become dry with bright spells during the morning with some sunshine for most places this afternoon.

    It will be breezy at times, making it feel cool with a maximum temperature of 8C (46F).

    More about the next few days is here.

    08:00: Good morning Alex Homer BBC Local Live

    I'm in the BBC Radio Derby newsroom bringing you news, sport, travel and weather updates for Derbyshire today.

    Let us know what you think about our updates over email, Facebook or Twitter.



Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.